I don't think the claim was that anti-town as the scum motivation for it was very weak. Of course, if you correctly assume that many townies will not realize that, then it was anti-town. Ineffective? Yes.

Drazerk

United Kingdom31255 Posts

December 18 2011 22:23 GMT

#3364

On December 19 2011 07:20 wherebugsgo wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't understand, what blunder did you commit day 1 that forced you to make a ludicrous fake claim?

My entire day 1 was a blunder

wherebugsgo

Japan10647 Posts

December 18 2011 22:25 GMT

#3365

On December 19 2011 07:22 syllogism wrote:
I don't think the claim was that anti-town as the scum motivation for it was very weak. Of course, if you correctly assume that many townies will not realize that, then it was anti-town. Ineffective? Yes.

I disagree, but I'll touch on this in my analysis.

It was actually very anti-town because he drew a medic protect n1 that should have been going to you, Palmar, or Radfield.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

December 18 2011 22:27 GMT

#3366

On December 19 2011 07:25 wherebugsgo wrote:

Show nested quote +

I disagree, but I'll touch on this in my analysis.

It was actually very anti-town because he drew a medic protect n1 that should have been going to you, Palmar, or Radfield.

Well yes that was bad, forgot about that. The medic shouldn't have protected him, but can't really fault him for that.

Risen

United States7927 Posts

December 18 2011 22:35 GMT

#3367

Well I for one, had a freakin' blast playing :D

Jackal58

United States4264 Posts

December 18 2011 22:36 GMT

#3368

A bit of advice for the hosts. If you are running a game that has had the time constraints removed from it don't post the day post seconds after mafia sends in their night actions. When Incog did that I knew that town had no night actions remaining.
All I had to do was hope for a vote on somebody that wasn't me at that point. It wasn't really fair to town. You should have waited an hour or two before posting. At least call for night actions. You outed town.

Risen

United States7927 Posts

December 18 2011 22:37 GMT

#3369

On December 19 2011 07:36 Jackal58 wrote:
A bit of advice for the hosts. If you are running a game that has had the time constraints removed from it don't post the day post seconds after mafia sends in their night actions. When Incog did that I knew that town had no night actions remaining.
All I had to do was hope for a vote on somebody that wasn't me at that point. It wasn't really fair to town. You should have waited an hour or two before posting. At least call for night actions. You outed town.

Couldn't town have sent theirs in and they were actually waiting on you?

So many points in this game had me laughing my ass off. Palmar's valiant stand was one of the better points I've had playing Mafia ((I've played a whopping 3 games >.>))

Jackal58

United States4264 Posts

December 18 2011 22:40 GMT

#3370

On December 19 2011 07:37 Risen wrote:

Show nested quote +

Night post - My hit - Day post. inside of 6 minutes or so. Nobody posting in the game at the time. Hyshes had a post about 45 minutes before the night post. I knew what it meant.

vaderseven

United States2556 Posts

December 18 2011 22:48 GMT

#3371

Ya I noticed that the fast night prolly ment that a smart mafai would know that means I had no action.

Barbiero

Brazil5259 Posts

December 18 2011 22:49 GMT

#3372

Things to do on a next game.

* Actually listen to logic, not feelings
* Actually scumhunt properly
* Analyze cases by their words, not by their author and specially not by the author's moves

Scum floridian is BS imo

But I don't think the game was imbalanced at all. Well, who am I to say anything about it.

GGWP.

xsksc

United Kingdom1044 Posts

December 18 2011 22:52 GMT

#3373

On December 19 2011 07:49 Zephirdd wrote:
Things to do on a next game.

* Actually listen to logic, not feelings
* Actually scumhunt properly
* Analyze cases by their words, not by their author and specially not by the author's moves

Scum floridian is BS imo

But I don't think the game was imbalanced at all. Well, who am I to say anything about it.

GGWP.

Happy birthday

Barbiero

Brazil5259 Posts

December 18 2011 22:56 GMT

#3374

Thanks ^^

VisceraEyes

United States21171 Posts

December 18 2011 23:27 GMT

#3375

gg guys, I can't believe Jackal pulled it out for us after 83% of our team outted in 1 fell swoop.

Jackal58

United States4264 Posts

December 18 2011 23:29 GMT

#3376

Pure luck man.

Refallen

452 Posts

December 18 2011 23:48 GMT

#3377

Hahaha, this was a really fun first game guys!

I think the reason for so many bad plays was because of night/day ending at timezones which were not convenient for most of the players...

Anyway, feedback for my play is appreciated.

Refallen

452 Posts

December 18 2011 23:49 GMT

#3378

On December 19 2011 07:27 syllogism wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well yes that was bad, forgot about that. The medic shouldn't have protected him, but can't really fault him for that.

Also, my bad, I protected Drazerk night 1 haha.

Curu

Canada2817 Posts

December 19 2011 00:02 GMT

#3379

On December 19 2011 06:47 hyshes wrote:
Maybe i'm a bit inactive, but v7 is to blaim.

And in no hell this game was town-favored. You give up 5 out of 6 scum for free and you can still win?

lol that's a joke. If any of the capable Town players had survived (or had anyone even listened to them) Town likely had an overwhelming victory.

I was talking with syllogism and we were able to establish Jackal as scum and redFF as Town in the first like 10 pages. You had Radfield and syllo pointing out how scummy Jackal was, you had Radfield AND syllo AND Palmar all telling you that annul was 100% scum. You had Toadesstern saying ridiculous shit like"I think annul is Mafia but since vaderseven said he is Town I will listen to vaderseven" which is basically CLAIMING MAFIA.

The last minute switch to redFF I think is the worst play I have ever seen out of a Town in the history of Mafia games. It's hilarious how the three best players in the game all accuse annul and all die and almost the entire scum team was bussing annul when he first came under pressure and Town still refused to lynch him.

annul

United States2841 Posts

December 19 2011 00:15 GMT

#3380

bottom line is the 2 KP coupled with the fact we had NO offense coupled with the fact town had a full medic, 2 shot vig, JAILKEEPER, and a jack, meant it was crazy imba.

we had to play perfectly to get a chance to win. we did. our last minute plans worked. we held jackal back knowing of the floridian powers that town had no idea we had.