|
All book discussion in this thread is now allowed. |
On April 17 2013 22:01 Hitch-22 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2013 21:58 SpikeStarcraft wrote:
maybe we need a thread where you can spoiler book 3 but not any further. so there is a place where you can compare the book to the tv show adaption without fearing to be spoilered when you havent finished all books yet and dont spoiler people that only watch the tv show. Doesn't work since some of the book is left out and some of the show features thins perhaps later in the series but drawn back a bit or expanded upon. You can just never be safe enough for a spoiler not to happen.
well apparently a lot of people do want to compare books and tv show, and they fear to go to the anything goes spoiler thread for whatever reason. So they end up here, because theres no where else to go.
|
Netherlands13554 Posts
It's not that hard to just treat this show as if there was never any book to talk about.
|
it's really not. just handing out bans until people learn is the way to go I think.
|
Or perhaps moderator to confirm all posts in this thread. Maybe after you click "post" you get warning "if you post spoilers from the book you get 30 day banned" before post is shown.
|
Zurich15345 Posts
On April 17 2013 21:58 SpikeStarcraft wrote:
maybe we need a thread where you can spoiler book 3 but not any further. so there is a place where you can compare the book to the tv show adaption without fearing to be spoilered when you havent finished all books yet and dont spoiler people that only watch the tv show.
because to me and a lot of other people that havent finished the books its like walking a tightrope. You have to be super careful with what you say here to not spoiler and if you go to the spoiler book thread you might stumble upon spoilers for book 5.
Yes, and then we need a thread for people who have just finished book 4 but not book 5. And while were are at it another 3 for people who are just over the middle of each upcoming book / season.
Just read faster 
In general a number of mods watch this thread continuously, so the time spoilers are live here is really really low I think.
|
On April 17 2013 22:12 Gene wrote:
it's really not. just handing out bans until people learn is the way to go I think.
It is on Season 3 and people can't avoid the spoils yet. I've read them and I like to read this topic to see the conclusions, but I avoid to comment anything about it because most of the times readers think something that happened in the show that actually only happened in the books.
|
Some people in this thread... Seriously, im going back and searching through the past 20 pages, people with 2 or more way too suspicious replies gonna get reported. I'm 100% sure about 1 guy, and 90% about another, but i need some proof.
|
On April 17 2013 21:58 SpikeStarcraft wrote:
maybe we need a thread where you can spoiler book 3 but not any further. so there is a place where you can compare the book to the tv show adaption without fearing to be spoilered when you havent finished all books yet and dont spoiler people that only watch the tv show.
because to me and a lot of other people that havent finished the books its like walking a tightrope. You have to be super careful with what you say here to not spoiler and if you go to the spoiler book thread you might stumble upon spoilers for book 5.
lol, even on sites dedicated to ASOIAF, discussion threads are not enforced by scope in terms of spoilers.
Sorry brah, it's all or none. I think it's better for you if you only hang out here and just talk about the show. It's better than the books anyway. =)
|
^ Blasphemy!
Anyway, i really liked the third episode, altough the Pod filler was a filler, which fills my heart with a bit of rage. But the rest was really good
|
United States7483 Posts
On April 17 2013 22:32 c0ldfusion wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2013 21:58 SpikeStarcraft wrote:
maybe we need a thread where you can spoiler book 3 but not any further. so there is a place where you can compare the book to the tv show adaption without fearing to be spoilered when you havent finished all books yet and dont spoiler people that only watch the tv show.
because to me and a lot of other people that havent finished the books its like walking a tightrope. You have to be super careful with what you say here to not spoiler and if you go to the spoiler book thread you might stumble upon spoilers for book 5. lol, even on sites dedicated to ASOIAF, discussion threads are not enforced by scope in terms of spoilers. Sorry brah, it's all or none. I think it's better for you if you only hang out here and just talk about the show. It's better than the books anyway. =)
There's another thread for people who want to discuss the show and the books together. This isn't it.
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=225659
|
On April 17 2013 22:29 Geo.Rion wrote:
Some people in this thread... Seriously, im going back and searching through the past 20 pages, people with 2 or more way too suspicious replies gonna get reported. I'm 100% sure about 1 guy, and 90% about another, but i need some proof.
you think some people are pretending to be watching just the tv show when they really have read all the book? That's pretty damn evil trolling if they are spoiling things under the guise of "i havnt read the books"
|
On April 18 2013 00:45 Whitewing wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2013 22:32 c0ldfusion wrote:On April 17 2013 21:58 SpikeStarcraft wrote:
maybe we need a thread where you can spoiler book 3 but not any further. so there is a place where you can compare the book to the tv show adaption without fearing to be spoilered when you havent finished all books yet and dont spoiler people that only watch the tv show.
because to me and a lot of other people that havent finished the books its like walking a tightrope. You have to be super careful with what you say here to not spoiler and if you go to the spoiler book thread you might stumble upon spoilers for book 5. lol, even on sites dedicated to ASOIAF, discussion threads are not enforced by scope in terms of spoilers. Sorry brah, it's all or none. I think it's better for you if you only hang out here and just talk about the show. It's better than the books anyway. =) There's another thread for people who want to discuss the show and the books together. This isn't it. http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=225659
You're preaching to the choir man. I'm just advising this guy to post here and talk only about the show.
|
There is a huge spoiler 2 pages back, I am done reading this topic.
|
On April 17 2013 11:36 furerkip wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2013 06:39 rezoacken wrote:On April 17 2013 05:54 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
HOLY SHIT HIS FUCKING HAND and the music right after lol. Made me think I downloaded a bad version of the episode. I don't think Jaime will be as handsome after this episode...
Anyways, is it supposed to be implied that Pod didn't actually have sex, and just took the money and ran? I thought Tyrion figured it out, but then he sat Pod down and made me not so sure anymore. Its implied Pod did have sex. The two possibilities are then: -the whores didn't take the money because he was too cute -the whores where paid in advance by Tyrion but to make Pod feel better he made Pod believe the whores genuinely didn't take the money. The second possibility makes no sense though; why would he want to make Pod feel like he was a god in bed, after already giving him 3 whores? Also, why would any of the 3 whores deny themselves MORE money, seeing as Pod had no idea he was supposed to take the money back to Tyrion? It's not like Tyrion can just be like "what the fuck, they didn't give me my money back? Let's get those assholes!" It's just more likely he gave him the 3 whores as an actual gift with the money rather than make Pod feel like a monster in bed because the whores gave him his money back even though he isn't. Also, he has experienced the same feeling from his dad Tywin with that old whore of his; why would he want to put Podrick in the exact same situation he faced and was left with nothing but the medicine of ale and the therapy of whores?
How does it makes no sense ? It makes Pod feel as if he was so good that they don't ask for the money. Looks pretty sensical to me. For his first time... builds confidence you know ? Instead of just being an average customer.
Why would they deny money ? Because they were asked not to take it ?
Also this is not the same thing as what happened to Tyrion... (Not wanting to say more, can't remember what exactly was said in the TV series). Also, Tyrion is a dwarf while Pod is a cute boy; even if he know about the deception, it wouldn't shatter his reality.
I'm not saying this is the right possibility anyway, but it's a possibility. You could argue however that Tyrion seemed genuinely surprised and that there isn't enough hints pointing to it, to dismiss it. Anyway... its no big deal, that was just a funny moment that won't have any ramification most probably.
On April 17 2013 11:13 Hitch-22 wrote:
There are 7 books ( think? and not all finished yet?) ... You're kinda rushing the plot on who will win the war prettttty quickly with like 5 campaigns running around lol. (btw this is no hint, I barely started the first book lol)
7 books scheduled, 5 already released.
|
So what about the story speculations in this topic?
I never red the books and still got temp banned two days ago.
Obviously I must have been quite correct about my predictions (no worries post is deleted now).
Just sayin...
|
|
|
Germany25657 Posts
On April 18 2013 01:03 lord_nibbler wrote:
So what about the story speculations in this topic?
I never red the books and still got temp banned two days ago.
Obviously I must have been quite correct about my predictions (no worries post is deleted now).
Just sayin...
Your ban was actually a mistake (that's why It got reverted) , feel free to post predictions.
|
On April 17 2013 22:21 zatic wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2013 21:58 SpikeStarcraft wrote:
maybe we need a thread where you can spoiler book 3 but not any further. so there is a place where you can compare the book to the tv show adaption without fearing to be spoilered when you havent finished all books yet and dont spoiler people that only watch the tv show.
because to me and a lot of other people that havent finished the books its like walking a tightrope. You have to be super careful with what you say here to not spoiler and if you go to the spoiler book thread you might stumble upon spoilers for book 5. Yes, and then we need a thread for people who have just finished book 4 but not book 5. And while were are at it another 3 for people who are just over the middle of each upcoming book / season. Just read faster In general a number of mods watch this thread continuously, so the time spoilers are live here is really really low I think.
Actually, I think a thread where you can talk about the books only to the point where we are in the show would be a good thing. A ton of people have requested it, as if you've read the book as far as the show, you can't talk in here. And you can't visit the other thread because its filled with spoilers from the last book.
|
On April 18 2013 01:05 KadaverBB wrote:Show nested quote +On April 18 2013 01:03 lord_nibbler wrote:
So what about the story speculations in this topic?
I never red the books and still got temp banned two days ago.
Obviously I must have been quite correct about my predictions (no worries post is deleted now).
Just sayin... Your ban was actually a mistake (that's why It got reverted) , feel free to post predictions.
No problem. 
And to be fair, after today's standard the ban would have been even longer, because I did speculate about the number of books and the length of the TV series.
|
On April 18 2013 00:58 EleanorRIgby wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2013 22:29 Geo.Rion wrote:
Some people in this thread... Seriously, im going back and searching through the past 20 pages, people with 2 or more way too suspicious replies gonna get reported. I'm 100% sure about 1 guy, and 90% about another, but i need some proof. you think some people are pretending to be watching just the tv show when they really have read all the book? That's pretty damn evil trolling if they are spoiling things under the guise of "i havnt read the books"
Yes. I specifically remember, after the last episode, someone quoting himself from earlier "blah and blah look like they're going to be the best characters on the show, although you have to give Jaime a hand too". He was practically patting himself on the back thinking he was SO clever in how he hid the spoiler.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
