To ensure this thread won't be closed, you must adhere to several a number of simple rules;
Please use spoilers when quoting a post with pictures and/or videos.
When posting large quantities of media (pictures or videos), please begin spoilering after the first piece. Grouping related videos in the same spoilers & labeling is recommended.
No reposting of old material unless justified
Posting any material with little or no relevent discussion accompanying it
No passion-induced flaming of each other because 'x said y sucked' etc.
Keep the expression hate of music individuals/groups to a minimal level
No 'pagetopping' in any form whatsoever, as it constitutes spam equal to posts similar to 'first'.
No vulgar fan fics or wet dream stories. It is creepy, weird, and it dehumanizes the people who you are here to celebrate/discuss.
Normal posting standards that you find throughout the rest of the site still apply and will be enforced more strictly from here forward (2012/03/11)
Due to the poor nature of this thread in the past, temporary two-day bans will occur more than often if people slip up.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
On January 22 2013 16:45 GTR wrote: I was excited when I heard that Davichi were going to leave CCM, as I felt leaving the company would compel them to return to their roots (where they produced their best music).
With them actually staying at CCM however, I have little to no faith that their new album will make me change their current opinion of them.
disagree, ccm is where they made their best music. if anything you'd have to blame their current trend of incorporating rap portions in ballads.
woosh, rofl at that coming from moon of all people.
KMK, obviously a qtpie but she misses notes awfully often in live performances outside davichi. Her range is pretty weak to be honest. Still qtpie and good enough, that gives her a leg up over 90+% of kpop singers, not actual singers though oh heavens she is bottom tier there. still qtpie though
Haeri you can't hate, she is pretty good and can pull off some wilder genres.
About their new album, eh, I'm happy with amaranth and their OSTs, everything else under CCM has been a throughout disappointment. Hope they change that and no fucking rap breaks please.
On January 22 2013 16:21 Aerisky wrote: In the KMK video a lot of the audience looks decidedly unimpressed though lol.
that show is kinda harsh sometimes, the pokerfaces on Miss A's thing were glorious.
^yeah, KMK isn't there to be an amazing vocalist she's there because she has the relatively rare kidol combination of being really hot while also being able to keep in tune (most are only good at one or average at both). Haeri is there to sound good, KMK is there to be the visuals/backup.
Plus she's gonna sound worse next to Haeri, slot her in a "dance" group and you'd be calling her one of the better singers in it.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
Thats cute, I can make a random bs "non-opinionated" ranking and then attempt to qualify it by saying I hate someone's voice too if I really had to, and guess what it would hold just as little water as your fun little attempt does.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
On January 22 2013 16:45 GTR wrote: I was excited when I heard that Davichi were going to leave CCM, as I felt leaving the company would compel them to return to their roots (where they produced their best music).
With them actually staying at CCM however, I have little to no faith that their new album will make me change their current opinion of them.
disagree, ccm is where they made their best music. if anything you'd have to blame their current trend of incorporating rap portions in ballads.
Just curious if you put Taeyeon in top 10 who are the ones you would put above her counting Hyorin and Davichi out?
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
On January 22 2013 16:45 GTR wrote: I was excited when I heard that Davichi were going to leave CCM, as I felt leaving the company would compel them to return to their roots (where they produced their best music).
With them actually staying at CCM however, I have little to no faith that their new album will make me change their current opinion of them.
disagree, ccm is where they made their best music. if anything you'd have to blame their current trend of incorporating rap portions in ballads.
Just curious if you put Taeyeon in top 10 who are the ones you would put above her counting Hyorin and Davichi out?
Ailee is the only one that comes straight to mind when I think of someone better than Taeyeon. Though mine is just opinion as I have zero idea about voice ranges, who reaches higher octaves and all that jazz.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
hhahaha is this real life? trollpost #1 for 2013 so far.
who cares, its just personal prefference in any case, if u like davichi u like davichi, if u dont u dont, as long as the voices make the song sound good to u, all is good. The stuff i here i cant complain about, i dont listen to most live stuff anyway and the dissapointment of t-ara or kara live is long gone (or for that matter cuz i just listen to them sohee live haha)
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
Thats cute, I can make a random bs "non-opinionated" ranking and then attempt to qualify it by saying I hate someone's voice too if I really had to, and guess what it would hold just as little water as your fun little attempt does.
Davichi top 3, decent joke I guess.
cute little deflection and attempt at disqualifying my opinion by belittling it without reason. I'm eagerly awaiting your more valid ranking based on the valuable input we always expect from your posts.
No seriously, I'm sure you're an avid fan of ballads and can give us great insight on rankings of vocal ability.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
On January 22 2013 16:45 GTR wrote: I was excited when I heard that Davichi were going to leave CCM, as I felt leaving the company would compel them to return to their roots (where they produced their best music).
With them actually staying at CCM however, I have little to no faith that their new album will make me change their current opinion of them.
disagree, ccm is where they made their best music. if anything you'd have to blame their current trend of incorporating rap portions in ballads.
Just curious if you put Taeyeon in top 10 who are the ones you would put above her counting Hyorin and Davichi out?
Ailee is the only one that comes straight to mind when I think of someone better than Taeyeon. Though mine is just opinion as I have zero idea about voice ranges, who reaches higher octaves and all that jazz.
strictly idols? off the top of my head: all of jyj, jokwon, changmin, lee hyun, jonghyun, yunheok and dk, kmk and lee haeri, etc.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
Thats cute, I can make a random bs "non-opinionated" ranking and then attempt to qualify it by saying I hate someone's voice too if I really had to, and guess what it would hold just as little water as your fun little attempt does.
Davichi top 3, decent joke I guess.
cute little deflection and attempt at disqualifying my opinion by belittling it without reason. I'm eagerly awaiting your more valid ranking based on the valuable input we always expect from your posts.
No seriously, I'm sure you're an avid fan of ballads and can give us great insight on rankings of vocal ability.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
On January 22 2013 16:45 GTR wrote: I was excited when I heard that Davichi were going to leave CCM, as I felt leaving the company would compel them to return to their roots (where they produced their best music).
With them actually staying at CCM however, I have little to no faith that their new album will make me change their current opinion of them.
disagree, ccm is where they made their best music. if anything you'd have to blame their current trend of incorporating rap portions in ballads.
Just curious if you put Taeyeon in top 10 who are the ones you would put above her counting Hyorin and Davichi out?
Ailee is the only one that comes straight to mind when I think of someone better than Taeyeon. Though mine is just opinion as I have zero idea about voice ranges, who reaches higher octaves and all that jazz.
strictly idols? off the top of my head: all of jyj, jokwon, changmin, lee hyun, jonghyun, yunheok and dk, kmk and lee haeri, etc.
Well I said in my own post that my opinion on this is no more important/correct than anyone else's and I'm not going to try to act like it is like you seemed to be trying to do with your post.
On January 22 2013 19:28 seiferoth10 wrote: Changmin 2am or DBSK? + Show Spoiler +
The correct answer is both.
Correct answer is that 2am Changmin rips everyone else's heads off, dude is pretty huge.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
Thats cute, I can make a random bs "non-opinionated" ranking and then attempt to qualify it by saying I hate someone's voice too if I really had to, and guess what it would hold just as little water as your fun little attempt does.
Davichi top 3, decent joke I guess.
cute little deflection and attempt at disqualifying my opinion by belittling it without reason. I'm eagerly awaiting your more valid ranking based on the valuable input we always expect from your posts.
No seriously, I'm sure you're an avid fan of ballads and can give us great insight on rankings of vocal ability.
On January 22 2013 16:02 Moonwrath wrote: Davichi is way overrated. Their vocals always sound the same. KMK is pretty bad tbh, I mean she's basically selling her body in that porn CF, she uses butt padding (lol I mean come on...) She basically doesn't have any redeemable qualities about her and is not really all that good looking. Much better singers out there too that can actually sing in different ways. Not good.
I'm not sure whether I should type a serious response to this. Disregarding all the hypocrisy, one thing I will say is that I agree Davichi aren't the best singers in the music industry by a long shot, but I'd definitely put them in the top 3 of idol vocalists. It's not a matter of taste, either. For reference, I hate Hyorin's voice with a passion, but I'd put her in top 5, and Taeyeon in maybe top 10, probably leaning towards top 15.
On January 22 2013 16:45 GTR wrote: I was excited when I heard that Davichi were going to leave CCM, as I felt leaving the company would compel them to return to their roots (where they produced their best music).
With them actually staying at CCM however, I have little to no faith that their new album will make me change their current opinion of them.
disagree, ccm is where they made their best music. if anything you'd have to blame their current trend of incorporating rap portions in ballads.
Just curious if you put Taeyeon in top 10 who are the ones you would put above her counting Hyorin and Davichi out?
Ailee is the only one that comes straight to mind when I think of someone better than Taeyeon. Though mine is just opinion as I have zero idea about voice ranges, who reaches higher octaves and all that jazz.
strictly idols? off the top of my head: all of jyj, jokwon, changmin, lee hyun, jonghyun, yunheok and dk, kmk and lee haeri, etc.
Oh I thought we were only talking about female idols haha. Oh hell yeah I know there's quite a few male singers, but like I said in my post I know nothing about singing so meh.
EPT![[image loading]](http://cfile2.uf.tistory.com/image/230D103350F411B4050F71)
