Bureaucracy Mafia! - Page 124

On July 21 2012 09:35 layabout wrote:
For all intents and purposes sandroba is town.

This game requires half of the thread to agree on a lynch. Kurumi is near confirmed scum.
+ Show Spoiler +

And yet there are 5 votes not on Kurumi! We are going to need focus more and we are going to need to stop joking around with votes and thread actions.

Palmar and Foolishness are calling syllogism mafia. Syllogism in turn is calling both Palmar and Foolishness mafia. Many of you insist on speculating that the host will have made the CEO one of these players (or sandroba or Meapak). It is always dangerous to make decisions based upon out-guessing the host. But if we are aiming to kill the CEO we should plac e our attention on those 3 players.

If we are looking for the person most likely to flip scum tomorrow we need look no further tahn our good friend zealos. I defended him initially but his actions since then show that he is either a mafia or a townie that isn't playing.

READ:

Before sandroba revealed that he had messaged zealos WBG considered zealos to be as likely scum as Kurumi. He did not explain his reasons explicitly but he expressed this opinion and we would be wise not to forget it.

It's useful to have a meta assessment so:


What was the most sgnificant event during day1?
+ Show Spoiler [Answer] +
Everyone should have paid their attention to that and thought about the various possibilities since for a time that event would have decided that days lynch and is deciding today lynch. It was your responsibility as town.

But are we to believe that until this morning zealos was unaware of the whole thing?

Zealos placed his first vote against austinmcc


He says nothing about austinmcc specifically and yet he feels that the only thing needed to justify his vote was thread momentum. At that time a few players were calling austinmcc scummy but there was nothing substantial said at all and he had very few votes. Zealos' vote was lazy and shows that he was trying to fit in rather than trying to get a successful lynch. It sounds a lot like the Zealos that HiroPro descibed.


So Zealos still was not reading the thread since austinmcc did not have a decent case against him and his comment about Kurumi demonstrates a complete lack of thread knowledge.

He also picks out Blazinghand not for being scummy but for being "odd". Which is strange since there should be enuogh players for him to find something that is scummy and not simply "odd".


I will simply re-post:


And what has he done?
Well he spent just long enough in the thread to have sandroba's message explained to him. He contributed nothing of his own and has not been productive. He is mafia.

##tomorrow we should vote zealos

On July 22 2012 00:47 Palmar wrote:
if you can shoot tonight kill foolishness, syllo, katina, BM, zealos etc

I'll be around later

On July 22 2012 00:54 supersoft wrote:
palmar, respond on the issue i raised about your activitylvl.
We are going to reach a point of time in the game where i need some informations.

On July 21 2012 17:36 supersoft wrote:
katina looks pretty cute :-o
she cant be scum.

On July 22 2012 00:47 Palmar wrote:
if you can shoot tonight kill foolishness, syllo, katina, BM, zealos etc

I'll be around later

On July 22 2012 02:15 VisceraEyes wrote:
Palmar two proven messenger roles that can target town. One is sum right? Its Chezinu imo imo.

On July 22 2012 02:32 Foolishness wrote:

Weren't you just trying to tell us sandroba was scum?

On July 22 2012 02:41 supersoft wrote:
6. Foolishness
10. Meapak_Ziphh
7. VisceraEyes
16. GGQ
15. syllogism

at least 2 of them are guaranteed scum, otherwise the setup makes no sense balancewise.

On July 22 2012 02:26 Katina wrote:
Why do you think I should be shot? You have yet to give any reasons to why you think I'm Mafia. You have done close to nothing this game besides popping in every now and then, and giving a brief hit and run then off again. You know who is known for hit and runs? Mafia, have you not seen the old Mafia movies??. Your uselessness this game has astounded me.

The same goes for Mattchew as well. Lack of contribution or care for find Mafia, close to no reads with almost no explanation or reasoning.

On July 20 2012 00:20 Palmar wrote:
I'm also reconsidering my stance on Katina being scum. I assumed she must be town because of how confrontational she was with me and foolishness. But for some reason she seemed to think Bugs was scum at one point (other most likely wrong reads in that list include supersoft and of course sandroba wtf.)

I have a hard time believing even she could be this wrong.

Also, I'm not included in that list. At the time I was active in the thread and there wasn't much interest in attacking me. I wonder if she forgot about me, or left me out due to popular opinion:



Looks like she remembered me later though, and funny enough, she remembered me at a time where I was not active in the thread at all, however, due to syllo's accusations, a few people had entertained the idea of me being scum.

perfect opportunity to slide me back into her suspicion list.



At least she fixed sandroba out this time. Popular opinion important right?

On July 22 2012 02:20 Palmar wrote:
I haven't caught up since last night. Did Chez ever claim messenger role?

On July 22 2012 03:21 supersoft wrote:
palmars performance so far is extremely poor that's true... However sandrobas scumrevealingpower makes one feel like it's unnecessary to analyze players.

On July 22 2012 03:21 supersoft wrote:
palmars performance so far is extremely poor that's true... However sandrobas scumrevealingpower makes one feel like it's unnecessary to analyze players.