TL Mafia Ban List - Page 70

On April 27 2011 12:42 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:
Well, I think Qatol's point is that Coag was acting insane and abrasive BEFORE any of the shit went down with the pardon and protact. So saying "I was mad because of all the shit in the game" may be a valid defense for what happened after the events, it doesn't excuse his previous behavior.

Although in Coag's defense, I don't think he was directly warned until after the first incident (judging by Qatol's log post).

On April 27 2011 12:52 BrownBear wrote:
My opinion is at least some of his anger is justified. His team did kinda get screwed over, and Meapak did tell him to "be an ass" in thread. That said, nothing can excuse the level to which he took his anger and the level to which he shit all over the thread. "Be an ass" does not equal "make the game unplayable for everyone except you".

However, I tend to be a forgiving guy. So, I'm still going to support only a one game ban PROVIDED Coag agrees to the following things:

-I think he should apologize to his team and to anyone else who he offended in game. He can just write a general apology, but it should be meaningful, not a flippant "lol sorry".
-Also, he has said he's going to work to manage his behavior in the future. I believe him, but still I think if he ever gets modkilled for behavioral issues again, we should consider something like a 4-5 game ban.


On the subject of behavioral vs. inactivity modkills - it really depends on the situation. In this game, obviously, the behavior was more disruptive than the inactivity, but there was also a recent game where a DT checked a red, got back red, and then went inactive and didnt get the red lynched, in pretty much a LYLO situation. That really screwed town over worse than any spammer/flamer.

So unless we want to split up the punishments between inactivity and behavior, which seems like way too much work for Qatol, I vote we leave it as is.