|
As for the rest of your post. Townies can accidentally play scummy. You seem to base your point on that this would be false. Your defense is that you had substantial evidence. While that might be true it does not tell us you are not mafia. I honestly don't see how leading a case against a townie using substantial evidence is seen as pro-town play. The result is a mis-lynch. Now I do not claim that this makes him Mafia. I am saying to me, this does not clear him.
But we don't know he is townie. Saying that town players can accidentally act scummy as a defense of said players just gives mafia the chance to hide behind this sort of cover. So I don't agree with what you are saying here.
In fact, when I come to think of it. Hapa's whole case against Mackin is based on information which was available to you when you decided he has posted his stance and was fine. Feel free to prove Hapa wrong. Otherwise my point that you are actively pursuing townie point rather than actively pursuing lynch of suspicious of players.
Not true. It has been awhile since he said he would post freely, as Hapa pointed out. I did not know at the time it would be this long. He has since gone back to lurking, and only posting when prompted to, as pointed out by Hapa. His most recent substantial post now is about how he won't even defend himself, and how it's easy for blue players and detective confirmed townies to get by without posting much compared to how hard it is for him. He also seems to want to lynch me purely because I pressured him earlier. If he wants me lynched he should come up with a case, or at least address some of your points against me Evul. I think he has been hiding behind the newbie card this whole game.
As for Mackin's indecisiveness, yes, I let off at the time because he finally gave us his opinion on he is actually mafia. However, since then, he has not done much at all once the pressure is off. His lurking and refusal to post unless prompted (and even his most recent post effectively didn't say anything new) still makes him scummy to me.
If you still think I'm juggling cases then there's nothing I can say to change your mind I suppose.
WIth that, I will be voting Mackin. I think he's scum and I know I'm town, so I won't allow my lynch to go through.
##Vote: Mackin
|
With that I'm off to bed.
|
@ EvulRabbits - Its wroth mentioning that for every accusation/point of suspicion you have against BassinSpace, Mackin does it 100x worse.
|
On July 12 2012 22:25 The_Zen_Man wrote:
Correct me if i am wrong, but is there not one miller and one scum that show red for dt check. Therefore, there has to be a 50% chance for him being scum. Analysis is good, but it does not increace or decreace the percentage in any way. This means that there is a 50% chance for him being scum, not "way below" that, as the monkey above me stated.
It is not a 50/50 chance! *Foaming at the mouth*
Calling it 50/50 is a vast oversimplification of things, especially if he's acting pro town. He's either 100% mafia, or 100% miller. Based on his pro-town actions, what do you think is more likely?
|
|
|
Sorry marv, forgot the bold 
##Vote BassInSpace
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Vote Count
Mackin (3) - YourHarry, Hapahauli, BassinSpace
BassinSpace (3) - EvulRabbitz, YourHarry, The_Zen_Man, Mackin
YourHarry (1) - Lazermonkey, Hapahauli
Yet to vote: JingleHell
Currently Mackin is set to be lynched. Voting closes in a bit less than 6 hours.
|
Yo Jingle, where are you? Vote Mackin or YourHarry! kkthxbye.
|
##Unvote
##Vote BassinSpace
|
Surprising. I just have to lynch BassinSpace. If he's not it, I will have a hell of a time having to defend myself. Oh well. Even then, I think this is definitely good for town.
|
##Vote Bassinspace
I can't imagine in what world Lazer thinks I'm going to listen to him when he alternates between coercive and insulting every time he vomits forth more ego-ridden horse shit into the thread.
Regardless, kill the miller/scum now, and worry about aftermath later. If Bass is the miller, I'd call that a good time to start looking at who voted where again, and start to reconsider some of our basic premises we've been trying to work from.
|
We're bandwagoning a guy with pro-town behavior on the hope and prayer that he's mafia.
This is the last newbie game I'm ever playing. I hope for my sanity that you guys are right.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
Vote Count
Mackin (2) - YourHarry, Hapahauli, BassinSpace
BassinSpace (5) - EvulRabbitz, YourHarry, The_Zen_Man, Mackin, YourHarry, JingleHell
YourHarry (1) - Lazermonkey, Hapahauli
Currently BassinSpace is set to be lynched. Voting closes in a bit less than 5 hours.
|
On July 13 2012 05:01 Hapahauli wrote:
We're bandwagoning a guy with pro-town behavior on the hope and prayer that he's mafia.
This is the last newbie game I'm ever playing. I hope for my sanity that you guys are right.
If Bass isn't scum, I'd suggest you start looking closely at people who have tried to dominate the thread and control where people voted, tried to stop discussion they didn't like, tried to force reaction over thought, and made personal attacks against anyone who suggested thinking outside the box.
|
On July 13 2012 04:55 JingleHell wrote:
##Vote Bassinspace
I can't imagine in what world Lazer thinks I'm going to listen to him when he alternates between coercive and insulting every time he vomits forth more ego-ridden horse shit into the thread.
Regardless, kill the miller/scum now, and worry about aftermath later. If Bass is the miller, I'd call that a good time to start looking at who voted where again, and start to reconsider some of our basic premises we've been trying to work from. This is the most stupid thing I've read. I doesn't matter if you like me or not, but why zeh fuck do you vote Bass? Did you even read his filter? Did you even read Mackins/Harrys filter? How can you possibly come to the conclusion that he is the most likely scum?
|
On July 13 2012 05:11 JingleHell wrote:Show nested quote +On July 13 2012 05:01 Hapahauli wrote:
We're bandwagoning a guy with pro-town behavior on the hope and prayer that he's mafia.
This is the last newbie game I'm ever playing. I hope for my sanity that you guys are right. If Bass isn't scum, I'd suggest you start looking closely at people who have tried to dominate the thread and control where people voted, tried to stop discussion they didn't like, tried to force reaction over thought, and made personal attacks against anyone who suggested thinking outside the box.
In the mean time, let's hold hands, skip around in a circle, and lynch Bass when all analysis screams otherwise.
|
## Vote Mackin
Harry is my stronger read atm, but a lynch on him seems quite unlikely. Mackin is a 100x better lynch than Bass tho.
|
On July 13 2012 02:16 Hapahauli wrote:
Its wroth mentioning that for every accusation/point of suspicion you have against BassinSpace, Mackin does it 100x worse.
|
|
|
Jingle, I understand that you've stopped caring for this game a while ago, but don't ruin it for the rest of us.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
