• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 02:24
CET 08:24
KST 16:24
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Rongyi Cup S3 - Preview & Info3herO wins SC2 All-Star Invitational12SC2 All-Star Invitational: Tournament Preview5RSL Revival - 2025 Season Finals Preview8RSL Season 3 - Playoffs Preview0
Community News
Weekly Cups (Jan 12-18): herO, MaxPax, Solar win0BSL Season 2025 - Full Overview and Conclusion8Weekly Cups (Jan 5-11): Clem wins big offline, Trigger upsets4$21,000 Rongyi Cup Season 3 announced (Jan 22-Feb 7)25Weekly Cups (Dec 29-Jan 4): Protoss rolls, 2v2 returns7
StarCraft 2
General
PhD study /w SC2 - help with a survey! herO wins SC2 All-Star Invitational Oliveira Would Have Returned If EWC Continued StarCraft 2 not at the Esports World Cup 2026 [Short Story] The Last GSL
Tourneys
$21,000 Rongyi Cup Season 3 announced (Jan 22-Feb 7) OSC Season 13 World Championship $70 Prize Pool Ladder Legends Academy Weekly Open! SC2 All-Star Invitational: Jan 17-18 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament
Strategy
Simple Questions Simple Answers
Custom Maps
[A] Starcraft Sound Mod
External Content
Mutation # 510 Safety Violation Mutation # 509 Doomsday Report Mutation # 508 Violent Night Mutation # 507 Well Trained
Brood War
General
[ASL21] Potential Map Candidates Which foreign pros are considered the best? Gypsy to Korea BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Fantasy's Q&A video
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues Azhi's Colosseum - Season 2 Small VOD Thread 2.0 [BSL21] Non-Korean Championship - Starts Jan 10
Strategy
Current Meta Simple Questions, Simple Answers Soma's 9 hatch build from ASL Game 2 Game Theory for Starcraft
Other Games
General Games
Beyond All Reason Nintendo Switch Thread Battle Aces/David Kim RTS Megathread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Awesome Games Done Quick 2026!
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
Vanilla Mini Mafia Mafia Game Mode Feedback/Ideas
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread European Politico-economics QA Mega-thread Canadian Politics Mega-thread NASA and the Private Sector
Fan Clubs
The herO Fan Club! The IdrA Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
How Esports Advertising Shap…
TrAiDoS
My 2025 Magic: The Gathering…
DARKING
Life Update and thoughts.
FuDDx
How do archons sleep?
8882
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 2285 users

I get Butterflies...

Blogs > SirJolt
Post a Reply
SirJolt
Profile Blog Joined October 2009
the Dagon Knight4010 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-29 21:13:59
May 29 2011 16:33 GMT
#1
I've noticed a lot of writing people on TL lately, and wondered if people would be kind enough to read this over for me and tell me what they think. I'd appreciate any constructive criticism, really. Thanks


When I was eight or nine, we used to stay with the grandparents in Wexford, down by the beach. We’d walk out to the dunes in summer and grow so thoroughly bored of the beach that we had no interest at all in going back after the first week, sick of sun and sand we'd sit around and mope.

From time to time, the father would be busy enough with school or work that we’d spend a week around Easter there too. The place was dead in Spring, the shops all seasonal and shuttered up, everywhere so different without the sunshine. We’d amuse ourselves as best we could in those pre-summer weeks, when the weather was poor enough that we couldn’t visit the beach for fear of windborne sand.

We’d go anyway though, and shield our eyes against the gritty gusts, to stumble through the dunes, cracking the wet-brown surface shell of sand to reveal the whiteness beneath. One afternoon, the sun breaking through for a warm few hours, we’d found a chrysalis hanging from the scrubby thorn-bushes that lined the shallow hollows of the dunes. We had found it just as it had begun to unravel; the first time I’d seen a cocoon and I’d be there to see it opened. How fine a thing it was.

From that husk emerged first a tiny speckled head, and, with great effort, the legs abdomen and crumpled wings followed, slowly unfolding to drink in the sun, to dry and prepare for flight. As we watched though, the butterfly extended further, sliding gradually from the limp shell to reveal a stretched, conjoined abdomen, a second set of wings, unfolding in turn. The second set of legs clutched at the stem as the wings unfolded, two butterflies laid end-to-end, hanging as they dried.

We were curious of the thing, beautiful as it was, in the way that only a child’s perception of a butterfly could be, splashes of red deepening in the warmth of the sun. For reasons I cannot at all remember, we had with us a jam-jar (all one word, in the way of the granny), and knowing this was too fine a thing to let escape. We filled the glass with plants and grasses, perhaps a little sand, and snagged it straight from the branch, using the lid to clip it free.

Once inside, the two flapped about in a confusion of compound eyes and glass, the black and red-orange of their wings a blur among the twigs and flora we’d scraped together. We grew afraid then, afraid that we had hurt them and that they might hurt themselves. We’d been convinced that their condition would prove fatal eventually, whether they simply couldn’t fly correctly, could never properly feed or would tear one another apart… it had seemed very unlikely they’d live.

So we did what any children would do. We walked down to the shore, the tide already going out, and flung the jar into the sea. Sadly, having only the throwing arms of kids, the jar failed to clear the sandbank about fifteen feet out, and we waded across to it, the jar heavy enough to have sunk to the bottom of the six-inch deep sea across the sandbar.

Under that thin pane of seawater was our glass, shining in the sun, the soft-green grass and bright red-on-black of frenetic floundering in that delicate bubble. One end was already an inch or two submerged in sand. We hadn’t the heart to cast the thing further into the sea, so we left it alone.

Maybe the tide drew them out along the bottom, our sweet Siamese submariners.





+ Show Spoiler +
I did post this on my personal blog a couple of days ago, but I thought TL might be the place to go to for some honest responses. I hope that's okay



****
Moderator@SirJolt
Spekulatius
Profile Joined January 2011
Germany2413 Posts
May 29 2011 20:36 GMT
#2
Children are the most cruel of all people.

I liked your little story a lot. I can't comment on your language as you clearly speak English better than I do.
From a writer's perspective, I'd rework the first two paragraphs. It doesn't matter that you've been there in summer and that it's totally different in the cold spring - or at least, it doesn't deserve a mention the length of a whole paragraph, one (accessory) sentence should suffice, considering the story is overall kept short.
Not a big deal though, it was very nice to read. Keep writing.
Always smile~
Yurie
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
12009 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-29 20:44:40
May 29 2011 20:44 GMT
#3
"perhaps a little sand, and snagged it straight from the branch with the lit to clip the little shell. "

Did you mean lid instead of lit? Over all the sentence feels odd. (Might just be me not understanding English well enough.)

As for criticism, what is the purpose of the text. Without a purpose criticism is impossible since it could fulfil one perfectly while failing at another.
SirJolt
Profile Blog Joined October 2009
the Dagon Knight4010 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-29 21:15:44
May 29 2011 21:12 GMT
#4
On May 30 2011 05:44 Yurie wrote:
"perhaps a little sand, and snagged it straight from the branch with the lit to clip the little shell. "

Did you mean lid instead of lit? Over all the sentence feels odd. (Might just be me not understanding English well enough.)

As for criticism, what is the purpose of the text. Without a purpose criticism is impossible since it could fulfil one perfectly while failing at another.


It should definitely say "lid," thanks.

I suppose the purpose of the text was to be a very short story, something small and entertaining. To be a pleasure to the reader

And thanks Spekulatius, that's exactly the kind of advice I was hoping for. There comes a point in editing where it's hard to see what's important and what needs to go. I'm too close to the text, I fear
Moderator@SirJolt
Spekulatius
Profile Joined January 2011
Germany2413 Posts
May 29 2011 22:37 GMT
#5
On May 30 2011 06:12 SirJolt wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 30 2011 05:44 Yurie wrote:
"perhaps a little sand, and snagged it straight from the branch with the lit to clip the little shell. "

Did you mean lid instead of lit? Over all the sentence feels odd. (Might just be me not understanding English well enough.)

As for criticism, what is the purpose of the text. Without a purpose criticism is impossible since it could fulfil one perfectly while failing at another.


It should definitely say "lid," thanks.

I suppose the purpose of the text was to be a very short story, something small and entertaining. To be a pleasure to the reader

And thanks Spekulatius, that's exactly the kind of advice I was hoping for. There comes a point in editing where it's hard to see what's important and what needs to go. I'm too close to the text, I fear


You're welcome. I know how helpful a second opinion from someone uninvolved always is. One tends to lose track of the work that gets presented in the end through all the thinking that is happening in its creation.
Always smile~
whatthefat
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
United States918 Posts
May 30 2011 00:32 GMT
#6
This is beautiful, thank you for sharing it. I don't have any criticisms; I found the narrative very immersive, and loved its poignancy.
SlayerS_BoxeR: "I always feel sorry towards Greg (Grack?) T_T"
Sleight
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
2471 Posts
May 30 2011 00:51 GMT
#7
I think this is very well written. I do think you need a bit of grammatical work and punctuation to clear it up, but it is mostly good. One big note.

Tone: Read the word choice and attitude of your piece. It is an adult-conveyed childhood reflection on something beyond the grasp of the child. Words like "chrysalis," "conjoined," and "submariners" pollute the image, in my opinion. I think you have masterfully blended a child's memory with an appropriate reinterpretation, but just using "cocoon", "bound", and "sailors" or the like would keep the balance of maturity and childhood better. I lose all sense of inexperience with those word choices.

Very entertaining read.
One Love
Torte de Lini
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
Germany38463 Posts
May 30 2011 01:13 GMT
#8
Hey, you messaged me to give this a read and so I will! I'm not going to tell you about oddness in grammar and shit because 1. I'm terrible at it 2. I like critiquing more on content than grammar issues you can usually comb over with a second good read and 3. Funner to talk about!

When I was eight or nine, we used to stay with the grandparents in Wexford, down by the beach. We’d walk out to the dunes in summer and grow so thoroughly tired (could loathsome work here?) of the beach that we had no interest at all in going back after the first week, sick of sun and sand we'd sit around and mope.

From time to time, our father would be busy enough with school or work that we’d spend a week around Easter there too. The place was dead in Spring, the shops all seasonal and shuttered up, everywhere so different without the sunshine. We’d amuse ourselves as best we could during those pre-summer weeks when the weather was poor enough that we couldn’t visit the beach for fear of windborne sand.

We’d go anyway though and shield our eyes against the gritty gusts. Only to stumble through the dunes, cracking the wet-brown surface shell of sand to reveal the whiteness beneath. One afternoon, the sun breaking through for a warm few hours, we’d find a chrysalis hanging from the scrubby thorn-bushes that lined the shallow hollows of the dunes. We had found it just as it had begun to unravel; the first time I’d seen a cocoon and I’d be there to see it opened. How fine a process of life (thing is an ugly word, replace D:<) it was.

From that husk emerged first a tiny speckled head and with great effort, the legs, the abdomen and crumpled wings followed, slowly unfolding to drink in the sun, to dry and prepare for flight. As we watched though, the butterfly extended further, sliding gradually from the limp shell to reveal a stretched, conjoined abdomen: a second set of wings, unfolding in turn. The second set of legs clutched at the stem as the wings unfolded, two butterflies laid end-to-end, hanging as they dried.

We were curious of this being, beautiful as it was, in the way that only a child’s perception of a butterfly could be: splashes of red deepening in the warmth of the sun. For reasons I cannot at all remember, we had with us a jam-jar (all one word, in the way of the granny), and knowing this was too fine a thing to let escape. We filled the glass with plants and grasses, perhaps a little sand, and snagged it straight from the branch, using the lid to clip it free.

Once inside, the two flapped about in a confusion of compound eyes and glass, the black and red-orange of their wings a blur among the twigs and flora we’d scraped together. We grew afraid then, afraid that we had hurt them and that they might hurt themselves. We’d been convinced that their condition would prove fatal eventually, whether they simply couldn’t fly correctly, could never properly feed or would tear one another apart… it had seemed very unlikely they’d live.

So we did what any children would do. We walked down to the shore, the tide already going out, and flung the jar into the sea. Sadly, having only the throwing arms of kids, the jar failed to clear the sandbank about fifteen feet out, and we waded across to it, the jar heavy enough to have sunk to the bottom of the six-inch deep sea across the sandbar.

Under that thin pane of seawater was our glass, shining in the sun, the soft-green grass and bright red-on-black of frenetic floundering in that delicate bubble. One end was already an inch or two submerged in sand. We hadn’t the heart to cast the thing further into the sea, so we left it alone.

Maybe the tide drew them out along the bottom, our sweet Siamese submariners.


I'll try avoiding breaking up your piece, I usually hate that, but in some parts it does a feel odd like in the first paragraph where you always add this last part of detail. It's like you're trying to be precise of the subject, but reading it allowed feels so out of order (I underlined it for you).

I bolded words that could use changing or that I changed (such as "bored" and "the father" to "our father")

Second paragraph opening sentence is odd too. Like... your father's so busy (or busy enough) that you got to go to your grandparents? Can't we work that out better such as: Our father was so busy that sometimes we'd be dismissed back to the beach/our grandparents.

___________________

I agree with the above. The first two paragraphs are odd, they're implying more than we can actually safely assume. Here's my edited version: Back when we were children, around the ages of eight and nine, we'd stay at our grand-parents back in Wexford,'s beach. We’d dilly-dally extensively on the dunes in summer and grow so thoroughly loathsome of the beach after a week or so. By association, we grew sick of the sun and the sand we often moped and dig our feet in.

From time to time, our father would be so busy with school or work that we’d be punished a week during Easter at Wexford too. The place was dead in Spring, the shops all seasonal and shuttered up, everywhere was so different without the sunshine. We’d amuse ourselves the best we could during those pre-summer weeks when the weather was so poor that we couldn’t visit the beach for fear of wind-borne sand.


___________________

Everything looks good, lay off the drug-addicting commas (sometimes you don't need commas to show for a pause or to emphasize a certain part of reading the sentence).
In the third paragraph, the underlining indicates it is hard to read or lacks flow.

Everything else is roughly good. Might want to give it a second gander for that occasional sentence.

Overall I liked it. Short, descriptive and cute. The ending was what I preferred more than the beginning purely because it seemed a lot more comfortable and clear than the setting of the scene or area.

Nonetheless, I hope those butterflies came out fine, so young in their life.
https://twitter.com/#!/TorteDeLini (@TorteDeLini)
Sleight
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
2471 Posts
May 30 2011 01:25 GMT
#9
I actually want to disagree with Torte de Lini about saying "our father" instead of "the father" and such. I think there is solid evidence in literature to not use possessive pronouns. I like the feel. Kids don't think about the difference of their parents and others, so the current speech feels authentic.
One Love
Torte de Lini
Profile Blog Joined September 2010
Germany38463 Posts
May 30 2011 01:34 GMT
#10
On May 30 2011 10:25 Sleight wrote:
I actually want to disagree with Torte de Lini about saying "our father" instead of "the father" and such. I think there is solid evidence in literature to not use possessive pronouns. I like the feel. Kids don't think about the difference of their parents and others, so the current speech feels authentic.


Yeah, I get it was intended to put the father instead of our father. But I don't think it works here. It's his or the sibling's father, not a specific non-determined father.
https://twitter.com/#!/TorteDeLini (@TorteDeLini)
Sleight
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
2471 Posts
May 30 2011 03:18 GMT
#11
On May 30 2011 10:34 Torte de Lini wrote:
Show nested quote +
On May 30 2011 10:25 Sleight wrote:
I actually want to disagree with Torte de Lini about saying "our father" instead of "the father" and such. I think there is solid evidence in literature to not use possessive pronouns. I like the feel. Kids don't think about the difference of their parents and others, so the current speech feels authentic.


Yeah, I get it was intended to put the father instead of our father. But I don't think it works here. It's his or the sibling's father, not a specific non-determined father.


That's exactly what I am saying, it is "HIS" father, but if the child does not feel that "his" father belongs to him, he would not use such a pronoun. I feel that it adds a certain distance to the piece, underlying a deeper separation and emphasizing the driftlessness of the children as metaphorical drowning Siamese sailors. Their lack of guidance and the butterflies independent and isolated nature mirror one another and are a portent of struggles to come.

I think it SHOULD feel uncomfortable and not sit quite right. I think this piece is wonderful and could easily inspire later works.

I wonder if the OP has considered the trend in modern flash fiction as a medium.
One Love
SirJolt
Profile Blog Joined October 2009
the Dagon Knight4010 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-05-30 11:30:07
May 30 2011 11:28 GMT
#12
I just wanted to say thanks to everyone who took the time to read this and offer advice

On May 30 2011 09:51 Sleight wrote:
Tone: Read the word choice and attitude of your piece. It is an adult-conveyed childhood reflection on something beyond the grasp of the child. Words like "chrysalis," "conjoined," and "submariners" pollute the image, in my opinion. I think you have masterfully blended a child's memory with an appropriate reinterpretation, but just using "cocoon", "bound", and "sailors" or the like would keep the balance of maturity and childhood better. I lose all sense of inexperience with those word choices.


I think this is some of the best advice I've heard in a long time, just in general. I think choosing words more carefully, if only to be more appropriate to the setting, is something I could really stand to spend more time on.

It seems like such a small thing to keep in mind, especially considering the potential payoff

On May 30 2011 10:13 Torte de Lini wrote:
thing is an ugly word, replace D:<.


This is pretty much exactly why I wanted you to read this Torte, much as you might denigrate your own ability, it really seems like you have a love for words. I knew I'd appreciate your input, even if I disagreed with some of the things you said. That kind of input is always valuable and not always easy to find

I'll try to play nicer with commas in future too; I have a disappointingly 19th century approach to punctuation



Edit: I completely forgot:

On May 30 2011 09:32 whatthefat wrote:
This is beautiful, thank you for sharing it. I don't have any criticisms; I found the narrative very immersive, and loved its poignancy.


Thank you so much for brightening up my morning. This is one of the nicest things I've read in a long time
Moderator@SirJolt
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
00:00
Rongyi Cup S3 - Group D
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
NeuroSwarm 161
StarCraft: Brood War
Hyuk 738
ggaemo 241
actioN 200
PianO 169
Shuttle 62
Hm[arnc] 57
Shinee 39
yabsab 29
ZergMaN 26
Larva 25
[ Show more ]
Yoon 22
GoRush 19
910 15
Free 13
Noble 12
Nal_rA 12
soO 11
Bale 6
Dota 2
febbydoto53
League of Legends
JimRising 741
C9.Mang0410
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King145
Other Games
summit1g12285
WinterStarcraft519
Sick60
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1133
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 12 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Lourlo1209
Other Games
• Shiphtur357
Upcoming Events
RongYI Cup
3h 36m
herO vs ShoWTimE
Solar vs Classic
Wardi Open
6h 36m
Monday Night Weeklies
9h 36m
OSC
16h 36m
Replay Cast
1d 1h
RongYI Cup
1d 3h
Clem vs TriGGeR
Maru vs Creator
WardiTV Invitational
1d 6h
Replay Cast
2 days
RongYI Cup
2 days
WardiTV Invitational
2 days
[ Show More ]
The PondCast
3 days
HomeStory Cup
4 days
Korean StarCraft League
4 days
HomeStory Cup
5 days
Replay Cast
5 days
HomeStory Cup
6 days
Replay Cast
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

BSL 21 Non-Korean Championship
OSC Championship Season 13
Underdog Cup #3

Ongoing

CSL 2025 WINTER (S19)
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 1
Acropolis #4 - TS4
Rongyi Cup S3
BLAST Bounty Winter 2026
BLAST Bounty Winter Qual
eXTREMESLAND 2025
SL Budapest Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 8
BLAST Rivals Fall 2025

Upcoming

Escore Tournament S1: W6
Escore Tournament S1: W7
Acropolis #4
IPSL Spring 2026
uThermal 2v2 2026 Main Event
Bellum Gens Elite Stara Zagora 2026
HSC XXVIII
Nations Cup 2026
PGL Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 1
BLAST Open Spring 2026
ESL Pro League Season 23
ESL Pro League Season 23
PGL Cluj-Napoca 2026
IEM Kraków 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.