• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 00:29
CET 06:29
KST 14:29
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #238[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over4Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
Trading/Investing Thread US Politics Mega-thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 24603 users

Collectivism v. Individualism - Page 6

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 4 5 6 7 8 19 Next All
Jibba
Profile Blog Joined October 2007
United States22883 Posts
April 27 2010 18:56 GMT
#101
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm

The problem is you're reducing something that's very complex and has many nuances into very elementary elements. The arguments I see in your post aren't very well developed; you stop advancing them once you get to the point that suits your pre-aligned political position. We're all guilty of that (it goes along with the objectivity being impossible thing) but I think you're doing a disservice to yourself by doing it, since you seem genuinely interested in this kind of thing. You're also drifting between ideas and using them incongruently, such as rational choice, altruism, consequentialism, etc.

I don't believe you can argue one is inherently worse than the other, as you're trying to do. Both perspectives have faults and society tends to gravitate within the two, given current political, economic and social climates.

I would assume like most people that refer to Austrian economics that you fall towards Kant's ethical model, which is fine and dandy (although it's absurd and likely impossible to ONLY subscribe to that in all situations) but if you want to prove the ends don't justify the means with regards to government, you haven't really proven how the means (in this case, collectivism - whether this is true or not is also arguable) are bad.

Basically, it's ok to lean towards individualism more than collectivism or vice versa, but I don't think your justification is very strong. I think before you try to develop and broadcast your own system, you should look to others who have done it before you and see how it fits, like Ayn Rand or something.
ModeratorNow I'm distant, dark in this anthrobeat
Three
Profile Joined April 2010
Japan278 Posts
April 27 2010 18:57 GMT
#102
On April 28 2010 03:56 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:54 Three wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:48 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:42 Three wrote:
Too simple to be correct. Human interaction can not be explained in a post. Additionally, your understanding of cells seems lacking based on your response. Do you know how stem cells differentiate? Either way, you should read this and related articles before being so dismissive of people who contradict your unproven, simple theories:

http://www.jstor.org/stable/2995525?cookieSet=1

(this is not new)


ok, and are individuals in a human society... "consist of a unified protoplast that is chambered into cells"?

I mean, we weren't even talking about plant cells, and even if we were, then the analogy wouldn't fit anyways?

How is an individual physically attached to another in society? Do we have invisible umbilical cords tying us together?


Read the article or don't
Responding before reading it is pointless

If you want to prove that my biology sucks, I concede, it does suck
Sorry I'm not going to read that. It's completely unrelated.


I'm glad you know that something you didn't read is unrelated. What was your purpose in making this thread exactly?
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
April 27 2010 19:00 GMT
#103
On April 28 2010 03:55 o[twist] wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:53 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:49 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm


the question - which you should recognize as a falsificationist - isn't which approach is better but whether, empirically, our assertions hold up


thats beggin the question isnt it. if you denote that the only way to prove something is inductively, then truth can only be reached inductively.

I beg to pardon but deduction is so much more logically concise.


but it doesn't really hold up in this scenario. for example, if the question is "do collectives operate in a way that distinguishes them from a set of individuals operating independently? i.e., does the notion of a 'collective' add anything to our understanding?" then you need to look at, you know, how individuals and collectives ACTUALLY OPERATE. if you're positing a rational actor model of the individual, well, that may or may not be an accurate model, empirically. you can't define away the empirical question.
A little empiricism can't hurt, ok. But some things can be so easily concluded from an "obvious" set of principles that I don't see why do you have to induct everything.

Does anything in social relations exist outside of individuals? No, it's absolutely all in their heads.
Therefore, human relations can be 100% understood by understanding individuals themselves

A set of individuals operating independently is still a set of individuals which can be independently understood. Sure you can study group action, but you got to remember at first, that nothing exists outside of the individual! A group has no goal but the goals of each individual, no wishes or needs. It's all aggregated, right?
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
April 27 2010 19:03 GMT
#104
On April 28 2010 03:57 Three wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:56 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:54 Three wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:48 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:42 Three wrote:
Too simple to be correct. Human interaction can not be explained in a post. Additionally, your understanding of cells seems lacking based on your response. Do you know how stem cells differentiate? Either way, you should read this and related articles before being so dismissive of people who contradict your unproven, simple theories:

http://www.jstor.org/stable/2995525?cookieSet=1

(this is not new)


ok, and are individuals in a human society... "consist of a unified protoplast that is chambered into cells"?

I mean, we weren't even talking about plant cells, and even if we were, then the analogy wouldn't fit anyways?

How is an individual physically attached to another in society? Do we have invisible umbilical cords tying us together?


Read the article or don't
Responding before reading it is pointless

If you want to prove that my biology sucks, I concede, it does suck
Sorry I'm not going to read that. It's completely unrelated.


I'm glad you know that something you didn't read is unrelated. What was your purpose in making this thread exactly?

Whatever the purpose was, it wasn't to discuss biology...
the cell analogies I did not make but only respond to were just analogies to understand or refute the on-topic concepts
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
uiCk
Profile Blog Joined December 2002
Canada1925 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-27 19:04:42
April 27 2010 19:03 GMT
#105
On April 28 2010 03:51 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:44 uiCk wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm

im pretty sure both can be used, and neither individualism nor collectivism need to be ignored. i dont see why your trying to make this a VS when i reality its a +. am i missing something here?

isnt democracy an individulistic concept (choice by the unit) formulated to concive a result based on a collective agreement starategy?

On a descriptive basis, I don't give a shit and you're right (i still doubt sociology or psychology can prove shit tho)

On a prescriptive basis, doing the top-bottom thing is impossible, due to the reasons in the op

only because you are able to describe how a herd behaves, doesn't mean it should act on one way or another
because the herd has no goal, so there can be no ought-ought prescription
the only thing that has goals are rational beings
individuals

fairly transparent, the bolded part, represent oldest existansial question, what is our goal? what is our purpouse? obviously it seems you have gained a new level and have come accross what we call a conscience, and your trying to make the world realize you just realized you are right! (well in your world at least)

sorry to say but you just sound like any other kid with a Wiki major / Youtube minor with a big opinion
I can no longer sit back and allow Communist infiltration, Communist indoctrination, Communist subversion and the international Communist conspiracy to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
April 27 2010 19:10 GMT
#106
On April 28 2010 03:56 Jibba wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm

The problem is you're reducing something that's very complex and has many nuances into very elementary elements.
simple=bad
k.

On April 28 2010 03:56 Jibba wrote: The arguments I see in your post aren't very well developed; you stop advancing them once you get to the point that suits your pre-aligned political position. We're all guilty of that (it goes along with the objectivity being impossible thing) but I think you're doing a disservice to yourself by doing it, since you seem genuinely interested in this kind of thing. You're also drifting between ideas and using them incongruently, such as rational choice, altruism, consequentialism, etc.
tell me where and I have no problem fixing.

you didn't mean praxeology when you said "rational choice theory"? what was it then?

altruism is a broad term anyways. let me define it now 4 u:
the idea that one's greater goal is of helping other individuals.
good enough? discuss. don't just say I'm being incongruent k?

consequentialism.. i haven't even used that word wtf.

On April 28 2010 03:56 Jibba wrote:
I don't believe you can argue one is inherently worse than the other, as you're trying to do. Both perspectives have faults and society tends to gravitate within the two, given current political, economic and social climates.
worse, for what end? LOL
I'm saying collectivism is almost, if not a total, impossibility.
and i haven't quite seen you facing the main premises yet. only beating round the bushes...

On April 28 2010 03:56 Jibba wrote:
I would assume like most people that refer to Austrian economics that you fall towards Kant's ethical model, which is fine and dandy (although it's absurd and likely impossible to ONLY subscribe to that in all situations) but if you want to prove the ends don't justify the means with regards to government, you haven't really proven how the means (in this case, collectivism - whether this is true or not is also arguable) are bad.
you guess wrong.
and i've said in the very op that i dont believe in objective morals
so.. wtf.

I'm saying there can't be a collective goal, which should be obvious given the premises, which you seem to ignore.

On April 28 2010 03:56 Jibba wrote:
Basically, it's ok to lean towards individualism more than collectivism or vice versa, but I don't think your justification is very strong. I think before you try to develop and broadcast your own system, you should look to others who have done it before you and see how it fits, like Ayn Rand or something.
This is the basic ofc, basic basic of praxeology.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-27 19:17:05
April 27 2010 19:11 GMT
#107
On April 28 2010 04:03 uiCk wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:51 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:44 uiCk wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm

im pretty sure both can be used, and neither individualism nor collectivism need to be ignored. i dont see why your trying to make this a VS when i reality its a +. am i missing something here?

isnt democracy an individulistic concept (choice by the unit) formulated to concive a result based on a collective agreement starategy?

On a descriptive basis, I don't give a shit and you're right (i still doubt sociology or psychology can prove shit tho)

On a prescriptive basis, doing the top-bottom thing is impossible, due to the reasons in the op

only because you are able to describe how a herd behaves, doesn't mean it should act on one way or another
because the herd has no goal, so there can be no ought-ought prescription
the only thing that has goals are rational beings
individuals

fairly transparent, the bolded part, represent oldest existansial question, what is our goal? what is our purpouse? obviously it seems you have gained a new level and have come accross what we call a conscience, and your trying to make the world realize you just realized you are right! (well in your world at least)
indeed

On April 28 2010 04:03 uiCk wrote:
sorry to say but you just sound like any other kid with a Wiki major / Youtube minor with a big opinion
and your assumption is correct, yet, does not make my points any less valid.

I think wiki and youtube are great sources of information. People without the internet would otherwise have to read books to get the same deal, and since less are willing to spend the time doing that, less information is disseminated. I say everything in laymans terms not only because it saves me the time of learning the formal concepts, but it also promotes a general undesrtanding of the same concepts

Why stick with the old methods if the new is much more efficient at reaching the supposedly same end?

I think people that preach for formal education rather do not have the goal of education, but of aesthetics and social status. They use the lingo not to promote debate, but to set themselves off the "uneducated" crowds. I don't like that at all.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
o[twist]
Profile Joined May 2008
United States4903 Posts
April 27 2010 19:15 GMT
#108
On April 28 2010 04:00 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:55 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:53 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:49 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm


the question - which you should recognize as a falsificationist - isn't which approach is better but whether, empirically, our assertions hold up


thats beggin the question isnt it. if you denote that the only way to prove something is inductively, then truth can only be reached inductively.

I beg to pardon but deduction is so much more logically concise.


but it doesn't really hold up in this scenario. for example, if the question is "do collectives operate in a way that distinguishes them from a set of individuals operating independently? i.e., does the notion of a 'collective' add anything to our understanding?" then you need to look at, you know, how individuals and collectives ACTUALLY OPERATE. if you're positing a rational actor model of the individual, well, that may or may not be an accurate model, empirically. you can't define away the empirical question.
A little empiricism can't hurt, ok. But some things can be so easily concluded from an "obvious" set of principles that I don't see why do you have to induct everything.

Does anything in social relations exist outside of individuals? No, it's absolutely all in their heads.
Therefore, human relations can be 100% understood by understanding individuals themselves

A set of individuals operating independently is still a set of individuals which can be independently understood. Sure you can study group action, but you got to remember at first, that nothing exists outside of the individual! A group has no goal but the goals of each individual, no wishes or needs. It's all aggregated, right?


how can you deduce the lack of something in social relations apart from individuals?
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-27 19:20:04
April 27 2010 19:18 GMT
#109
On April 28 2010 04:15 o[twist] wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 04:00 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:55 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:53 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:49 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm


the question - which you should recognize as a falsificationist - isn't which approach is better but whether, empirically, our assertions hold up


thats beggin the question isnt it. if you denote that the only way to prove something is inductively, then truth can only be reached inductively.

I beg to pardon but deduction is so much more logically concise.


but it doesn't really hold up in this scenario. for example, if the question is "do collectives operate in a way that distinguishes them from a set of individuals operating independently? i.e., does the notion of a 'collective' add anything to our understanding?" then you need to look at, you know, how individuals and collectives ACTUALLY OPERATE. if you're positing a rational actor model of the individual, well, that may or may not be an accurate model, empirically. you can't define away the empirical question.
A little empiricism can't hurt, ok. But some things can be so easily concluded from an "obvious" set of principles that I don't see why do you have to induct everything.

Does anything in social relations exist outside of individuals? No, it's absolutely all in their heads.
Therefore, human relations can be 100% understood by understanding individuals themselves

A set of individuals operating independently is still a set of individuals which can be independently understood. Sure you can study group action, but you got to remember at first, that nothing exists outside of the individual! A group has no goal but the goals of each individual, no wishes or needs. It's all aggregated, right?


how can you deduce the lack of something in social relations apart from individuals?

TIME OUT.
I cannot, and you got me there.

HOWEVER. I can falsify the claims that there exists something, when it does not.

which is the point of the thread.

no, wait, I'm confused, let me put on my thinking hat for a second.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
hefty
Profile Joined January 2005
Denmark555 Posts
April 27 2010 19:20 GMT
#110
I really think the OP needed a more precise definition on collectivism. Perhabs other thnigs as well, but this problem seems to repeat itself over and over in this thread:

- Yurebis state that collectivists are false in claiming that they "know what's best" since they are only individuals, and thus can not speek on behalf of others (a sentiment I can agree with to some extend - at least I don't accept that anyone can be more right than I on the subject that is my needs/wishes).

- Yurebis tries to prove this through and elaborate range of statements and premises, some of which are highly debatable*. Among these are the one critical to most of this thread: We can only know what is on our own mind, leading Yurebis to state/insinuate that nothing is collective, it is only individuals participating.

- People criticize this claim as it seems evident that a lot of things are collective in nature (they don't necessarily touch on the original concern though - whether a collectivist (here: someone who feels right to enforce a notion of the common good upon his fellow men) can really know what is best for the individual.

- Yurebis responds to said critics, never having to sweat because people's criticism doesn't really apply to his original statement (as we understand it if we accept the agenda I have hereby presented), but rather to the many claims that were made along the way.


I think, Yurebis, you could have been clearer on what you said out to do with this. As for me, I could easily accept/discuss the idea that anyone who claims to know what's better for his neighbour than the neighbour himself is in the wrong, what I can't really be bothered to discuss however, is whether collective manifestations exists.


* And imo outright wrong. Noone needs to agree with all the objections against these points, but at least it should be very obvious that they aren't all undisputable. Whether a group is only a set of individuals is highly debatable, whether people act consciously most of the time also, psychology being bs is definately a very opinionated claim etc. I realize that many of these aren't part of the OP, but the one that matters to the arguement (not in this footnote, but above) is.

On April 28 2010 03:42 Three wrote:
Too simple to be correct. Human interaction can not be explained in a post. Additionally, your understanding of cells seems lacking based on your response. Do you know how stem cells differentiate? Either way, you should read this and related articles before being so dismissive of people who contradict your unproven, simple theories:


Whole-heartedly agreed. My whole problem with this is that so many things are lost in mere rhetorics here, a greater respect for different spheres of knowledge would be welcome.


Finally, I need to add that this is not an attempt to patronize Yurebis. I merely got fed up with how the discussion stagnated because of misunderstandings.
uiCk
Profile Blog Joined December 2002
Canada1925 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-27 19:25:52
April 27 2010 19:23 GMT
#111
On April 28 2010 04:11 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 04:03 uiCk wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:51 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:44 uiCk wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm

im pretty sure both can be used, and neither individualism nor collectivism need to be ignored. i dont see why your trying to make this a VS when i reality its a +. am i missing something here?

isnt democracy an individulistic concept (choice by the unit) formulated to concive a result based on a collective agreement starategy?

On a descriptive basis, I don't give a shit and you're right (i still doubt sociology or psychology can prove shit tho)

On a prescriptive basis, doing the top-bottom thing is impossible, due to the reasons in the op

only because you are able to describe how a herd behaves, doesn't mean it should act on one way or another
because the herd has no goal, so there can be no ought-ought prescription
the only thing that has goals are rational beings
individuals

fairly transparent, the bolded part, represent oldest existansial question, what is our goal? what is our purpouse? obviously it seems you have gained a new level and have come accross what we call a conscience, and your trying to make the world realize you just realized you are right! (well in your world at least)
indeed

Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 04:03 uiCk wrote:
sorry to say but you just sound like any other kid with a Wiki major / Youtube minor with a big opinion
and your assumption is correct, yet, does not make my points any less valid.

I think wiki and youtube are great sources of information. People without the internet would otherwise have to read books to get the same deal, and since less are willing to spend the time doing that, less information is disseminated. I say everything in laymans terms not only because it saves me the time of learning the formal concepts, but it also promotes a general undesrtanding of the same concepts

Why stick with the old methods if the new is much more efficient at reaching the supposedly same end?

I think people that preach for formal education rather do not have the goal of education, but of aesthetics and social status. They use the lingo not to promote debate, but to set themselves off the "uneducated" crowds. I don't like that at all.

the internet, wiki, youtube, are based on collective systems; networking and such. and its all just a delivery method of the information, and this information comes originaly from academia, so yea there is a huge diference between geting that information from the source and getting footnotes. makes you an amateur, and the one with the diploma is the expert. for you do 'disaprouve' a reliable system of collectivism because of some flaws you just discovered that are in cahoots with some of your individualistic thoughts. im also showing you why your not converting many people at the moment, and being very vague, just like wiki/youtube.

anyways, cheers, its gonna be a bumpy road ahead
I can no longer sit back and allow Communist infiltration, Communist indoctrination, Communist subversion and the international Communist conspiracy to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids
Jibba
Profile Blog Joined October 2007
United States22883 Posts
April 27 2010 19:25 GMT
#112
I have zero desire to go after your premise, this is like a repeat of a 100 and 200 level course. I'm just saying that I understand what you're trying to do, but you're not doing it successfully and you need to look deeper if you want to prove it to other posters, and I suspect maybe yourself as well. Parsimony is great, but you're chopping all the branches off the tree.

I'm just trying to help you out in your own personal quest for knowledge. For instance, when I say things like Kantian ethics or consequentialism, I don't think you know what I'm talking about. I'm not suggesting you read Weber or Mannheim (yet), Rand and Hayak are both fairly readable.
ModeratorNow I'm distant, dark in this anthrobeat
o[twist]
Profile Joined May 2008
United States4903 Posts
April 27 2010 19:30 GMT
#113
On April 28 2010 04:25 Jibba wrote:
I have zero desire to go after your premise, this is like a repeat of a 100 and 200 level course. I'm just saying that I understand what you're trying to do, but you're not doing it successfully and you need to look deeper if you want to prove it to other posters, and I suspect maybe yourself as well. Parsimony is great, but you're chopping all the branches off the tree.

I'm just trying to help you out in your own personal quest for knowledge. For instance, when I say things like Kantian ethics or consequentialism, I don't think you know what I'm talking about. I'm not suggesting you read Weber or Mannheim (yet), Rand and Hayak are both fairly readable.


everyone should read kant and weber; rand and hayek, less important
hefty
Profile Joined January 2005
Denmark555 Posts
April 27 2010 19:32 GMT
#114
On April 28 2010 04:00 Yurebis wrote:
A set of individuals operating independently is still a set of individuals which can be independently understood. Sure you can study group action, but you got to remember at first, that nothing exists outside of the individual! A group has no goal but the goals of each individual, no wishes or needs. It's all aggregated, right?


Arg!

This is one of the horrendeously wrong statements you keep repeating. Since you haven't responded to the more philosophical critique of this position let's make it simple.

Try to explore the individuals feeling of being part of a group without the group.
Jibba
Profile Blog Joined October 2007
United States22883 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-27 19:36:43
April 27 2010 19:36 GMT
#115
On April 28 2010 04:30 o[twist] wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 04:25 Jibba wrote:
I have zero desire to go after your premise, this is like a repeat of a 100 and 200 level course. I'm just saying that I understand what you're trying to do, but you're not doing it successfully and you need to look deeper if you want to prove it to other posters, and I suspect maybe yourself as well. Parsimony is great, but you're chopping all the branches off the tree.

I'm just trying to help you out in your own personal quest for knowledge. For instance, when I say things like Kantian ethics or consequentialism, I don't think you know what I'm talking about. I'm not suggesting you read Weber or Mannheim (yet), Rand and Hayak are both fairly readable.


everyone should read kant and weber; rand and hayek, less important

I think it's like asking all SC players to start on iccup before they've touched the game, only the learning curve is even more intense.
ModeratorNow I'm distant, dark in this anthrobeat
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
April 27 2010 19:38 GMT
#116
On April 28 2010 04:18 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 04:15 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 04:00 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:55 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:53 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:49 o[twist] wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:39 Yurebis wrote:
On April 28 2010 03:27 o[twist] wrote:
in a very basic sense the collective is of course a set of individuals but there's actually considerable academic debate over whether it can be accurately analyzed in that way. herd behavior and crowd psychology are huge topics. your above reduction of state-based democracy to raw collectivism is pretty weak from a political philosophy standpoint and i'm not sure exactly how you intend to deploy karl popper in this debate; it doesn't seem relevant.

Alright first of all I'm sorry I can only talk to you in layman's terms but I hope you see my premises for what they are.

...but where exactly are you rejecting my line of thought? just because it's nothing like you've seen it means its wrong? I haven't invented it either... this methodological individualism type of deal... it has a long history too.

there may be an academic attempt out there that tries to make sense of atomic forces by studying how planets move, but has it proven anything?
May not be a good analogy, but I think it's much easier to start with an atom and then move on to planets.

I'm not saying either top-bottom or bottom-up is right by default but, it seems to me that bottom-up is much more concise and complete than top-bottom atm


the question - which you should recognize as a falsificationist - isn't which approach is better but whether, empirically, our assertions hold up


thats beggin the question isnt it. if you denote that the only way to prove something is inductively, then truth can only be reached inductively.

I beg to pardon but deduction is so much more logically concise.


but it doesn't really hold up in this scenario. for example, if the question is "do collectives operate in a way that distinguishes them from a set of individuals operating independently? i.e., does the notion of a 'collective' add anything to our understanding?" then you need to look at, you know, how individuals and collectives ACTUALLY OPERATE. if you're positing a rational actor model of the individual, well, that may or may not be an accurate model, empirically. you can't define away the empirical question.
A little empiricism can't hurt, ok. But some things can be so easily concluded from an "obvious" set of principles that I don't see why do you have to induct everything.

Does anything in social relations exist outside of individuals? No, it's absolutely all in their heads.
Therefore, human relations can be 100% understood by understanding individuals themselves

A set of individuals operating independently is still a set of individuals which can be independently understood. Sure you can study group action, but you got to remember at first, that nothing exists outside of the individual! A group has no goal but the goals of each individual, no wishes or needs. It's all aggregated, right?


how can you deduce the lack of something in social relations apart from individuals?

TIME OUT.
I cannot, and you got me there.

HOWEVER. I can falsify the claims that there exists something, when it does not.

which is the point of the thread.

no, wait, I'm confused, let me put on my thinking hat for a second.


Ok back.
My claim that a collective goal does not exist is SOMEWHAT circular, that is why I was confused.

This is because of my epistemological grounds.

Sadly, we cannot claim any objective truth without a few circular, introspective premises. I will layout how the work for me:

-There exists a universe.
-There exists my consciousness.
-My consciousness retrieves facts about the universe through my senses.
-Such retrieval can never be perfect, but it is good enough to assume it's perfect

From there we form all the positivist, inductive theories about the universe, and use them as we may.

However, from that point, no certainty can be affirmed. I can only assume that your consciousness and epistemological build is similar to mine because we share similarities which I associate with rational beings.

If your consciousness is anything like mine, then it is not collective by any means.
I took the liberty to assume in the OP that you people, fellow humans, have a similar type of consciousness as mine!
When in fact you *could* be some kind of cyborgs who receive "consciousness waves" from an overarching entity. My theory would not hold then, because not only are you not human, but you don't have the same consciousness setup as I.

So my premise #1 is circular. I admit. If you want to claim that your consciousness is indeed collective (like, you can see the world literally through other peoples eyes, maybe you have multiple personalities, idk), then disregard every post of mine. you are indeed superior, and perhaps super human!

perhaps I should have defined what a HUMAN is to include that circular premise of mine, huh.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
baal
Profile Joined March 2003
10708 Posts
April 27 2010 19:41 GMT
#117
this is quite a simple issue actually i mean, most of us agree that the majority of people are just fucking retarded, so being ruled by the majority will only lead to retarded decisions, simple examples like weed being illegal or gay marriage being illegal.
Im back, in pog form!
Three
Profile Joined April 2010
Japan278 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-04-27 19:46:24
April 27 2010 19:41 GMT
#118
The form of society at this moment in time forces contraints on any individual child learning how to survive and fulfill its need to belong.
Concurrently, the actions of individuals, especially of those who move from one segment of society to another, will be able to change how society is formed.

Neither one occurs first or separately. In time you may learn that there does not exist anything in this universe that does not have an effect on everything else in this universe. Everything is inherently entangled, and we only separate it into parts to be able to understand it with what our intelligence is capable of. We desire to believe in end and starting points because we can understand this by relating it to our limited experience. This is consistant with our desire to find events such as "the beginning of time", or the creation of the universe by a god, which cannot conceptually exist.

for relevence: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_entanglement
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
April 27 2010 19:45 GMT
#119
On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
I really think the OP needed a more precise definition on collectivism. Perhabs other thnigs as well, but this problem seems to repeat itself over and over in this thread:
hi

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
- Yurebis state that collectivists are false in claiming that they "know what's best" since they are only individuals, and thus can not speek on behalf of others (a sentiment I can agree with to some extend - at least I don't accept that anyone can be more right than I on the subject that is my needs/wishes).
also without consent

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
- Yurebis tries to prove this through and elaborate range of statements and premises, some of which are highly debatable*. Among these are the one critical to most of this thread: We can only know what is on our own mind, leading Yurebis to state/insinuate that nothing is collective, it is only individuals participating.
yep, i've found it's circular and all. please do claim you can, I can't disprove it. Like I can't disprove you can talk to god. I'm a sad panda.

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
- People criticize this claim as it seems evident that a lot of things are collective in nature (they don't necessarily touch on the original concern though - whether a collectivist (here: someone who feels right to enforce a notion of the common good upon his fellow men) can really know what is best for the individual.

- Yurebis responds to said critics, never having to sweat because people's criticism doesn't really apply to his original statement (as we understand it if we accept the agenda I have hereby presented), but rather to the many claims that were made along the way.
yes

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
I think, Yurebis, you could have been clearer on what you said out to do with this. As for me, I could easily accept/discuss the idea that anyone who claims to know what's better for his neighbour than the neighbour himself is in the wrong, what I can't really be bothered to discuss however, is whether collective manifestations exists.
yeah I guess I should do it like you and shut the fuck up when people claim to have imaginary friends...

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
* And imo outright wrong. Noone needs to agree with all the objections against these points, but at least it should be very obvious that they aren't all undisputable. Whether a group is only a set of individuals is highly debatable, whether people act consciously most of the time also, psychology being bs is definately a very opinionated claim etc. I realize that many of these aren't part of the OP, but the one that matters to the arguement (not in this footnote, but above) is.
Funny that no one can tell me what that "more" is.
They just assert it and leave it at that.

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
Show nested quote +
On April 28 2010 03:42 Three wrote:
Too simple to be correct. Human interaction can not be explained in a post. Additionally, your understanding of cells seems lacking based on your response. Do you know how stem cells differentiate? Either way, you should read this and related articles before being so dismissive of people who contradict your unproven, simple theories:


Whole-heartedly agreed. My whole problem with this is that so many things are lost in mere rhetorics here, a greater respect for different spheres of knowledge would be welcome.

I have no respect for empty assertions...

On April 28 2010 04:20 hefty wrote:
Finally, I need to add that this is not an attempt to patronize Yurebis. I merely got fed up with how the discussion stagnated because of misunderstandings.

its k
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
BruceLee6783
Profile Joined March 2007
United States196 Posts
April 27 2010 19:45 GMT
#120
On April 27 2010 13:11 Yurebis wrote:
First I want to establish the obvious and say that the collective is nothing but a collection of individuals, much like a forest is nothing but a collection of trees (not my analogy by far). Many talk of the "greater good", or the "will" of a nation, but those terms are completely empty. There is no greater good, there may be a net good of every individual, but without the individuals, the greater good simply does not exist anywhere in reality. Without its citizens, the nation's will does not exist.


I definitely agree with this. A group of people who are in superficial agreement (or supposed to be, on the surface anyways), for the "greater good" (which is bullshit), are nothing but the sum of many SELF INTERESTS.

There is huge evidence of this in history. That "angry mob" mentality is fucking scary.
Look at the Salem witch trials. Look at the Roman's crucifixion of Jesus (if you believe in that
kind of stuff). One or 2 people get a crazy idea, other people start to agree with it prematurely (not taking time to fully consider the impact of their decision), the fact that people are agreeing with their idea reinforces the idea, which spreads more and more influence...and the end result is something terrible.

Ever notice how if you have a lone complaint about something, nothing gets done about it?
But when a group of people all start striking or making a scene, then suddenly the offending party
begins to take it seriously? I can remember this in college (students didn't agree with a teachers
decision to fail most of the class on a test, as they said the test was unfair, and irrelevant to the
material presented in class and homework/study assignments). Administration told the teacher
to readminister the test and throw out the grades from the first test. If a single student alone had
complained about the teacher, NOTHING WOULD HAVE BEEN DONE ABOUT IT.
You have enemies? Good. It means you stood up for something.
Prev 1 4 5 6 7 8 19 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
08:00
SC2 Kevin Scrim
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RuFF_SC2 229
StarCraft: Brood War
GuemChi 1391
ZergMaN 43
sOs 33
Icarus 8
Force[name] 4
Dota 2
NeuroSwarm146
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr55
Other Games
summit1g9565
Coldzera 1178
C9.Mang0338
taco 165
ViBE49
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick952
BasetradeTV147
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• practicex 12
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota21250
• lizZardDota2126
League of Legends
• Rush811
Other Games
• Shiphtur565
Upcoming Events
Online Event
4h 31m
GSL
6h 1m
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
8h 31m
OSC
10h 31m
Replay Cast
17h 31m
KCM Race Survival
1d 4h
Ultimate Battle
1d 6h
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
2 days
BSL
2 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
3 days
[ Show More ]
IPSL
3 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
3 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
3 days
WardiTV Weekly
4 days
Kung Fu Cup
5 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.