We can't worry about uselessness when it is possibly LYLO, and barring the way this resolves tonight, I wouldn't be surprised if we had lost. We need to be worried about who isn't town, not who is "useful". You aren't really being useful either, with your unfounded accusations which are not only misleading but falsities and lies.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

February 21 2011 07:17 GMT

#1084

you seem mighty edgy there. First you give an excuse to being inactive as if that excuses you for poor play, and now you say I'm bringing up unfounded accusations which are misleading (who?) but falsities and lies.

What falsities have and lies sir? Where - point them out. The game has been going on for how many days and you're exhibiting the same behavior from Day 1.

So once again I'm going to ask - where are your contributions to the town winning?

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 09:43 GMT

#1085

My contribution lies through the fact that I am voting people properly, based upon them messing up illogically where it would be logical for town to not mess up. I feel as if your unfounded accusations lie through the likelihood that you, yourself, flipped scum, and are trying to derail a thread in which you're dead in.

You then begin to attack me as opposed to my words, calling me "jumpy", when I am in fact not jumpy whatsoever. You say I exhibited the same information I did Day 1? Probably because I'm the same role, with the same information.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

February 21 2011 09:47 GMT

#1086

Everyone alive should roleclaim after the day post.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

February 21 2011 09:51 GMT

#1087

role list is hidden and no role reveals. Don't know how much that will help them to solve anything :/

pevergreen

Australia252 Posts

February 21 2011 10:59 GMT

#1088

Martok brought together the five survivors.

"We were lucky, no one died last night."

As he said that, chaoser broke into spasms and died quickly.

"Well, 'khaan died. Still, no loss. Continue as usual, but at this rate we'll all be dead tomorrow."

Alive: 4/30
SiNiquity
gryffindor
Beefy187
GMarshal

Lynched: 6/30
zerroth (Strike for the South)
Misder (Csargo)
GGQ (a completely inoffensive name)
Mr. Wiggles (Seamus Fermanagh)
thefluffyone93 (Sasaki Kojiro)
Insanious (Crazed Rabbit)

Killed: 12/30
bumatlarge (TheSpartan)
Ace (TinCow)
kitaman27 (pevergreen)
Node (Askthepizzaguy)
BrownBear (Gregoshi)
why (Andres)
Coagulation (TosaInu)
aidnai (Kagemusha)
Believer (Beirut)
JBright (Renata)
deconduo (GeneralHankerchief)
chaoser (Yaseikhaan)

Suicided out of despair: 1/30
LunarDestiny (Louis VI the Fat)

Wrath of God: 7/30
me_viet (Omanes)
ELITECubWarman8 (Centurion1)
SouthRawrea (Glenn)
Johnhughthom (Sigurd)
Project Psycho (Kommodus)
darmousseh (atheotes)
ilovejonn (Beefy187)

If you fail to vote in any round from now on, you will be modkilled

It is now Day 6. Day will end at Tuesday, Feb 22 11:00am GMT (GMT+00:00)

gryffindor

United States524 Posts

February 21 2011 11:19 GMT

#1089

So, from my perspective, GMarshal is my town read.
Considering there were only 2 kills, I'm guessing the SK is dead.
That means either SiNiquity or Beefy is town, and the one who isn't is the Godfather.
If it's 3v1, like I expect, the proper play is to no lynch as it is MYLO
if it is 2v1v1, with the mafia and the SK still left, having cross-killed, we are fucked
In that scenario, it would be best to no lynch hoping they try to kill each other, leaving us in proper-LYLO tomorrow.

This shouldn't even really be a discussion, because we can't no lynch, so look at my aforementioned points that GMarshal is pretty clear through my eyes via his behavior towards me in PMs. I am not familiar with Beefy's play, but I have to say that I have not really seen SiNiquity ever try this hard, and it has me up in arms. I really feel like he is the most likely to be the last scum.

Vote: SiNiquity

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

February 21 2011 12:25 GMT

#1090

There was one kill so SK is still out there, Insanious was GF obviously. Its mylo so vote no lynch today to better the odds.

GMarshal

United States22154 Posts

February 21 2011 12:35 GMT

#1091

On February 21 2011 21:25 deconduo wrote:
There was one kill so SK is still out there, Insanious was GF obviously. Its mylo so vote no lynch today to better the odds.

Except no lynch isn't a possibility, also in my opinion we did hit the SK and the GF is still alive, he just payed attention to one of my hints, in which I suggested that he *had* to only kill one person in case we had missed the SK with the lynch. Its also possible that someone had a vet like ability and absorbed a hit, which would confirm them as town (if so, then claim right away).

At the very least this clears chaoser as a possible suspect.

I'm not sure of who among the remaining players is scum, however as soon as I am done with this pesky physics exam I'll go ahead and take a closer look

Oh, by the way beefy is Chaotix.

GMarshal

United States22154 Posts

February 21 2011 12:39 GMT

#1092

On February 21 2011 21:25 deconduo wrote:
There was one kill so SK is still out there, Insanious was GF obviously. Its mylo so vote no lynch today to better the odds.

Also, if you are wrong and we did hit the SK and the GF is still left alive then that guarantees him the win. No, we *have* to lynch today.

Insanious

Canada1251 Posts

February 21 2011 12:48 GMT

#1093

Also, GF could of hit SK and SK could be immune to night hits... meaning GF did hit, just hit the wrong person.

Now the funny thing is, if GF and SK role claimed... two would chose who won.

Lynch GF, SK kills 1 town = 1 sk and 1 town (tie).

Lynch SK, GF kills 1 town = GF wins...

But

Lynch town = 1 sk 1 gf 1 town

night would be a massacre with either gf winning or sk (sk can win if immune to night hits)

fun end game scenario.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

February 21 2011 12:50 GMT

#1094

Yah I misread the rules, you can't no lynch. Hmm tough one then, I was pretty certain with insanious.

At this point I think its time to lynch GMarshal. He's the only veteran TL player that wasn't killed which speaks volumes.

In addition, beefy pointed out that in .org games, the SK gets a night kill and a rolecheck, which would also point towards GMarshal.

deconduo

Ireland4122 Posts

February 21 2011 12:52 GMT

#1095

Of the others, gryffindor is the scummiest. Sinquity and beefy haven't done enough for me to get a read on them. Going over the game I think GMarshal is who to hit however.

GMarshal

United States22154 Posts

February 21 2011 13:58 GMT

#1096

On February 21 2011 21:50 deconduo wrote:
Yah I misread the rules, you can't no lynch. Hmm tough one then, I was pretty certain with insanious.

At this point I think its time to lynch GMarshal. He's the only veteran TL player that wasn't killed which speaks volumes.

In addition, beefy pointed out that in .org games, the SK gets a night kill and a rolecheck, which would also point towards GMarshal.

I hate to tell you but if I were the GF the last person I would have killed would have been chaoser, as he was the one being pointed out as mafia before the day ended, I think whoever killed him made a stupid move, but then again it does set me up as the last surviving TL mafia "vet" (I don't consider myself a veteran by any means, but thanks)

beefy187

Japan39 Posts

February 21 2011 14:02 GMT

#1097

Vote: gryffindor

gryffindor has lived for too long. I believe he is the last surviving baddy and he must be lynched.

GMarshal

United States22154 Posts

February 21 2011 14:03 GMT

#1098

Actually I just did a quick post search with the words SiNiquity and mafia as search terms, it looks like I'm not the only TL player with experience left...

(For reference PYP2, XXXI and XXXVI, I knew the name seemed familiar)