EPTI want to see if he is going to respond. For now, I still request a 1-game ban.
TL Mafia Ban List - Page 172
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Corazon
United States3230 Posts
I want to see if he is going to respond. For now, I still request a 1-game ban. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
| ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25552 Posts
The point I'm trying to make is that this isn't about "did his play make the game worse for others" or even "did his play personally inconvenience Cora and cause the game to end quickly" but rather "was he playing maliciously" if we ban people for playing poorly, but not maliciously, that's just brutal and vindictive. we all have bad games. If he was trying to troll, though, or trying to make the game unplayable for his scum teammate, and had malicious intent, then he absolutely deserves a ban. I can't imagine a situation where he deserves a warning. Either he played maliciously or he didn't-- if he played maliciously, he shoudl be banned. If he didn't play maliciously, then it doesn't matter that it inconvenienced you personally, he doesn't deserve a punishment. It's also worth noting his scum teammate, the one besides him who was alive in the game, doesn't seem to think he should be banned, but really it's up to you to say "the guy acted maliciously and should be banned" or "the guy didn't act maliciously, and although his poor play dicked things up for his team, he does not deserve any punishment" no middle ground. he was malicious or he wasn't. | ||
|
Alakaslam
United States17336 Posts
| ||
|
s0Lstice
United States1832 Posts
Not trying to throw anyone under the bus here, but I'd say Z-B did this. Anything can happen in mafia...even with spectacular town play, a scum team can fight back with persistence and skill. Being outed in thread by posting the scum QT was totally unfair for the rest of the scum team imo. Concession is a TEAM decision. It's one thing for an individual scum member to screw up and out himself, but quite another to betray the identity of the remainder of his team without their consent. It doesn't matter whether rayn wanted to play it out or not...it matters that he didn't even get to make that choice. I see this as playing against ones wincon. However small, the rest of the scum team could have won, and hence also give Z-B a win. His actions definitively ended the game for his team...he chose a zero percent chance to win over a non-zero percent chance to win. | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25552 Posts
| ||
|
s0Lstice
United States1832 Posts
| ||
|
Hapahauli
United States9305 Posts
On July 27 2013 17:10 Blazinghand wrote: I thought the situation was he posted the scum QT to the thread after he already claimed scum + rayn scum with him to a member of the town? I suppose that's probably like warnworthy or something. Pretty much this. Resigning the game without consulting your scum-team member would be ban-worthy normally. However in this case, I think a warn would suffice since the scum-team was 99.9999% screwed, and that his scumbuddy (Rayn) seems not to mind the decision, | ||
|
marvellosity
United Kingdom36161 Posts
| ||
|
iamperfection
United States9644 Posts
| ||
|
Corazon
United States3230 Posts
Good to know everyone supports sharing scum QTs and making all of my work go to basically nothing. | ||
|
Acrofales
Spain18077 Posts
On July 27 2013 22:56 cDgCorazon wrote: Fine then. I request him to get a warning then. Good to know everyone supports sharing scum QTs and making all of my work go to basically nothing. Well, he'd already claimed the team to a townie. So Rayn would have had to play mindblowingly fantasticularly to even survive the next lynch after ZBo's death, let alone survive 2 or 3 (don't know how the balance works out) subsequent lynches. While I don't support an undiscussed surrender, I don't see how Rayn could have won that game, so /shrug. As for when posting scumQT is a good thing: check out the last PTP (and my nomination of austin for his claim). Posting your scumQT in the thread: the new TL Mafia meta? :D | ||
|
WaveofShadow
Canada31495 Posts
On July 24 2013 13:59 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote: Requesting a ban for DrH. Ragequit Sicilian over minor BS and after a day of inactivity confirmed his rage quit via PM. I find this unacceptable to sign up for a game and rage quit and therefore ruining the game for other players. Did essentially the same thing in Bluelightz's game. | ||
|
Blazinghand
United States25552 Posts
On July 27 2013 22:56 cDgCorazon wrote: Fine then. I request him to get a warning then. Good to know everyone supports sharing scum QTs and making all of my work go to basically nothing. I don't feel like the two options here are "ban Z-B" and "I love it when people post scum QTs and make Cora unhappy"-- you yourself said you were on the fence and were considering a warning, right? I don't think surrendering without consulting your teammate is something that should be encouraged so a warning is appropriate, but Z-B did nothing malicious, On July 27 2013 23:44 WaveofShadow wrote: Did essentially the same thing in Bluelightz's game. Man that's very unlike DrH. I hope the dude is doing OK. Before he went afk for a while he afked out of a game I was hosting as well. | ||
|
FirmTofu
United States1956 Posts
This is deserving of a warning, but not a ban. | ||
|
Ange777
Germany1164 Posts
 | ||
GMarshal
United States22154 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On July 29 2013 02:35 GMarshal wrote: Consensus seems to be warning, and that seems reasonable, because posting excepts from the scum qt, no matter how desperate the situation, is playing against his wincondition. Tell that to Austinmcc  It won him a game. | ||
|
Bluelightz
Indonesia2463 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + On July 23 2013 22:44 cDgCorazon wrote: Oats if you're going to act like an asshole, you might as well just not say anything at all. On July 23 2013 22:49 phagga wrote: Please stop the insults. Now. Next, for the other replacements; god. Zephirdd I think deserves to get off without a punishment because he replaced out early enough to not mess with any discussion (although votecounts... hrmmm!). Austin had a plausible reason to replace out, no punishment I guess. jrkirby should get a warning for activity though this is debatable. I think this is it? | ||
|
IMCaptainJackSparrow
Bahamas303 Posts
I'm Corazon btw...I smurf-slipped in Titanic so it doesn't matter anymore lol | ||
| ||
