|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
Straight outta Johto18973 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [Hayate no Gotoku 452] +OH MY GOD CHIHARU <3
Also she's learning from Aika. And wtf is Kayura with CDs.
ALSO CLIFFHANGER. Probably Hayate returning with the box of curry or Athena in normal mode. Or Hayate's Brother.
On June 03 2014 04:28 goody153 wrote:
haha i hear you .. is K-On any good ? i just wanna watch shows that will either give me diabetes or make me smile like a madman
Sure. Follow it up with Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!, Toradora, Yuru Yuri, Haiyore! Nyaruko-san and Kanokon.
|
On June 02 2014 21:48 goody153 wrote:
can anybody give me a LIGHTHEARTED(when i mean lighthearted not those who will make me mad because it's so bad) anime all for the laughs and lolz and happy feels
[edited]
full moon wo sagashite
http://www.animenfo.com/statistic/top.php?type=anime
can u not fuckin spoil game of thrones in an anime thread
|
you should watch k-on.
and aiura. and yuyushiki.
|
|
|
D-Frag! was chalk full of stupid fun... but it also wasn't exactly what I would call good per se so keep that in mind. All the MC yelling. :/ Sadly that's all I have in regards to that type that isn't just boatloads of terrible.
Is it just me or has Nanana gotten really stale? The first few episodes were a lot of fun and quite good but recently I'm just kinda bored with it. edit: though I have yet to watch ep8, still trying to catch up on everything after my almost two week break.
|
On June 03 2014 11:06 InfSunday wrote:
D-Frag! was chalk full of stupid fun... but it also wasn't exactly what I would call good per se so keep that in mind. All the MC yelling. :/ Sadly that's all I have in regards to that type that isn't just boatloads of terrible.
Is it just me or has Nanana gotten really stale? The first few episodes were a lot of fun and quite good but recently I'm just kinda bored with it. edit: though I have yet to watch ep8, still trying to catch up on everything after my almost two week break.
Too much (bad) drama, not enough treasure adventuring. Unfortunately it looks like they're only going to keep ramping the drama up with the new antagonist guy.
|
Alright i'll be watching K-On. All i know about the show is mio is cute but let's see if i like it.
On June 03 2014 08:03 FFGenerations wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2014 21:48 goody153 wrote:
can anybody give me a LIGHTHEARTED(when i mean lighthearted not those who will make me mad because it's so bad) anime all for the laughs and lolz and happy feels
[edited] full moon wo sagashite http://www.animenfo.com/statistic/top.php?type=animecan u not fuckin spoil game of thrones in an anime thread
Sorry i thought the spoiler was enough.
On June 03 2014 06:48 Sterlymobile wrote:Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 06:39 Souma wrote:On June 03 2014 06:03 goody153 wrote:On June 03 2014 06:01 Sentenal wrote:On June 03 2014 05:52 Toadesstern wrote:On June 03 2014 05:28 IceHism wrote:On June 03 2014 04:39 Toadesstern wrote:On June 03 2014 04:26 IceHism wrote:On June 03 2014 04:07 goody153 wrote:On June 03 2014 03:49 The Fish wrote:
[quote]
Have you tried Usagi drop or Yuyushiki? I know that Usagi Drop is cute and all but what bugs me since i was not been able to guard a little spoiler of it which was + Show Spoiler +The daughter will in later episodes seek romance on her foster father which made me decide to never watch the show. I know it's not technically incest but dude that is still her father. Biological or not. Kinda creepy for me. Idk if the anime reaches that part though. . is Yuyushiki better than baka-to-test ? On June 03 2014 04:01 IceHism wrote:
Finished bakemonogatari. Was really good. Love shaft style and the dialogue was eccentric and interesting.
I'll be starting mirai Nikki or higurashi next which I'll be watching with Chihayafuru still Have you watch the sequels of bakemonogatari ? nisemonogatari,nekomonogatari and monogatari s2 ? Not yet, I'm getting to the monogatari sequels/prequels. I have other things to watch and rather have a pause before I watch Nise. Also, little screentime for Senjougahara and people I know tell me Nise is a bit forgettable compared to Bake so I don't want to dive in too quickly. forgettable isn't really the word I'd use for Nise. Some of that stuff was as unforgettable as you'll get. The focus just shifted a little for Nise On June 03 2014 04:28 goody153 wrote:On June 03 2014 04:09 Emnjay808 wrote:On June 03 2014 04:07 goody153 wrote:[quote] I know that Usagi Drop is cute and all but what bugs me since i was not been able to guard a little spoiler of it which was + Show Spoiler +The daughter will in later episodes seek romance on her foster father which made me decide to never watch the show. I know it's not technically incest but dude that is still her father. Biological or not. Kinda creepy for me. Idk if the anime reaches that part though. . is Yuyushiki better than baka-to-test ? [quote] Have you watch the sequels of bakemonogatari ? nisemonogatari,nekomonogatari and monogatari s2 ? lol no haha i hear you .. is K-On any good ? i just wanna watch shows that will either give me diabetes or make me smile like a madman .. i'm still having a horrible feeling because of + Show Spoiler [GameOfThrones latest ep] + it's moe and nothing else. Just check it out and see if you like it. It's not really funny either but you could probably call it a light hearted feel good show? But yeah, Baka test would be a lot better for that purpose. What do you mean by shifting the focus? some more along the lines of this: + Show Spoiler [NSFW] +Though I don't actually remember if that's from neko or nise Yeah, because Nisemonogatari is the only Monogatari season that is stuffed full of fanservice. Toothbrush scene will always have a special place in my heart. Thought you didn't like incestual stuff. Maybe goody is really into oral hygiene
Whut ? lol The act itself is highly interesting but i just pretend it's not incestual just like how i pretend in my mind that bleach already ended during + Show Spoiler +when ichigo lost his powers and the sweet scene where he and rukia said there final goodbyes
On June 03 2014 07:48 MoonBear wrote:+ Show Spoiler [Hayate no Gotoku 452] +OH MY GOD CHIHARU <3
Also she's learning from Aika. And wtf is Kayura with CDs.
ALSO CLIFFHANGER. Probably Hayate returning with the box of curry or Athena in normal mode. Or Hayate's Brother. Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 04:28 goody153 wrote:
haha i hear you .. is K-On any good ? i just wanna watch shows that will either give me diabetes or make me smile like a madman Sure. Follow it up with Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!, Toradora, Yuru Yuri, Haiyore! Nyaruko-san and Kanokon.
Haiyore! Nyaruko-san seems interesting.
|
TLADT24920 Posts
On June 02 2014 16:04 Slaughter wrote:
From what I read it sounds like its a continuation that happens after this series ended.
seems like it. Guess it's to make sure everything is wrapped up and just provide more information afterwards.
On June 02 2014 18:41 Maxie wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2014 15:20 BigFan wrote:Finished Madoka. + Show Spoiler +Well, I guess that ending was better than I envisioned though still "losing" her wasn't great  I mean, she's 'there' but she's not as well seeing as only Homura remembers her existence which I find to be quite sad but understandable in the context of the story. I'm kinda split on whether to like this ending or not. She went out with a strong finish and pretty much did the best possible wish saving all the magical girls from becoming witches and such so I like that but I still don't like that she's gone rofl. I think I'm mostly disappointed that only Homura remembers her though. Would've liked it had Sayaka, Kyoko and Mami remembered her seeing as they are all magical girls. I think the only part that could use some work is the wish part. I mean, they can be granted any wish? That seems a bit much seeing as you can wish for anything but I guess they had to make some incentive for them to become magical girls. Also, Sayaka still dying in the final timeline after Madoka makes her wish seemed really out of the ordinary to me but I guess she doesn't regret the wish so she doesn't regret dying either it seems. Is it a good idea to watch the third movie? Seems like it's post though apparently, there is no plot to it. Do watch the third movie. I want to know your reaction.
On June 02 2014 19:26 Bashnek wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2014 15:20 BigFan wrote:Finished Madoka. + Show Spoiler +Well, I guess that ending was better than I envisioned though still "losing" her wasn't great I mean, she's 'there' but she's not as well seeing as only Homura remembers her existence which I find to be quite sad but understandable in the context of the story. I'm kinda split on whether to like this ending or not. She went out with a strong finish and pretty much did the best possible wish saving all the magical girls from becoming witches and such so I like that but I still don't like that she's gone rofl. I think I'm mostly disappointed that only Homura remembers her though. Would've liked it had Sayaka, Kyoko and Mami remembered her seeing as they are all magical girls. I think the only part that could use some work is the wish part. I mean, they can be granted any wish? That seems a bit much seeing as you can wish for anything but I guess they had to make some incentive for them to become magical girls. Also, Sayaka still dying in the final timeline after Madoka makes her wish seemed really out of the ordinary to me but I guess she doesn't regret the wish so she doesn't regret dying either it seems. Is it a good idea to watch the third movie? Seems like it's post though apparently, there is no plot to it. the third movie is great. watch it.
that's the plan! lol.
On June 02 2014 22:53 Toadesstern wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2014 15:20 BigFan wrote:Finished Madoka. + Show Spoiler +Well, I guess that ending was better than I envisioned though still "losing" her wasn't great I mean, she's 'there' but she's not as well seeing as only Homura remembers her existence which I find to be quite sad but understandable in the context of the story. I'm kinda split on whether to like this ending or not. She went out with a strong finish and pretty much did the best possible wish saving all the magical girls from becoming witches and such so I like that but I still don't like that she's gone rofl. I think I'm mostly disappointed that only Homura remembers her though. Would've liked it had Sayaka, Kyoko and Mami remembered her seeing as they are all magical girls. I think the only part that could use some work is the wish part. I mean, they can be granted any wish? That seems a bit much seeing as you can wish for anything but I guess they had to make some incentive for them to become magical girls. Also, Sayaka still dying in the final timeline after Madoka makes her wish seemed really out of the ordinary to me but I guess she doesn't regret the wish so she doesn't regret dying either it seems. Is it a good idea to watch the third movie? Seems like it's post though apparently, there is no plot to it. + Show Spoiler +homura remembering madoka has very little to do with homura being a magical girl so it doesn't really make sense for the other girls to remember madoka. But I guess the little brother remembering Madoka doesn't make sense either and that's just there for sentimental reasons. The girls remembering would have lessened the whole point though, at least in my opinion. The other girls dying though was prevented as red girl obviously only died because of Sayaka turning into a witch, which didn't happen in the end.
Also Sayaka dying has not a lot to do with anything. Madoka's wish was that the girls would not be made into witches. All those girls that you see when Madoka "transforms" in past and future don't magically live on forever. They still die, they just don't turn into witches. And Sayaka's problem was something that wasn't changed by madokas wish at all, it's just that her turning into a witch was prevented.
That being said. It's a Drama and not a happy go lucky show like it was advertized early on so obviously it's going to be sad and ending it on a happy end would have made the whole thing laughable and the story would have become irrelevant due to some bullshit just to make people smile. That's the "shock" factor peopel were talking about despite everyone repeatedly stating that there's no shack factor to Madoka and that it's more of a "I didn't except it to turn THAT grim"
+ Show Spoiler +well, ya, you're right. I'm just saying I kinda wish she was remembered more is all. I can understand why she was only remembered by Homura. For her brother though, she was appearing to him as an "imaginary friend" according to her mom so it wouldn't be surprising that he knows her. Makes the anime that much sadder ya, true true. well, yes, that's also true. I know that Sayaka dying doesn't have to do anything with Madoka's wish. I just find it ironic that she still went all out and ended up dying (the first in this timeline) after having her wish granted. It's like, did she still suffer a similar effect and went into despair then eventually went all out and died (like previously but didn't become a witch or was it a normal death after going all out but she still retained her sanity?). Take a look at it this way: Kyoko was surprised that she was gone like that. There were four of them fighting against that witch (whoever it was). I'm almost sure that she didn't need to go that far but still did. Just feels reckless I guess. Still, at least she got to talk with Madoka, saw the one she loved play the violin again and doesn't regret her actions. well, yes, that's also true lol (notice the trend  ). I just didn't think they'll go as far as killing almost everyone off then kinda bringing them back but making the main character omnipotent with only her best friend and her little brother ever remembering her. Well, definitely a shock factor considering what the anime seemed it would be about. I figured it was just some girls getting powers and fighting evil or something. I guess Sailor moon style or something (obviously different but some similarities too). Still, I'm glad I watched it but I'm a sucker for happy endings and Madoka didn't deliver that lol.
On June 03 2014 02:30 maru~ wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2014 15:20 BigFan wrote:Finished Madoka. + Show Spoiler +I think the only part that could use some work is the wish part. I mean, they can be granted any wish? That seems a bit much seeing as you can wish for anything but I guess they had to make some incentive for them to become magical girls. + Show Spoiler +No, that's not how it works (unless you're Madoka).
+ Show Spoiler +lol seems like it though to be fair, most made the wish in a life or death situation. In Sayaka's case, it was because she was in love with someone so it clouded her judgement. On top of that, most of them didn't know about magical girls turning into witches either so at least when it was Madoka's turn, she knew that and worked to fix it 
On June 03 2014 03:44 Ecael wrote:Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 02:30 maru~ wrote:On June 02 2014 15:20 BigFan wrote:Finished Madoka. + Show Spoiler +I think the only part that could use some work is the wish part. I mean, they can be granted any wish? That seems a bit much seeing as you can wish for anything but I guess they had to make some incentive for them to become magical girls. + Show Spoiler +No, that's not how it works (unless you're Madoka). I am sure that's how it will work when you have enough love. If it doesn't, you just need to love more.
Love cures all! Universal cure! Spread the love! <3 <3 lol.
|
Goody: Haiyore! Nyaruko-san is fine in small doses but its so silly and exaggerated (because its a parody) that I am watching it slowly. It has some funny moments though and it references a lot of anime.
BigFan: Madoka:
+ Show Spoiler +If you read my comments on the series when I watched it I questioned some of the characters (and the universes) logic. The whole wish system seemed broken and wasn't exploited at all by Madoka. She could have made so many different types of wishes to have an actual happy ending. Not this bullshit that magical girls still die when they accumulate enough corruption. Oh so they avoid becoming witches? Oh my isn't someone ambitious. She was basically God and those cat asshole things said "any" wish. I also questioned why such an advanced race that can grant any fucking wish can't manage to find an alternate means to harvest energy without doing what they were doing.
|
TLADT24920 Posts
On June 03 2014 13:55 Slaughter wrote:Goody: Haiyore! Nyaruko-san is fine in small doses but its so silly and exaggerated (because its a parody) that I am watching it slowly. It has some funny moments though and it references a lot of anime. BigFan: Madoka: + Show Spoiler +If you read my comments on the series when I watched it I questioned some of the characters (and the universes) logic. The whole wish system seemed broken and wasn't exploited at all by Madoka. She could have made so many different types of wishes to have an actual happy ending. Not this bullshit that magical girls still die when they accumulate enough corruption. Oh so they avoid becoming witches? Oh my isn't someone ambitious. She was basically God and those cat asshole things said "any" wish. I also questioned why such an advanced race that can grant any fucking wish can't manage to find an alternate means to harvest energy without doing what they were doing.
+ Show Spoiler +yes! exactly! If she basically became God, she could change anything. That part was a bit confusing. Why not just ask to become God and just change everything? I mean, her wish wasn't bad but you're right, so many different wishes she could have wished for. It did also seem odd to me as well that these cats can grant any wish as well. I mean, wtf? Why can't you just wish the energy deficiency away yourself or as you mentioned, find an alternative source? Well, I think we're just supposed to accept that it's for the story, maybe they were afraid to mess with entropy and unbalance energy
Love this song: + Show Spoiler +
|
Nike is literally the only thing that saves that show from being dropped. Everything else is either generic or terrible.
|
On June 03 2014 14:06 BigFan wrote:Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 13:55 Slaughter wrote:Goody: Haiyore! Nyaruko-san is fine in small doses but its so silly and exaggerated (because its a parody) that I am watching it slowly. It has some funny moments though and it references a lot of anime. BigFan: Madoka: + Show Spoiler +If you read my comments on the series when I watched it I questioned some of the characters (and the universes) logic. The whole wish system seemed broken and wasn't exploited at all by Madoka. She could have made so many different types of wishes to have an actual happy ending. Not this bullshit that magical girls still die when they accumulate enough corruption. Oh so they avoid becoming witches? Oh my isn't someone ambitious. She was basically God and those cat asshole things said "any" wish. I also questioned why such an advanced race that can grant any fucking wish can't manage to find an alternate means to harvest energy without doing what they were doing. + Show Spoiler +yes! exactly! If she basically became God, she could change anything. That part was a bit confusing. Why not just ask to become God and just change everything? I mean, her wish wasn't bad but you're right, so many different wishes she could have wished for. It did also seem odd to me as well that these cats can grant any wish as well. I mean, wtf? Why can't you just wish the energy deficiency away yourself or as you mentioned, find an alternative source? Well, I think we're just supposed to accept that it's for the story, maybe they were afraid to mess with entropy and unbalance energy Love this song: + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46-w0D5i6MY
the song sounds like ending theme. What anime is this from ?
|
TLADT24920 Posts
On June 03 2014 14:12 Slaughter wrote:
Nike is literally the only thing that saves that show from being dropped. Everything else is either generic or terrible.
lol ya, she's a great character. Main character still feels like such a kid and has many mood swings lol.
On June 03 2014 14:14 goody153 wrote:Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 14:06 BigFan wrote:On June 03 2014 13:55 Slaughter wrote:Goody: Haiyore! Nyaruko-san is fine in small doses but its so silly and exaggerated (because its a parody) that I am watching it slowly. It has some funny moments though and it references a lot of anime. BigFan: Madoka: + Show Spoiler +If you read my comments on the series when I watched it I questioned some of the characters (and the universes) logic. The whole wish system seemed broken and wasn't exploited at all by Madoka. She could have made so many different types of wishes to have an actual happy ending. Not this bullshit that magical girls still die when they accumulate enough corruption. Oh so they avoid becoming witches? Oh my isn't someone ambitious. She was basically God and those cat asshole things said "any" wish. I also questioned why such an advanced race that can grant any fucking wish can't manage to find an alternate means to harvest energy without doing what they were doing. + Show Spoiler +yes! exactly! If she basically became God, she could change anything. That part was a bit confusing. Why not just ask to become God and just change everything? I mean, her wish wasn't bad but you're right, so many different wishes she could have wished for. It did also seem odd to me as well that these cats can grant any wish as well. I mean, wtf? Why can't you just wish the energy deficiency away yourself or as you mentioned, find an alternative source? Well, I think we're just supposed to accept that it's for the story, maybe they were afraid to mess with entropy and unbalance energy Love this song: + Show Spoiler +https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46-w0D5i6MY the song sounds like ending theme. What anime is this from ?
http://myanimelist.net/anime/22101/Soredemo_Sekai_wa_Utsukushii
|
On June 03 2014 05:52 Toadesstern wrote:Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 05:28 IceHism wrote:On June 03 2014 04:39 Toadesstern wrote:On June 03 2014 04:26 IceHism wrote:On June 03 2014 04:07 goody153 wrote:On June 03 2014 03:49 The Fish wrote:On June 02 2014 21:48 goody153 wrote:
can anybody give me a LIGHTHEARTED(when i mean lighthearted not those who will make me mad because it's so bad) anime all for the laughs and lolz and happy feels
i really need one right now. i am having a surge of extremely sad emotion granted by the latest episode of game of thrones.. Have you tried Usagi drop or Yuyushiki? I know that Usagi Drop is cute and all but what bugs me since i was not been able to guard a little spoiler of it which was + Show Spoiler +The daughter will in later episodes seek romance on her foster father which made me decide to never watch the show. I know it's not technically incest but dude that is still her father. Biological or not. Kinda creepy for me. Idk if the anime reaches that part though. . is Yuyushiki better than baka-to-test ? On June 03 2014 04:01 IceHism wrote:
Finished bakemonogatari. Was really good. Love shaft style and the dialogue was eccentric and interesting.
I'll be starting mirai Nikki or higurashi next which I'll be watching with Chihayafuru still Have you watch the sequels of bakemonogatari ? nisemonogatari,nekomonogatari and monogatari s2 ? Not yet, I'm getting to the monogatari sequels/prequels. I have other things to watch and rather have a pause before I watch Nise. Also, little screentime for Senjougahara and people I know tell me Nise is a bit forgettable compared to Bake so I don't want to dive in too quickly. forgettable isn't really the word I'd use for Nise. Some of that stuff was as unforgettable as you'll get. The focus just shifted a little for Nise On June 03 2014 04:28 goody153 wrote:On June 03 2014 04:09 Emnjay808 wrote:On June 03 2014 04:07 goody153 wrote:On June 03 2014 03:49 The Fish wrote:On June 02 2014 21:48 goody153 wrote:
can anybody give me a LIGHTHEARTED(when i mean lighthearted not those who will make me mad because it's so bad) anime all for the laughs and lolz and happy feels
i really need one right now. i am having a surge of extremely sad emotion granted by the latest episode of game of thrones.. Have you tried Usagi drop or Yuyushiki? I know that Usagi Drop is cute and all but what bugs me since i was not been able to guard a little spoiler of it which was + Show Spoiler +The daughter will in later episodes seek romance on her foster father which made me decide to never watch the show. I know it's not technically incest but dude that is still her father. Biological or not. Kinda creepy for me. Idk if the anime reaches that part though. . is Yuyushiki better than baka-to-test ? On June 03 2014 04:01 IceHism wrote:
Finished bakemonogatari. Was really good. Love shaft style and the dialogue was eccentric and interesting.
I'll be starting mirai Nikki or higurashi next which I'll be watching with Chihayafuru still Have you watch the sequels of bakemonogatari ? nisemonogatari,nekomonogatari and monogatari s2 ? lol no haha i hear you .. is K-On any good ? i just wanna watch shows that will either give me diabetes or make me smile like a madman .. i'm still having a horrible feeling because of + Show Spoiler [GameOfThrones latest ep] + it's moe and nothing else. Just check it out and see if you like it. It's not really funny either but you could probably call it a light hearted feel good show? But yeah, Baka test would be a lot better for that purpose. What do you mean by shifting the focus? some more along the lines of this: + Show Spoiler [NSFW] +Though I don't actually remember if that's from neko or nise
If the only thing they added was fan service then I don't really care. Fan service doesn't do anything in how I enjoy a series. I'm completely apathetic to it so as long as the dialogue remains similarly great then I'm fine with this fan service in nise thing.
To me, its about balance. If you have too much fan service that your story suffers like high school of the dead, well..... If you have an okay amount while making it up with a good story, then I can go past it not caring.
|
On June 03 2014 14:12 Slaughter wrote:
Nike is literally the only thing that saves that show from being dropped. Everything else is either generic or terrible.
One of the most predictable shows ever that, getting harder to watch each week. Which is a shame, because the first two episodes were pretty enjoyable.
|
TLADT24920 Posts
One Week Friends: + Show Spoiler +well, I guess it was expected that something would happen. Wonder what promise he was talking about though. Also, why did she lose her memories of him rather than remembering some past memories aside from the guy's name? Seems a bit odd to me. Maybe she partially remembers them but hasn't disclosed it yet. Either way, next episode is going to be one crazy roller coaster one. If she remembers the other people in the class, I think it would confirm that she forgets names of those who she loves which is what I think this guy was, an old lover and something happened between them way back.
|
On June 03 2014 08:03 FFGenerations wrote:Show nested quote +On June 02 2014 21:48 goody153 wrote:
can anybody give me a LIGHTHEARTED(when i mean lighthearted not those who will make me mad because it's so bad) anime all for the laughs and lolz and happy feels
[edited] full moon wo sagashite
There's literally cancer and death everywhere.
|
ALLEYCAT BLUES50625 Posts
|
|
|
On June 03 2014 13:47 BigFan wrote:Show nested quote +On June 03 2014 02:30 maru~ wrote:On June 02 2014 15:20 BigFan wrote:Finished Madoka. + Show Spoiler +I think the only part that could use some work is the wish part. I mean, they can be granted any wish? That seems a bit much seeing as you can wish for anything but I guess they had to make some incentive for them to become magical girls. + Show Spoiler +No, that's not how it works (unless you're Madoka). + Show Spoiler +lol seems like it though to be fair, most made the wish in a life or death situation. In Sayaka's case, it was because she was in love with someone so it clouded her judgement. On top of that, most of them didn't know about magical girls turning into witches either so at least when it was Madoka's turn, she knew that and worked to fix it
+ Show Spoiler [Madoka] +No, it was a major point of the show and was explained in detail as well as brought up many times, so I'm not sure how you missed that. Madoka was the only one who could have pulled off that wish. Just rewatch the first 2 minutes of episode 11.
As for her wish, while her potential is immense I don't think it is infinite (addressing your "become an omnipotent being" wish).
Most of the other wishes people tend to throw out there don't actually accomplish what Madoka meant to accomplish or have major issues.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/ni2Q2hl.gif)
