EPT1.Taeyeon
2.Jessica
3.Tiffany
4.Seohyun
5.+ Show Spoiler +
you mad? 
Korean Music Discussion - Page 2240
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
To ensure this thread won't be closed, you must adhere to
Due to the poor nature of this thread in the past, temporary two-day bans will occur more than often if people slip up. | ||
|
KroplaBeskidu
1093 Posts
1.Taeyeon 2.Jessica 3.Tiffany 4.Seohyun 5.+ Show Spoiler + | ||
|
PatouPower
Canada1119 Posts
| ||
|
Pulselol
Canada1628 Posts
On January 15 2012 14:08 KroplaBeskidu wrote: top 5 vocals: 1.Taeyeon 2.Jessica 3.Tiffany 4.Seohyun 5.+ Show Spoiler + you mad? not even close to mad + Show Spoiler + I almost agree for spots 2-5 | ||
|
RezChi
Canada2368 Posts
On January 15 2012 14:08 KroplaBeskidu wrote: top 5 vocals: 1.Taeyeon 2.Jessica 3.Tiffany 4.Seohyun 5.+ Show Spoiler + you mad? What is this? Top 5 vocals of SNSD, maybe. But 2-4 can't even sing. | ||
|
lifeisgood99
Canada915 Posts
| ||
|
mizU
United States12125 Posts
| ||
|
Moonwrath
United States9568 Posts
Tiffany #2 Jessica Seohyun Sunny tie for #3 Sunny is seriously underrated. | ||
|
Fawkes
Canada1935 Posts
On January 15 2012 14:12 PatouPower wrote: ^I totally agree with your top 1. Taeyeon es #1. I don't even know who I would rank second in the industry...*goes and listen to things* | ||
|
Megaliskuu
United States5123 Posts
| ||
|
UrASofty
Canada772 Posts
On January 15 2012 13:52 andyrau wrote: lol people in this thread that judge singing. If you've ever been vocally tutored or trained, or have any experience with vocals, you'd know that range is naturally bestowed. Even with practice you can only increase/decrease your range by a second, maybe a third at max. Claiming that hyorin can hit high notes live is like saying yao ming can touch the rim without standing on his toes. Range, like height, is simply a given and not impressive in itself. There's also nothing extraordinary about her intensity/power; a million other vocalists can project just as well as she can, and her control isn't something to be awed by either. Since we're talking about control, I chuckle to myself every time someone shits on IU's vocals. Because of her incredible real voice range, she's able to transition from high to low with ease without break, and that's innate talent. On second thought, a lot of people can't project for shit and people still say they're good singers for some reason (Jessica) so I guess this might have some merit, but still debatable. so what does that leave hyorin with? a moderately powerful husky voice, ok. nothing but an above average singer. In terms of "idol vocal capability," she'd maybe make it into my top 5, but that's not saying much, is it? look what u started good job bro + haters gon hate | ||
|
Moonwrath
United States9568 Posts
1. Taeyeon 2. IU 3. KMK 4. Hyorin 5. Tiffany | ||
|
UrASofty
Canada772 Posts
| ||
|
MethodSC
United States928 Posts
On January 15 2012 13:52 andyrau wrote: lol people in this thread that judge singing. If you've ever been vocally tutored or trained, or have any experience with vocals, you'd know that range is naturally bestowed. Even with practice you can only increase/decrease your range by a second, maybe a third at max. Claiming that hyorin can hit high notes live is like saying yao ming can touch the rim without standing on his toes. Range, like height, is simply a given and not impressive in itself. There's also nothing extraordinary about her intensity/power; a million other vocalists can project just as well as she can, and her control isn't something to be awed by either. Since we're talking about control, I chuckle to myself every time someone shits on IU's vocals. Because of her incredible real voice range, she's able to transition from high to low with ease without break, and that's innate talent. On second thought, a lot of people can't project for shit and people still say they're good singers for some reason (Jessica) so I guess this might have some merit, but still debatable. so what does that leave hyorin with? a moderately powerful husky voice, ok. nothing but an above average singer. In terms of "idol vocal capability," she'd maybe make it into my top 5, but that's not saying much, is it? Boom | ||
|
DystopiaX
United States16236 Posts
On January 15 2012 13:52 andyrau wrote: lol people in this thread that judge singing. If you've ever been vocally tutored or trained, or have any experience with vocals, you'd know that range is naturally bestowed. Even with practice you can only increase/decrease your range by a second, maybe a third at max. Claiming that hyorin can hit high notes live is like saying yao ming can touch the rim without standing on his toes. Range, like height, is simply a given and not impressive in itself. There's also nothing extraordinary about her intensity/power; a million other vocalists can project just as well as she can, and her control isn't something to be awed by either. Since we're talking about control, I chuckle to myself every time someone shits on IU's vocals. Because of her incredible real voice range, she's able to transition from high to low with ease without break, and that's innate talent. On second thought, a lot of people can't project for shit and people still say they're good singers for some reason (Jessica) so I guess this might have some merit, but still debatable. so what does that leave hyorin with? a moderately powerful husky voice, ok. nothing but an above average singer. In terms of "idol vocal capability," she'd maybe make it into my top 5, but that's not saying much, is it? Idc about the trained/natural thing though; it doesn't matter why they're good, just that they are. Much in the same way that Yao Ming is good cause he's tall, genetics could be the only differentiating factor between iu and, say, yoona, but I don't give a fuck. All that matters is that she sounds better. @moonwrath even ignoring the obvious taeyeon bias having kmk on there but haeri not on there makes no sense, since haeri has the main(better) vocal position in the group. | ||
|
Hall0wed
United States8486 Posts
Yao Ming retired. | ||
|
Moonwrath
United States9568 Posts
| ||
|
Craton
United States17233 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/vV66I.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/gFKb8.jpg) + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/EIrbh.jpg) ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/PXLG8.jpg) | ||
|
Ym1r
United States1164 Posts
Better example would be what I think about IU. I like her a bit, and a couple of her songs, but I really, really don't like her voice. So I rate her below a ton of people. | ||
|
mizU
United States12125 Posts
IU Davichi Taeng Sunny KMK maybe. | ||
|
chiwawa
330 Posts
On January 15 2012 16:07 mizU wrote: Hmmm. IU Davichi Taeng Sunny KMK maybe. Even though that list is highly personal I don't get how Sunny gets a spot there when Hyorin isn't even on the list. On January 15 2012 16:00 Ym1r wrote: Some people just don't like the way voices sound. For instance, people like Jessica's voice but I think it's kind of raspy and annoying. Her speaking voice is fine, but when she sings, I'm just not very fond of it. . It's quite obvious that I like her voice but I can totally see why some people don't like it. Her voice just isn't strong enough for a lot of songs, when she gets a song that fits her it sounds really good in my opinion but you can never expect her to do stuff like Hyorin/Taeyeon/KMK does. | ||
| ||
