|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
On January 11 2013 11:18 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 11:10 Sentenal wrote:On January 11 2013 11:07 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:On January 11 2013 10:57 Ecael wrote:
That said, a lot of the hate for it is also because it is a mainstream show, the MAL scores are probably really bipolar between the mainstream and those who want to be hipster. ya everyone in this thread is terrified of liking mainstream shows so if a show is popular you can expect to find page long discussions trashing it Cheep do you actually like SAO? Never watched it, probably isn't a great show/something I'd like, but it probably doesn't deserve the amount of vitriol that's frequently flung in its direction by people here - few shows do.
So... If you haven't watched it, how can you say it doesn't deserve the hate its given?
|
On January 11 2013 10:30 Elem wrote:Sasami-san@Ganbaranai: + Show Spoiler +HOLY SHIT
THAT OP
THAT HIKKI YUNO
THAT BROTHER
ALL THOSE OTHER GIRLS I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT
ALL THAT CHOCOLATE
Anime of the decade confirmed. If SHAFT don't fuck this up they are gods. I'm so glad their animation didn't ruin it for me so far, cos it's by far the show I was most hyped for.
Shinbo is up to his old tricks again
On January 11 2013 10:57 Ecael wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 10:48 Yokoblue wrote:
Just listened to Sword Art Online in 2 shot...
I dont understand all the hate that anime get... It was less good in the 2nd half but it wasnt bad. first part was like 9/10 and 2nd part was like 7/10...
I understand that for some people they didnt like the filler at the start but i though it was setting the world of the anime nicely. I can understand too that some people wanted action action action and there's a big part of romance right in the middle but... wtf.
on MAL all the highest review give notes of like 3-5/10... this anime clearly deserve a 8-9/10.... no ? What makes it deserve 8~9/10? Though if you are really curious about the bad reputation it has, you can just search through this thread for the past SAO discussions that should've covered both anime and LNs. That said, a lot of the hate for it is also because it is a mainstream show, the MAL scores are probably really bipolar between the mainstream and those who want to be hipster.
I have no problem give it a 6, and if people want give it a 7, go ahead. It's when people think it's greatest thing ever since Code Geass that drive me nuts.
|
On January 11 2013 11:18 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 11:10 Sentenal wrote:On January 11 2013 11:07 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:On January 11 2013 10:57 Ecael wrote:
That said, a lot of the hate for it is also because it is a mainstream show, the MAL scores are probably really bipolar between the mainstream and those who want to be hipster. ya everyone in this thread is terrified of liking mainstream shows so if a show is popular you can expect to find page long discussions trashing it Cheep do you actually like SAO? Never watched it, probably isn't a great show/something I'd like, but it probably doesn't deserve the amount of vitriol that's frequently flung in its direction by people here - few shows do.
No, Cheep. It's actually shit.
|
If it wasn't popular though, pretty sure everyone would just leave it as "it's shit" and move on, there's a lot of pretty bad shows out there.
|
Baa?21248 Posts
On January 11 2013 11:31 atombombforpeace wrote:
If it wasn't popular though, pretty sure everyone would just leave it as "it's shit" and move on, there's a lot of pretty bad shows out there.
Yea pretty much. People (not just here, in general) like to give shows more hate than it deserves, relative to its actual qualify, due to a show's popularity.
|
On January 11 2013 11:32 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 11:31 atombombforpeace wrote:
If it wasn't popular though, pretty sure everyone would just leave it as "it's shit" and move on, there's a lot of pretty bad shows out there. Yea pretty much. People (not just here, in general) like to give shows more hate than it deserves, relative to its actual qualify, due to a show's popularity.
We are just trying to keep the universe in balance. If a terrible show gets alot of praise, in order to keep physics working properly, it has to receive a proportional amount of hate to counter-act the misplaced praise.
|
Baa?21248 Posts
On January 11 2013 11:36 Sentenal wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 11:32 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:On January 11 2013 11:31 atombombforpeace wrote:
If it wasn't popular though, pretty sure everyone would just leave it as "it's shit" and move on, there's a lot of pretty bad shows out there. Yea pretty much. People (not just here, in general) like to give shows more hate than it deserves, relative to its actual qualify, due to a show's popularity. We are just trying to keep the universe in balance. If a terrible show gets alot of praise, in order to keep physics working properly, it has to receive a proportional amount of hate to counter-act the misplaced praise.
You might as well go join the legions trolling Justin Bieber videos on Youtube. Just seems silly to me. -shrug-
|
On January 11 2013 11:38 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 11:36 Sentenal wrote:On January 11 2013 11:32 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:On January 11 2013 11:31 atombombforpeace wrote:
If it wasn't popular though, pretty sure everyone would just leave it as "it's shit" and move on, there's a lot of pretty bad shows out there. Yea pretty much. People (not just here, in general) like to give shows more hate than it deserves, relative to its actual qualify, due to a show's popularity. We are just trying to keep the universe in balance. If a terrible show gets alot of praise, in order to keep physics working properly, it has to receive a proportional amount of hate to counter-act the misplaced praise. You might as well go join the legions trolling Justin Bieber videos on Youtube. Just seems silly to me. -shrug-
Meh, I don't care about Justin Bieber, so I'll leave that crusade for those people. ANIME, however, is serious fukin business.
|
Anime is pretty wack for the most part. Some shows have something to say (logh) or create a unique universe (fate~) but most of this stuff gets by on being pretty and badass. When that works its pretty good, but alot of the time its kind of redundant. Anime might be serious business, but lets be real - its much more Justin Bieber than Stanley Kubrick. I mean most of the discussion here is about what girl or robot suit is prettier... I love it, but it just makes it seem pathetic when you apply an elitist attitude
|
Question, which one is the worst out of:
Code Geass
EVA
SAO
Mirai Nikki
Soul Eater
Elfen Lied
K-On
Edit: Also - Seed Destiniy
|
Baa?21248 Posts
On January 11 2013 11:53 ragz_gt wrote:
Question, which one is the worst out of:
Code Geass hilarious comedy
EVA good, but some ppl here hate it; also rebuild is good so
SAO dunno
Mirai Nikki manga was funny idk about anime
Soul Eater manga was funny idk about anime
Elfen Lied lol
K-On aids
so theres only one thats legit bad and it's k-on
|
On January 11 2013 11:53 ragz_gt wrote:
Question, which one is the worst out of:
Code Geass
EVA
SAO
Mirai Nikki
Soul Eater
Elfen Lied
K-On My "a chance to hate on K-On! senses were tingling, forcing me out of sleep. I guess it isn't hard to guess which I'll choose.
+ Show Spoiler +Answer is actually EVA, I could get through 2 seasons of boring K-ON but holy shit EVA was awful. Dropped so hard.
|
Baa?21248 Posts
On January 11 2013 12:00 Elem wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 11:53 ragz_gt wrote:
Question, which one is the worst out of:
Code Geass
EVA
SAO
Mirai Nikki
Soul Eater
Elfen Lied
K-On My "a chance to hate on K-On! senses were tingling, forcing me out of sleep. I guess it isn't hard to guess which I'll choose. + Show Spoiler +Answer is actually EVA, I could get through 2 seasons of boring K-ON but holy shit EVA was awful. Dropped so hard.
wow you hate eva didn't expect that
rebuild is legit good man ~_~
|
So does the hate of SAO extend to Accel World too given the similar premise and same author? I enjoyed them both, but I also enjoy mainstream anime.
|
I actually enjoyed EVA most when I watched it, though I was also 12 at the time.
+ Show Spoiler +I had more problem with Death Note anime than all of those
Also shoulda add Seed Destiny to the list
|
On January 11 2013 12:04 BlackMagister wrote:
So does the hate of SAO extend to Accel World too given the similar premise and same author? I enjoyed them both, but I also enjoy mainstream anime.
AW is tons better than SAO, despite flying pig MC. Most people here don't hate mainstream anime... just bad ones. Cowboy Bebop, FMA, FMP, GiTS, FZ, Nanoha, Bakemonogatari etc are fine (though taste vary).
|
On January 11 2013 12:04 BlackMagister wrote:
So does the hate of SAO extend to Accel World too given the similar premise and same author? I enjoyed them both, but I also enjoy mainstream anime. I liked AW a lot more than SAO. I'm hoping for a s2.
On January 11 2013 12:02 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 12:00 Elem wrote:On January 11 2013 11:53 ragz_gt wrote:
Question, which one is the worst out of:
Code Geass
EVA
SAO
Mirai Nikki
Soul Eater
Elfen Lied
K-On My "a chance to hate on K-On! senses were tingling, forcing me out of sleep. I guess it isn't hard to guess which I'll choose. + Show Spoiler +Answer is actually EVA, I could get through 2 seasons of boring K-ON but holy shit EVA was awful. Dropped so hard. wow you hate eva didn't expect that rebuild is legit good man ~_~ I'm not going to live through 10 more eps of that junk to get to that.
|
On January 11 2013 12:02 Carnivorous Sheep wrote:Show nested quote +On January 11 2013 12:00 Elem wrote:On January 11 2013 11:53 ragz_gt wrote:
Question, which one is the worst out of:
Code Geass
EVA
SAO
Mirai Nikki
Soul Eater
Elfen Lied
K-On My "a chance to hate on K-On! senses were tingling, forcing me out of sleep. I guess it isn't hard to guess which I'll choose. + Show Spoiler +Answer is actually EVA, I could get through 2 seasons of boring K-ON but holy shit EVA was awful. Dropped so hard. wow you hate eva didn't expect that rebuild is legit good man ~_~
rebuild sucks because it isnt deep enough
also theres no congratulations (yet?)
|
Canada4481 Posts
I hated AW mainly cause of flying pig MC, and that Chiyu bitch, and Taku. I liked the actual SAO world, not so much the story within it, and ALO was stupid because of how much Kirito cheats. The level 75 boss in SAO looked badass.
|
The anime somehow managed to skip the all-so-important fact that the entire series is about how good Kirito is at cheating and beating the system.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
