And yes, Im willing to side on occums razor, in that it would be extremely unlikely that the DT check him, and the killed him with deadshot protected with the intention of setting up this whole situation. but I want to know if its a possibility k?

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 22:29 GMT

#3849

lol wow, what a ninja that was, both saying Occums razor ^__^

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 22:30 GMT

#3851

no straws, just logic

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 22:39 GMT

#3854

good, glad your on board Adam, now we can move on to talking about which person we should lynch today based on all this info.

the Problem : both could be telling the truth.
the answer: lets lynch the one that is scum.

Could we have a discussion about motives and postings around both of them, seeing how this is a game of analysis? Im gonna read both there filter very carefully, then come back with some findings

would you mind doing the same? ^__^

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 22:44 GMT

#3856

lol, your right, what I meant to say is that both storys are plausible

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 23:04 GMT

#3863

rg, you have to realize that there are only 2 people up for lynch today; evan and JB.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 23:06 GMT

#3865

no, If JB is telling the truth, he will be dead tomorrow from a vig hit because he said he already got hit, remember?

Adam, you are not playing logically...

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 23:25 GMT

#3868

I gave you all plenty of time to kill me in the early game, I hell fucking asked for asked for it. Its not my fault that the vigs decide Im not worth the trouble, so now your stuck with me, because its most certainly LYLO. I did so because my work can go from chill to crazy busy without prior warning. There are many games I have played as town where I post little, and this is always the reason. My reads have been bad because I dont have the time to read everything as well as I should. Should I have asked for a replacement? maybe, but I wanted to play and I was hoping work would quite down so I could focus on this game. And besides, Im far from the most scummy lurker this game is infested with, so i dont feel to guilty.

If you cant understand why Its a lynch between Evan and JB, then I got nothing left to say... your ether dumb or scum.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 23:28 GMT

#3869

Im tired to Adam, so lets I wont fault you on that account

I too would like to hear what Forumite will say.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 19 2012 23:38 GMT

#3871

your right, touche Adam ^__^ Im liking that we are each others logical compass. oh and here is something everyone should look at:

On February 17 2012 19:35 VisceraEyes wrote:
You should not be shooting me tonight. You should be shooting hiro protagonist or JayBrundage tonight.

gonna take a nap, brb

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 01:24 GMT

#3889

And Im awake.

On February 20 2012 09:08 Forumite wrote:
Jay has allready been shot, and Evantrees hasn´t. I say we lynch jaybrundage, because he´s the most likely liar and because he won´t soak up more hits than anyone else. If jaybrundage flips Veteran, then I kill Evantrees. If jaybrundage flips scum then I either shoot Evantrees to confirm him, or try to aim for Town.

this seems to be the best course of action to take for the day. lets do it.

##Vote: Jaybrundage

Also Adam, Lets vote for scum, not forked tonged people. You cant argue with my logic anyway: lynching one of the claimers is the best move town can make today.

You know its true. And if you guy do something otherwise, well... thats just too funny for words.

Im off to+ Show Spoiler +

surprise!

work. see you after the lynch.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 01:33 GMT

#3891

On February 20 2012 08:40 Adam4167 wrote:
In a game that's seen more busses then a depot, you're going to point to a scum telling us to kill you as proof of your innocence?

Nah.

No.

call people out for lynches is one thing. it takes consensuses, and people can switch votes all the time. busing for someone by lynch is easy.

busing on a VIG shot... now Maybe one of me and JB is scum, but do you think VE would have the GAUL to call out a shot on 1 or 2 of his teammates when there are TONs of other scummy lurkers that are town? I think not.

WIFOM, I know, but I know my alignment as town, so I think it sheds some motivating factors on this statement: VE wanted Palmar to miss fire into town. This is just my opinion and I cant back this up, but I think JB is town.

with that, Im out.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 01:39 GMT

#3893

I would rather lynch someone I think is town than myself, because I Know Im town.
would you switch with me? I would rather lynch evan but it seems like most of you think Its JB thats lying. I have to go, so we need to make this decision in like, the next 5 min....

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 01:44 GMT

#3894

guess not. have fun guys

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 17:42 GMT

#3929

lol, wow. god I wish I was scum, because Im gonna look so dumb when I flip town. oh well.

This game is locked down for town. best course of action is for Forumite to shoot me tonight so you guys can figure out the last scum. I think its Katina at this point.

This is different than me randomly asking to be hit earlier in the game, I do think the best course of action is to shoot me tonight.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 21:53 GMT

#3944

yeah adam, I miss counted. shooting me is not optimal at this point.

hiro protagonist

1294 Posts

February 20 2012 22:02 GMT

#3948

Im not scum. i actually miss counted. sorry if you dont believe me.

I still think Katina would be one of the last scum, but Im not sure about anyone else...