|
That's cute and all trackdoor but it's kinda like dancing after the party is over.
If you had expressed something like this when it was needed you would indeed contribute to the discussion.
Now you just look like a cornered scum scraping for his life.
Anyway, as a golden mafia rule, when you state an opinion, provide your reasoning. If you don't you end up like this.
I'm gonna try to help you though. Give us your opinion on hawkins,zelblade and midnight. I expect something good if you are indeed town.
|
I'm surprised to see gum making coherent posts. And formated correctly! lol
These last posts about hawkings make me see him as scum as well. I'll add trackdoor on top of that.
Do you think we got good chanses for more scum in this case? Meaning 3/4 or even 4/4?
And what do you think of trackdoor? It's like everyone is avoiding him. Please share.
|
Oh fuck me sideways!
Gg DYH, gl next game, Q_Q.
Anyway, I wanna hear what sloosh and echellon have to say about DYH flipping green and how that affects their views if at all.
Regarding your hawkings case gum I agree. What do you think about my trackdoor one?
And lastly what about our lurkers? Schloe is posting scarcely and Janaan and Midnight have dropped their activity quite a bit in the last 2 days.
|
I agree on Trackdoor and Hawkins. Think we should push that. I have yet to see something solid on Midnight or Alderan.
Midnight that sort of super soft defense won't do you any good. Just look at DYH, lol(nice pic btw greymist, xP). You have to form relations with people so we can look on them when/if you die. That's what good town do. That's what DYH did when he realized that he was a goner.
What's your opinion on Sloosh?
|
Ok, so I read again these last few pages to try and get the big picture. Some posts did make sense about midnight. I had a soft town read on him until recently but I'm reevaluating now.
These are the posts I'm speaking of.
On February 21 2012 06:34 gumshoe wrote:+ Show Spoiler +On February 21 2012 05:34 MidnightGladius wrote:Show nested quote +On February 21 2012 05:27 Alderan wrote:On February 21 2012 05:19 MidnightGladius wrote: Alderan, your analysis isn't paired with any actual conclusions, and I have to respectfully disagree with the idea that town players shouldn't be inclined to share their cases and suspicions. Are you still getting town reads from DYH? You certainly don't seem intent on providing a defense. Your last sentence implies that your current scum read is trackdoor, but could you confirm that that is indeed the case?
Mattchew, those switches came in the context of an impending deadline, when I didn't know how many people were active, and the consensus formed quickly of pure necessity. The way I play, and the way I think the rest of the town should play, is you only defend those that you think are town if they are getting lynched. You will never see me make a large post about why someone is town. Ever. It's bad play and only helps mafia. Whoops, I thought that you had posted a town-read on DYH earlier. In that case, why aren't you voicing any opinions on him? Also, stop avoiding the actual question. In your opinion, who should we lynch today? Trackdoor? Midnight who do you think we should lynch today? I wanted to wait for your opinion earlier before voting but you sorta vanished and I ended up voting on DYH because I reasoned his death would tell us a lot (god I'm a hypocrite. Another thing, I have a concern, if DYH flips town tonight, that'll mean that two of our solid posters accused you and then died.
Very good find, but we should note that it's not something from which you can defend yourself against even if you are town. It adds up though, it adds up.
Another post,
On February 22 2012 12:40 Janaan wrote: EBWOP I'm comparing the way that DYH responded to literally being hours away from certain lynching, and the way you (Midnight) are reacting to being days away from possible lynching. DYH poured everything he had into the town when he only had hours. You're giving up, even though you have days to convince us you're not scum. It's just making you look scummier to me.
Janaan is making some good points here. When scum is close to be exposed they stop even fake-contributing to the town. They either go batshit crazy or go afk. That's what both Midnight and Hawkins are doing atm.
So, anyway, our best bet is to push for our best scum read. Atm that's Hawkins. Let's take it from there.
Oh and another note. I don't know why you people going heavy on Mattchew. He's just doing his best to win, granted a bit too much on the phrasing he uses. But focus on results please. If Hawkins flips scum tomorrow we will be back on track.
|
+ Show Spoiler +Um, a bit(ok a lot) out of loop here, but I wanna share with you mates. Guild wars 2 opened beta sign ups only for 48 hours, go and sign up!
|
On February 23 2012 05:45 trackd00r wrote: But I insist that TK is probably being manipulated by his team mates by the way he is playing.
Maybe perhaps there is more than a reason that TK is RQing.
Oh come on dude. That's even more bull coming out from you. And I'm not even talking about the obvious WIFOM logic in this.
You are taking as granted that Hawkings is scum. Ok, lets go with that. Do you realize that the hosts read the qt? If that would be just an elaborate plan from scum team, marshal wouldn't bus them, by posting this post
On February 22 2012 22:10 GMarshal wrote: Chill folks, just because I haven't been around to stomp on assholery, doesn't mean its ok to be an asshole.
Capish?
EDIT: This isn't actually aimed at anyone in particular, just a statement on the rampant hostility over the last 4 pages or so. Seriously people, mafia is a game, not a life or death affair, chill and stop going at each others throats. I'm looking at the lot of you
EDIT2: Don't discuss behavioral modkills publicly, if you think a player is out of line PM me the offending post or posts, and I'll ook at it, but don't try to use the hosts to influence the game.
His warning indicates that it was an honest rq by Hawkings, well If he was indeed scum, which I tend to also believe. Your posts are weak man.
|
And btw rofl. I just overlooked a HUGE SCUMSLIP!
How are you so sure that Hawkings is scum trackdoor? You didn't make a case ending it with "Hawkings is scum". You just made a completely random wifomly comment. Why did you treat Hawkings as if you already know his allingment?
And these questions are rhetorical. Don't bother to answer.
|
On February 23 2012 06:45 slOosh wrote:Wow this is really uncanny how Mattchew even pulled this one off. His four picks are (so far) good as individual cases. trackd00r: Show nested quote +On February 19 2012 08:35 trackd00r wrote: Lynch time is approaching. ET, I just hope that you keep posting good cases like that. Even though I disagree with MG lynch, your last posts are making up my mind. I'm going to unvote by now.
Show nested quote +On February 21 2012 05:29 trackd00r wrote: This was careless play by my part. I tried to push a ET lynch. Half an hour before the lynch, I realized that we were about to no-lynch. -I didn't want to hold my vote to ET because there were a couple of players that wouldn't change his vote to him by any means.
Contradiction! 1st quote: I am unvoting because he is making good cases / posts. 2nd quote: I unvoted because we couldn't lynch him on time. I'd auto vote you for this right here. Chance at redemption: Post your reads on MG and zel. They had better be good.
Woah nice find. How did I miss it in my case on him, T_T. Well with all these new elements his case is now stronger even than Hawkings' lol.
|
|
Ok ok, we need some reasoning here, don't panic, don't throw it all in the garbage, don't start going at each other again. Despite that midnight turned green I still think the cases we have on trackdoor and hawkings are strong enough to carry their own weight. The most logical thing to do is push these 2 now.
Pls start talking and sharing immediately.
Gg midnight and janaan, gl next game. T_T
|
Ima gonna sleep now as well, you americans take over pls, be active and share.
|
On February 18 2012 21:25 Steveling wrote:
Well after examining trackdoors filter
On February 18 2012 21:25 Steveling wrote:
Well after examining trackdoors
On February 18 2012 21:25 Steveling wrote:
Well after examining
On February 18 2012 21:25 Steveling wrote:
Well after
On February 18 2012 21:25 Steveling wrote: AFTER
If you are gonna go all DYH on me too, I don't know what else to say.
|
I think my quotations were pretty obvious to go into trouble to explain.
I hadn't yet filtered him obviously. I just had the impression of pro-town posting behavior. I made this case AFTER I filtered him and seen each post individually.
And anyway,besides that, how on earth are you ignoring trackdoors and hawkings cases to turn on me? What's the reason behind this turn?
I'm calling to your reasoning, you didn't listen to it on DYH case for which you said you took full responsibility and I didn't hold you accountable for that, because I reasoned things out. Do the same.
|
What is going on mate?
We just had bad luck with our vigi shooting maybe the only towny in the case and the scum getting lucky and shooting our vigi. There's nothing more, nothing less. We have 2 solid cases and we must go on with them.
|
I can not fathom how your reading "difficulties" are gonna cost us the game.
The amount of evidence against trackdoor and hawkins, is overwhelming and proportional to the mind boggling I suffer from, at the moment. There's not a single reason to drop their cases for me. And what's even more fascinating is that I have no case. You just didn't understand plain words.
|
Have you even read the cases on those two?
|
On February 23 2012 11:53 slOosh wrote: How can you approach today's lynch with such confidence?
Because I value cases. That's how. Do you know why I didn't believe Midnight was scum? Did you even read my filter? Because I said there wasn't a solid case against him. Only minor stuff.
The real question here is HOW CAN YOU vote for me above all when we are in MYLO situation. There's no solid case on me. There's not even a case. And you are skipping on two hard constructed cases for what?
If this was day one I wouldn't mind. But we will lose now, and we will lose because you are fixating on a comprehension error based on a 7 years old vocabulary. You are not making sense.
|
How can you even ask me that after all I said.
Let me make clear my opinion, anyone else except trackdoor and hawkings is suicide.
|
What happened to 1 lynch at a time. Just hours ago everyone thought of it like a gospel. Guess what changed with the double town killing tonight. Nothing. That's right. There are still four scum. We still have two solid cases.
It's 5am now but the worse thing is, I feel like nothing good came out of it. Cya tomorrow.
|
|
|
|