| Forum Index > BW General |
|
fazek42
Hungary438 Posts
On March 02 2019 16:34 FFW_Rude wrote: I never saw her on the sidebar in TL always bad timing or not featured ? I was also wondering about this. Great interview and gl Cadenzie! | ||
|
scissorhands
United States68 Posts
 | ||
|
Highgamer
1440 Posts
Big enough... and 50 million people, but being a foreigner surely helps to get recognized, lel. | ||
|
bovienchien
Vietnam1152 Posts
| ||
|
Favian[PaiN]
United States75 Posts
| ||
|
Cheesefome
314 Posts
| ||
|
Highgamer
1440 Posts
On March 08 2019 00:44 Cheesefome wrote: One would think that in this day and age this interview would be done via video considering every human being alive has a camera in their pockets. I get that you probably just want a bit more convenience but: An interview held face-to-face (in person or via camera) is different to a written conversation and it's not per se better or more authentic because it's via video. The form in which you communicate influences the content in different ways. It highly depends on the interviewers/interviewees preferences and traits how well it will turn out in either form. Generally speaking, answers (and questions) will be more spontaneous and less thought through if you have to answer verbally. Obviously this adds a certain liveliness and maybe even thrill sometimes, but it does not always benefit the interview's accuracy and validity. Also, speaking face to face comes with all kinds of effects on how people feel and behave (discomfort, antipathy, shyness, awkwardness, rudeness, subtle ways of exerting influence) that can lead to a less honest, less fruitful interaction that is not intended. For these and other reasons, many interviews that are intended to be a bit more in-depths are being held in written form or, if held verbally, are being reviewed after they were held - not to cover or polish things up, but because we don't always talk in our right minds. On a sidenote: You're probably exaggerating intentionally, but not every human being has cameras in their pockets, not even all of those who could afford it. (Just a general reminder: half the world's population or so doesn't have a smartphone and you exclude them from "humans alive" in your sentence, and maybe in your everyday-thinking.) In this case though, they had phones in their pockets, probably. Admittedly, most people who have a camera in their pocket probably never asked themselves, in serious time, whether they should or not. More importantly: even a streamer might not want to be filmed in all situations. signed: prolly stoneage nerd | ||
|
Cheesefome
314 Posts
On March 08 2019 01:33 Highgamer wrote: I get that you probably just want a bit more convenience but: An interview held face-to-face (in person or via camera) is different to a written conversation and it's not per se better or more authentic because it's via video. The form in which you communicate influences the content in different ways. It highly depends on the interviewers/interviewees preferences and traits how well it will turn out in either form. Generally speaking, answers (and questions) will be more spontaneous and less thought through if you have to answer verbally. Obviously this adds a certain liveliness and maybe even thrill sometimes, but it does not always benefit the interview's accuracy and validity. Also, speaking face to face comes with all kinds of effects on how people feel and behave (discomfort, antipathy, shyness, awkwardness, rudeness, subtle ways of exerting influence) that can lead to a less honest, less fruitful interaction that is not intended. For these and other reasons, many interviews that are intended to be a bit more in-depths are being held in written form or, if held verbally, are being reviewed after they were held - not to cover or polish things up, but because we don't always talk in our right minds. On a sidenote: You're probably exaggerating intentionally, but not every human being has cameras in their pockets, not even all of those who could afford it. (Just a general reminder: half the world's population or so doesn't have a smartphone and you exclude them from "humans alive" in your sentence, and maybe in your everyday-thinking.) In this case though, they had phones in their pockets, probably. Admittedly, most people who have a camera in their pocket probably never asked themselves, in serious time, whether they should or not. More importantly: even a streamer might not want to be filmed in all situations. signed: prolly stoneage nerd You're wayyyyy overthinking it. She's a streamer, i'm pretty sure having a camera in her face is the least of her concern or worries. She literally does this for a living and has been for years. If shyness was the issue she wouldn't be using a cam in the first place. Obviously not every single human being has a cell phone. Did you actually waste time explaining that? What we know is that these people being interviewed own PC's and phones that was my point. Personally would prefer to see her express her experiences in a video vs reading it.. Actually think it would be more authentic and also I'm sure people could appreciate the gamers personality. BTW you can edit the videos if something was said that the interviewer or interviewee did not like. To be clear, I'm not complaining about the interviews in fact i love them and appreciate them. | ||
|
Highgamer
1440 Posts
No harm intended though, just that I tend to try. I just think a little more subtlety and questioning in conversations can be enriching sometimes but it's so off the usual tone, especially on the internet, that people take it for pedantism. | ||
|
XenOsky
Chile2281 Posts
| ||
|
JieXian
Malaysia4677 Posts
| ||
EsportsJohn
United States4883 Posts
On March 08 2019 14:00 Cheesefome wrote: You're wayyyyy overthinking it. She's a streamer, i'm pretty sure having a camera in her face is the least of her concern or worries. She literally does this for a living and has been for years. If shyness was the issue she wouldn't be using a cam in the first place. Obviously not every single human being has a cell phone. Did you actually waste time explaining that? What we know is that these people being interviewed own PC's and phones that was my point. Personally would prefer to see her express her experiences in a video vs reading it.. Actually think it would be more authentic and also I'm sure people could appreciate the gamers personality. BTW you can edit the videos if something was said that the interviewer or interviewee did not like. To be clear, I'm not complaining about the interviews in fact i love them and appreciate them. Just to add to this conversation, it's pretty interesting how the format of the interview affects the answers you receive. Generally I've found that text (dialogue) interviews are very...constructed. They give the interviewee plenty of time to think through their responses and choose the best words, and as a result, you get both a more precise point but also potentially a less sincere one. Audio and video interviews definitely present more candid moments but can often lose some meaning as the interviewee rambles or tries to cover up the silence when they're thinking. It's a give and take, and I think both have their merits. In our case, Ty2 chose to go for a text interview because 1) Korea is on the other side of the world and time zones create issues with audio or video interviews, and 2) text interviews are much much easier. EDIT: Q&A interviews (you send a list of questions, the person sends a list of answers back) are awful unless it's literally like 3-4 questions and you're mostly just doing it for a few quotes. | ||
|
lemmata
468 Posts
The reason such "live" interviews are better in quality (IMO) is because the first answer you get often doesn't answer your question or doesn't give you enough. So doing it live lets the interviewer to have a conversation with the subject instead of just reading the questions. You sometimes even massage their egos to make them open up a bit. It is a major pain, especially since VOIP quality often varies. I am glad I don't have to do these anymore now that my passion is dead. Everyone who writes for TL pretty much has a RL job and family obligations. I hope people will be more understanding of these text interviews. Let me tell you, these are not easy to set up either. Granted, cadenzie speaks English, so this was probably easier than dealing with Koreans, but the answers are pretty informative from what I can see. Heck they're better than answers from some live interviews. Looks like Ty2 got some good answers. I would be thankful that we aren't getting more interviews that are one liner spams. | ||
|
Highgamer
1440 Posts
On March 09 2019 17:51 lemmata wrote: I would be thankful that we aren't getting more interviews that are one liner spams. God gives commandments, that's why those answers are clear and brief. | ||
|
Rus_Brain
Russian Federation1893 Posts
http://reps.ru/news.php?act=lang&lang=rus&news=comment&id=7678 | ||
|
samantha_beth
1 Post
| ||
|
Xeln4g4
Italy1209 Posts
Is she going out with Shine ... is she secretely in love with Larva ... or other way around with ... Tossgirl? | ||
|
ne4aJIb
Russian Federation3209 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games Grubby2074 FrodaN1405 fl0m1099 ceh9465 B2W.Neo361 KnowMe204 Harstem185 Skadoodle181 Liquid`VortiX178 Hui .150 ArmadaUGS102 C9.Mang093 Mew2King51 Trikslyr43 ZombieGrub29 OptimusSC20 |
|
Replay Cast
The PondCast
OSC
CrankTV Team League
Team Liquid vs Team Falcon
Replay Cast
WardiTV Invitational
ByuN vs Spirit
herO vs Solar
MaNa vs Gerald
Rogue vs GuMiho
Epic.LAN
CrankTV Team League
BASILISK vs TBD
Replay Cast
Epic.LAN
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
