EPT##Unvote
##Vote: ChewOnStu
Only answered a question once directed at him, sheeped hardcore onto NW vote. Things need doing, and unfortunately he is not doing the doing.
So Chew...
Watcha gonna do?
Newbie Mini Mafia XXXVIII - Page 22
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Rainbows
Germany1217 Posts
##Unvote ##Vote: ChewOnStu Only answered a question once directed at him, sheeped hardcore onto NW vote. Things need doing, and unfortunately he is not doing the doing. So Chew... Watcha gonna do? | ||
|
MeatlessTaco
United States302 Posts
##Vote: ChewOnStu | ||
|
TheRavensName
United States911 Posts
| ||
|
Rainbows
Germany1217 Posts
On March 08 2013 11:38 MLuneth wrote: Good morning all (well morning for me) I will be able to answer questions in 2-3 hours. I will also explain my stance on NW/Daishi when I get back. ty for your patience + Show Spoiler + | ||
|
MeatlessTaco
United States302 Posts
| ||
|
MeatlessTaco
United States302 Posts
| ||
|
MLuneth
Australia557 Posts
Considering changing vote to one of several people When will Arctic Daishi be replaced if he doesn't respond? | ||
|
bduddy
United States1326 Posts
I don't want to vote for Arctic Daishi, it would be a total waste at this point if he hasn't posted at all. Rainbows is a bit... aggressive for my tastes. MeatlessTaco's bandwagoning onto CoS worries me a bit, but he seems fine other than that. I'm actually most suspicious of TheRavensName - he wanted to excuse liars, he piled onto making a "joke vote", and as others have said he posted right before the game started and then was silent. Again, I will definitely post more than once per day after this, I've just had other issues. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
It hasn't been that long for Luneth, give him a shot. NW is basically DOA this evening though if he doesn't show up and defend himself adequately or give us something better to go on. In other news, there are a LOT of people lurking hard in this thread. We're going to have a damn near impossible time of winning this game if we don't get more out of you guys with <1 page worth of filter. If you're not scum, you'd better speak up or you're throwing the game for us. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
 I'm going to hope that next time you give us more than a list of your 'worries and suspicions,' and give us some hard evidence and scumreads. Think you could make that happen? | ||
|
TheRavensName
United States911 Posts
On March 08 2013 14:38 bduddy wrote: OK... I have had a lot of stuff to do (yes, there are things that are more important than Mafia... like getting a job...), and I've been spending a while trying to read the posts here, but trying to catch up on so much stuff at once is a bit annoying. Anyway, as for nobodywonder, I can understand the suspicion towards me, and given that I've had an excuse of my own I'm willing to buy his excuse of being new. I don't want to vote for Arctic Daishi, it would be a total waste at this point if he hasn't posted at all. Rainbows is a bit... aggressive for my tastes. MeatlessTaco's bandwagoning onto CoS worries me a bit, but he seems fine other than that. I'm actually most suspicious of TheRavensName - he wanted to excuse liars, he piled onto making a "joke vote", and as others have said he posted right before the game started and then was silent. Again, I will definitely post more than once per day after this, I've just had other issues. Hurts my feelings. and I didn't say excuse liars. I was saying, or trying to, remember that this is a newbie game and people are going to make mistakes. You need to be sure of it being a lie rather than it just being a simple slip up. Thats all. | ||
|
MLuneth
Australia557 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + To put it simply my Vote was a pressure vote to try and get Arctic to speak up (I'm saying this now because I believe that Arctic Daishi will stay afk). My vote on Diashi was a coin flip between Daishi/BDuddy/ChewOnStu because none had made posts at this point. My view of NW at the time + Show Spoiler + At this time I was more interested in getting everyone talking. I also felt that while NW's actions were potentially scummy that they could be explained by being a newbie and making a foolish mistake (I mean, it's not the brightest thing to do to introduce yourself by sheeping someone else's attack on a lurker). I was content at that point to simply remain suspicious of NW rather than straight up voting for him. My view on Lynching Lurkers vs Active people that seem scummy at the time + Show Spoiler + At this point in time there were multiple people who hadn't made any posts while others (NW, Matiarch TheRavensName etc had made very few. My goal at this point was to force more posts rather than try and kill NW. My view at the was and still remains is that unless I am confident that there is a high chance of an active person being scum I will Vote for an inactive scummy Lurker This explains my stance/view on these matters at the time of posting this + Show Spoiler + While I believe that nobodywonder's actions have been suspicious and that his case is less than stellar, I feel that it is foolish to lynch someone who has made an addition to the game (albeit at this point small) should not be lynched over a person that has simply lurked for 2 days straight. I feel I need to point out that Frogon, as well as Krafla and Matriarch (to a lesser extent) have all input a similar amount of information as nobodywonder. At this stage with so little info to go on I can only flip a coin on whether to vote Artic Daishi or bduddy I will move on to address current questions (Would I Vote NW now etc) after a half hour break | ||
|
MLuneth
Australia557 Posts
My view at the time was and still remains is that unless I am confident that there is a high chance of an active person being scum I will Vote for an inactive scummy Lurker | ||
|
MeatlessTaco
United States302 Posts
You all need to make a stand. Are you going to let marines kills our broodlings one by one? Vote and make a case. | ||
|
Mocsta
Australia9389 Posts
On March 08 2013 14:20 MLuneth wrote: When will Arctic Daishi be replaced if he doesn't respond? As per OP: "If a player is modkilled then they will be replaced by a player on the replacement list if possible." & "Activity: You must post in this thread once per day/night cycle and vote every day while you are alive. If you fail to do so, you will be warned or modkilled at host's discretion." | ||
|
Matriarch
United States21 Posts
On March 08 2013 09:28 nobodywonder wrote: @WoS. you're fine. although I want Krafla to explain himself still @OE.. hmmmm his posts are really long and windy, just check his filter. just like krafla, his posts are either useless or just too long, may indicate somewhat scummy + Show Spoiler + Alright.. not much to work with and if anybody has any counter-questions for me please ask. Even if you think it's a dumb question, it's best to get them out of the way. I'd like to try and get some discussion going so.. @MLuneth Could you expand on why you chose Arctic to vote on when there were others (bduddy, ChewOnStu) without any content as well. Other than it just being a coin flip. @Krafla+ Show Spoiler + karla @ChewOnStu Welcome to the game On the subject of lurkers, how do you feel we should deal with them if not for voting on them/lynching them when they become a problem? Every vote is meant to lynch so without that pressure how do we force bad town/scum to participate? I do agree that it is too early to assume anybody is lurking and not just busy but it is important to be able to react quickly, especially on D1. @WoS you mentioned strategies town should implement, or rather asked about them. I was hoping you could expand on your own thoughts on the matter. Do you have anything to say about my opening post or anything to add to it? @Matriarch How do you feel about the Lynch All Liars policy. Should town attempt to coax out scum by lying and possibly confusing the rest of us / hurting town in the process? @Raven same question as above, how do you feel about Lynching all Liars. As Scum has to lie to survive do you think this would add pressure and eventually lead to a correct lynch if we caught somebody? @Rainbows You mention Luneth being scummy, what do you think about his vote on Arctic? As Arctic has yet to show up, do you think it is more town oriented (trying to get a lurker to post) or scummy (attacking the easiest player early on in hopes that Arctic doesn't defend himself). @Frorgon You mention suspicious behavior being one of the key things you will be looking for, is there anything you could note so far that you would consider suspicious? @NobodyWonder You say you don't want to lynch anybody D1 if it is unjustified, could you expand and does that mean if we have no concrete proof of scum you will vote to no-lynch or would you get rid of the scummiest lurker? @Arctic Can give us your thoughts on what has happened so far and answer most of the questions I have asked to the others. @Taco Could you give your thoughts on Luneth voting for Arctic, which alignment do you believe it favors? If I missed anybody sorry =/ however one of the most interesting thing is where he chastises Raven + Show Spoiler + On March 08 2013 04:14 TheRavensName wrote: Show nested quote + Cause I dunno what I am doing and its what all the cool kids are doing? And I talk about bussing cause I mea the only mafia I've really played is the SC2 one, its realy really common to bus on it. So I just kinda assumed its the same way here. I'm just dumb I guess? As there has been no case against you and I see no reason to suspect you of being scummy at this point in time I'm going to step in and defend you / chastise you a little bit. First thing On March 08 2013 03:15 WaveofShadow wrote: Show nested quote + Why do you have to make a decision now? Why are you talking about bussing? Why are you making a useless list post? To be fair Raven didn't say we had to make a decision now, he said the decision at the moment is between Luneth and NW which was correct. WoS if you truely like what Rainbow has been saying without giving any specifics I assume you also meant you wanted to focus on one thing at a time. However Raven there are a few things I have a problem with in this post. One is the mention of an SK, keep that thought out of mind until the end of N1, it is not a certain thing that there is an SK, in all 3 of my previous newbie games there hasn't been one so it's best to leave that alone until there is proof of a 3rd party. The second thing is the mention of bussing so early into D1 while some people have still barely said anything. I don't believe it makes sense for mafia to try and bus each other this early. We can start to look at it closer to the deadline / after the flip and try to come to any conclusions then. I also personally just dislike it when people try to play the victim card. You have voiced some decent opinions about how we should go about the game and if you follow it up with some good scum hunting and cases it'll ease my suspicion of you greatly. This is more like some friendly advice to you if you are town to help prove it and keep yourself away from the lynch mob. And just be aware that when people pressure you, you should think about a better defense than "I guess I'm just dumb" If it keeps up, it'll look pretty scummy without any real explanations. why would he even defend Raven? Raven has played like a noob or somewhat scummy (see: "I guess I'm just dumb"), why wouldn't OE try to pressure Raven. As I see it, OE and Raven have the same allegiance and confirm each other's role. therefore possibly both mafia or chobolings. He gets asked about OE and he says that he makes long posts and so he's scummy? Why does that make him scummy? And if you look at his posts earlier he looks more like he thinks (or knows!) OE is town. I think that's pretty shady! ##Vote: nobodywonder | ||
|
nobodywonder
United States848 Posts
ok cool thanks bduddy for contributing, agree about the Arctic Daishi thing. I'd like replies from the non-voters too. I will reread the filters and get ready to make my case. | ||
|
bduddy
United States1326 Posts
On March 08 2013 14:41 WaveofShadow wrote: I don't know exactly what kind of "hard evidence" you're looking for, other than "I'm the cop and..." All I have are the same posts as everyone else, and I've tried to read through them quickly so I can post before stuff starts happening so I probably haven't even read them as fully as everyone else. I did say that I'm feeling a bit suspicious towards TRN and Rainbows, is that what you mean by "scumreads"?Alright bduddy, welcome to the thread. I'm going to hope that next time you give us more than a list of your 'worries and suspicions,' and give us some hard evidence and scumreads. Think you could make that happen? I'm just not seeing nobodywonder as scum (and I'm not just saying that because he unvoted me!), he seems like a genuine new townie to me. I am now somewhat suspicious towards Matriarch; very few posts (I see the post about a child, I understand that that would be far more important than posting here but it would also be a great excuse) and came straight back to jump on the nobodywonder bandwagon for reasons that don't really make sense to me. For now, though, I'm going to ##Vote: TheRavensName who still seems most suspicious to me. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On March 08 2013 14:59 nobodywonder wrote: ##Unvote ok cool thanks bduddy for contributing, agree about the Arctic Daishi thing. I'd like replies from the non-voters too. I will reread the filters and get ready to make my case. I look forward to hearing from you. Luneth your stance on voting an inactive scummy lurker is likely not going to get us anywhere. Let me tell you the tale of the absolutely fucking retarded township of NMM 37 (that I was a part of). D1 was full of lurk, barely half the thread showed up to do anything. Everyone eventually voted except for 2 people who were eventually replaced. But WHERE did people vote? Well people took the stance of voting for lurkers, and since there were so many to choose from, everyone essentially chose their own candidate and ended up lynching a townie, because it was real easy for mafia to hide and spread out their votes. Since there were so many people lurking (similar to this game) it was essentially a complete crapshoot anyway as to whether we hit a scummy lurker or a town lurker. Better in the end to go with some educated guessing and learn from that than lynch someone who has contributed barely anything so we learn nothing after the flip. D1 sucks, and sometimes you lynch town, but it happens. If it happens we move on and keep hunting scum and learn from our mistake. | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On March 08 2013 15:09 bduddy wrote: I don't know exactly what kind of "hard evidence" you're looking for, other than "I'm the cop and..." All I have are the same posts as everyone else, and I've tried to read through them quickly so I can post before stuff starts happening so I probably haven't even read them as fully as everyone else. I did say that I'm feeling a bit suspicious towards TRN and Rainbows, is that what you mean by "scumreads"? I'm just not seeing nobodywonder as scum (and I'm not just saying that because he unvoted me!), he seems like a genuine new townie to me. I am now somewhat suspicious towards Matriarch; very few posts (I see the post about a child, I understand that that would be far more important than posting here but it would also be a great excuse) and came straight back to jump on the nobodywonder bandwagon for reasons that don't really make sense to me. For now, though, I'm going to ##Vote: TheRavensName who still seems most suspicious to me. You didn't just claim cop D1 did you?  Alright bduddy I'll spell out a couple things for you. 1) Claiming a blue role this early in the game essentially paints a big ol' bullseye on your back for mafia to target. If they manage to shoot you N1 you won't have performed any checks and are useless to us. 2) When I'm asking for your scumreads, I'm asking you to tell us who you think are scum and WHY. "I have a good feeling about NW," or "I feel suspicious" means dick all if you don't have anything to back it up. In conclusion, do a little a thinking before you post about the repercussions of your actions and what it means to other people when you say certain things, and you'll go a long way. Don't just spew your thoughts into the thread for no apparent reason. It doesn't help us find scum. | ||
| ||
