|
Hello TL
I come from a school that is considered pretty big. Infact, it is apparently the largest high school in Ontario, Canada. Everyone plays games here.... but not the type one might think.
Everyone plays console games...
Anyway when most people in Canada in general think gaming, they think consoles.
Now lets take the game Guitar Hero. Sure its an amazing game. The fact that you can press coloured buttons on a plastic guitar rapidly with flashing lights sounds very fun. Infact, Guitar Hero is a great party game. However is it an e-Sport?
In my opinion, not really. Well sure its competitive, because you still need atleast 200 APM on those Guitars to really score points, but does it require any analytics at all? Maybe finger placement, or proper stances or what not, but there is no strategy involved at all. Even conventional sports require pre-game thinking. For example, in football, there are plays (our build orders) that are outlined, and practiced like a build order in sc, weeks ahead of the game. This goes for soccer, hockey, you name it. But Guitar Hero? I think not.
However, most people in my area really like it, including me. Its fun. I've only played it twice, but there is a slight magic to that game, just like there was when I first killed a zergling with a marine in sc. The devs really amde sure that the game was fun, and the guitars were not gimmicky. However, I still think its not an e-sport.
But, a music teacher in my school has opened up a Guitar Hero competition, with an entrance fee of 2 bucks.
When I first heard this, I facepalmed hard. But then I realized something: this is e-sports in the making. Sure its only a slight competition, but its something the entire school population enjoys, much like how Many Koreans, Chinese, and Russians enjoy computer games. I mean Guitar Hero was chosen over starcraft in the WCG last year. That's how popular it is.
Now should we be angry? Yes, because they took out SC OVER THIS SHT. But, we really shouldnt be, because this is our "e-sportS", and maybe society will make this an e-sport, and we might have our very own "BoxeR" in Guitar Hero, who shows us strategy, if any, behind the game.
Now I am hoping, this is just a fad, and that computer games will become popular amongst the population, much like how the 360 is now.
- Sharp-eYe
 
|
Wtf? Guitar Hero over SC? MADNESS!!
|
north america is plagued by console "esports" because of the mlg.
but I guarantee the MLG picks up sc2
|
Cant forget Halo, very popular MLG game. I think, since I dont follow it.
|
On October 31 2009 16:11 andeh wrote:
north america is plagued by console "esports" because of the mlg.
but I guarantee the MLG picks up sc2
i know eh? My friend wore an MLG shirt once.. I raged a bit. Also my other friend told me his friend is a "pro-gamer" in Halo
|
On October 31 2009 16:14 Sharp-eYe wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2009 16:11 andeh wrote:
north america is plagued by console "esports" because of the mlg.
but I guarantee the MLG picks up sc2 i know eh? My friend wore an MLG shirt once.. I raged a bit. Also my other friend told me his friend is a "pro-gamer" in Halo
i uh
i don't understand why this is rage-worthy or why your friend's friend can't be a halo pro
|
i liked the read and agree share the same thoughts as you OP
especially the falmpalm @ GH
|
Katowice25012 Posts
You're making a mistake by calling it "esports"
|
scorn those halo and guitar hero playing noobs
not tr00 e-sports !
also, he's a music teacher dude. of course he is going to do guitar hero and not starcraft because guitar hero is associated with music (loosely... )
|
T.O.P.
Hong Kong4685 Posts
I don't share your go esports!!! attitude because I don't care about about any esport other than starcraft.
|
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it.
|
I've always wanted to try playing GH out of curiosity. Nice read.
|
On October 31 2009 17:41 HwangjaeTerran wrote:
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it.
it makes people that cant play a real guitar / too lazy to learn feel good about themselves
|
On October 31 2009 18:24 JohnColtrane wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2009 17:41 HwangjaeTerran wrote:
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it. it makes people that cant play a real guitar / too lazy to learn feel good about themselves
yes exactly, but i mean they still have fun even though real guitar is better. it's just like how some people still play starcraft because they're not good enough to play warcraft 3 which is better in every aspect and they have fun with it
|
well fun is the most important thing
|
On October 31 2009 20:11 pandabearguy wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2009 18:24 JohnColtrane wrote:On October 31 2009 17:41 HwangjaeTerran wrote:
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it. it makes people that cant play a real guitar / too lazy to learn feel good about themselves yes exactly, but i mean they still have fun even though real guitar is better. it's just like how some people still play starcraft because they're not good enough to play warcraft 3 which is better in every aspect and they have fun with it
...
|
On October 31 2009 20:11 pandabearguy wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2009 18:24 JohnColtrane wrote:On October 31 2009 17:41 HwangjaeTerran wrote:
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it. it makes people that cant play a real guitar / too lazy to learn feel good about themselves yes exactly, but i mean they still have fun even though real guitar is better. it's just like how some people still play starcraft because they're not good enough to play warcraft 3 which is better in every aspect and they have fun with it
5/5
|
organize and mobilize. do people KNOW starcraft = win?
|
On October 31 2009 20:11 pandabearguy wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2009 18:24 JohnColtrane wrote:On October 31 2009 17:41 HwangjaeTerran wrote:
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it. it makes people that cant play a real guitar / too lazy to learn feel good about themselves yes exactly, but i mean they still have fun even though real guitar is better. it's just like how some people still play starcraft because they're not good enough to play warcraft 3 which is better in every aspect and they have fun with it
lol :D
|
I would argue that while SC is easily the best game ever, Guitar Hero and Rock Band are more fun. That's probably why they have a wider audience - and they're easier to pick up.
|
music teacher will fucking bunr
|
United States2822 Posts
On October 31 2009 20:11 pandabearguy wrote:Show nested quote +On October 31 2009 18:24 JohnColtrane wrote:On October 31 2009 17:41 HwangjaeTerran wrote:
GH is retarded cmon!
You "play" with plastic "guitar" and it´s so cool........
I really don´t see the point, if you want to play music you could use Winamp or something like that and if you want to play an instrument, you play an instrument. You can also put some music playing from your player and play along, it´s just like GH but not compeletely retarded and doesn´t have flashy lights or points shown to you in tv-screen....
Yes I have tried it. it makes people that cant play a real guitar / too lazy to learn feel good about themselves yes exactly, but i mean they still have fun even though real guitar is better. it's just like how some people still play starcraft because they're not good enough to play warcraft 3 which is better in every aspect and they have fun with it
Yes, but finding a group of 4 people who like video games to make a new band on Rock Band is a hell of a lot easier than finding a person who plays guitar/bass/drums and a good singer to make an actual band.
And I'll ignore the part about War3 because I don't want to flame.
|
why are you guys bashing on guitar hero..calling it people who cant play feel good about themselves? wtf its a video game.... having that guitar makes it feel more real and fun to play and thats the whole point of buying guitar hero. some points in here are retarded
|
i'm guessing the war3 comment was a troll. i mean, it has to be, right?
|
It wasn't a troll, it was highlighting why people who bash guitar hero for being worse than playing an actual guitar have no fucking clue what they're talking about.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
