|
On March 19 2012 07:19 sandroba wrote:
Hey. Let's lynch jackal just for kicks. Jonnywup I'm pretty sure is town. I kinda think VE is town too and I'm expecting him to carry me this game if his reads are half as good as they were in storm mafia. I'm confirmed town masoned with jcarl. Sup.
Vote: Jackal
Son, I am disappoint.
|
On March 19 2012 07:22 Nemesis wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2012 07:19 sandroba wrote:
Hey. Let's lynch jackal just for kicks. Jonnywup I'm pretty sure is town. I kinda think VE is town too and I'm expecting him to carry me this game if his reads are half as good as they were in storm mafia. I'm confirmed town masoned with jcarl. Sup.
Vote: Jackal Oooh you're finally here. jcarl, want to confirm that claim? And isn't that kind of contradictory? You say that Jonnywup is town and you expect VE to carry you through the game even though he thought jonnywup is scum?
Yes. What is the point of this question? I'm confirmed town.
|
On March 19 2012 07:22 Nemesis wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2012 07:19 sandroba wrote:
Hey. Let's lynch jackal just for kicks. Jonnywup I'm pretty sure is town. I kinda think VE is town too and I'm expecting him to carry me this game if his reads are half as good as they were in storm mafia. I'm confirmed town masoned with jcarl. Sup.
Vote: Jackal Oooh you're finally here. jcarl, want to confirm that claim? And isn't that kind of contradictory? You say that Jonnywup is town and you expect VE to carry you through the game even though he thought jonnywup is scum?
Is confirmed. We haven't spoken until just now (SOMEBODY WAS MIA)
|
I'm disappoint that you think jonny is mafia. Let's kill jackal gogogo
|
Sandroba stop goading Jackal plx XD
You're not confirmed anything, you're just much more likely town than idiot scum.
|
On March 19 2012 07:32 sandroba wrote:
I'm disappoint that you think jonny is mafia. Let's kill jackal gogogo
any particular reason or do you just feel like it?
|
##Vote: Probulous
As I said before, you are usually a lot more helpful as non-scum, and you are usually a bit spammy with your posts. But in here you've only posted once.
|
No it's pretty random. It's only fair that I should decide the lynch today since I'm confirmed town =P
|
that may be true but really we have no reason to think jackal is town or scum.
|
but if you feel strongly that jackal is scum i will vote with you
|
Sandroba why are you confirmed town again?
|
On March 19 2012 07:41 VisceraEyes wrote:
Sandroba why are you confirmed town again?
If one of them came up as scum in a dt check or whatever, it auto kills them both. I don't really see why they'd risk that if they're scum o.O
|
So Sandroba, JCarlson: why reveal blue right away? Doesn't that make you guys immediate scum targets?
|
On March 19 2012 01:24 Nemesis wrote:Probulous, I just took a quick look at your history, and you are usually a lot more helpful when you are not scum. You still haven't even made the list you promised before the game started.
Since we're on the subject, we might as well get more discussion. What does the rest of you think about VE's case on jonnywup? That is Jackal, Probulous, and whoever else who haven't given their opinion.
Firstly, if you want the list, make it yourself. That little back and forth with Snarfs was a joke because last game I played I made it and got called scum for the whole first day because of it. Not wasting our time with that again.
I was writing up why I think Johnny is town and that if VE continues his push to a lynch he is scum, but this sandroba claim changes things. If it is true then JCarl is confirmed town as well.
@Sandroba, Why the Jackal vote? He always lurks day 1.
Why the town read on VE?
Johnny is looking townie to me because if he was scum he would have been told to shut up by now. I mean he was posting stuff continuously when he was being pushed and has tried to defend himself. The initial case against him was he wasn't confident in his reads. Well no shit, it is his first game and it was early day 1, no reason to be confident. That doesn't make him scum. I am not voting for someone based off of that.
Unfortunately I am coming into this game a little late but what exactly is the case against Johnny? Is there anything else then his wishy-washy read and subsequent bad defense of himself?
|
Since they have both claimed to be masoned we either have two town or 2 scum, when one dies we find out which, since them doing this as scum would be possibly the worst possible move imaginable we should be treating them as confirmed for now.
The only scenario that would screw with us is 1 scum 1 town which would requre both players to be something close to insane.
Viscera if you wish to take the lead you need to cut the silly questions and scare tactics.
I think we should lynch Nemesis. The first person to call bullshit on a claim is usually scum.
/laya
|
On March 19 2012 07:52 Tobon wrote:
So Sandroba, JCarlson: why reveal blue right away? Doesn't that make you guys immediate scum targets?
Because it pretty much confirms them as town until one of them flips, or is checked red. That is hugely powerful day 1. Plus JCarl was somewhat of a possible lynch so it makes sense to head that off.
|
Okay, going back then: VE, why the unvote on Johnny? There was supposedly an explanation pending.
|
If scum shoots me or jcarl they auto confirm the other and since by claiming mason we are likely town already as it is pretty retarded for scum to do this, we make good targets for medics since scum wants to get rid of confirmed town. So scum has to either risk shooting us and get blocked by a medic or to leave us alive and get screwed by the worse odds of getting lynched. Also avoids a DT wasting a check on us or a vig shooting us by retardness. If anyone is miller they need to claim right now.
|
I think Nemesis would be a good day 1 lynch.
His posts have been quite uninspiring up until this point. Most of his posts are simply asking questions or pointing out information, such as who hasn't posted.
Hmmm, it seems that snarfs and sandroba hasn't posted yet. Hopefully they don't get modkilled as 18 hours have passed since the game has started.
This particularly doesn't seem like something a towny would say.
He also conveniently skips over comments directed towards himself (VE's made a couple, Sandroba has now as well).
His vote is against someone who had given a valid excuse for why he hasn't posted yet (it was his mom's birthday yesterday and he probably just got into work today).
I'm really not impressed with his filter overall aside from the defense of Johnny. I think he's the best candidate so far though.
#Vote Nemesis
|
On March 19 2012 07:33 xsksc wrote:Show nested quote +On March 19 2012 07:32 sandroba wrote:
I'm disappoint that you think jonny is mafia. Let's kill jackal gogogo any particular reason or do you just feel like it?
Are you still on the fence about Johnny? To me his reaction was pretty townie. He changed his read because he realised he had nothing to base it on. How is that scummy? Since then he has been on the backfoot all game long. VE just keeps nailing him with small errors that could come from both a town or scum.
So why do think Johnny is scum?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
