To xatolas. It's not entirely based on WIFOM, although I see you have a point. However to say something about killing being less suspicious than stutters before the vig call then after that instantly makes him scum is odd.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 11:34 GMT

#723

I still think kush is town btw but don't be an idiot. Think about this.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 11:40 GMT

#724

Ok my two largest scum reads right now are Sonic and Xatalos I have temp dropped killing to a lower priority. But seeing that Sonic and Xatalos are both voting killing I think I have worked it all out.

Negative elimination I think I am town kush obviously thinks I am town and he thinks I am on the wrong track but hear me out. Stutters is town. Sonic and xatalos are both voting killing. I think kush is town. My two top scum reads are voting killing. I’m casey, I thought he was town but my read was based off knowing WeeTee. Not as strong as I thought.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 11:40 GMT

#725

Everyone was happy voting killing. Is this not strange to you kush....

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 11:48 GMT

#726

Look I have been going for killing all game... I should know how strong the killing case was if you truly think I am town think about this.The case is entirely based on "He isn’t confident and circumstantial stuff." I thought it was strong because I went into OMGUS mode. I just saw the light at the end of the tunnel I made the connections I just need your support. No offence but you do have a 100% miss rate. Trust me I implore you. I thought we were safe today but we are not. Killing is not this safe mafia lynch like you think. Sorry for getting hyped up but we have this I just need to convice you somehow.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

September 09 2012 12:21 GMT

#727

@jacob I don't think you are understanding the new mechanics of this game. everyone NEEDS to vote for the same person or mafia changes their vote at the last second and we lose.
so either you vote for killing or you convince everyone else to vote for someone else.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

September 09 2012 12:37 GMT

#728

On September 09 2012 20:40 JacobStrangelove wrote:
Everyone was happy voting killing. Is this not strange to you kush....

No because as I said before it only makes sense for scum to bus one of their own at this point.
Think about this scenario... We lynch killing and he flips red. We know that everyone who didn't vote for killing is scum, because if any town voted for someone else, mafia would have all vote changed and town would have lost.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 12:43 GMT

#729

I think killing is town, I think stutters is town I think you are town and I think I am town. I will not vote for someone I think is town. This might seems strange. We were talking about the bus so much though. Don't you think they might go.. you know what lets not bus and mess with there heads. They only need one misslynch. They can pull this kind of stuff.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 12:46 GMT

#730

Look I almost have to out right refuse a lynch on killing. You know I am town. If I don't lynch vote killing according to you we lose so you need to vote sonic I am almost making it our only option for winning.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 12:54 GMT

#731

This probably seems strange to you considering everything that has happened but think for one minute if killing is town. Xatalos/Sonic are voting for him. These are now my top two scum reads. I can't believe I have been this stupid all game. Sorry if I am getting frustrated I just need to make you see this. The imcasey is town was a weak case. Why do you think I had so much trouble explaining my town read on him. Your read on him is related to my read (im part) and I think my read is actually messed up. In sonic pretending to bus imcasey I realised imcasey is scum. However not his intention I worked everything else out.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

September 09 2012 12:57 GMT

#732

@Jacob I do trust you as town and I am more certain of that than anything else in this game. But I think you are being really stupid about how you are going about this.
I am not opposed to a different bandwagon, but you need to say who we are bandwagoning and see if you can convince everyone to bandwagon with you.

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

September 09 2012 13:18 GMT

#733

Say who you want to bandwagon andsayit quick because we need all 4 town to vote for this person.
And where is iamcasey seriouslty. Maybe its a bad idea to bandwagon him because he is gonna get modkilled soon maybe.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 13:37 GMT

#734

Sonic, We should go on sonic

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 13:39 GMT

#735

I am trying to convince you. I am sure stutters will also go on sonic. For one he has to the two people that I am sure he knows are town are on sonic and we will lose otherwise. Mafia can last minute switch like I said.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 13:39 GMT

#736

ebwop you said*

Xatalos

Finland9673 Posts

September 09 2012 13:42 GMT

#737

I'll have to leave soon, but I have to comment on one matter. Stutters695 said he'd be able to post at 5 EST. Since he's the only confirmed town at the moment, he basically has the final word. I'm not that good with timezones, so I don't know how close to the deadline that is, but I can't almost certainly be online when he decides to vote. With that in mind, he has been most suspicious of KillingTime, so I'd say his vote will be KillingTime. I can't take the risk of voting for Sonic Death Monkey now in this situation - and more importanly, Jacob's theory is just too WIFOM so far. I don't see why we should throw away player analysis and rely on team combination theories before we even know the identity of one Mafia for certain.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 13:48 GMT

#738

You are telling us what sutters will vote, He hasn't read the thread since he has been gone. Look... if killing was mafia and I don't think so. Sonic as least has a 2 in 3(3 in 4) chance of being mafia. While I am now practicly 100% sure he is mafia jsut going with the maths.... My theory may be WIFOM partly but you are in that group so of course you would argue against me.

JacobStrangelove

Australia1572 Posts

September 09 2012 14:06 GMT

#739

I'm telling you there is no killings case and that sonic is the best mafia case

kushm4sta

United States8878 Posts

September 09 2012 14:13 GMT

#740

@Xatalos I will vote for sonic, Jacob will vote for sonic, obviously stutters is going to join our bandwagon. If you are town vote for sonic. No he's not my strongest read, but I at this point we don't have a choice because without consensus we autolose.