• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 00:59
CET 06:59
KST 14:59
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #235[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over1Dark completes military service, returns to SC215[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon No more SC2 streamers on team liquid?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion List of top players active on ShieldBattery NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 15054 users

Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread - Page 263

Forum Index > General Games
6725 CommentsPost a Reply
Prev 1 261 262 263 264 265 337 Next
CicadaSC
Profile Joined January 2018
United States2088 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-10 09:57:00
September 10 2025 09:56 GMT
#5241
I still think unit movement doesn't feel as good as in SC2, and that is so fundamental to a good RTS.

Everything feels floaty or like they are gliding to me. I think adding more impactful footstep sounds could go a long way but I worry it may go deeper than that.
Remember that we all come from a place of passion!!
_Spartak_
Profile Joined October 2013
Turkey464 Posts
September 10 2025 11:18 GMT
#5242
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.
Manit0u
Profile Blog Joined August 2004
Poland17875 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-10 11:49:00
September 10 2025 11:46 GMT
#5243
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.
Time is precious. Waste it wisely.
qwerty4w
Profile Joined January 2024
54 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-10 19:30:29
September 10 2025 13:33 GMT
#5244
Frost Giant was forced to launch Stormgate's early access prematurely to get some additional budget for the game's development. The early access' game content was barebone and the subsequent development was rushed, so it seems Frost Giant was already running low on money when the focus of the development was still more on the technical side (Snowplay), and it probably wouldn't have mattered much if the game's content side had less stuff in development simultaneously or not. There would not be enough money left to polish the game modes even if there were less of them.

And Frost Giant want coop and MOBA-like 3v3 (likely an idea from the cancelled C&C: Generals 2) because they believe these modes have more potential for monetization than the core RTS modes, a F2P RTS with only the core RTS modes wouldn't be sustainable anyway.
_Spartak_
Profile Joined October 2013
Turkey464 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-10 13:41:39
September 10 2025 13:35 GMT
#5245
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:

Show nested quote +

Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.

Show nested quote +

Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
Acrofales
Profile Joined August 2010
Spain18502 Posts
September 10 2025 18:50 GMT
#5246
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.
Manit0u
Profile Blog Joined August 2004
Poland17875 Posts
September 10 2025 22:22 GMT
#5247
On September 11 2025 03:50 Acrofales wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.


Full agreement here. I'm a software dev (not game dev) but even I could see disaster brewing here basically from the get go (you can check my posts earlier in this thread, where I went from optimistic on announcement to pessimistic when they have shown their first stuff way back when). I'd expect an experienced team of devs to know what they're doing. Apparently they might have experience making games but it was all under the umbrella of a huge corp with pretty much infinite resources they could pour into it so they had no idea how it works in the "real world" outside of this bubble.

Kinda like all those ex-FAANG devs trying to find work outside of those 5 companies and facing harsh realities (quite often they're un-hirable outside of this bubble because of not just their bloated egos but also biases taken from working for big corps that simply don't work in smaller settings).
Time is precious. Waste it wisely.
RogerChillingworth
Profile Joined March 2010
Chad3132 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-10 23:56:05
September 10 2025 23:36 GMT
#5248
Yeah, it's all about scope. “Too much surface area”. That's why Mickey Nielson's script was a bag of hot turds. It's the grand scope that did it. That's why the faction design is derivative and boring. Scope just too huge. That's why the art went from meh to liquid dogshit. Too much surface area. That's why coop was chinese water torture from day 1, and 3v3 was a nothingburger that never saw the light of day. Reach exceeds grasp. That's why the sound design was like chopsticks on a folger's can.

Like I'm tellin ya, if the mechanic gives my car back with more problems, I'm gonna pay him again. To polish it. Because it's just a matter of time. Not because he sucks at working on cars.

Spartak you are 100% downs, and should be remanded to working in a toll booth in New Mexico for the rest of your life. without food or water
RogerChillingworth
Profile Joined March 2010
Chad3132 Posts
September 10 2025 23:52 GMT
#5249
Fuck, jebaited by Sparty again. Such a curb-stompable face though, I can't help it. Anyone taking bullets for Tim M or Tim C at this point are aggressively stupid, or simply have no humility. And how utterly myopic it is to believe, even ostensibly, that a “next great Blizz-style RTS” is impossible based on the performance of Stormgate. Quite possibly the worst take in human history. 150 points from Hufflepuff.

User was warned for this post
iPlaY.NettleS
Profile Blog Joined June 2010
Australia4464 Posts
September 11 2025 02:18 GMT
#5250
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:

Show nested quote +

Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


.

Combination of the guilt of blowing through 35+ million of investor/kickstarter money to create a dud and trying to put a positive spin on it since he will be out in the private sector again soon no doubt looking for a new gig.Another crowdfund is out of the question.

They probably should have released the campaign editor during early access, announced a 6 month window for people to make a custom campaign and entered into a profit sharing agreement with the creators of the best campaigns, the creators keeping 25% and FG 75%.Price a 10 mission campaign at 4.99 or something reasonable.

That way they bring in revenue without using FG resources and gives incentive to creators to make the best campaign possible as there is financial incentive.Obviously would help if the game was better, but seems a better way to reach those very high financial goals.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7PvoI6gvQs
_Spartak_
Profile Joined October 2013
Turkey464 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-11 07:01:13
September 11 2025 07:00 GMT
#5251
On September 11 2025 03:50 Acrofales wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.
I don't think they thought they would be able to deliver everything at SC2 quality level at release. They probably knew they would first release a rough around the edges product and then iterate on it for a long time. They might have expected the audience to be more tolerant/supportive of the initial release knowing that it can't match SC2's current quality, content and features. You can argue they should have guessed that but I think that is only obvious with hindsight. It is not like anyone else tried it before. Stormgate was the first big budget RTS of this type since SC2. It will possibly be the last.
CicadaSC
Profile Joined January 2018
United States2088 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-11 09:17:24
September 11 2025 08:32 GMT
#5252
On September 11 2025 16:00 _Spartak_ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 11 2025 03:50 Acrofales wrote:
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.
I don't think they thought they would be able to deliver everything at SC2 quality level at release. They probably knew they would first release a rough around the edges product and then iterate on it for a long time. They might have expected the audience to be more tolerant/supportive of the initial release knowing that it can't match SC2's current quality, content and features. You can argue they should have guessed that but I think that is only obvious with hindsight. It is not like anyone else tried it before. Stormgate was the first big budget RTS of this type since SC2. It will possibly be the last.

again, its not about people not being tolerant or supportive. Frost Giant should have never released a campaign in that initial state for early access. The entire blame falls on them. It was a mockery that they expected people to pay for those missions. The launch would have been better had it not been included at all. work in progress is not an excuse to put just anything out to the public, especially not if it is paid content. I cant recall any other early access that had that low level of quality control. I dont get how that was approved. I can somewhat understand wanting to get larger campaign mission feedback from a playerbase, but those cutscenes and character models had no right seeing the light of day.
Remember that we all come from a place of passion!!
Gorsameth
Profile Joined April 2010
Netherlands22711 Posts
September 11 2025 09:06 GMT
#5253
On September 11 2025 16:00 _Spartak_ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 11 2025 03:50 Acrofales wrote:
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.
I don't think they thought they would be able to deliver everything at SC2 quality level at release. They probably knew they would first release a rough around the edges product and then iterate on it for a long time. They might have expected the audience to be more tolerant/supportive of the initial release knowing that it can't match SC2's current quality, content and features. You can argue they should have guessed that but I think that is only obvious with hindsight. It is not like anyone else tried it before. Stormgate was the first big budget RTS of this type since SC2. It will possibly be the last.
which would just further prove their incompetence.
You dont turn up with 4 things done incredibly badly. You focus on 1 thing and make it good and fun to play and then you add more.

You dont need the power of hindsight to understand that.
It ignores such insignificant forces as time, entropy, and death
_Spartak_
Profile Joined October 2013
Turkey464 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-11 09:32:09
September 11 2025 09:31 GMT
#5254
On September 11 2025 17:32 CicadaSC wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 11 2025 16:00 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 11 2025 03:50 Acrofales wrote:
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.
I don't think they thought they would be able to deliver everything at SC2 quality level at release. They probably knew they would first release a rough around the edges product and then iterate on it for a long time. They might have expected the audience to be more tolerant/supportive of the initial release knowing that it can't match SC2's current quality, content and features. You can argue they should have guessed that but I think that is only obvious with hindsight. It is not like anyone else tried it before. Stormgate was the first big budget RTS of this type since SC2. It will possibly be the last.

again, its not about people not being tolerant or supportive. Frost Giant should have never released a campaign in that initial state for early access. The entire blame falls on them. It was a mockery that they expected people to pay for those missions. The launch would have been better had it not been included at all. work in progress is not an excuse to put just anything out to the public, especially not if it is paid content. I cant recall any other early access that had that low level of quality control. I dont get how that was approved. I can somewhat understand wanting to get larger campaign mission feedback from a playerbase, but those cutscenes and character models had no right seeing the light of day.
It would have been better, sure. I don't think it would have been enough even if they released the campaign only at full launch and even if they made all those improvements without needing EA feedback. I think the bar a game of this style has to hit to get good reception is higher.
Gorsameth
Profile Joined April 2010
Netherlands22711 Posts
September 11 2025 09:33 GMT
#5255
On September 11 2025 18:31 _Spartak_ wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 11 2025 17:32 CicadaSC wrote:
On September 11 2025 16:00 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 11 2025 03:50 Acrofales wrote:
On September 10 2025 22:35 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:46 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 20:18 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 18:30 Manit0u wrote:
On September 10 2025 16:43 _Spartak_ wrote:
On September 10 2025 04:18 Gorsameth wrote:
The idea that the RTS market is saturated is just bullshit and Stormgate even proves that by showing the hype that exists for a game to be the next big RTS.
Hype existed for Stormgate because SC2 community (at least a big part of it) thought it would be an SC2 spiritual successor. They expected the game to match the quality, content and features SC2 developed over 5-7 years of development + 10 years of post-launch support with the resources of one of the biggest game studios out there. When those expectations weren't met, then it became a shitshow and then FG was blamed as to why they were hyping their game so much.

That kind of "hype" is a poisoned chalice. There might be room for other types of RTSes or smaller scope RTSes but I don't think there is a room for an SC2-like RTS to be a big success (ie. "the next big RTS") and that's what FG were aiming for. If someone said there was no room for an RTS to sell a few hundred thousands of copies and be a financial success for a smaller studio with a smaller budget, then they would obviously be incorrect.


But it's all going back to the point of them trying to do too much at the start. Even if the game would be touted as a spiritual successor to SC2 then considering the studio size and funding available they should start smaller and grow over time. Like it is mentioned in the video I posted above from Bearlike (one of the 2 devs behind Mechabellum, which right now is running it's 5th season, has competitive scene including automated 1v1 and 2v2 tournaments as well as cash prize tournaments and cosmetic mtx) - you get one chance at this and you better not screw it up. But once you had a successful launch even on a smaller project you can then grow it since at least you have some stable user base and now know your available funds and can adjust the scope accordingly. Baby steps.

Edit: Also, I think people would appreciate it a bit more if they were at least honest and came out and said that they fucked up and need to cut their losses. They tried, they failed (no shame in that). But the constant gaslighting is just obnoxious.
I don't think anyone (including Tim Morten) is disputing that they bit off more than they could chew.


In his own words:


Stormgate intended to build upon knowledge gained from StarCraft II. The historical numbers were clear: campaign players are the biggest audience, competitive players are the most persistent and vocal audience. Co-op appeals to a cross-section of both, and provides a vector for new players. Arcade is gravy on top.

Beyond these core modes, there's a need to grow the audience: even StarCraft II didn't have a big enough audience to warrant a sequel in today's market. In order to truly revitalize RTS, Stormgate had to aim higher.

So we set out for Stormgate to provide four foundational pillars (campaign, competitive, co-op, and custom), with expanded social play, and to consciously straddle the tastes of both existing players and a broader new audience. That's a tall order for a newly formed studio working in a new engine, building a new universe, with less time and resources than Blizzard. But this scope was based on data, and with some uniquely experienced developers, we believed we at least had a shot.


They deliberately chose this huge scope and they thought they could make it.


Would the outcome have been different with a smaller surface area? Would the outcome have been different focusing on just the existing audience?

The short answer is yes, but it's not clear that that would be a winning strategy either. Other recent releases with smaller surface area who focused on the existing audience produced $10M to $25M in gross revenue, according to Gamalytic. That's a better outcome than Stormgate, but still far short of the bar.

From the perspective of many large publishers, $100M in revenue is a modest outcome. $500M starts to get interesting. $1B and up is a typical aspiration for new releases.


And here he pretty much admits they weren't interested in starting small to grow later but tried to go for the top right off the bat.

Yeah? They did think they could pull it off in 2020. It doesn't mean he doesn't realize now that it was a mistake in hindsight.

Here is him shortly after EA launch saying that the big lesson they learned was that the game would have been more successful if they went with a narrower scope but a higher polish level:
https://youtu.be/IKbYztXs5uc?si=8LDrm5g1TVf6kA-f&t=1139

But that isn't a lesson 2 senior game producers and a whole team of experienced devs should still need to learn. That might be something their intern still needs to learn, but ffs, iterative design has been a staple of any software design for roughly 30 years now.
I don't think they thought they would be able to deliver everything at SC2 quality level at release. They probably knew they would first release a rough around the edges product and then iterate on it for a long time. They might have expected the audience to be more tolerant/supportive of the initial release knowing that it can't match SC2's current quality, content and features. You can argue they should have guessed that but I think that is only obvious with hindsight. It is not like anyone else tried it before. Stormgate was the first big budget RTS of this type since SC2. It will possibly be the last.

again, its not about people not being tolerant or supportive. Frost Giant should have never released a campaign in that initial state for early access. The entire blame falls on them. It was a mockery that they expected people to pay for those missions. The launch would have been better had it not been included at all. work in progress is not an excuse to put just anything out to the public, especially not if it is paid content. I cant recall any other early access that had that low level of quality control. I dont get how that was approved. I can somewhat understand wanting to get larger campaign mission feedback from a playerbase, but those cutscenes and character models had no right seeing the light of day.
It would have been better, sure. I don't think it would have been enough even if they released the campaign only at full launch and even if they made all those improvements without needing EA feedback. I think the bar a game of this style has to hit to get good reception is higher.
Yes, the bar is indeed higher then complete dogshit.
Thankfully.

Is it higher then can be reached with 40 million? Absolutely not.
It ignores such insignificant forces as time, entropy, and death
_Spartak_
Profile Joined October 2013
Turkey464 Posts
September 11 2025 10:12 GMT
#5256
I don't think current campaign is "dogshit" by any reasonable definition. The mission design is quite good. Calling it dogshit is proving my point about the bar being unrealistically high.
WombaT
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Northern Ireland27482 Posts
September 11 2025 12:24 GMT
#5257
On September 11 2025 19:12 _Spartak_ wrote:
I don't think current campaign is "dogshit" by any reasonable definition. The mission design is quite good. Calling it dogshit is proving my point about the bar being unrealistically high.

It’s pretty OK

If this was the first pass, and first chance most got to get their hands on the game, I think reception would have been ‘hey this is pretty good, it’s not SC2’s campaign quality, but not bad!’.

Unfortunately for Frost Giant, it’s way harder to pull back a bad impression with a ‘pretty good’, than it is to start off ‘pretty good’.

If I have a terrible first date, if I somehow convince her to go for a second, the second has to be like top tier good. A bad one followed by a merely decent one, hm, probably not enough. If we had a decent first date, and a decent/good second, that’s some decent momentum to build on.
'You'll always be the cuddly marsupial of my heart, despite the inherent flaws of your ancestry' - Squat
TL+ Member
ChillFlame
Profile Joined August 2024
336 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-11 14:22:11
September 11 2025 12:38 GMT
#5258
It's still miles behind the SC2 campaign.
Mission design, writing, characters, meta progression, cinematics. Everything is just a worse version of SC2.
So why would I play this if I can replay SC2 campaign for the 20th time and get a better experience?
Convincing players to pay for something that is just a bad copy of what they already have is hard.
I'd get it if the SG campaign did its own thing. But no, it just tries to copy SC2, but doesn't succeed.
RogerChillingworth
Profile Joined March 2010
Chad3132 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-11 16:59:42
September 11 2025 14:07 GMT
#5259
waste of time. my bad. gl hf !
_Spartak_
Profile Joined October 2013
Turkey464 Posts
Last Edited: 2025-09-12 05:44:15
September 11 2025 16:08 GMT
#5260
Screenshots above look far better than the ones below. Even on the subreddit, which is notoriously negative about the game, the art improvements were considered a big positive even if most of them didn't think it was enough.

Edit: For context, the above message was comparing the screenshots from the initial gameplay reveal of SG with screenshots from the current build, claiming that the former were better.
Prev 1 261 262 263 264 265 337 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
PiGosaur Cup
10:00
#108
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RuFF_SC2 218
SortOf 74
ProTech26
StarCraft: Brood War
Hyuk 169
ToSsGirL 102
Bale 39
ZergMaN 23
Noble 15
sOs 14
Icarus 8
Force[name] 5
League of Legends
JimRising 690
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King21
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr52
Other Games
summit1g12154
WinterStarcraft541
C9.Mang0339
ViBE71
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick945
[ Show 10 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2154
League of Legends
• Rush1456
Upcoming Events
The PondCast
4h 2m
University League
4h 2m
LiuLi Cup
5h 2m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
10h 2m
Replay Cast
17h 2m
GSL
1d 5h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 8h
OSC
1d 10h
Replay Cast
1d 17h
KCM Race Survival
2 days
[ Show More ]
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.