|
To ensure this thread won't be closed, you must adhere to several a number of simple rules; - Please use spoilers when quoting a post with pictures and/or videos.
- When posting large quantities of media (pictures or videos), please begin spoilering after the first piece. Grouping related videos in the same spoilers & labeling is recommended.
- No reposting of old material unless justified
- Posting any material with little or no relevent discussion accompanying it
- No passion-induced flaming of each other because 'x said y sucked' etc.
- Keep the expression hate of music individuals/groups to a minimal level
- No 'pagetopping' in any form whatsoever, as it constitutes spam equal to posts similar to 'first'.
- No vulgar fan fics or wet dream stories. It is creepy, weird, and it dehumanizes the people who you are here to celebrate/discuss.
- Normal posting standards that you find throughout the rest of the site still apply and will be enforced more strictly from here forward (2012/03/11)
Due to the poor nature of this thread in the past, temporary two-day bans will occur more than often if people slip up. |
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far.
|
Man that post... Was lurking then but I wish I could find it now. I mean I probably could it would just take work, and I forget if name changes apply to previous posts.
|
That happens to me too Dystopia, believe it or not, if you open up iTunes first before Chrome, it will display properly.
You have to do it everytime you reboot though.
|
On November 29 2011 14:15 Skysec wrote:
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far.
The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable?
I'm sorry, but I can't agree with this one. Look at some of the biggest "pop" acts active in the US in the past few years . . . Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Black Eyed Peas, T-pain, Flo-rida, Kanye West . . . .
Their music aren't good and listenable. I'm pretty certain that on average, K-pop idols (male ones at least) are far superior performers and musicians compared to typical "American pop music".
Yeah, it's hard for Asians to be accepted by mainstream America, but the music itself is not bad compared to what Americans get.
|
|
|
On November 29 2011 14:20 chenchen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:15 Skysec wrote:
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far. The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable? I'm sorry, but I can't agree with this one. Look at some of the biggest "pop" acts active in the US in the past few years . . . Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Black Eyed Peas, T-pain, Flo-rida, Kanye West . . . . Their music aren't good and listenable. I'm pretty certain that on average, K-pop idols (male ones at least) are far superior performers and musicians compared to typical "American pop music". Yeah, it's hard for Asians to be accepted by mainstream America, but the music itself is not bad compared to what Americans get.
You insult yourself by putting Justin Bieber on that list. Justin Bieber is an amazing singer that is more talented than any kpop artist ever, K!!!!?^_^ Gosh, this kid wouldn't even know talent even if it hit him in the face.
|
On November 29 2011 14:20 chenchen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:15 Skysec wrote:
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far. The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable? I'm sorry, but I can't agree with this one. Look at some of the biggest "pop" acts active in the US in the past few years . . . Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Black Eyed Peas, T-pain, Flo-rida, Kanye West . . . . Their music aren't good and listenable. I'm pretty certain that on average, K-pop idols (male ones at least) are far superior performers and musicians compared to typical "American pop music". Yeah, it's hard for Asians to be accepted by mainstream America, but the music itself is not bad compared to what Americans get.
Old Black Eyed Peas is actually good, they just chose to make something more poppy and marketable.
And really, the 19-34 male internet-savvy people are the only ones with these opinions. You talk to everyone else whose internet consists of their email, facebook page, and youtube and they genuinely like those artists.
Also have no idea how Soyeon ranked so low on his list based on that gif alone...
but HyunA still wins. HyunA best kpop booty.
edit- @Skysec it's probably cause they're trained to look innocent (which means partly dumb pretty much because of the role they have to take), and then the accent. Those without the accent are mostly from Cali, and regrettably the part of Cali where every girl, no matter how intelligent, ends up sounding dumb as fuck (not hating, but listen to Jessica/Tiffany and it's a pretty strong accent, now tinged with a little Korean, it's maddening). The girls aren't stupid necessarily, the lack of schooling makes them ignorant about certain topics but in the everyday conversation they'd need to get through they'd do fine- again if it wasn't for the accent.
But again, you seem to be assuming they're going for mainstream, billboard topping success. I'm sure they'd love that, but at the same time even doing mediocre/only doing well with the kpop fanbase is enough to generate tons of money for them comparitively.
|
On November 29 2011 14:20 chenchen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:15 Skysec wrote:
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far. The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable? I'm sorry, but I can't agree with this one. Look at some of the biggest "pop" acts active in the US in the past few years . . . Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Black Eyed Peas, T-pain, Flo-rida, Kanye West . . . . Their music aren't good and listenable. I'm pretty certain that on average, K-pop idols (male ones at least) are far superior performers and musicians compared to typical "American pop music". Yeah, it's hard for Asians to be accepted by mainstream America, but the music itself is not bad compared to what Americans get.
I was more focusing on the tunes and beat rather then the lyrics. If you look at Beiber's songs without the lyrics, they can be really catchy ("Banelings banelings banelings").
I'm going to have to disagree with you on Lady Gaga being unlistenable, I actually really like her music, but this is KMD.
And I was thinking more along the lines of Taylor Swift for current "poppy" music, and nsync/backstreet boys/britney spears for old pop. You can hate them all you want, but damn if their music wasn't catchy.
I will agree that a lot of kpop songs are very catchy just like britney/bsb/nsync songs were back in the 90s and that's actually a big reason why I started listening to them. But you can't get big in America by putting out subpar music and then following it up with a killer dance routine like a certain 9 member girl group recently.
|
No, you just need a good electric beat and songs about partying and getting women- see LMFAO. Neither of them are attractive none of their songs are good- except the instrumentals and the one hook that they always have (I'm sexy and I know it, Everyday I'm Shufflin, SHOTSHOTSSHOTSHOTSHOTSHOTS) and bring the hot women into the videos. There's no reason (other than culture) that a korean artist couldn't do that.
Now, you may say "well yeah, that music's not subpar then if the beat is good"- but then all these companies have to do is buy the beat/instrumentals from any of the composers that do write for these top 40 artists (Wikipedia who composed these songs, often the same group of people over and over), get a songwriter to make inane, easy-to-pronounce lyrics- and there you go.
edit- also 09 HyunA best HyunA. After that she starts the steady decent into butterfacin'
|
51705 Posts
GETTING SLIZZARD LIKE A GEE SIX
|
On November 29 2011 14:20 chenchen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:15 Skysec wrote:
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far. The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable? I'm sorry, but I can't agree with this one. Look at some of the biggest "pop" acts active in the US in the past few years . . . Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Black Eyed Peas, T-pain, Flo-rida, Kanye West . . . . Their music aren't good and listenable. I'm pretty certain that on average, K-pop idols (male ones at least) are far superior performers and musicians compared to typical "American pop music". Yeah, it's hard for Asians to be accepted by mainstream America, but the music itself is not bad compared to what Americans get.
this guy actually just said kanye's music is horrible. nbomb is u serious?
lmao
kanye, lady gaga and bep >> anything idols will ever make. sorry bro. they also produce and write their own music. name 3 top idols that do this.
stop dat
|
On November 29 2011 14:36 UrASofty wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:20 chenchen wrote:On November 29 2011 14:15 Skysec wrote:
Kpop won't make it big in America because of a few big reasons.
(I'm going to just assume the songs are in English, because LOL if otherwise)
1. They can't speak english for shit.
2. If they do, they have huge accents, and asian accents don't have the "sexy-foreign" allure that european or australian accents do
3. If they mannage to get past all that, they come out as dumb as rocks. I'm sorry, I love these Idols just as much as you, but when 90% of your life is dedicated to singing, looking good, and acting sexy/cute you don't have much time to be intelligent. Of course there's the obvious outliers to all 3 of those points (yes I know Tablo went to Stanford and Sojin has a Mech E major) but the majority of Idols out there couldn't multiply their way out of a paper box.
4. There are still big sterotypes about asians.
5. Americans don't like "cute" music. I really can't think of a really famous artist here currently that's known for being "cute".
6. Americans are pretty big music snobs. You will get wreaked here for putting out shitty music (Rebecca Black, Ke$ha). The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable. The music industry here is more about the audio then the visual, which cuts out a huge selling point of the Kpop industry, and 75% of Idols can't sing at all and are just there because they can dance or they look good.
Being cute or hot can only take you so far. The really big artists here that are poppy got big because their music was good and listenable? I'm sorry, but I can't agree with this one. Look at some of the biggest "pop" acts active in the US in the past few years . . . Justin Bieber, Lady Gaga, Black Eyed Peas, T-pain, Flo-rida, Kanye West . . . . Their music aren't good and listenable. I'm pretty certain that on average, K-pop idols (male ones at least) are far superior performers and musicians compared to typical "American pop music". Yeah, it's hard for Asians to be accepted by mainstream America, but the music itself is not bad compared to what Americans get. this guy actually just said kanye's music is horrible. nbomb is u serious? lmao kanye, lady gaga and bep >> anything idols will ever make. sorry bro. they also produce and write their own music. name 3 top idols that do this. stop dat
They produce and write their own music? Doesn't really matter if it's complete crap. The stuff the average Kpop producer comes out with (Scandinavians!!!!!!) is actually loads higher quality. Have you LISTENED to the stuff the BEP, Kanye, and Lady Gaga have churned out in the past three years?
As for idols producing their own music, that's not their job. They are professional performers and a lot of them are DAMN good at it.
Nevertheless, Teee Veee Ekssss Kyuuuuuuuu >>> any recent American pop act . . . by a lot . . a lot a lot a lot
|
TVXQ may be the ONLY exception though. And I like Kanye's music, but mostly the older stuff and the stuff he doesn't promote- much like k-idols, his title tracks may be the catchiest but they're not the best.
Also many kpop songs don't come from Scandinavians- that seems to be mostly SM although others do it too.
And I've said it before, but go back to before Boom Boom Pow and listen to something like "Like That", it's actually not that bad.
edit- also that's just like, your opinion man. The argument started about if kmusic will have mass appeal, and what it comes down to is that it doesn't matter if current kmusic does or not, they can just buy compositions from western composers.
|
Damn, its like this thread gradually degrades with more and more trolling per total content every post.
We can argue what's good music all you want, but my main point is that in America, you can't sell music through visuals, which is half Kpop's appeal.
Catchy songs will still do well if they can get past the whole Asian and language thing, but in the end if your music isn't catchy and makes people want to claw their ears out, you won't sell.
|
On November 29 2011 14:45 Skysec wrote:
Damn, its like this thread gradually degrades with more and more trolling per total content every post.
We can argue what's good music all you want, but my main point is that in America, you can't sell music through visuals, which is half Kpop's appeal.
Catchy songs will still do well if they can get past the whole Asian and language thing, but in the end if your music isn't catchy and makes people want to claw their ears out, you won't sell.
And as I've said before, it doesn't matter if current k-music is catchy or not, they can simply buy songs from western composers who write songs for American top 40 artists, and there you go. Catchy shit that we internet hipsters hate.
|
On November 29 2011 14:44 DystopiaX wrote:
TVXQ may be the ONLY exception though. And I like Kanye's music, but mostly the older stuff and the stuff he doesn't promote- much like k-idols, his title tracks may be the catchiest but they're not the best.
Also many kpop songs don't come from Scandinavians- that seems to be mostly SM although others do it too.
And I've said it before, but go back to before Boom Boom Pow and listen to something like "Like That", it's actually not that bad.
edit- also that's just like, your opinion man. The argument started about if kmusic will have mass appeal, and what it comes down to is that it doesn't matter if current kmusic does or not, they can just buy compositions from western composers.
Yeah it is my opinion.
I just find it silly when people start saying things like "oh Kpop is bad musically compared to mainstream American pop music" . . . . like seriously . . .
|
On November 29 2011 14:46 chenchen wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:44 DystopiaX wrote:
TVXQ may be the ONLY exception though. And I like Kanye's music, but mostly the older stuff and the stuff he doesn't promote- much like k-idols, his title tracks may be the catchiest but they're not the best.
Also many kpop songs don't come from Scandinavians- that seems to be mostly SM although others do it too.
And I've said it before, but go back to before Boom Boom Pow and listen to something like "Like That", it's actually not that bad.
edit- also that's just like, your opinion man. The argument started about if kmusic will have mass appeal, and what it comes down to is that it doesn't matter if current kmusic does or not, they can just buy compositions from western composers. Yeah it is my opinion. I just find it silly when people start saying things like "oh Kpop is bad musically compared to mainstream American pop music" . . . . like seriously . . .
I think a better way to put it is that kpop is different from western pop music in a way that makes it unappealing to those that like western pop music, and therefore unlikely to be successful.
|
I think K-Pop probably won't make it big in the US because the artists are not sideshows like Lady Gaga and LMFAO.
|
On November 29 2011 14:48 DystopiaX wrote:Show nested quote +On November 29 2011 14:46 chenchen wrote:On November 29 2011 14:44 DystopiaX wrote:
TVXQ may be the ONLY exception though. And I like Kanye's music, but mostly the older stuff and the stuff he doesn't promote- much like k-idols, his title tracks may be the catchiest but they're not the best.
Also many kpop songs don't come from Scandinavians- that seems to be mostly SM although others do it too.
And I've said it before, but go back to before Boom Boom Pow and listen to something like "Like That", it's actually not that bad.
edit- also that's just like, your opinion man. The argument started about if kmusic will have mass appeal, and what it comes down to is that it doesn't matter if current kmusic does or not, they can just buy compositions from western composers. Yeah it is my opinion. I just find it silly when people start saying things like "oh Kpop is bad musically compared to mainstream American pop music" . . . . like seriously . . . I think a better way to put it is that kpop is different from western pop music in a way that makes it unappealing to those that like western pop music, and therefore unlikely to be successful.
I can agree with that . . . Kpop is still distinctly Korean and American pop music is distinctly American, but the fact that this sentiment exists in KMD is perplexing.
|
On November 29 2011 14:49 Moonwrath wrote:
I think K-Pop probably won't make it big in the US because the artists are not sideshows like Lady Gaga and LMFAO.
Stellar. Too bad they came 2 years too late.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
