• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 18:06
CEST 00:06
KST 07:06
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Tournament Spotlight: FEL Cracow 20259Power Rank - Esports World Cup 202577RSL Season 1 - Final Week9[ASL19] Finals Recap: Standing Tall15HomeStory Cup 27 - Info & Preview18
Community News
[BSL 2025] H2 - Team Wars, Weeklies & SB Ladder0EWC 2025 - Replay Pack1Google Play ASL (Season 20) Announced25BSL Team Wars - Bonyth, Dewalt, Hawk & Sziky teams10Weekly Cups (July 14-20): Final Check-up0
StarCraft 2
General
#1: Maru - Greatest Players of All Time EWC 2025 - Replay Pack Tournament Spotlight: FEL Cracow 2025 Power Rank - Esports World Cup 2025 I offer completely free coaching services
Tourneys
FEL Cracov 2025 (July 27) - $10,000 live event Esports World Cup 2025 $25,000 Streamerzone StarCraft Pro Series announced $5,000 WardiTV Summer Championship 2025 WardiTV Mondays
Strategy
How did i lose this ZvP, whats the proper response
Custom Maps
External Content
Mutation # 484 Magnetic Pull Mutation #239 Bad Weather Mutation # 483 Kill Bot Wars Mutation # 482 Wheel of Misfortune
Brood War
General
[BSL 2025] H2 - Team Wars, Weeklies & SB Ladder Google Play ASL (Season 20) Announced [Update] ShieldBattery: 2025 Redesign Dewalt's Show Matches in China BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL20] Non-Korean Championship 4x BSL + 4x China CSL Xiamen International Invitational [CSLPRO] It's CSLAN Season! - Last Chance
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers [G] Mineral Boosting Does 1 second matter in StarCraft?
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Total Annihilation Server - TAForever [MMORPG] Tree of Savior (Successor of Ragnarok) Path of Exile
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
UK Politics Mega-thread US Politics Mega-thread Stop Killing Games - European Citizens Initiative Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Russo-Ukrainian War Thread
Fan Clubs
INnoVation Fan Club SKT1 Classic Fan Club!
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [\m/] Heavy Metal Thread Movie Discussion! [Manga] One Piece Korean Music Discussion
Sports
2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 NBA General Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Installation of Windows 10 suck at "just a moment" Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
TeamLiquid Team Shirt On Sale The Automated Ban List
Blogs
Ping To Win? Pings And Their…
TrAiDoS
momentary artworks from des…
tankgirl
from making sc maps to makin…
Husyelt
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Eight Anniversary as a TL…
Mizenhauer
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 691 users

An Asteroid Shield - Page 2

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next All
micronesia
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States24676 Posts
March 14 2013 00:18 GMT
#21
On March 14 2013 08:58 FiWiFaKi wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 14 2013 08:52 Jonoman92 wrote:
On March 14 2013 08:06 Ettick wrote:
I think this is definitely something that should be looked into more deeply since asteroids can cause terrible, terrible damage to civilization. Imagine if an asteroid the size of New York hit the earth. Everyone would be fucked.


Well yeah, but if that is in the stars to happen, as they say, then we can't do anything about it anyway. GL having any effect on anything that big.

While I don't think there is necessarily a right or wrong decission to be made, I think we should accept there are some things we can't do anything about. I'm not as well educated on the topic as you, but I think resources would be better spent elsewhere, even just making a global pool fund to help in the aftermath of meteor (if someone corrects me that I'm using this word wrong I will cut you) strikes. Assuming it's not on the magnitude of zomg Armageddon type strike ofc.


Exactly, just how if a black hole happened nearby our solar system, we would be fucked, and there's nothing we could do about it, we are not at a point where we can afford to be doing something like this to worry about such a petty cause, of a few people dying once a decade.

Statisticl hippos are responsible for more deaths that meteors, maybe focus on solving those issues first?

I think you would benefit from doing some research on the topic as I am doing. From your first post:

"If we find a rock big enough to destroy humanity, it'll be too late to stop it"

This is not necessarily true. We may have years of notice, due to our improved ability to predict the path of objects in our solar system. The larger the rock, and the more capable of destroying humanity, the more likely we can predict its path.

"last time it has happened was a long time back"

Which? The mass extinction event? I agree. We honestly shouldn't focus our attention on preventing such a large impact; it would be better to focus on more manageable ones. Even if we are only tracking them, that's still better than doing nothing and burying our heads in the sand. If we have some success with the simpler problems, we can tackle the major ones like an eventual mass-extinction threat later on. It's possible with a little more effort in detection and modelling we will become able to determine there will be a huge strike in hundreds of years, giving us plenty of time (and motivation) to address it as best we can.

"the odds are fine, if we worried about every single little threat nothing would be done"

Doesn't this sound like a cop-out to you? Are you saying we should never address threats unless the odds are high? Have you done the math to see how big the threat really is? What are the odds of an impact of size X happening? What is the average number of people who would die from such an impact? What would be the other environmental impacts? This is very complicated, but is being studied. As I mentioned earlier, I wanted to research this stuff more before posting so I could actually compare the estimated threat/danger of impacts vs other things we spend a lot of time and money on, but I'm not prepared to do that yet.

"I imagine doing this is very expensive, with all the needed infrastructure and need to hire smart people, to save what, maybe 100 out of 7 billion people in their lifetime?"

It could be 100. It could be 5 million. Last time (1908) we were lucky, save for the millions of trees and thousands of reindeer who weren't. Let's not forget, saving the lives of people in potential ground zeroes is not the only possible benefit out of the type of work being proposed. The technology being worked on to prepare for moon/Mars/etc missions is related to the technology being discussed in this thread. The potential good-will between nations working together to possibly save the planet is enormous. There could be benefits none of us have thought of.

"Global issues, flaws of capitalism, poverty, rich getting richer, cancer, global warming, HIV, pollution, cultural differences are going to have a much larger impact to people, and those are the issues that need to be solved or improve first before we tackle something as insignificant as this. "

They may have a much larger impact (in say, the next 200 years) than meteors. That, alone, is not grounds to dismiss addressing this as well. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying this is the only major problem we face. It's pointless to spend tons of resources developing detection technology and working on a 'shield' if we all obliterate ourselves in nuclear war 50 years from now. However, you could use the argument "why should we focus on problem x, when there are still major problems with y z 1 2 3?" to try to block any advancement.

"this asteroid defence shield crap is one of the silliest things I've read on teamliquid for a while"

Again I invite you to actually do some research (alongside me) into exactly how big the threat is. We have come a long way in detection which also means we are getting better at assessing the risk. Even if you don't agree with any work on the 'shield' due to the reasons you gave above, detection should still be focused on. With proper detection, it becomes easier to ascertain if the 'shield' is actually needed or not in a given century.

In summary: humans are not very good at qualitatively assessing risk. Some threats have a high chance of occurring but a low penalty when they do (not wearing gloves when you handle wood can get you a splinter). Some threats have a low chance of occurring but a high penalty (Tanguska if it struck Moscow instead of Siberia). You need to use quantitative methods to compare the overall threat of each outcome.
ModeratorThere are animal crackers for people and there are people crackers for animals.
emc
Profile Joined September 2010
United States3088 Posts
March 14 2013 00:23 GMT
#22
the odds only matter if they are against you. we probably won't do anything until the odds of a big asteroid hitting us is higher than we are comfortable with, and by then it will probably be too late.
Scarecrow
Profile Blog Joined July 2009
Korea (South)9172 Posts
March 14 2013 00:25 GMT
#23
Waste of time and money, the chance of a meteor strike similar to that which wiped out the dinosaurs is so small as to be irrelevant.
Yhamm is the god of predictions
naastyOne
Profile Joined April 2012
491 Posts
March 14 2013 00:26 GMT
#24
Been a topic for quite a wile.

I`m pretty sure that a few nukes, can shatter a 100m-1km asteroid, if needed. But, we only learn after something horrible happens.
micronesia
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States24676 Posts
March 14 2013 00:27 GMT
#25
On March 14 2013 09:25 Scarecrow wrote:
Waste of time and money, the chance of a meteor strike similar to that which wiped out the dinosaurs is so small as to be irrelevant.

As was mentioned, a dinosaur-extinction level event is not the only one worth preventing. Also, it's easy to dismiss this as a 'waste of time and money' but don't forget that the benefits of such work would not be limited to an asteroid shield. This would require technological advancement which could benefit the world in some of its other problems.
ModeratorThere are animal crackers for people and there are people crackers for animals.
jinorazi
Profile Joined October 2004
Korea (South)4948 Posts
March 14 2013 00:30 GMT
#26
iron curtain?
age: 84 | location: california | sex: 잘함
Young Terran
Profile Joined April 2012
United Kingdom265 Posts
March 14 2013 00:34 GMT
#27
seems like a message
micronesia
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States24676 Posts
March 14 2013 00:41 GMT
#28
mierin thank you for suggesting that part of the Tyson interview. I agree with him. These investments are super important.
ModeratorThere are animal crackers for people and there are people crackers for animals.
Fruscainte
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
4596 Posts
March 14 2013 00:44 GMT
#29
I never understood the "there's too many problems here, fuck space" position.

There's always going to be problems here, when is it going to be okay to start progressing and moving on instead of sitting around fumbling with the same ol' same ol'?
[UoN]Sentinel
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
United States11320 Posts
March 14 2013 00:46 GMT
#30
On March 14 2013 09:27 micronesia wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 14 2013 09:25 Scarecrow wrote:
Waste of time and money, the chance of a meteor strike similar to that which wiped out the dinosaurs is so small as to be irrelevant.

As was mentioned, a dinosaur-extinction level event is not the only one worth preventing. Also, it's easy to dismiss this as a 'waste of time and money' but don't forget that the benefits of such work would not be limited to an asteroid shield. This would require technological advancement which could benefit the world in some of its other problems.


I agree. We got the drive to create cellphones using the communication technology we put into Space Shuttles - smaller size because you want the least weight possible and save fuel -> portable wireless telephone you can carry around in your pocket.

Imagine what we could do with the technology we develop to put an observatory beyond Earth orbit (well the kind we're occupying right now at any rate). Maybe it could pave the way to have a space station at L1 someday and do cool things with it.
Нас зовет дух отцов, память старых бойцов, дух Москвы и твердыня Полтавы
Zaros
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
United Kingdom3692 Posts
March 14 2013 00:47 GMT
#31
Pretty Sure America or Russia firing its nuclear arsenal at a giant meteor would destroy it, but then the other nations have no real way of knowing if its actually going to hit a meteor or if the nukes are heading for them and we get a nuclear apocalypse scenario .
FabledIntegral
Profile Blog Joined November 2008
United States9232 Posts
Last Edited: 2013-03-14 00:56:41
March 14 2013 00:55 GMT
#32
I simply don't think the costs are worth the benefits. It simply should not be a priority of our funds, at least at this point. Only when we have a surplus, really, could we afford something like this imo. Simple reasoning being there are plenty of massive threats, each with very minor chances of occurrence. We can't prepare for all of them without simply sacrificing what we have existing. When we're already massively struggling on budget cuts, which even once implemented we'll still be running a deficit, we need to have our priorities on the now.

On March 14 2013 09:47 Zaros wrote:
Pretty Sure America or Russia firing its nuclear arsenal at a giant meteor would destroy it, but then the other nations have no real way of knowing if its actually going to hit a meteor or if the nukes are heading for them and we get a nuclear apocalypse scenario .


Pretty sure if destroying the meteor with a nuke was a valid scenario it would be announced to all the other countries and they would know what was actually happening. How you can see *that* as an issue is beyond me.
iNfeRnaL *
Profile Blog Joined August 2005
Germany1908 Posts
March 14 2013 00:58 GMT
#33
On March 14 2013 09:47 Zaros wrote:
Pretty Sure America or Russia firing its nuclear arsenal at a giant meteor would destroy it, but then the other nations have no real way of knowing if its actually going to hit a meteor or if the nukes are heading for them and we get a nuclear apocalypse scenario .

Public announcement // government internal messages "Hi, there's an meteor coming, we're going to nuke it, would you all just please not freak out and hold back?"
I don't think any nation would be sending nukes out instantly before one actually hit anywhere.
Yes, everyone would freak out and send some jets to see if its heading to them and possibly shoot it, but that's about it.
It's not like 10 nations would just randomly nuke each other, that's just non sense.
gyth
Profile Blog Joined September 2009
657 Posts
March 14 2013 00:58 GMT
#34
The only effective doomsday prep is funding off-planet colonization.
The plural of anecdote is not data.
Grumbels
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
Netherlands7031 Posts
March 14 2013 00:59 GMT
#35
I certainly think we should do this eventually, like, in the next few hundred years. This fantasy that we need to get one right now to prevent the minuscule threat of an asteroid doing serious damage is stupid though. Most asteroids will crash into uninhabited places, it is well within our means already to track the route of any asteroid big enough to threaten humanity, the only class that remains are the asteroids in between that can maybe destroy a city if they happen to land on a highly populated area (just a few % of the earth). I think it's safe to take some chances, like someone else said: if we all think that the War on Terror and so many other things are massive wastes of money, then the same would apply to spending a lot of money on developing a highly advanced asteroid deterrence scheme.
Well, now I tell you, I never seen good come o' goodness yet. Him as strikes first is my fancy; dead men don't bite; them's my views--amen, so be it.
iNfeRnaL *
Profile Blog Joined August 2005
Germany1908 Posts
March 14 2013 00:59 GMT
#36
On March 14 2013 09:58 gyth wrote:
The only effective doomsday prep is funding off-planet colonization.

The slight difference being the fact that off planet colonization is still years away and a possible anti meteor "shield" is not.
Sadist
Profile Blog Joined October 2002
United States7227 Posts
March 14 2013 01:01 GMT
#37
Seems like a good idea.

What about doing something to prevent super volcanoes though? Say learning how to create a controlled eruption on a small scale?

How do you go from where you are to where you want to be? I think you have to have an enthusiasm for life. You have to have a dream, a goal and you have to be willing to work for it. Jim Valvano
furymonkey
Profile Joined December 2008
New Zealand1587 Posts
March 14 2013 01:11 GMT
#38
IMO preventing asteroids from hitting is pointless if it cannot be done in a cost efficient manner, however ramping up detection make sense, if you can see it coming, you could evacuate the population from impact zone.
Leenock the Punisher
oBlade
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
United States5583 Posts
March 14 2013 01:26 GMT
#39
It's interesting to see so many people basing their dismissal of this threat off of the idea that 1) you can't deflect a Chicxulub sized impactor so there's no use trying 2) meteor showers are so tiny they just streak in the atmosphere and don't hurt us, and strangely 3) that these are the only two sizes of asteroids that exist.
"I read it. You know how to read, you ignorant fuck?" - Andy Dufresne
hypercube
Profile Joined April 2010
Hungary2735 Posts
March 14 2013 02:23 GMT
#40
So anyway, here's the report from NASA to Congress:

http://neo.jpl.nasa.gov/neo/report2007.html

Too bad nothing happened. At least we had 4 more years of the space shuttle and a space telescope that will revolutionize our view of the universe if it ever gets off the ground. But in the meantime it's suffocating space science.

Hubble's successor: doomed or saved?

The telescope that ate astronomy
"Sending people in rockets to other planets is a waste of money better spent on sending rockets into people on this planet."
Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
BSL20 Non-Korean Champi…
18:00
RO8 Round Robin Group - Day 4
Bonyth vs Zhanhun
Dewalt vs Mihu
Hawk vs Sziky
Sziky vs QiaoGege
Mihu vs Hawk
Zhanhun vs Dewalt
Fengzi vs Bonyth
ZZZero.O195
LiquipediaDiscussion
FEL
09:00
Cracow 2025
Reynor vs ClemLIVE!
RotterdaM2575
ComeBackTV 2224
IndyStarCraft 577
WardiTV475
CranKy Ducklings176
3DClanTV 169
EnkiAlexander 141
Rex61
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RotterdaM 2575
IndyStarCraft 577
JuggernautJason65
Rex 61
StarCraft: Brood War
ZZZero.O 195
NaDa 34
Dota 2
capcasts251
LuMiX1
League of Legends
Grubby3400
JimRising 474
febbydoto15
Counter-Strike
Fnx 2504
fl0m2400
Stewie2K850
flusha470
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King1729
hungrybox1688
AZ_Axe504
Heroes of the Storm
Liquid`Hasu516
Khaldor294
Other Games
tarik_tv18776
summit1g8412
gofns3876
Sick46
ToD10
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick3233
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 18 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• davetesta41
• StrangeGG 32
• Adnapsc2 6
• IndyKCrew
• sooper7s
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• Migwel
• intothetv
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Kozan
StarCraft: Brood War
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
• BSLYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota22876
League of Legends
• Doublelift5126
Other Games
• imaqtpie1666
• Scarra797
• Shiphtur396
Upcoming Events
Wardi Open
12h 54m
Sparkling Tuna Cup
1d 11h
WardiTV European League
1d 17h
Online Event
1d 19h
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
2 days
The PondCast
3 days
Replay Cast
4 days
Korean StarCraft League
5 days
CranKy Ducklings
5 days
Sparkling Tuna Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
Esports World Cup 2025
Murky Cup #2

Ongoing

Copa Latinoamericana 4
Jiahua Invitational
BSL 20 Non-Korean Championship
BSL 20 Team Wars
FEL Cracov 2025
CC Div. A S7
Underdog Cup #2
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25

Upcoming

ASL Season 20: Qualifier #1
ASL Season 20: Qualifier #2
ASL Season 20
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
BSL Season 21
RSL Revival: Season 2
Maestros of the Game
SEL Season 2 Championship
WardiTV Summer 2025
uThermal 2v2 Main Event
HCC Europe
ESL Pro League S22
StarSeries Fall 2025
FISSURE Playground #2
BLAST Open Fall 2025
BLAST Open Fall Qual
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.