On December 15 2011 23:54 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
EBWOP : Just woke up, meant to say "If I said I'm getting a really scum read on Giygas would anyone know why?"

No, he is pretty much a confirmed townie

GiygaS

Canada1043 Posts

December 15 2011 15:27 GMT

#1313

I'm going to be gone fore the rest of the day, but I'm going to be rereading the thread, based off the info we now know. Info from this will come tonight.

Cwave

Netherlands313 Posts

December 15 2011 15:30 GMT

#1314

On December 16 2011 00:09 Arctocod wrote:

Show nested quote +

No, he is pretty much a confirmed townie

Herpederp, can you respond to my question about who you think are scum.
Who do you got a read/case on?

On December 15 2011 02:58 Arctocod wrote:
Probably Comprissent/Marserblood or Dropbear. Dropbear disappeared completely once the pressure was off and last time appeared quite quickly after being called out

This is the only active stance you take on who is red. Rest is "problaly green this, problaly green that".
Do you have any good solid reads on someone? Or are you gonna vote on Dropbear(bumatlarge)?

My vote stands on GiygaS for the election for now.

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

December 15 2011 15:35 GMT

#1315

Ok with the confirmation from kiyamsn that the runner up does recieve a unique power, we should defiantly elect Giygad into that position. The reason for this is because, as I said before, he has already announced his role. Therefor, the potential drawback that his role would be revealed to the mafia is null, as it already has been. Arcto should still be elected in the 1st position because he has not yet revealed his role, and that happening could be detrimental to the town (although he is already a pretty big target if his hit claim is true.)

Arctocod

Norway251 Posts

December 15 2011 15:39 GMT

#1316

On December 16 2011 00:35 GreYMisT wrote:
Ok with the confirmation from kiyamsn that the runner up does recieve a unique power, we should defiantly elect Giygad into that position. The reason for this is because, as I said before, he has already announced his role. Therefor, the potential drawback that his role would be revealed to the mafia is null, as it already has been. Arcto should still be elected in the 1st position because he has not yet revealed his role, and that happening could be detrimental to the town (although he is already a pretty big target if his hit claim is true.)

What are you talking about? Where did everyone get the idea that Secretary of Defense's role will be announced in public? All it says is that no one will know what the position does until elections are over, and even then only the person elected into that position will be told about it.

Your role will be revealed to you upon election!

Giygas should be the Surgeon General

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

December 15 2011 15:48 GMT

#1317

On December 16 2011 00:39 Arctocod wrote:

Show nested quote +

Giygas should be the Surgeon General

Ah I see, I misinterpreted the way it works. That makes a ton more sense now. In any case, I still believe the election should go to both you and Giygas, but now that I know there is no role reveal, I am torn on if you would be better in the second spot due to its potential. Do you believe Giygas can accurately use the surgeon generals powers?

GreYMisT

United States6736 Posts

December 15 2011 15:48 GMT

#1318

EBWOP: use his powers "effectively"

zeks

Canada1068 Posts

December 15 2011 15:52 GMT

#1319

On December 15 2011 21:06 Jitsu wrote:
Somethings I would like to note on.
MrZentor claimed blue role yesterday, but never really came out and said what it was after it became "useless." Not sure what the role was/could have been, but when he was called on it, I think he just ignored the post and faded out?

I would like to see Arcto/GigyaS for the new selections. My reasoning? We are all pretty much aware that GigyaS is town, because of his role. The question was is Arcto playing the role of town up? It could be possible. I believe Arcto is town, at least right now. So at this point, they will be getting my two roles for elections.

From what has been said by Zentor it is suggested he was unlynchable only on day 1? Then he ignored my question

Arcto withdrawing from election is enough of a reason for me to feel he's town
Before that he was going to be pardoner uncontested if he were scum why would he need to pull a stunt like that?

GigyaS for his role should be town

All the surgeon general does is GRANT power to someone so all he gets is the ability to handpick a medic

Whereas secretary of defense sounds like it has bigger potential