|
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here.
If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers.
If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. |
On March 18 2022 23:12 evilfatsh1t wrote:
shanks was not a nobody when he met luffy in east blue. he was already very well known, hence wb's surprise when he returned without an arm.
and i wouldnt go as far as saying luffy's fruit being special now is a retcon. oda very obviously planned his story out, and with the exception of shanks' arm there isnt much in the story that oda hasnt planned for.
you only have to look at virtually every theory out there about anything that shows oda leaves hints throughout his whole story telling process. some of the hints are completely outrageous by the way, and it only highlights how meticulously well thought out oda's storytelling actually is.
luffy's fruit has been seemingly average until wano and only now are we realising that theres a secret behind it, but i wouldnt go as far as saying its a complete asspull by oda to change luffy's fruit entirely. the fact that he chose rubber for luffy's fruit at the beginning of the story was curious enough that it only makes sense now there was a reason oda chose rubber, instead of literally a billion other possibilities.
Rough Shanks timeline:
24 Years Ago: Watches Rodger's execution
22 Years ago: Begins forming Red head pirates including recruiting Yasopp
??: Fights Blackbeard and gets his scar
12 Years ago: East Blue, Hangs out with Luffy, Defeats Whos Who
6 Years ago: Becomes a Yonko
3-5 Years Ago: Meets Ace
2 Years ago: Ends Marineford War
0 Years Ago: Sneaks into Mariejois
|
On March 18 2022 23:12 evilfatsh1t wrote:
shanks was not a nobody when he met luffy in east blue. he was already very well known, hence wb's surprise when he returned without an arm.
and i wouldnt go as far as saying luffy's fruit being special now is a retcon. oda very obviously planned his story out, and with the exception of shanks' arm there isnt much in the story that oda hasnt planned for.
you only have to look at virtually every theory out there about anything that shows oda leaves hints throughout his whole story telling process. some of the hints are completely outrageous by the way, and it only highlights how meticulously well thought out oda's storytelling actually is.
luffy's fruit has been seemingly average until wano and only now are we realising that theres a secret behind it, but i wouldnt go as far as saying its a complete asspull by oda to change luffy's fruit entirely. the fact that he chose rubber for luffy's fruit at the beginning of the story was curious enough that it only makes sense now there was a reason oda chose rubber, instead of literally a billion other possibilities.
Ya, there is for sure some asspull-ness to it all. Like, in original Romance Dawn I think one of Shank's crew didn't believe or know about devil fruits? And that'd be impossible for a Yonko. Also there is some schennangians because I think they kinda had to justify, what was this Yonko planning to do with the fruit? Like, it HAD to have been a very important fruit if it was just chillin on a yonko's ship?
I hate it, but I don't think it is asspully....but it is a consequence of having to retrofit Shank's international importance into Romance Dawn which was a much smaller world.
|
On March 19 2022 00:32 cLutZ wrote:Show nested quote +On March 18 2022 23:12 evilfatsh1t wrote:
shanks was not a nobody when he met luffy in east blue. he was already very well known, hence wb's surprise when he returned without an arm.
and i wouldnt go as far as saying luffy's fruit being special now is a retcon. oda very obviously planned his story out, and with the exception of shanks' arm there isnt much in the story that oda hasnt planned for.
you only have to look at virtually every theory out there about anything that shows oda leaves hints throughout his whole story telling process. some of the hints are completely outrageous by the way, and it only highlights how meticulously well thought out oda's storytelling actually is.
luffy's fruit has been seemingly average until wano and only now are we realising that theres a secret behind it, but i wouldnt go as far as saying its a complete asspull by oda to change luffy's fruit entirely. the fact that he chose rubber for luffy's fruit at the beginning of the story was curious enough that it only makes sense now there was a reason oda chose rubber, instead of literally a billion other possibilities. Rough Shanks timeline: 24 Years Ago: Watches Rodger's execution 22 Years ago: Begins forming Red head pirates including recruiting Yasopp ??: Fights Blackbeard and gets his scar 12 Years ago: East Blue, Hangs out with Luffy, Defeats Whos Who 6 Years ago: Becomes a Yonko 3-5 Years Ago: Meets Ace 2 Years ago: Ends Marineford War 0 Years Ago: Sneaks into Mariejois
I thought there was a recently vivre card that said he became an emperor 13 years ago?
|
On March 19 2022 02:33 lestye wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2022 00:32 cLutZ wrote:On March 18 2022 23:12 evilfatsh1t wrote:
shanks was not a nobody when he met luffy in east blue. he was already very well known, hence wb's surprise when he returned without an arm.
and i wouldnt go as far as saying luffy's fruit being special now is a retcon. oda very obviously planned his story out, and with the exception of shanks' arm there isnt much in the story that oda hasnt planned for.
you only have to look at virtually every theory out there about anything that shows oda leaves hints throughout his whole story telling process. some of the hints are completely outrageous by the way, and it only highlights how meticulously well thought out oda's storytelling actually is.
luffy's fruit has been seemingly average until wano and only now are we realising that theres a secret behind it, but i wouldnt go as far as saying its a complete asspull by oda to change luffy's fruit entirely. the fact that he chose rubber for luffy's fruit at the beginning of the story was curious enough that it only makes sense now there was a reason oda chose rubber, instead of literally a billion other possibilities. Rough Shanks timeline: 24 Years Ago: Watches Rodger's execution 22 Years ago: Begins forming Red head pirates including recruiting Yasopp ??: Fights Blackbeard and gets his scar 12 Years ago: East Blue, Hangs out with Luffy, Defeats Whos Who 6 Years ago: Becomes a Yonko 3-5 Years Ago: Meets Ace 2 Years ago: Ends Marineford War 0 Years Ago: Sneaks into Mariejois I thought there was a recently vivre card that said he became an emperor 13 years ago?
That would be surprising because Brannew in CH 957 calls him, "A six year member of the emperor class." or in another translation, "An emperor for six years."
|
On March 19 2022 03:05 cLutZ wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2022 02:33 lestye wrote:On March 19 2022 00:32 cLutZ wrote:On March 18 2022 23:12 evilfatsh1t wrote:
shanks was not a nobody when he met luffy in east blue. he was already very well known, hence wb's surprise when he returned without an arm.
and i wouldnt go as far as saying luffy's fruit being special now is a retcon. oda very obviously planned his story out, and with the exception of shanks' arm there isnt much in the story that oda hasnt planned for.
you only have to look at virtually every theory out there about anything that shows oda leaves hints throughout his whole story telling process. some of the hints are completely outrageous by the way, and it only highlights how meticulously well thought out oda's storytelling actually is.
luffy's fruit has been seemingly average until wano and only now are we realising that theres a secret behind it, but i wouldnt go as far as saying its a complete asspull by oda to change luffy's fruit entirely. the fact that he chose rubber for luffy's fruit at the beginning of the story was curious enough that it only makes sense now there was a reason oda chose rubber, instead of literally a billion other possibilities. Rough Shanks timeline: 24 Years Ago: Watches Rodger's execution 22 Years ago: Begins forming Red head pirates including recruiting Yasopp ??: Fights Blackbeard and gets his scar 12 Years ago: East Blue, Hangs out with Luffy, Defeats Whos Who 6 Years ago: Becomes a Yonko 3-5 Years Ago: Meets Ace 2 Years ago: Ends Marineford War 0 Years Ago: Sneaks into Mariejois I thought there was a recently vivre card that said he became an emperor 13 years ago? That would be surprising because Brannew in CH 957 calls him, "A six year member of the emperor class." or in another translation, "An emperor for six years."
oh my b.
|
|
|
Ive been seeing that too, how insane does a chapter have to be to warrant that kind of ultra-anti spoiler reaction?
Extremely excited.
|
Ugh I just read the spoilers. This is really just awful.
|
Why bring that in here, I normally dont care about spoilers but even second hand spoilers here feel pretty fucking-my-enjoyment-and-surprise-over
|
On March 22 2022 22:10 Hyperbola wrote:
yeah fuck outta here with that shit
|
Huh? You're already talking about the spoilers, posting Twitter posts from the scanlators claiming that they're "amazing". That's second hand spoilers.
|
The problem is the specificity, theres a difference between "Its big dont look," and [REDACTED]
|
|
|
Alright, well if that specific comment was an issue, I edited my post, I recommend you do the same. Also next time don't start talking about spoilers if you don't want to hear/discuss the spoilers.
|
there were no spoilers, "ITS BIG NEWS" isnt spoilers
|
God I'm gonna have to start avoiding this channel till I read the chapter huh?
|
On March 23 2022 09:25 Zooper31 wrote:
God I'm gonna have to start avoiding this channel till I read the chapter huh?
I think we got it sorted out.
|
Austria24420 Posts
You guys do know that TL has a spoiler function, yes? + Show Spoiler +This is exactly what it's for. Please use that.
|
United States97276 Posts
well... that was a chapter
|
+ Show Spoiler +Yeah I hate this a lot this is making me not even want to bother reading One Piece anymore it’s so bad
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
