Discussing the show and past episodes is fine. Do not put things that have happened in the TV series in spoilers. However, don't spoil things from the books that may happen in future episodes. Put book spoilers in spoiler tags with a CLEAR WARNING that it is from the book.

-Archangel-

Croatia7457 Posts

October 14 2014 13:22 GMT

#8441

On October 14 2014 21:52 Faust852 wrote:
Wow that was a really great episode ! Full Rambo Carol too

Don't forget Tyreese "I stick zombies on pikes, go through doors like they are not there and punch the people to death"

Nekovivie

United Kingdom2599 Posts

October 14 2014 14:44 GMT

#8442

On October 14 2014 09:03 parkufarku wrote:

Show nested quote +

err he was introduced last season..

By introduced, I think he meant had more than one line of dialogue.

Hyperbola

United States2539 Posts

October 14 2014 19:43 GMT

#8443

I know this show is AMC's cash cow right now and I know that the actors are fighting tooth and nail to stay in but why the fuck did no one die this episode? It's just plain cheap when all of the characters get out unscathed from a life and death situation like that. Glen should be dead. So should Tyrese. So should the baby. Perhaps even Carol?
Besides that, I'm loving the portrayal of violence in the series. I know that's a weird thing to say but I think that TWD handles the gritty aspects of violence in a very nice way. It isn't over-glorified or glamorized. It's just raw. A lot of other shows would have someone cut a person in half in a single stroke and have blood gushing out all over the walls. In TWD you take a piece of wood, stab it in someone's throat and that's the end of that. That said, Carol's firework was still kind of bullshit.

roseinkspillred

United States19 Posts

October 14 2014 20:08 GMT

#8444

Carol's firework trick is possible (albeit difficult). The only problem I have with it is that much propane should have blew up half of Terminus, at least. Also how long do you think the wearing zombie guts trick works? After a while, walkers would notice you with really old blood.

Cel.erity

United States4890 Posts

October 14 2014 20:13 GMT

#8445

Best episode since season 1 IMO. Brutal and suspenseful, didn't feel like any of the moments on screen were wasted. There were some convenient coincidences and TV magic, but hey, it's still a zombie show. I hope they keep the quick pace for the trek to DC or whatever is coming next.

One minor nitpick: Although I liked the interaction between Tyreese and the random redneck guy, I thought it was pretty unrealistic how loosely he was tied up. I mean, it basically went like this:

R: "Hey man, I'm totally going to kill you and that baby over there."

T: "Naw, you wouldn't do that. Besides, that baby is at least three feet away from you, and you have a seatbelt around your wrists. What harm could you possibly do? Now, let me just turn my back for a sec-- hey! No fair!"

Jett.Jack.Alvir

Canada2250 Posts

October 15 2014 09:34 GMT

#8446

On October 15 2014 05:13 Cel.erity wrote:
Best episode since season 1 IMO. Brutal and suspenseful, didn't feel like any of the moments on screen were wasted. There were some convenient coincidences and TV magic, but hey, it's still a zombie show. I hope they keep the quick pace for the trek to DC or whatever is coming next.

One minor nitpick: Although I liked the interaction between Tyreese and the random redneck guy, I thought it was pretty unrealistic how loosely he was tied up. I mean, it basically went like this:

R: "Hey man, I'm totally going to kill you and that baby over there."

T: "Naw, you wouldn't do that. Besides, that baby is at least three feet away from you, and you have a seatbelt around your wrists. What harm could you possibly do? Now, let me just turn my back for a sec-- hey! No fair!"

A great episode, but I agree with the Tyreese situation.

Why the fuck did he always have his back to that redneck? Tyreese deserved to die in this episode for his stupidity and chicken shit nature.

And Carol miraculously saving Rick and friends just before they are about to have their head smashed and throat slashed. Its a little to convenient. I like a good deus ex machina, but this is just a little to convenient. Not to mention aiming a firework at the propane tank. I don't see another way they could have had Carol save them all.

I did like how bad-ass she was walking amongst the walkers and shooting the Terminus citizens. And she is cold hearted, letting that woman die to walkers!

Klogon

MURICA15980 Posts

October 15 2014 20:50 GMT

#8447

Just caught up on about 6 episodes after seeing the first 10 minutes of this premier. This episode was so well done.

Nekovivie

United Kingdom2599 Posts

October 16 2014 14:28 GMT

#8448

too much redshirt at the start of the ep imo.

Requizen

United States33802 Posts

October 16 2014 14:32 GMT

#8449

Did people really just expect them to kill off a main character in the first episode with no buildup or anything? If they had killed off Glenn or Daryl in the first 5 minutes, the shitstorm would have been huuuuuuuuuuuge beyond reason.

Twisted

Netherlands13554 Posts

October 16 2014 15:25 GMT

#8450

Nah people are just mentioning that the whole scene was too obvious. 4 nobodies in a row and then our 4 heroes. Obviously they were gonna stop at Glenn. I guess they just wanted a gruesome scene in the episode apart from zombies eating faces.

Nemireck

Canada1875 Posts

October 16 2014 20:13 GMT

#8451

The Red-Shirt scene would have been more satisfying if Rick had been able to cut his bonds and save the entire lineup, only to have the Reds die during the ensuing scuffle.

kwizach

3658 Posts

October 16 2014 21:49 GMT

#8452

Anyone else thinking Tyreese may not have actually killed the guy in the hut?

GreenHorizons

United States23263 Posts

October 16 2014 22:00 GMT

#8453

On October 16 2014 23:32 Requizen wrote:
Did people really just expect them to kill off a main character in the first episode with no buildup or anything? If they had killed off Glenn or Daryl in the first 5 minutes, the shitstorm would have been huuuuuuuuuuuge beyond reason.

Pretty sure people have threatened to riot if they kill Daryl. Not that I support such action but it would be interesting to see a show forced at riot point to keep a character.

I feel like it's going to be a bit of a cop out by killing Bob and calling that 'killing of a main character'

+ Show Spoiler +

But I wouldn't be surprised to see carol die after they + Show Spoiler +

find Beth.

Just curious what the protocol is for stuff discussed by actors and such on talking dead (semi-spoilers)?

GreenHorizons

United States23263 Posts

October 16 2014 22:02 GMT

#8454

On October 17 2014 06:49 kwizach wrote:
Anyone else thinking Tyreese may not have actually killed the guy in the hut?

I feel like if he killed him he wouldn't have been so aggressive in stopping Rick from going inside (maybe just a heads up he is zombified). The guy's brain is definitely short some cells though either way.

{CC}StealthBlue

United States41117 Posts

October 17 2014 00:39 GMT

#8455

Daryl is a ratings magnet which is why he is still alive. Which begs the question what happens in the next two seasons when they have to do... ya know, in order to move the very big confrontation.

EDIT: Of course this could change as they have already deviated way far from the comics, look at Carol for example.

tofucake

Hyrule19077 Posts

October 17 2014 01:03 GMT

#8456

Well Daryl isn't in the comics so they can do whatever the hell they want with him.

{CC}StealthBlue

United States41117 Posts

October 17 2014 01:33 GMT

#8457

Still say they should have tied Daryl to the spin off and story line. Ratings gold.

crms

United States11933 Posts

October 17 2014 02:06 GMT

#8458

On October 17 2014 10:03 tofucake wrote:
Well Daryl isn't in the comics so they can do whatever the hell they want with him.

considering how they've changed characters from the comics from physical characteristics to entire storylines, I'm not sure being in the comic means much anyway.