• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 20:59
CET 02:59
KST 10:59
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over6Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
People still play BW? SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement Potentially helpful Shield Battery feedback. List of top players active on ShieldBattery XUN appreciation thread
Tourneys
2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19)
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread The PlayStation 5 Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread The Games Industry And ATVI Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 19527 users

The Elephant in the Room - Page 270

Forum Index > Final Edits
6515 CommentsPost a Reply
Prev 1 268 269 270 271 272 326 Next
Big J
Profile Joined March 2011
Austria16289 Posts
February 13 2012 19:02 GMT
#5381
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:17 Seraphone wrote:
On February 13 2012 23:03 Big J wrote:
On February 13 2012 22:31 Squeegy wrote:
[quote]

Now, now, don't be so hard on yourself. But when you are willing to learn, do come back to me. I will gladly teach you. Meanwhile, make sure you don't strain yourself working at that assembly line.

So you agree 100% with what the article tried to convey. That is with what I've been saying. I think you are a very confused one. You should make up your mind.

[quote]

You'd think the best RTS player would do better in an RTS. No, there are many BW players better than him.


Moon>Flash in WC3 (from what they have achieved yet)
Moon>Flash in SC2 (from what they have achieved yet)
Flash>Moon in BW (from what they have achieved yet)
2-1 for Moon in terms of in how many categories they have competed on high level. (Flash is just an example... read Jaedong/Bisu/anyone who has played BW only until now if you want to)

Other objective indicators?!
Prize money? I think Moon is the one who won the most money with gaming yet, but don't know. Couldn't google the exact stats, but I think Artosis mentioned it somewhere in the OpenGSL seasons.
Market value? He had best contract up to now of all esport gamers with 500.000$ for 3years at WeMadeFox.


Not saying he is the best (I don't think anyone can be the best in a such a huge genre... that's like saying Albert Einstein was the best scientist ever...), but a lot of objective indicators that I know of all point towards him.
Of course if you argue NaDa or Boxer or even Grubby, it will become a lot more tricky...


This is a truly ridiculous post. Just unbelievably absurd.


you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem
Seraphone
Profile Joined January 2012
United Kingdom1219 Posts
February 13 2012 19:06 GMT
#5382
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:17 Seraphone wrote:
On February 13 2012 23:03 Big J wrote:
[quote]

Moon>Flash in WC3 (from what they have achieved yet)
Moon>Flash in SC2 (from what they have achieved yet)
Flash>Moon in BW (from what they have achieved yet)
2-1 for Moon in terms of in how many categories they have competed on high level. (Flash is just an example... read Jaedong/Bisu/anyone who has played BW only until now if you want to)

Other objective indicators?!
Prize money? I think Moon is the one who won the most money with gaming yet, but don't know. Couldn't google the exact stats, but I think Artosis mentioned it somewhere in the OpenGSL seasons.
Market value? He had best contract up to now of all esport gamers with 500.000$ for 3years at WeMadeFox.


Not saying he is the best (I don't think anyone can be the best in a such a huge genre... that's like saying Albert Einstein was the best scientist ever...), but a lot of objective indicators that I know of all point towards him.
Of course if you argue NaDa or Boxer or even Grubby, it will become a lot more tricky...


This is a truly ridiculous post. Just unbelievably absurd.


you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


I take that back actually, Tiger Woods is the best.
Mvp, Nestea, Leenock, MC, Oz, Jjakji!
Big J
Profile Joined March 2011
Austria16289 Posts
February 13 2012 19:08 GMT
#5383
On February 14 2012 04:06 Seraphone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:17 Seraphone wrote:
[quote]

This is a truly ridiculous post. Just unbelievably absurd.


you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


I take that back actually, Tiger Woods is the best.


then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.
Seraphone
Profile Joined January 2012
United Kingdom1219 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 19:12:19
February 13 2012 19:11 GMT
#5384
On February 14 2012 04:08 Big J wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 04:06 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
[quote]

you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


I take that back actually, Tiger Woods is the best.


then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.


Nope, wrong again I'm afraid.

Football might be the most popular sports but Golf is also extremely popular and difficult and Messi is not the greatest footballer of all time, he's just the current best, where as Tiger Woods is the greatest of all time. Which puts him ahead of Messi.

Moon is the greatest of all time (only just over Grubby) in a far inferior game which is much easier to be the best in. Where as he's up against the absolute undisputed greatest of all time in a superior game in Flash.

There is a balance to be struck and Moon falls way short of it, where as Tiger Woods does not.
Mvp, Nestea, Leenock, MC, Oz, Jjakji!
dsousa
Profile Joined October 2011
United States1363 Posts
February 13 2012 19:15 GMT
#5385
Check out the top players on the right hand side of this page ---->

Even in Korea..... MMA, DRG and Leenock were not BW pro's. A year ago the top 5 had more BW representation (with people like Rainbow, Tester and Fruitdealer being much more relevant

BW influence on SC2 in waning, as is evident by the up and coming crop of players.

The elephant in the room is that there are 10 million 12-15 year old kids, who will soon be entering their prime while having grown up playing SC2. That's what current pro's need to worry about, not people playing another game.
BlazeFury01
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
United States1460 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 19:19:23
February 13 2012 19:19 GMT
#5386
On February 12 2012 21:33 david0925 wrote:
Saying SC2 has a low skill ceiling is just a roundabout way of saying how BW is harder than SC2 and how people wish SC2 kept the old things from BW.

I know BW has that immaculate place in a lot of old fans' hearts, but let's be realistic here.

1.Even pros make tons of macro or mechanic mistakes. People have been arguing that pros in SC2 suck compared to pros in BW, and we can't really confirm or deny that notion until those players deemed good BW players make the shift and either prosper or fail in the SC2 scene.

2.A lot of changes from BW to SC2 are just quality of life changes. Sure they are "easier", but that's no different than doing complicated math with a calculator or screwing in bolts with an electric screwdriver: the tools improve. If you really want to play the old way you can limit yourself to 12 units per control group, set your miner rally next to mineral lines, and individually group up casters to avoid smartcasts. I do not have a good proposal of how to make your Stalkers mimic the retarded Dragoon movement in BW though.



Well, the reason why they say the SC2 pros suck compared to the SC1 pros is because the SC2 pros are ex-brood war players that were considered nothing more the mediocre, MVP included. MC was known as the "Suicide Toss" namely because he did a ceremony before the game and always ended up losing thus making him a laughing stock of the scene.

However, I think the argument should be left alone because well...It isn't really solving anything and it's really matter of opinion (besides the evidence from the past about SC-2 Pros).
Big J
Profile Joined March 2011
Austria16289 Posts
February 13 2012 19:20 GMT
#5387
On February 14 2012 04:11 Seraphone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 04:08 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:06 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
[quote]

I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


I take that back actually, Tiger Woods is the best.


then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.


Nope, wrong again I'm afraid.

Football might be the most popular sports but Golf is also extremely popular and difficult and Messi is not the greatest footballer of all time, he's just the current best, where as Tiger Woods is the greatest of all time. Which puts him ahead of Messi.

Moon is the greatest of all time (only just over Grubby) in a far inferior game which is much easier to be the best in. Where as he's up against the absolute undisputed greatest of all time in a superior game in Flash.

There is a balance to be struck and Moon falls way short of it, where as Tiger Woods does not.


From wikipedia
At the turn of the 21st century, the game was played by over 250 million players in over 200 countries, making it the world's most popular sport. - football has the greater scale --> Messi is the best by your logic.

Also I wrote active sportsman. Not in the last post, but if you have something called memory, I'm sure you will remember it.
rasers
Profile Joined February 2010
Sweden691 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 19:23:41
February 13 2012 19:22 GMT
#5388
On February 14 2012 03:50 TheDougler wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:17 Seraphone wrote:
On February 13 2012 23:03 Big J wrote:
On February 13 2012 22:31 Squeegy wrote:
On February 13 2012 19:18 Longshank wrote:
[quote]

You are correct, I truly do not understand, and I probably never will. Much like a child being taught algebra by a donkey, it's futile. I just hope you understand why there is confusion when by 'dominate' he meant 'playing roughly at the same level as', 'SC2 scene' was really 'non ex-BW players' and now when the 300 players that could come in and dominate at any given time also includes the current(at the time) 40-50 ex-bw pros that had already switched.

[quote]

I agree 100% with this. The problem is the language and the construction of the OP. He could have chosen a different approach, one more balanced and leveled, one that wouldn't alienate 90% of the readers. He didn't unfortunately.


I'm done with this topic, the ugly thing can not die if I keep bumping it :/



Now, now, don't be so hard on yourself. But when you are willing to learn, do come back to me. I will gladly teach you. Meanwhile, make sure you don't strain yourself working at that assembly line.

So you agree 100% with what the article tried to convey. That is with what I've been saying. I think you are a very confused one. You should make up your mind.

On February 13 2012 15:47 canikizu wrote:
[quote]
I'm thinking Moon tbh lolz.


You'd think the best RTS player would do better in an RTS. No, there are many BW players better than him.


Moon>Flash in WC3 (from what they have achieved yet)
Moon>Flash in SC2 (from what they have achieved yet)
Flash>Moon in BW (from what they have achieved yet)
2-1 for Moon in terms of in how many categories they have competed on high level. (Flash is just an example... read Jaedong/Bisu/anyone who has played BW only until now if you want to)

Other objective indicators?!
Prize money? I think Moon is the one who won the most money with gaming yet, but don't know. Couldn't google the exact stats, but I think Artosis mentioned it somewhere in the OpenGSL seasons.
Market value? He had best contract up to now of all esport gamers with 500.000$ for 3years at WeMadeFox.


Not saying he is the best (I don't think anyone can be the best in a such a huge genre... that's like saying Albert Einstein was the best scientist ever...), but a lot of objective indicators that I know of all point towards him.
Of course if you argue NaDa or Boxer or even Grubby, it will become a lot more tricky...


This is a truly ridiculous post. Just unbelievably absurd.


you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.

Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Really buddy? Are you actually telling me there were more people playing SCBW at it's peak in Korea than playing WC3 at it's peak in China, Korea and Europe combined? Hell, I'm pretty certain that even if you just compared SCBW in Korea to WC3 in China, Korea get's it's ass handed to it. And of course WC3 players are saying it's harder to be a top player in SC2 than WC3, it's a different game than the game that they had grown up playing and being competitive players in. SC2 and SCBW are economy based RTS games, WC3 is not. That doesn't mean that WC3 is less competitive just that they are different games


well there are most likely more people playing wc3. but they dont play it for Wc3. they play it for dota.

so if u talk about wc3 players (not dota) yes SCBW has more players. if u add the Dota players in most likely not.
and plz... Thorzain and Naniwa werent that top players in wc3... so dunno hwo they can say its easier if they werent at the top in wc3.

Seraphone
Profile Joined January 2012
United Kingdom1219 Posts
February 13 2012 19:24 GMT
#5389
On February 14 2012 04:20 Big J wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 04:11 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:08 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:06 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
[quote]


Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


I take that back actually, Tiger Woods is the best.


then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.


Nope, wrong again I'm afraid.

Football might be the most popular sports but Golf is also extremely popular and difficult and Messi is not the greatest footballer of all time, he's just the current best, where as Tiger Woods is the greatest of all time. Which puts him ahead of Messi.

Moon is the greatest of all time (only just over Grubby) in a far inferior game which is much easier to be the best in. Where as he's up against the absolute undisputed greatest of all time in a superior game in Flash.

There is a balance to be struck and Moon falls way short of it, where as Tiger Woods does not.


From wikipedia
At the turn of the 21st century, the game was played by over 250 million players in over 200 countries, making it the world's most popular sport. - football has the greater scale --> Messi is the best by your logic.

Also I wrote active sportsman. Not in the last post, but if you have something called memory, I'm sure you will remember it.


You completely missed the point.
Mvp, Nestea, Leenock, MC, Oz, Jjakji!
Pooploop
Profile Joined June 2011
United States10 Posts
February 13 2012 19:32 GMT
#5390
On February 14 2012 04:15 dsousa wrote:
Check out the top players on the right hand side of this page ---->

Even in Korea..... MMA, DRG and Leenock were not BW pro's. A year ago the top 5 had more BW representation (with people like Rainbow, Tester and Fruitdealer being much more relevant

BW influence on SC2 in waning, as is evident by the up and coming crop of players.

The elephant in the room is that there are 10 million 12-15 year old kids, who will soon be entering their prime while having grown up playing SC2. That's what current pro's need to worry about, not people playing another game.


MMA was on SKT1 and DRG was a CJ practice partner...
1Eris1
Profile Joined September 2010
United States5797 Posts
February 13 2012 19:40 GMT
#5391
On February 14 2012 04:15 dsousa wrote:
Check out the top players on the right hand side of this page ---->

Even in Korea..... MMA, DRG and Leenock were not BW pro's. A year ago the top 5 had more BW representation (with people like Rainbow, Tester and Fruitdealer being much more relevant

BW influence on SC2 in waning, as is evident by the up and coming crop of players.

The elephant in the room is that there are 10 million 12-15 year old kids, who will soon be entering their prime while having grown up playing SC2. That's what current pro's need to worry about, not people playing another game.


MMA and DRG were bw pros though, just not very successful ones. It was bw that got them into sc2...

Also lolol @ 10-15 million players. There's only several hundred thousand sc2 players in Korea, and maybe two million in the world. Plus not all of them are kids...
Known Aliases: Tyragon, Valeric ~MSL Forever, SKT is truly the Superior KT!
Zorkmid
Profile Joined November 2008
4410 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 19:45:25
February 13 2012 19:45 GMT
#5392
On February 14 2012 04:11 Seraphone wrote:
Then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.

Nope, wrong again I'm afraid.

Football might be the most popular sports but Golf is also extremely popular and difficult and Messi is not the greatest footballer of all time, he's just the current best, where as Tiger Woods is the greatest of all time. Which puts him ahead of Messi.


Tiger being the best golfer ever is debatable.

On February 14 2012 04:11 Seraphone wrote:
Moon is the greatest of all time (only just over Grubby) in a far inferior game which is much easier to be the best in. Where as he's up against the absolute undisputed greatest of all time in a superior game in Flash.

There is a balance to be struck and Moon falls way short of it, where as Tiger Woods does not.


It doesn't whether or not you subjectively believe that WC3 is either inferior or superior to X game, what matters is the number and quality of the competitors.

A better comparison would be that it's easier to become the best box lacrosse player than the best golfer or soccer player...due to the number of competitors.


Taiki
Profile Joined December 2011
Norway57 Posts
February 13 2012 19:46 GMT
#5393
On February 14 2012 04:15 dsousa wrote:
Check out the top players on the right hand side of this page ---->

Even in Korea..... MMA, DRG and Leenock were not BW pro's. A year ago the top 5 had more BW representation (with people like Rainbow, Tester and Fruitdealer being much more relevant

BW influence on SC2 in waning, as is evident by the up and coming crop of players.

The elephant in the room is that there are 10 million 12-15 year old kids, who will soon be entering their prime while having grown up playing SC2. That's what current pro's need to worry about, not people playing another game.


Wait. I'm pretty sure that MMA was on SKT (remember a interview where Oov said that he was sad that MMA switched to SC2) , according to Liquidpedia DRG was on CJ, MvP was on Woongjin and Nestea was on KT. The only one I couldn't find any BW info on was Leenock.

I don't really support any side, but right is right.

As for my own opinion. I think that if all the BW players switched at the time when this article was writting, most of them would've been the top of SC2 along with those who were already playing the game and the best of the best at BW would've settled comfortably in top10 of SC2. I also don't think there is enough room (in SC2) for a player like Flash to dominate a player like MvP as hard as he would've done in BW.
Seraphone
Profile Joined January 2012
United Kingdom1219 Posts
February 13 2012 19:52 GMT
#5394
On February 14 2012 04:45 Zorkmid wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 04:11 Seraphone wrote:
Then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.

Nope, wrong again I'm afraid.

Football might be the most popular sports but Golf is also extremely popular and difficult and Messi is not the greatest footballer of all time, he's just the current best, where as Tiger Woods is the greatest of all time. Which puts him ahead of Messi.


Tiger being the best golfer ever is debatable.


Jack is like Boxer/Nada and Tiger is like Flash. There's a few nostalgics who still maintain Boxer/Nada are the greatest but objectively Flash/Tiger are the more successful and better players.
Mvp, Nestea, Leenock, MC, Oz, Jjakji!
RvB
Profile Blog Joined December 2010
Netherlands6328 Posts
February 13 2012 19:56 GMT
#5395
On February 14 2012 04:15 dsousa wrote:
Check out the top players on the right hand side of this page ---->

Even in Korea..... MMA, DRG and Leenock were not BW pro's. A year ago the top 5 had more BW representation (with people like Rainbow, Tester and Fruitdealer being much more relevant

BW influence on SC2 in waning, as is evident by the up and coming crop of players.

The elephant in the room is that there are 10 million 12-15 year old kids, who will soon be entering their prime while having grown up playing SC2. That's what current pro's need to worry about, not people playing another game.


How is that an elephant in the room, it works like that in every sport and it was the same in BW.
scDeluX
Profile Blog Joined October 2007
Canada1341 Posts
February 13 2012 19:57 GMT
#5396
On February 14 2012 04:46 Taiki wrote:
As for my own opinion. I think that if all the BW players switched at the time when this article was writing, most of them would've been the top of SC2 along with those who were already playing the game and the best of the best at BW would've settled comfortably in top10 of SC2.


I think this is still stands. If all the A-teamer would switch after the current proleague/OSL, I would not be surprised to see the top 25 in code S / code A within 3 month. They have the infrastructures, money, coaches, time and most importantly the skill. I believe SC2 can be learn relatively fast.


On February 14 2012 04:46 Taiki wrote:
I also don't think there is enough room (in SC2) for a player like Flash to dominate a player like MvP as hard as he would've done in BW.


Sadly this is true.
Brood War is forever
zawk9
Profile Joined March 2011
United States427 Posts
Last Edited: 2012-02-13 19:58:50
February 13 2012 19:57 GMT
#5397
On February 14 2012 04:20 Big J wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 04:11 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:08 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:06 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
[quote]


Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


I take that back actually, Tiger Woods is the best.


then either you are wrong with that, or your logic is wrong, because your logic says Messi is the best.


Nope, wrong again I'm afraid.

Football might be the most popular sports but Golf is also extremely popular and difficult and Messi is not the greatest footballer of all time, he's just the current best, where as Tiger Woods is the greatest of all time. Which puts him ahead of Messi.

Moon is the greatest of all time (only just over Grubby) in a far inferior game which is much easier to be the best in. Where as he's up against the absolute undisputed greatest of all time in a superior game in Flash.

There is a balance to be struck and Moon falls way short of it, where as Tiger Woods does not.


From wikipedia
At the turn of the 21st century, the game was played by over 250 million players in over 200 countries, making it the world's most popular sport. - football has the greater scale --> Messi is the best by your logic.

Also I wrote active sportsman. Not in the last post, but if you have something called memory, I'm sure you will remember it.


No sorry your assuming the difference between those sports is smaller than it is.

Brood War and SC2, like those physical sports share some commonalities in terms of skill set, but aren't identical.

I'd argue the skills involved far more similar than the two sports you cite (which is actually quite easy to objectively evaluate).
there's a bug in the new patch where the other player keeps killing all my dudes.. please nerf this
setzer
Profile Joined March 2010
United States3284 Posts
February 13 2012 20:03 GMT
#5398
On February 14 2012 04:15 dsousa wrote:
Check out the top players on the right hand side of this page ---->

Even in Korea..... MMA, DRG and Leenock were not BW pro's. A year ago the top 5 had more BW representation (with people like Rainbow, Tester and Fruitdealer being much more relevant

BW influence on SC2 in waning, as is evident by the up and coming crop of players.

The elephant in the room is that there are 10 million 12-15 year old kids, who will soon be entering their prime while having grown up playing SC2. That's what current pro's need to worry about, not people playing another game.


I know it's your mission on this forum to try and disparage BW and it's players but at least attempt to do so without posting blatantly false information. How can you even claim that BW influence is waning when BW is still the most popular game in Korea and there is still a vast number of progamers that could potentially switch from that game and be better than the current best.
jobber123rd
Profile Joined December 2011
United States501 Posts
February 13 2012 20:03 GMT
#5399
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:17 Seraphone wrote:
On February 13 2012 23:03 Big J wrote:
[quote]

Moon>Flash in WC3 (from what they have achieved yet)
Moon>Flash in SC2 (from what they have achieved yet)
Flash>Moon in BW (from what they have achieved yet)
2-1 for Moon in terms of in how many categories they have competed on high level. (Flash is just an example... read Jaedong/Bisu/anyone who has played BW only until now if you want to)

Other objective indicators?!
Prize money? I think Moon is the one who won the most money with gaming yet, but don't know. Couldn't google the exact stats, but I think Artosis mentioned it somewhere in the OpenGSL seasons.
Market value? He had best contract up to now of all esport gamers with 500.000$ for 3years at WeMadeFox.


Not saying he is the best (I don't think anyone can be the best in a such a huge genre... that's like saying Albert Einstein was the best scientist ever...), but a lot of objective indicators that I know of all point towards him.
Of course if you argue NaDa or Boxer or even Grubby, it will become a lot more tricky...


This is a truly ridiculous post. Just unbelievably absurd.


you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


Muggsy Bogues, Earl Boykins, and Spud Webb would say otherwise
"I'm always going to survive. Only reason I can't survive is if I'm dead or something." --Mike Tyson
zawk9
Profile Joined March 2011
United States427 Posts
February 13 2012 20:03 GMT
#5400
On February 14 2012 04:02 Big J wrote:
Show nested quote +
On February 14 2012 03:45 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:44 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:15 Seraphone wrote:
On February 14 2012 03:08 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 02:20 TheDougler wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:29 Djabanete wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:27 Big J wrote:
On February 14 2012 01:17 Seraphone wrote:
On February 13 2012 23:03 Big J wrote:
[quote]

Moon>Flash in WC3 (from what they have achieved yet)
Moon>Flash in SC2 (from what they have achieved yet)
Flash>Moon in BW (from what they have achieved yet)
2-1 for Moon in terms of in how many categories they have competed on high level. (Flash is just an example... read Jaedong/Bisu/anyone who has played BW only until now if you want to)

Other objective indicators?!
Prize money? I think Moon is the one who won the most money with gaming yet, but don't know. Couldn't google the exact stats, but I think Artosis mentioned it somewhere in the OpenGSL seasons.
Market value? He had best contract up to now of all esport gamers with 500.000$ for 3years at WeMadeFox.


Not saying he is the best (I don't think anyone can be the best in a such a huge genre... that's like saying Albert Einstein was the best scientist ever...), but a lot of objective indicators that I know of all point towards him.
Of course if you argue NaDa or Boxer or even Grubby, it will become a lot more tricky...


This is a truly ridiculous post. Just unbelievably absurd.


you care to say why, or is it just a rediculous post?
Like green is just the same as blue.


I'd tend to think the best RTS player is Flash, but maybe I just don't understand how good Moon was at WC3. I'd also tend to think BW is a better RTS than WC3, but maybe I just don't understand how good WC3 is.

Basically, it's a meaningless comparison. But if I gave each of them one year to master an RTS and then play a Bo7, I'd bet on Flash to win every single match (including SC2) except WC3.

(Wow, I looked at Moon's wiki page and it seems like he's won a lot. That is cool!)



Edit: Also, I don't know about WC3 being less competitive. It was the first truly globally competitive e-sport. An argument could be made that it was "easier to learn" but as SCBW was only truly competitive in Korea, while WC3 had top players from around the world (Grubby, Sky, and Moon being the pinnacle of the three main regions), I've got to give it to WC3 for being more competitive as it had a larger competitive player base to draw from.


Quoting the part I edited in after a half hour. The more I think about that actually the more true I believe it is that WC3 was the more competitive game. Yeah Korea has a HUGE population of SCBW players, and a few competitive international players as well of course... But WC3 has all that, more europeans and MOTHERFUGGIN CHINA. So I mean... that's a SERIOUS note in the talk of "best RTS player". But still, I agree that it's an awful lot like asking "who is the best player at sports". Most will realize it's a stupid question, others (such as myself) will vehemently claim Wayne Gretzky, or Mohamed Ali, or Michael Jordan because we fucking love Wayne Gretzky or "those other guys". It's fanboyism and it's awesome but it often gets taken to extremes, which has happened a lot in this thread. Even if CLEARLY the Great One is the best.


Your point is wrong because while Wc3 was more international there was far more people in Korea alone making a living (i.e playing professionally not needing to work/study/sponge off parents) playing BW in Korea than in the entire Wc3 scene.

It doesn't matter which country something happened in so long as it is on a greater scale.


Also the sole fact Wc3 was international is testament to how much easier it was to be good. You literally had zero chance of every being at all competitive in BW without living in a Korean pro house. You could easily play from home and grind Battle.net and be good at Wc3.

Why do you think you know more than Sase and Naniwa who have both stated that it is much harder to be a top player in Sc2 than Wc3 nevermind BW.


Lionel Messi is the best active football player (by professional voting, the generally accepted decisionmaking for that term in football; 3times in a row). Football is the biggest sport (greater scale than any other sport; more active players, professionals, fans, viewers).
By your logic Lionel Messi is the one true and undisputed best active sportsman in the world.
I rest my case, your logic has beaten me.


Messi is the best active sportsman in the world so no problem.


Ok... I just hope he is never gonna switch to basketball. I heard you gotta be really tall for that sport.
(not even want to think about him playing chess or something)
But by your logic... no problem


This is wrong as well. There have been extremely short basketball players who make up for it with sheer athleticism, speed, agility, or other various skills.

As I said the skill sets are different, but they do translate and this is why there are so many multisport stars on college teams in the United States. Think of Bo Jackson for instance- an undeniable star in both of the two ridiculously different sports he played.
there's a bug in the new patch where the other player keeps killing all my dudes.. please nerf this
Prev 1 268 269 270 271 272 326 Next
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
The PiG Daily
06:25
Best Games of SC
Clem vs Classic
Rogue vs Neeb
MaxPax vs Bunny
SHIN vs Clem
GuMiho vs SHIN
PiGStarcraft490
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft490
StarCraft: Brood War
Shuttle 478
MaD[AoV]25
910 10
Counter-Strike
fl0m382
Heroes of the Storm
Khaldor213
Other Games
gofns10371
summit1g8001
JimRising 432
Trikslyr66
Mew2King57
WinterStarcraft23
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1029
BasetradeTV108
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 98
• Airneanach16
• davetesta9
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Pr0nogo 2
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Other Games
• Scarra777
Upcoming Events
RSL Revival
11h 1m
Clem vs Serral
herO vs Rogue
OSC
11h 1m
IPSL
15h 1m
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
18h 1m
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
21h 1m
WardiTV Weekly
1d 10h
Kung Fu Cup
2 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
2 days
The PondCast
4 days
KCM Race Survival
4 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
RSL Offline Finals
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

CSL Season 23: Qualifier 1
Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
CSL 2026 Winter (S23) - 3v3
CSL 2026 Winter (S23)
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.