Sorry, why would that exchange from JX make you even consider changing your vote?

If anything, its adding to his scumminess vibe?

<Lurks all day>
<Comes in, takes a pop shot>
<Leaves>

WTF is that.

phagga

Switzerland2194 Posts

February 07 2013 10:57 GMT

#462

I just wanted to point out that I did not see that post when I originally posted my vote, and that I see no reason to change my vote because of it.

I agree completely that it makes him look even worse, hence no need to change my vote.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 11:10 GMT

#463

right now after jx latest post he is equal to me with prplhz. Im happy to vote for which of the two is vote leader.

Phagga since u r online. What do u make of my points against prplhz?

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 07 2013 11:52 GMT

#464

I'm stuck at page 20 but I just want to say that lynching Palmar is silly right now. First of all he could just be busy and in a trolly mood and once he snaps out of it he could be really useful to us. Second of all, he promised us something concrete very soon: the day 2 plan to ravage scum. Come day 2 and he doesn't have anything then he's lying and then we just lynch him, ezpz.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 07 2013 11:57 GMT

#465

The problem is that he skates by by his reputation, which I dont think is a good way to play and is abhorrent to the notion of playing to win

he didnt say anything about being busy, nothing is indicated in his tone that he is busy.
He is just trolling. And I dont care how 'good' he is, this play shouldnt be encouraged.
Talking about Palmer by the way.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 07 2013 12:30 GMT

#466

But we're not lynching people because you think their play is "abhorrent to [your] notion of playing to win". His reputation is well earned and it's silly to lynch him on day 1 unless there's a really good case but the entire case against him can be explained away with "he's had a mental breakdown" and we can tolerate that for a single day as long as he isn't straight up lying to us so lets just wait it out and see what happens. Only bad thing about that is that we have to lynch someone else and this game isn't making much sense to me. I think I need to talk to slOosh.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 12:31 GMT

#467

Prplhz surely it doesnt take an hour to read 3 pages.

I am keen to hear your thoughts

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 12:32 GMT

#468

Lol sniped

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 07 2013 12:41 GMT

#469

We are lynching people because they are LURKING.
Understand prp? What makes it worse is that he should know that lurking DOES NOT help town and thus, if he is town, he is playing against his wincon.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 07 2013 12:52 GMT

#470

EBWOP: Palmer, not people.

yamato77

11589 Posts

February 07 2013 12:56 GMT

#471

Can anyone come up with a good reason to not lynch JX?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 13:26 GMT

#472

On February 07 2013 21:41 Oatsmaster wrote:
We are lynching people because they are LURKING.
Understand prp? What makes it worse is that he should know that lurking DOES NOT help town and thus, if he is town, he is playing against his wincon.

Oats, you advocating Palmar lynch.

Can I have your thoughts on Prplhz/JX please.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 13:28 GMT

#473

On February 07 2013 21:56 yamato77 wrote:
Can anyone come up with a good reason to not lynch JX?

I cant.

Between him and prplhz I will vote for whoever is leading.

Im surprised prplhz felt the need to consult with sl0osh before addressing the points I raised against him.

The only town point I can think for prplhz is that I havent seen someone roll scum two games in a row.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 07 2013 13:32 GMT

#474

Something rubs me the wrong way about jaybrundage and his case on Djodref. No one else really reacted strongly to Djodref's silly random vote because everybody knew what it was: some sort of scheme to draw out scum. Pretty rediculous but at least he doing something. jaybrundage also acknowledges this himself here but he still uses it as a reason to vote Djodref. This gives him a place to put his vote and even though he's since gradually recanted this (like here), he hasn't unvoted. It seems like he is trying to keep the Djodref door open while not pushing it and not wanting to actually push anything else.

It doesn't seem like a townie thinking "fuck yea, i nailed this cracker and it's so obvious! now i just have to get everybody else to listen to me!", more like "cool, i can just put my vote on him and then chill".

How do you guys feel about jaybrundage?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 13:33 GMT

#475

On February 07 2013 11:31 jaybrundage wrote:
Palmar is a very strong town player. I have played a decent number of games with him. If he is town scum will want to try to kill him asap. But in this set up they can't unless they lead a mislynch on him. Whether it be via a normal day mislynch or a mislynch in a nomination day. I actually haven't played with scum palmar So maybe I don't really consider the possibility of him being scum.

But I can judge palmar by his results if he doesnt lead the town to some good scum lynches ill be willing to lynch him. But given who he is I give him more leeway then I would others.

@Jay, am I reading this correctly.

You would consider voting "prplhz" to ascertain whether Palmar is looking to flip scum?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 13:36 GMT

#476

On February 07 2013 22:32 prplhz wrote:
Something rubs me the wrong way about jaybrundage and his case on Djodref. No one else really reacted strongly to Djodref's silly random vote because everybody knew what it was: some sort of scheme to draw out scum. Pretty rediculous but at least he doing something. jaybrundage also acknowledges this himself here but he still uses it as a reason to vote Djodref. This gives him a place to put his vote and even though he's since gradually recanted this (like here), he hasn't unvoted. It seems like he is trying to keep the Djodref door open while not pushing it and not wanting to actually push anything else.

It doesn't seem like a townie thinking "fuck yea, i nailed this cracker and it's so obvious! now i just have to get everybody else to listen to me!", more like "cool, i can just put my vote on him and then chill".

How do you guys feel about jaybrundage?

I have to disagree.

I actually thought Jay identified the same lack of conviction I felt with Djo.

I took the approach: Djo needs to consider himself if he wants to be serious about RNG - (Djo ignored this pressure.)

Jay pressured along the same lines, but more detailed - The outcome: Djo caved in and admitted he wasnt trying to follow through with it as he felt Oats was town.

I think this was a more than valid lead to follow.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 07 2013 13:39 GMT

#477

But if it was a pressure vote then why didn't jaybrundage react in any way when the pressure "succeeded"? jaybrundage just said "maybe djo is just fucking around" and that's all he's said and done about it since his big case. I don't like that.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

February 07 2013 13:40 GMT

#478

Yeah JX seems to be trolling,
However,
WHICH SCUMMY LURKER DO WE LYNCH?
Im not down with prp lynch by the way, I dont think he is scum.

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 13:43 GMT

#479

On February 07 2013 22:39 prplhz wrote:
But if it was a pressure vote then why didn't jaybrundage react in any way when the pressure "succeeded"? jaybrundage just said "maybe djo is just fucking around" and that's all he's said and done about it since his big case. I don't like that.

If you look @ Jay last post; its before Djo "conceded"

That might explain the lack of a follow up response?

Mocsta

Australia9389 Posts

February 07 2013 13:45 GMT

#480

On February 07 2013 22:40 Oatsmaster wrote:
Yeah JX seems to be trolling,
However,
WHICH SCUMMY LURKER DO WE LYNCH?
Im not down with prp lynch by the way, I dont think he is scum.

Im not going to ask for why you think prplhz is not scum; as I would still prefer if *he* addresses my points first.

Now, scummy lurker, I assume we talking about palmar or JX.

Do you include Snarfs in this spectrum?

If just Palmar/JX for you.. JX is the common link and I could swing his way. Hes 50/50 (Shared with prplhz)