|
On December 29 2008 02:40 decembrie wrote:yeah, haha quote wikipedia.. lol  they must know alot about macro :D buildings - yes research - no units - yes intake - no expending - yes As you can see: - even making buildings has been taken out of macro somewhat, with terran getting reactors to make 2 in each... lol - MBS > units gg no re. - MBS > expending gg no re - automine > intake gg no re Its as simple as that. You have no fucking idea, stop talking.
|
Oh, look who is shouting now, trying to make your point like this won't work.
|
Possible Lore
SCV: Seismic Hammer Drone: Acidic Venom Probe: Psionic Shock
Strip Mining minerals are characterized by small green cracks. Animation is glowing. Wasteful Strip Mining minerals are characterized by large red cracks. Animation is throbing.
As workers shave minerals off in regular mode cracks recede and disappear. The value of the mineral is dependant upon the integrity of the crystal. Each race has developed a rapid mining technique however excess rapid mining damages the integrity of the crystal veins.
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
Stop trolling/being a douche decembrie
|
Wouldn't this just mean people can strip mine and rush every game and while it is slightly more all-in, if your opponent does not have these extra minerals they are as good as dead? You would be forced to strip mine early game to defend against possible tier 1 rushes with the extra minerals, unless you come up with some awesome wall in or something which you'd have to do every game if you opt out of strip mining.
The way I see it the additional minerals faster is much stronger than the efficiency decrease because with the excess minerals you can probably afford an expansion and still have the same army size as your opponent :/
Perhaps I am reading it wrong.
|
On December 29 2008 08:29 Lamentations wrote: Wouldn't this just mean people can strip mine and rush every game and while it is slightly more all-in, if your opponent does not have these extra minerals they are as good as dead? You would be forced to strip mine early game to defend against possible tier 1 rushes with the extra minerals, unless you come up with some awesome wall in or something which you'd have to do every game if you opt out of strip mining.
The way I see it the additional minerals faster is much stronger than the efficiency decrease because with the excess minerals you can probably afford an expansion and still have the same army size as your opponent :/
Perhaps I am reading it wrong.
If you are reading this wrong then it seems everyone is 
I also fail to see how more minerals early at the expense of less efficiency in the long run is going to hurt you and why would anyone choose not to get this advantage early on.
|
On December 29 2008 08:48 Manit0u wrote:Show nested quote +On December 29 2008 08:29 Lamentations wrote: Wouldn't this just mean people can strip mine and rush every game and while it is slightly more all-in, if your opponent does not have these extra minerals they are as good as dead? You would be forced to strip mine early game to defend against possible tier 1 rushes with the extra minerals, unless you come up with some awesome wall in or something which you'd have to do every game if you opt out of strip mining.
The way I see it the additional minerals faster is much stronger than the efficiency decrease because with the excess minerals you can probably afford an expansion and still have the same army size as your opponent :/
Perhaps I am reading it wrong. If you are reading this wrong then it seems everyone is  I also fail to see how more minerals early at the expense of less efficiency in the long run is going to hurt you and why would anyone choose not to get this advantage early on.
It would make sense if Resources were actually scarce. Overall Resource amounts would have to be reduced so that running out of them was a usuall occurence - it´s a matter of Map balancing. Strip miners can only be allowed a slight advantage or they would be mandatory. Maybe it would be researched to prevent it being used on the starting base.
|
at first i thought of it like the dumb upkeep shit at wc3, but after reading all that stuff i think its a good idea because there are so many posibilitys it creats
@unentschieden the best thing of this is because it is available in early game, sure it will be mandatory to get the alternating style to stay at 7/10 but it also could create really strong (but scoutable) rushes if you let it go until 7/15 because your game had no future to begin with. face it bw got boring because there are those ultimate builds which are pretty imune to any kind of earlygame agression
btw i consider myself as really sceptical towards changes from the bw style, but this could really add a lot deep into the game
|
Or some mineral patches could be set to permanent wasteful in map editor, there are countless possible tweaks.
|
Sounds to me like you're just gonna have to come back to your base and watch that you're not going into wasteful. Don't really see how it adds depth.
|
How exactly does one use it?
Generally, you’d want to stay in Strip Mining Mode for as long as possible, without going into Wasteful Strip Mining Mode. However, things are not as easy as they may seem - you need to consider a multitude of factors when deciding which mining mode to choose for particular resource node, such as:
- mineral line saturation - the amount of minerals remaining - your build order/opening/strategy etc. - your and your opponent’s economy - whether you’ll be able manage to avoid going into Wasteful Strip Mining Mode (you might be busy defending or harassing, etc.) - whether the expansion is safe (or maybe you’re trying to capitalize on a hidden expansion?)
Additionally, you’d have to decide how frequently you’d want to go back to your base (you could adjust the mining modes with every new worker produced or even as rarely as every five workers) and plan ahead you macro cycles, depending on what you focus on in your playstyle and the current state of the game.
“If thing’s are supposedly not as easy, then are there any instances where I’d want to mine in one mining mode for an extended period of time?”, you might ask.
Well, of course, there are. Here are two short lists of the most evident cases:
The reasons why you’d want to mine in Regular Mining Mode for longer:
1) Your mineral line is saturated and you're wasting too much resources (especially if minerals are running dry in that particular expansion) by mining is Strip Mining Mode.
2) You're gathering minerals faster than you can spend them because:
a) You're low on popcap because your opponent killed your Depots/Pylons/Overlords or you were sloppy building additional ones.
b) You're low on production structures because of enemy's destroying them or your timing mistake.
And another list, this time showing why mining in Strip Mining Mode for an extended period of time might be necessary despite eventually going into Wasteful Strip Mining Mode:
- you've been harassed and you need to recover in terms of worker count
- you've discovered that your opponent has been mining from a hidden expansion and you want to get even economically
- you're trying to capitalize on an economic/army advantage
- you're preparing a Warp-in drop
- you're trying to capitalize on a hidden expansion
- you're trying to maximize the income from an expansion you know you're going to lose
- you're cheesing with half your workers and the other half are constantly mining in mode 2
- you're trying to churn out as many reinforcements (mineral only units like Marines or Lings) to help your push or whatever
Clearly, there are numerous such examples. By mining constantly in Strip Mining Mode the player tries to seize the initiative, but he's not guaranteed that he does so – if he fails he’s behind… It’s all about taking calculated risks.
Possible fixes if strip mining becomes a necessity and/or is the best option late game:
- strip mining as an upgrade (if early game becomes abusive)
- all mineral patches in main (and possibly natural) permanently have wasteful strip mining status + adequate mineral count (if earlygame becomes abusive)
- the efficiency decrease depends on the player's popcap in some way
- balance between mining rate increase and efficiency decrease in both strip mining modes
- (more radical, if remote macro is still a problem) making mining mode switching an "AoE spell" at the main buildings (this way you have to go back to base to use it)
And last but not least, is strip mining (not wasteful, assuming Blizzard can balance that) being a necessity really that bad? It's not like managing that early game is actually hard.
|
I think making this an upgrade that costs a little bit of gas would be a better idea, as it prevents it being standard in every game and early game abuse, as well as making it a big factor in how a game pans out, e.g skipping strip-mining to get that tank out a little earlier etc.
|
On December 29 2008 11:44 Qeet wrote: at first i thought of it like the dumb upkeep shit at wc3, but after reading all that stuff i think its a good idea because there are so many posibilitys it creats
@unentschieden the best thing of this is because it is available in early game, sure it will be mandatory to get the alternating style to stay at 7/10 but it also could create really strong (but scoutable) rushes if you let it go until 7/15 because your game had no future to begin with. face it bw got boring because there are those ultimate builds which are pretty imune to any kind of earlygame agression
btw i consider myself as really sceptical towards changes from the bw style, but this could really add a lot deep into the game
And what would a "normalminer" do about an enemy that has a 5 to 7 advantage in terms of resources, even IF he scouts it (at that point that is a element of luck since starting positions are random). Currently rushes are fair since the agressor has inevitably less economy after a failed attack since he invested in units instead of peons.
"Superbuilds" in BW are there because competative players value consistency. They don´t want to gamble and avoid all-ins if it wouldn´t give them a significant advantage.
Tense gameplay still exists but these players simply aren´t at the top. Well sometimes you see top players doing some "fanservice" though.
|
Imo strip mining should be used only:
@ at the start when you want to get your first attack troops a bit sooner @ for safe expo at the start @ and mainly for timing attacks @ some other minor reason which I forgot... ;d
To accomplish this, strip mining shouldn't be profitable if turned on all the time. First step is to reduce the additional resources gathered by workers in this mode; secondly : efficiency in strip mining mode should be decreased a bit, and finally going to wasteful strip mining should punish very hard the player who forgot about his workers.
So, here is my proposal for stats for this mechanic: -as most of us know in normal mining mode workers mine 5 minerals without any wasted ones, 100% efficiency - strip mining mode: 6 minerals mined (so only 20% increase) and 10 taken from the mineral node ( that means 60% efficiency) - wasteful strip mining: 6 minerals mined and 20 taken from mineral node (only 30% efficiency), this way leaving your workers on strip mining all the time would be very painful for your economy
Player using strip mining mode would have about 1/5 more troops on the battlefield, but would be forced to take an expansion almost two times more often.
|
I think all the major concerns are caused by people taking the arbitrary numbers I used way too seriously. I gave those figures just so that things make more sense. Otherwise things might've been too ambiguous.
Obviously, all those stats would go through rigorous testing.
And adding to what Tritanis (thanks for productive feedback, by the way ^^) has said, one should notice that not only the decreased efficiency matters - 20 minerals per trip is FOUR times faster mining rate compared to regular mining!
This, coupled with mineral patches in main possibly being set to permanent wasteful status, renders any abusive rushes VERY risky.
These are all details, however, in my opinion. Things like that would get balanced on map by map basis.
|
Personally, I don't think I'd like to struggle with my workers/mineral patches instead of struggling against oponents army.
|
So you want SC2 to be a micro focused game like WC3, etc.?
|
The only way I could see this work is if the numbers were tweaked to say,
8/8 normal mining 10/12 strip mining (or any values X/Y where X>8 and Y>X) 7/15 wasteful strip mining (or any values Z/A where Z<8 and A>Y)
and then (maybe) with a mid-to-late game upgrade, 9/15 wasteful strip mining (or any values B/A where X>=B>8 and C>Y).
Even so, this feature might add enough clicks to compensate the addition of auto-mine, but it doesn't even touch the MBS problem.
|
Normal mining is supposed to be 5...
And it's not supposed to fix MBS.
After all, if you're going to adjust your mining modes every new worker or so produced, it's probably more than enough. SC2 is going to be different - more dynamic, etc. That's something to keep in mind.
|
On December 30 2008 00:56 Manit0u wrote: Personally, I don't think I'd like to struggle with my workers/mineral patches instead of struggling against oponents army.
It appears to be a misconception about the nature of Micro (struggling against the enemy via unit control) and Macro (struggling against the game via everything not involving Micro).
I would like to have "perfect" control over the economical parts of the game right away. The success in that category should be entirely dependant on my desicions, not my handspeed. That is obviously a radically different aproach from many many suggestion bought up usually (just think of the term "APM-Sink")
|
|
|
|
|
|