Insane Mafia - Page 160

On November 06 2010 10:22 infinitestory wrote:

bottom of page 155

it says that Lexpar's role is Careful Doctor, which will die if he protects a red
Lexpar stated that if he died night 1, then DrH is red... which means Lexpar probably protected DrH and survived

On November 06 2010 10:23 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

i thought either you or pandain were mafia on day 2 when my poke didn't come through

I'm more inclined to believe that you were mafia based on the posting but when you claimed DT and got coagulation killed I rejected the notion until I realized it is an easy bus and you did absolutely nothing to confirm your role and there are things about your roleclaim that make me think its more likely a lie than the truth

like the rng check and the 1/4th chance versus 10%, it's inconsistent with the other known ADD role in the game

not to mention it's awfully convenient that the results returned were the roles and alignments of a player any mafia would know whether or not he had DT powers, you had no information that every mafia didn't already have just information town didn't necessarily have

On November 06 2010 10:24 DCLXVI wrote:
Wow so DocH says:
"I.S. is my #1 suspect"
--why?
"Wait, let me read through his posts to find out"
He faked his role by offering up another mafia teammate, sure. The way someone becomes #1 suspect is to find mafia.
What is this shit?

On November 06 2010 10:24 infinitestory wrote:

the only reason it was 1/4 is because it randomly selects a member from the game
at the time (beginning of night 2), there were 7 reds and 21 blues
hence, probability of finding a red is 7/28 = 1/4

On November 06 2010 10:25 DoctorHelvetica wrote:


you said it had a 1/4th chance of failure if i am remembering correctly

do you not remember the way the role you faked works?

On November 06 2010 10:28 LunarDestiny wrote:
So infinitestory fake claim to kill coag? Damn, that is some high level mafia play...

Shouldn't we keep it real, and play with logic.

On November 06 2010 10:58 youngminii wrote:

wait what

changing my vote to coag

On November 06 2010 10:58 youngminii wrote:

wait what

changing my vote to coag

We need someone who is good at mafia but terrible at manipulation.

pandain is probably the best candidate under these parameters. he is an extremely organized and tactical scum hunter his analyses skills are good and he has a good level head about what needs to be done.

i have also noticed that he is a terrible lier and his posting style makes his motives extremely transparent. this would make it much easier for us to spot a slip up if he is mafia. and greatly increases the chances that he would fail at getting away with scum moves if it turns out he is a red.

DocH You basically said YOU WILL PROVE your town and then basically said "MAYBE DEPENDING ON WHAT HAPPENS I WILL PROVE IT IM NOT SURE"

I dont think pandain would be the greatest mayor
However
i would rather pandain then Annul and his manipulation if he is RED
and i would rather pandain then fishbowl and his "EXTREMELY SHY?? circle"
I would really really like for you to make me feel comfortable voting for you for mayor. but your doing a bad job so far.

Now i am sticking with pandain because he is most likely not a red trying to gain control of town based on the fact that he is not campaigning relentlessly.


Pandain is more then capable of using what tools he has at his disposal to help coordinate a good town strategy and i doubt he would run for mayor if he thought his role wasnt capable of contributing greatly as mayor.. and I FEEL HE is the most TRUSTWORTHY candidate so far BASED ON HIS ACTIONS IN THIS GAME. I Dont get the same feeling from you when your Threatening "FOS" On anyone that doesnt vote you..


IM NOT VOTING on WHOS PROMISING SOME BULLSHIT IF THEY GET MAYOR (town circle?? where??)
IM VOTING ON WHO I TRUST THE MOST IN MY GUT

IS THAT REASON ENOUGH?

Dodging a lynch sounds alot like a scum role.. anyone else think so?

OK i have caught up on reading

1. DOCH naturally I still cant trust you 100% until I can see some of your claims of verifying yourself come to light. I really hope your not a red otherwise we may as well just bend over and let you get to fucking.

2. you have a moron for a bodyguard

3. Node is asking for invites to the circle? i would think twice before letting people who request in. looks like 1 red was already in the circle. he dies and now Node starts asking to get in?(could be mafia trying to get a man back inside)
looks bad but not gonna dwell on it too much yet..

4. pandain I dunno what the hell you are talking about. Im not gonna keep my mouth shut if someone looks scummy just because they are not around to defend themselves.

dt needs to investigate pandain for sure considering he was running for mayor.

also the other people who wanted elected mayor
bumatlarge
fishball
annul
ghrur
glasse
node

also worth keeping an eye on node who is asking for people to invite him into circle.

well regardless we need to get to the bottom of the youngminii thing somehow i think thats the point hes trying to make. i still feel like there is a good possibility that his ability is either a red ability or he was saved by a red allie. i dont want this to just blow under the radar

@Glasse
no your right. for the most part however your "cat like" actions are more along the lines of when the cat shits in your sock drawer. the sock drawer being this thread.

On November 06 2010 11:02 Nemesis wrote:

WTF, you were planning to change your vote to coag after learning that Mad Hatter will lose their bomb if coag is lynched?

On November 06 2010 11:02 Hyperbola wrote:

















Not sure if anybody analyzed Coagulation's post history extensively before, but now that he's flipped scum I believe it's worthwhile. I did not quote all of his posts but I did quote all relevant to my conclusions. Also Coag got the 1337 post.

Ok so solely based off of Coagulation's post history I've discerned the following.

1. Pandain is almost certainly scum (common opinion at this point). Coagulation supports Pandain all throughout his election and shits on the other candidates. I only quoted some of his posts but he has maaany in support of Pandain.

2. Doctor Helvetica is almost certainly innocent. Coagulation spent the entire thread accusing DocH. If he was a fellow scum then Coagulation, as the prime accuser, might have single handedly caused DocH to get lyched due to all of his attacks. Thus, the probability is low.

3. Youngminii is almost certainly town. Coag again attacks him repeatedly throughout the thread and always tries to draw attention to him.

4. Node is probably innocent and not lying. Although I thought he was suspicious before, Node's credibility is questioned by Coag more than once in the thread.

5. Glasse is probably town aligned. He badmouths Glasse a few times in the thread. Not very strong but there's nothing on Glasse to prove otherwise.

On November 06 2010 11:06 infinitestory wrote:


just at a glance, one major thing wrong is that if X shows animosity towards Y, that doesn't mean X and Y are opposite alignments. Same if X shows support for Y, that doesn't mean they're the same alignment. This is especially relevant for points 4 and 5 IMO

On November 06 2010 11:11 Hyperbola wrote:

I actually considered this. Not to be insulting to Coagulation, but I didn't think him the type of player to use reverse logic as you are suggesting. As for number 4, he has a decent amount of posts against Node to discourage him from joining the mailman circle and questions his credibility. I don't think someone would do that as reverse psychology for a role as sensitive as Node's.