EPTElection Mafia - Page 64
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
nyczbrandon
United States124 Posts
| ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
| ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
| ||
|
nyczbrandon
United States124 Posts
On December 15 2011 13:18 bumatlarge wrote: I'll apply for surgeon general. There is no reason to give this to scum, so we can assure ourselves at least one town medic with me in charge. I think there is some risk here applying for the position, since the secretary is a dangerous role for scumt o get into. hm wait who are you | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
Bum the reason we are going for Giygas and arct is that we are more sure than really any other person that they are town, due to the events that transpired around them. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
| ||
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
On December 15 2011 12:20 Radfield wrote: Well, so much for my protection.... Ok, so Arctocod for Secretary of Defence. Then the medic ability can be WIFOMed between the two of us. Someone who is very likely town in Surgeon General, probably Gigyas. I assume someone took a hit last night? On December 15 2011 12:45 Radfield wrote: Whoops, I read the Surgeon General wrong. He does not act as a medic himself, instead he makes a different player a medic with 2 protections. Not sure what the best play is there then. I'll think about it in the morning. Was your writing of both of these just an accident? You said that the ability could be WIFOM'ed between two people in a post before and then this one you say that you read it wrong. It seems that you already knew this. Giygas + Arcto are the obvious two picks for the positions. Arcto, your acting unlike you this last day. I'm not very happy that you killed Eiii without waiting to hear him respond. And with all of the elected other powers, like pardoner / mayor we agreed that it should be majority. Why is it so different here in Giygas ONLY asking you Arcto? I really think this was if nothing else stupid. Even if we have one person who is "for sure clean" which I think Arcto is, its stupid to only go off of his oppinion. I realize I havn't been here for this so I can't complain too much. But I'm really suprised in this. Why did you just decide to take this power just on yourself Arcto? We could have discussed more as a group who we wanted to vig shot and then went with that. I even posted before I went "Hey lets figure out who we should vig shot this night" and then it wasn't figured out as a group, but only as you two. I understand why you did this and its easy for me to judge, but still. | ||
|
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
On December 15 2011 12:31 Refallen wrote: I think Arc should be the secretary, since the surgeon role is probably simpler, and we don't even know what the SoD does. Probably Arc would be experienced enough to do a better job of the SoD. Also, now that prplhz is dead (and was clearly town in day 1 imo), what can we say about people who suspected him in day 1, which iirc included Sheth? The fact that I suspected Prplhz adds a slight percentage more that I could be mafia. It doesn't say anything more about me being town. Other people have had other false calls, like Eiii for instance. Or even as a group we did Spaackle. Those who suspected Prplhz or Eiii or xsksc have the same thing applied to them. Just a slightly higher chance there mafia. It only really means something if someone defends or really attacks someone who flips mafia. | ||
|
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
| ||
|
evantrees
Canada497 Posts
On December 15 2011 12:46 Refallen wrote: kind of doubt either list will be particularly helpful.The idea that the list of those who had voted for ProfBA to be pardoner has to have some mafia in it is something I've seen more than one person espousing in the thread so I just want to say that I completely disagree with this line of thinking right now. Firstly, as ProfBA has pointed out, he was the natural choice of pardoner after palmar/syllo votes were nulled. And he was even there at that time to immediately step up and say "I am the natural choice," something that I am sure many people agreed with. There is simply no reason for mafia to need to vote ProfBA to get him to office (note that I'm not actually saying that ProfBA is scum/town or anything, but just illustrating the fact that the idea that scum votes must be on ProfBA is false, since even if he was scum, the mafia didn't need to vote for him because of the lack of another viable candidate as well as ProfBA actively going for the pardoner role.) So no, if anything I think the Radfield list is more likely to contain scum. What do you guys think? given most of the ProfBA list is dead or GiygaS. ProfessorBadass (7): GreYMisT, xsksc, prplhz, GiygaS, -GiygaS, GiygaS, Eiii, Refallen, Radfield xsksc, prplh, Eiii dead that leaves ProfessorBadass (3): GreYMisT, Refallen, Radfield can't say I would be surprised if one of them was scum but have don't have any arguments for people being scum period yet and the Radfield list is a good bit longer. Radfield (12): risk.nuke, zeks, Jitsu, Spaackle, Comprissent, Eiii, Nisani201, MarserBlood, cascades, DropBear, Cwave, Liquid`Sheth, ProfessorBadass, DEUS-ex-MAFIA, -Eiii Spaackle, lynched Radfield (11): risk.nuke, zeks, Jitsu, Comprissent, Nisani201, MarserBlood, cascades, DropBear, Cwave, Liquid`Sheth, ProfessorBadass, DEUS-ex-MAFIA, and the others. DEUS-ex-MAFIA (1): TotallyNotTwoPeople TotallyNotTwoPeople (1): evantrees prplhz (1): Arctocod Arctocod (2); MrZentor ,nyczbrandon (the annoying one to get) | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
On December 15 2011 13:30 GreYMisT wrote: he is the replacement for dropbear. Bum the reason we are going for Giygas and arct is that we are more sure than really any other person that they are town, due to the events that transpired around them. Hmm ok, but I think we should be a bit aggressive with the second voting spot. It's a public rolecop check, so let's use it as such. It seems better to have someone we can deduce as mafia and not be able to lyncht the next day, rather then out a townie to prevent something that would never happen anyway. One of the two as surgeon general sounds superduper. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
I am going to put my vote down on Risk.Nuke for now. I have been mentioning the things wrong with his posts since midway through day one, and if you look back i posted a sample of his day1 analysis in newbie mini mafia, and compared it to his posting here. Not only does a drastic difference exist, but one that suggests a mafia agenda. In newbie mafia he was tasked with activly looking for scum, and his posting reflected that. on the other hand if he rolled mafia, he doesnt have to scum hunt, and that is reflected in his posts this game. Not to mention his refusal to provide reasoning behind his suspicions and thoughts. On another not we need to make sure arcto ends up as the elected official. I am fairly certain due to the events that have taken place yesterday, as well as due to his posting, that he is town. | ||
|
GreYMisT
United States6736 Posts
On December 15 2011 14:02 bumatlarge wrote: Hmm ok, but I think we should be a bit aggressive with the second voting spot. It's a public rolecop check, so let's use it as such. It seems better to have someone we can deduce as mafia and not be able to lyncht the next day, rather then out a townie to prevent something that would never happen anyway. One of the two as surgeon general sounds superduper. I was suggesting MrZentor for the time being because i do not have a better idea yet for the rolecheck, I am fine with another but i felt that putting Zentor there will confirm or deny a lot of the loose ends day1 left. | ||
|
Liquid`Sheth
United States2095 Posts
| ||
|
evantrees
Canada497 Posts
On December 15 2011 14:02 bumatlarge wrote: Hmm ok, but I think we should be a bit aggressive with the second voting spot. It's a public rolecop check, so let's use it as such. It seems better to have someone we can deduce as mafia and not be able to lyncht the next day, rather then out a townie to prevent something that would never happen anyway. One of the two as surgeon general sounds superduper. To clarify they get pardoned the day they are elected we can still lynch them the following day. Election winners/runner ups will be pardoned during the corresponding day lynch. "I think we should be a bit aggressive with the second voting spot. It's a public rolecop check, so let's use it as such." I feel a tad doubtful on how good of a alignment check it would be but definitely seems worth considering. its an alignment check not role check we want though isn't it, don't see how it would work as a role check. | ||
|
Arctocod
Norway251 Posts
| ||
|
Arctocod
Norway251 Posts
| ||
|
ProfessorBadass
94 Posts
| ||
|
ProfessorBadass
94 Posts
On December 15 2011 14:41 evantrees wrote: To clarify they get pardoned the day they are elected we can still lynch them the following day. "I think we should be a bit aggressive with the second voting spot. It's a public rolecop check, so let's use it as such." I feel a tad doubtful on how good of a alignment check it would be but definitely seems worth considering. its an alignment check not role check we want though isn't it, don't see how it would work as a role check. That's not how I interpreted it to work, it's a role with powers but you don't learn what it does until you get elected. Kita can you clarify? | ||
|
ProfessorBadass
94 Posts
| ||
| ||
