• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 22:40
CET 04:40
KST 12:40
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over6Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery Shield Battery Server New Patch SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube Practice Partners (Official)
Tourneys
[BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19)
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread The PlayStation 5 Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread The Big Programming Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 13648 users

[SCL Contest] The Mineral Mechanic - Page 7

Forum Index > SC2 General
Post a Reply
Prev 1 5 6 7 8 9 Next All
Manit0u
Profile Blog Joined August 2004
Poland17875 Posts
December 29 2008 22:49 GMT
#121
On December 30 2008 06:02 maybenexttime wrote:
I want you to answer that question: why should macro be solely dependent on your decision making abilities whereas micro can be dependent on speed/mechanics/whatever (besides decision making)?

edit:

What you're essentially arguing macro should not be is the actual premise of this thread and this whole contest in general, so I think this is not the right place for this type of discussion.


I never said I want macro to be depending solely on decision making. I just don't want to struggle too much while doing it (I don't intend to play competetively so I may be a bit biased here but I'm trying to look at it from all perspectives and choose some sort of golden spot), I really don't care if there will be automine or not (especially that in SC2 most likely your idle workers will show up as an icon on the screen and you'll be able to click on it to select them thus reducing the chances of forgetting to send newly built workers to mine at your expansions) but I will always be heavy against "unnatural" mechanics like the current gas mechanic or what you have proposed here.

I can live with flawed UI, I can't live with artificial handspeed/whatever demands forced upon me. This things just don't "feel" right and might actually be utterely boring/repetetive/irritating/insert another similar word here, and many people will be thrown back from the game by them.
Time is precious. Waste it wisely.
Unentschieden
Profile Joined August 2007
Germany1471 Posts
December 29 2008 23:41 GMT
#122
On December 30 2008 06:02 maybenexttime wrote:
I want you to answer that question: why should macro be solely dependent on your decision making abilities whereas micro can be dependent on speed/mechanics/whatever (besides decision making)?

edit:

What you're essentially arguing macro should not be is the actual premise of this thread and this whole contest in general, so I think this is not the right place for this type of discussion.


I already answered that question, that is what the whole Biathlon comparison was about.
It can´t be as extreme as you´re saying it would be (...solely...) it is after all in the end a single game.


It is absolutely a issue of this thread - YOU modified the original criteria(thouse that don´t remember, look at the opening post, especially the bold parts):

SCLegacy wrote:
* The ideal mechanic should be direct in its usage and provide beneficial gameplay.
* The ideal mechanic should have both advantages and disadvantages.
* The ideal mechanic should not have a drastically negative effect for any player, whether for you, your teammate or an opponent and his teammate.
* The ideal mechanic should not discourage micro.
* The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features.
* The ideal mechanic should be flexible in its ability to be balanced.
* The ideal mechanic should not be forced upon a specific map or upon a certain type of player.
* The ideal mechanic's effect should not be random - its results must have definite results.
* Preferably, the ideal mechanic will be dependent upon a player’s choices.


Especially this one:

* The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features.

The very idea your suggestion is build on is already flawed in my opinion.
Therefore I´m obviously biased. I´m asking the other readers to evaluate the mechanic on the ORIGINAL criteria, not the ones that were used to create this.
It is up to the other readers and Blizzard (it´s a competition remember?) to judge.

ShaperofDreams
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
Canada2492 Posts
December 30 2008 01:37 GMT
#123
I really like this idea, although the mixed (modes) workers at the minerals might be clumsy, im sure that it is refinable, and that it can be tweaked to fit gameplay, it would add much more importance to timing and scouting, as well as adding a physically challenging mechanic.
Bitches don't know about my overlord. FUCK OFF ALDARIS I HAVE ENOUGH PYLONS. My Balls are as smooth as Eggs.
Dreadwave
Profile Joined January 2008
Netherlands254 Posts
December 30 2008 02:22 GMT
#124
Unentschieden, SClegacy's criteria are based on Maybenexttime's own criteria as posted here at TL many times, as well as on the bnet forums (as Zergish). Archerofaiur adapted them (changed a word) and posted them on Blizzforums, he even links back to a thread on bnet forums where Maybenexttime posted them, here (as Zergish, scroll down far).

Maybenexttime's(original)
1) The mechanic must have direct strategical value.

2) The mechanic must not punish players for using automine.

3) The mechanic provides a viable attention/APM sink in macro department.

4) The mechanic creates a wide skill gradient and allows players of different playstyles to distinguish themselves.

5) The mechanic allows for UI features such as MBS or auto-mining to remain untouched and does not punish the players for using them.

6) The mechanic in dynamic in the sense that it depends on the player and his opponent's choices.

7) The mechanic gives plenty of room for necessary tweaks.

8) The mechanic gives the player different alternatives, each having their advantages and disadvantages.

9) The mechanic does not force a specific map design (unlike the current Blizzard gas mechanic).

10) The mechanic is not mindless nor repetitive.


Archerofaiur's adaptation
1) The mechanic must have direct strategical value.

2) The mechanic must not punish players for using micro.

3) The mechanic provides a viable attention/APM sink in macro department.

4) The mechanic creates a wide skill gradient and allows players of different playstyles to distinguish themselves.

5) The mechanic allows for UI features such as MBS or auto-mining to remain untouched.

6) The mechanic is dynamic in the sense that it depends on the player and his opponent's choices.

7) The mechanic gives plenty of room for necessary balancing.

8) The mechanic gives the player different alternatives, each having their advantages and disadvantages.

9) The mechanic does not force a specific map design.

10) The mechanic is not mindless nor repetitive.

I bolded the only difference between the two. Archerofaiur was also the first to propose a "macro contest" on multiple forums.

The way he reworded 2) means that you can not have a mechanic that allows(or forces) for a micro/macro trade-off because you are not allowed to "punish micro". Anything that forces your attention away from battles can be argued to "discourage/punish micro", even having to place a depot/pylon does that, nevermind things like expanding.
This means that anything that follows these criteria does not address the problem as perceived by the anti-automation side. It is also in direct contradiction with 3) ("The mechanic provides a viable attention/APM sink in macro department.").

You can easily trace back SClegacy's criteria to Maybenexttime's as altered by Archerofaiur. They also dropped 3 ("The mechanic provides a viable attention/APM sink in macro department.
") and 4 (" The mechanic creates a wide skill gradient and allows players of different playstyles to distinguish themselves.") for some reason.

The original(Maybenexttime's) criteria were intended to spawn mechanics that would please both sides, i.e. a compromise. In dropping the apm/timesink and wide skill gradient criterium and adding the "cannot discourage micro" clause SClegacy's criteria are mostly geared to pleasing the pro-automation side.
AttackZerg
Profile Blog Joined January 2003
United States7713 Posts
December 30 2008 09:02 GMT
#125
I don't give a fuck about the competetion. If blizzard reads alot of well thought and inteligent macro systems such as this, then maybe sc2 won't blow for real gamers.


maybenexttime
Profile Blog Joined November 2006
Poland5929 Posts
Last Edited: 2008-12-30 10:12:09
December 30 2008 10:00 GMT
#126
On December 30 2008 08:41 Unentschieden wrote:
I already answered that question, that is what the whole Biathlon comparison was about.
It can´t be as extreme as you´re saying it would be (...solely...) it is after all in the end a single game.


Then we can't really argue as our basic perception of what RTS is supposed to be is different.

We can only agree to disagree and try to find a compromise that more or less satisfies both sides, which is something you're not fond of... The "anti-MBS" crowd has already made a step in that direction.

It is absolutely a issue of this thread - YOU modified the original criteria(thouse that don´t remember, look at the opening post, especially the bold parts):

Show nested quote +
SCLegacy wrote:
* The ideal mechanic should be direct in its usage and provide beneficial gameplay.
* The ideal mechanic should have both advantages and disadvantages.
* The ideal mechanic should not have a drastically negative effect for any player, whether for you, your teammate or an opponent and his teammate.
* The ideal mechanic should not discourage micro.
* The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features.
* The ideal mechanic should be flexible in its ability to be balanced.
* The ideal mechanic should not be forced upon a specific map or upon a certain type of player.
* The ideal mechanic's effect should not be random - its results must have definite results.
* Preferably, the ideal mechanic will be dependent upon a player’s choices.


Especially this one:

* The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features.

The very idea your suggestion is build on is already flawed in my opinion.
Therefore I´m obviously biased. I´m asking the other readers to evaluate the mechanic on the ORIGINAL criteria, not the ones that were used to create this.
It is up to the other readers and Blizzard (it´s a competition remember?) to judge.



First of all, read carefully:

"The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features."

=

"The ideal new macro mechanic should allow for UI features such as MBS and/or auto-mining to remain unchanged and not punish the players for using them."


I changed it? How? Semantics??


OK, so we have that one cleared up.


The reason why I changed the criteria (mainly by adding this one: "The ideal new macro mechanic should provide a viable attention sink in the macro department in order to reward good multi-tasking and micro-to-macro decision making.") was to make this mechanic a COMPROMISE - something the list provided by SCLegacy did not ensure at all.

What SCLegacy makes sure of is simply that the new mechanic satisfies the casuals (or "pro-MBS" or whatever you want to call them), it does nothing to please the competitive players ("anti-MBS").

And if that's the case, then why implement any mechanic at all in the first place? Casuals/"pro-MBS" have never been dissatisfied with SC2 macro. It were always the competitive/"anti-MBS" players. So if your new mechanic is not supposed to address any concerns raised by compatitive players, why even introduce it?

This just doesn't make any sense (what SCLegacy did). You make a contest that's supposed to solve the concerns raised by the "anti-MBS" side (again, "pro-MBS" crowd never questioned SC2 macro) and then completely and deliberately ignore those very players?


edit:

So if one's already content with SC2 macro, why even bother coming up with different macro mechanics or provide feedback by SCLegacy's (flawed in my opinion) criteria?

edit2:

I think it's only fair to judge the Mineral Mechanic as a compromise.
decembrie
Profile Joined December 2008
93 Posts
Last Edited: 2008-12-30 12:59:04
December 30 2008 12:53 GMT
#127
SCLegacy moves in mysterious ways...

The only solution i can think of is to forget macro altogether and make micro so complicated it hurts.. lol

Add 2 types of attack:

- Normal attack using "A" key

- Micro attack using "another key" (maybe "P") kind of like microing with "patrol" is in BW; for example microing vultures with patrol is much more efficient than using normal attack because with patrol the "turn animation" is much much shorter.

So basically this type of attack would be added to most of the units in the game and would reduce their turning animation drastically.

+ 90% of the units get at least 1 cooldown spell (not energy based), possibly 2, one offensive and one defensive.

+ micro combos: 2 or 3 different units deal more damage together against a certain unit or building

+ You add spell combos: When using 2 or 3 spells at the same time you receive various damage(for attack) or shield(for defense) bonuses.

... And you keep on adding more stuff until having 300 apm becomes useful again.

Thats the only solution i see available to replace what MBS and automine will ruin.
nada.
maybenexttime
Profile Blog Joined November 2006
Poland5929 Posts
December 30 2008 14:31 GMT
#128
No, not at all.

At least I don't really care about APM that much. ;;
InRaged
Profile Joined February 2007
1047 Posts
December 30 2008 14:48 GMT
#129
decembrie, I think that facepalm from last page is even more appropriate now.
ParasitJonte
Profile Joined September 2004
Sweden1768 Posts
December 30 2008 15:25 GMT
#130
I like the idea as proposed in the opening post.

The third post by LonelyMargarita brings up the only concern I would have. Since you gain minerals faster it seems the optimal strategy would be to just always strip-mine and expand faster.

And perhaps that's not a problem.

But the ultimate mineral mechanic in my eyes would be something that is optional (like this), rewarding (like this), but not always optimal. Basically, it should be optimal in certain states - but not all the time. To think of such a mechanic would of course be immensly hard...

My personal suggestion would be to take your mineral mechanic and modify it so that strip-mining is only efficient below a certain food cap. So, early game it's >>> regular mining. Then perhaps you pass a certain food cap and it becomes just > regular mining. And then finally you pass another food cap and suddenly it's just wasteful (i.e the efficiency is brought down to an appropriate level).

That way, players who are behind have a chance to catch up if they strip-mine properly. Players relying on micro can afford to do so and have few units and 1-2 bases and win games through strip-mine.

Well, I don't know. This is just what I thought of right now. I still like the original idea - just needs some polishing.
Hello=)
closed
Profile Blog Joined July 2008
Vatican City State491 Posts
December 30 2008 16:00 GMT
#131
On December 30 2008 02:57 decembrie wrote:
Its precisely because macro-ing like Idra did is VERRY difficult and you need 250+ apm at least, (not mindless spamming like they do in W3) that we, the fans, the spectators, the casual gamers and pro's alike are able to appreciate the effort Idra put into the game, just how much he wanted to win and how many hours he practiced to reach this level.


I want Starcraft to be a nice game, where both speed strategy micro and macro are important.
You want to turn it into a stupid clickfest. I dont give a damn about Idra. I play the game, not watch it.

This is just what the PC gamer dude said while bashing starcraft - it can sometimes depend not on strategy, but on mindless clicking.

On December 30 2008 21:53 decembrie wrote:
SCLegacy moves in mysterious ways...

The only solution i can think of is to forget macro altogether and make micro so complicated it hurts.. lol

Add 2 types of attack:

- Normal attack using "A" key

- Micro attack using "another key" (maybe "P") kind of like microing with "patrol" is in BW; for example microing vultures with patrol is much more efficient than using normal attack because with patrol the "turn animation" is much much shorter.

So basically this type of attack would be added to most of the units in the game and would reduce their turning animation drastically.

+ 90% of the units get at least 1 cooldown spell (not energy based), possibly 2, one offensive and one defensive.

+ micro combos: 2 or 3 different units deal more damage together against a certain unit or building

+ You add spell combos: When using 2 or 3 spells at the same time you receive various damage(for attack) or shield(for defense) bonuses.

... And you keep on adding more stuff until having 300 apm becomes useful again.

Thats the only solution i see available to replace what MBS and automine will ruin.


Facepalm. So apparently APM should win the game?
The idea to give each unit an useless spell sounds like Warcraft3 which was a completely different game. The idea of units combining was good in Power Rangers...
According to what you wrote, Idra, with his "250+ apm", should win vs me, just because he has 250+ apm. In starcraft 1 you can still win without apm, just position your units right. There are 120apm B+ players. Of course there are no 100 apm progamers, but the game is made not only for them, but also for an average Joe. Of course it should be good at high level, but you want to make it good ONLY at high level. You seem like these people who never play the game, but only watch the VODs. And when you finally play you wonder why do you lose with your 300apm.

On December 31 2008 00:25 ParasitJonte wrote:
My personal suggestion would be to take your mineral mechanic and modify it so that strip-mining is only efficient below a certain food cap. So, early game it's >>> regular mining. Then perhaps you pass a certain food cap and it becomes just > regular mining. And then finally you pass another food cap and suddenly it's just wasteful (i.e the efficiency is brought down to an appropriate level).

That way, players who are behind have a chance to catch up if they strip-mine properly. Players relying on micro can afford to do so and have few units and 1-2 bases and win games through strip-mine.


This is actually a wrong way of thinking IMO. This idea punishes players who are better. Let's imaging that a player makes a hidden expo which allows him to get few more units. Suddenly BAH he gets into "high upkeep"* and gets only 3 minerals instead of 8 from each miner. This punishes the better player IMO.
I have never played Warcraft 3 competetively, but such a thing was implemented in that game. I tried to play it "starcraft style" and mass expand everywhere in order to get a lot of units. It did not work, the more I had the less I earned... I thought I should easily outmacro my opponents due to my multiple expos but it did not work at all... - I earned much less than I should (not to mention the fact that they were focusing on their heores..).

I will write it once again, why noone has added any ideas which "add to the gameplay" by giving some another thing to make. Both slow and fast players will have to divide their speed by doing it - with the obvious consequence that the faster players will do it faster (but not necessarily smarter). I proposed adding mineral storage points and pipelines. There are probably other possibilities.
Unentschieden
Profile Joined August 2007
Germany1471 Posts
December 30 2008 16:32 GMT
#132
On December 30 2008 19:00 maybenexttime wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 30 2008 08:41 Unentschieden wrote:
I already answered that question, that is what the whole Biathlon comparison was about.
It can´t be as extreme as you´re saying it would be (...solely...) it is after all in the end a single game.


Then we can't really argue as our basic perception of what RTS is supposed to be is different.

We can only agree to disagree and try to find a compromise that more or less satisfies both sides, which is something you're not fond of... The "anti-MBS" crowd has already made a step in that direction.

Show nested quote +
It is absolutely a issue of this thread - YOU modified the original criteria(thouse that don´t remember, look at the opening post, especially the bold parts):

SCLegacy wrote:
* The ideal mechanic should be direct in its usage and provide beneficial gameplay.
* The ideal mechanic should have both advantages and disadvantages.
* The ideal mechanic should not have a drastically negative effect for any player, whether for you, your teammate or an opponent and his teammate.
* The ideal mechanic should not discourage micro.
* The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features.
* The ideal mechanic should be flexible in its ability to be balanced.
* The ideal mechanic should not be forced upon a specific map or upon a certain type of player.
* The ideal mechanic's effect should not be random - its results must have definite results.
* Preferably, the ideal mechanic will be dependent upon a player’s choices.


Especially this one:

* The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features.

The very idea your suggestion is build on is already flawed in my opinion.
Therefore I´m obviously biased. I´m asking the other readers to evaluate the mechanic on the ORIGINAL criteria, not the ones that were used to create this.
It is up to the other readers and Blizzard (it´s a competition remember?) to judge.



First of all, read carefully:

"The ideal mechanic should not alter the MBS or auto-mining features."

=

"The ideal new macro mechanic should allow for UI features such as MBS and/or auto-mining to remain unchanged and not punish the players for using them."


I changed it? How? Semantics??


OK, so we have that one cleared up.


The reason why I changed the criteria (mainly by adding this one: "The ideal new macro mechanic should provide a viable attention sink in the macro department in order to reward good multi-tasking and micro-to-macro decision making.") was to make this mechanic a COMPROMISE - something the list provided by SCLegacy did not ensure at all.

What SCLegacy makes sure of is simply that the new mechanic satisfies the casuals (or "pro-MBS" or whatever you want to call them), it does nothing to please the competitive players ("anti-MBS").

And if that's the case, then why implement any mechanic at all in the first place? Casuals/"pro-MBS" have never been dissatisfied with SC2 macro. It were always the competitive/"anti-MBS" players. So if your new mechanic is not supposed to address any concerns raised by compatitive players, why even introduce it?

This just doesn't make any sense (what SCLegacy did). You make a contest that's supposed to solve the concerns raised by the "anti-MBS" side (again, "pro-MBS" crowd never questioned SC2 macro) and then completely and deliberately ignore those very players?


edit:

So if one's already content with SC2 macro, why even bother coming up with different macro mechanics or provide feedback by SCLegacy's (flawed in my opinion) criteria?

edit2:

I think it's only fair to judge the Mineral Mechanic as a compromise.


You are looking at the problem as a attempt to negotiate between 2 "factions" - casuals and pros. Therefore your aproach creates 2 gameplay aproaches - casuals would just use "normal" mode and don´t bother to switch and "pros" would hassel with manualy switching every peon, comming back to monitor mining status etc. - in effect even worse than how SC:BW did it since there the optimum "only" required you to send the peon to the minerals ONCE.

Therefore your idea isn´t a compromise but a Alternative. That is not the point of the contest. A Compromise would be a solution everyone would be happy with, you have 2 solutions.



So if one's already content with SC2 macro, why even bother coming up with different macro mechanics or provide feedback by SCLegacy's (flawed in my opinion) criteria?

On December 30 2008 19:00 maybenexttime wrote:
This just doesn't make any sense (what SCLegacy did). You make a contest that's supposed to solve the concerns raised by the "anti-MBS" side (again, "pro-MBS" crowd never questioned SC2 macro) and then completely and deliberately ignore those very players?

So if one's already content with SC2 macro, why even bother coming up with different macro mechanics or provide feedback by SCLegacy's (flawed in my opinion) criteria?


Stop seeing the world as black/white or Casual/Pro. The idea is to make the game BETTER not to trade elements to make certain groups happy.

Don´t even think about it as a "compromise". You need to look at it from a "Gamers" perspective, not specificately a "noob", "newb", "casual", "serious", "proffessional", whatever. A person that will stick (and improve) with the game as long as it is FUN.


The current Economy model in SC2 is to simplistic, Blizzard themselves said so and started experimenting with the Gas stuff.

What they want is ONE solution, not 2 that can coexist. Once you start talking "It will make Group 1 happy because... and Group 2 for another reason..., you messed up.

That is why you think SCLegacy contradicts themselves. Obviously it´s not a "Group Pro is unhappy, come up with something to appease them but don´t change anything for Group Casual" Contest as you seem to think it is if I read your argumentation right.
ParasitJonte
Profile Joined September 2004
Sweden1768 Posts
December 30 2008 17:27 GMT
#133
On December 31 2008 01:00 closed wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 31 2008 00:25 ParasitJonte wrote:
My personal suggestion would be to take your mineral mechanic and modify it so that strip-mining is only efficient below a certain food cap. So, early game it's >>> regular mining. Then perhaps you pass a certain food cap and it becomes just > regular mining. And then finally you pass another food cap and suddenly it's just wasteful (i.e the efficiency is brought down to an appropriate level).

That way, players who are behind have a chance to catch up if they strip-mine properly. Players relying on micro can afford to do so and have few units and 1-2 bases and win games through strip-mine.


This is actually a wrong way of thinking IMO. This idea punishes players who are better. Let's imaging that a player makes a hidden expo which allows him to get few more units. Suddenly BAH he gets into "high upkeep"* and gets only 3 minerals instead of 8 from each miner. This punishes the better player IMO.
I have never played Warcraft 3 competetively, but such a thing was implemented in that game. I tried to play it "starcraft style" and mass expand everywhere in order to get a lot of units. It did not work, the more I had the less I earned... I thought I should easily outmacro my opponents due to my multiple expos but it did not work at all... - I earned much less than I should (not to mention the fact that they were focusing on their heores..).


I agree that the whole "upkeep" element was really bad in wc3. And that it's generally bad to punish someone for being good. So I see your point entirely. But I don't think it would have such a dramatic effect. Of course it depends on balancing.
Hello=)
Liquid`Jinro
Profile Blog Joined September 2002
Sweden33723 Posts
Last Edited: 2008-12-30 21:22:50
December 30 2008 21:17 GMT
#134
Stop seeing the world as black/white or Casual/Pro. The idea is to make the game BETTER not to trade elements to make certain groups happy.

There's no such thing as an objective better, it's ALL about finding solutions that both sides can live with, regardless of what you want to call it.

And seriously wtf, group casual and group pro will ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS approach the game in different ways.

Group Pro decides to micro his 12 marines vs the 3 lurkers and beats them, Group Casual decides to attack move in a line and loses all marines killing nothing.
Moderatortell the guy that interplanatar interaction is pivotal to terrans variety of optionitudals in the pre-midgame preperatories as well as the protosstinal deterriggation of elite zergling strikes - Stimey n | Formerly FrozenArbiter
Archerofaiur
Profile Joined August 2008
United States4101 Posts
Last Edited: 2008-12-30 22:13:30
December 30 2008 22:12 GMT
#135
Is it possible that both of you right?


1) There will always be some differences in playstyles between pros and casuals.



2) Fun things are generally fun for both sides. The funner the mechanic the better it overlaps with both parties.
http://sclegacy.com/news/28-scl/250-starcraftlegacy-macro-theorycrafting-contest-winners
maybenexttime
Profile Blog Joined November 2006
Poland5929 Posts
December 30 2008 22:48 GMT
#136
On December 31 2008 00:25 ParasitJonte wrote:
I like the idea as proposed in the opening post.

The third post by LonelyMargarita brings up the only concern I would have. Since you gain minerals faster it seems the optimal strategy would be to just always strip-mine and expand faster.

And perhaps that's not a problem.

But the ultimate mineral mechanic in my eyes would be something that is optional (like this), rewarding (like this), but not always optimal. Basically, it should be optimal in certain states - but not all the time. To think of such a mechanic would of course be immensly hard...

My personal suggestion would be to take your mineral mechanic and modify it so that strip-mining is only efficient below a certain food cap. So, early game it's >>> regular mining. Then perhaps you pass a certain food cap and it becomes just > regular mining. And then finally you pass another food cap and suddenly it's just wasteful (i.e the efficiency is brought down to an appropriate level).

That way, players who are behind have a chance to catch up if they strip-mine properly. Players relying on micro can afford to do so and have few units and 1-2 bases and win games through strip-mine.

Well, I don't know. This is just what I thought of right now. I still like the original idea - just needs some polishing.


Yes, I suggested this as a possible fix on page 5. ;]


On December 31 2008 01:00 closed wrote:
This is just what the PC gamer dude said while bashing starcraft - it can sometimes depend not on strategy, but on mindless clicking.


Yeah, and he's also made a bunsh of flawed assumptions as to how StarCraft is played on high level (and how anything competitive, for that matter, works on high level), and added couple straw mans and examples of his ignorance to the mix.

Are you going to defend him? lol

This is actually a wrong way of thinking IMO. This idea punishes players who are better. Let's imaging that a player makes a hidden expo which allows him to get few more units. Suddenly BAH he gets into "high upkeep"* and gets only 3 minerals instead of 8 from each miner. This punishes the better player IMO.
I have never played Warcraft 3 competetively, but such a thing was implemented in that game. I tried to play it "starcraft style" and mass expand everywhere in order to get a lot of units. It did not work, the more I had the less I earned... I thought I should easily outmacro my opponents due to my multiple expos but it did not work at all... - I earned much less than I should (not to mention the fact that they were focusing on their heores..).

I will write it once again, why noone has added any ideas which "add to the gameplay" by giving some another thing to make. Both slow and fast players will have to divide their speed by doing it - with the obvious consequence that the faster players will do it faster (but not necessarily smarter). I proposed adding mineral storage points and pipelines. There are probably other possibilities.


How can you downplay a possible fix like that just because it vaguely resembles the upkeep from WC3?

If strip mining turns out to get out of control late game and making it popcap dependent solves that, then so be it.

I also have no idea what you're trying to say in your last paragraph. ;;
Unentschieden
Profile Joined August 2007
Germany1471 Posts
December 31 2008 00:29 GMT
#137
On December 31 2008 06:17 FrozenArbiter wrote:
Show nested quote +
Stop seeing the world as black/white or Casual/Pro. The idea is to make the game BETTER not to trade elements to make certain groups happy.

There's no such thing as an objective better, it's ALL about finding solutions that both sides can live with, regardless of what you want to call it.

And seriously wtf, group casual and group pro will ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS approach the game in different ways.

Group Pro decides to micro his 12 marines vs the 3 lurkers and beats them, Group Casual decides to attack move in a line and loses all marines killing nothing.



What you are describing may be true but it already highlights the issue with design approaches that support this.
Just imagine the balancing PoV - it needs to be fair all the time, just like it needs to be FUN all the time. Right now I´m refering to approaches based on skill.

You´d expect that Lurkers > Marines. But once Lurkers < Marines something might not work anymore. What if Lurkers are the only realistic counter to Marines for the Zerg player for some reason? That is unfair and not fun -for either side. (Unless you are a poor soul that equalises winning with fun)

That does NOT mean that units shouldn´t perform better under better players - that is obviously wanted. But you don´t want to mess up the balance, especially between "equal" Players (however you´d mesure that).

The mechanic proposed intentionally changes gameplay completely for someone who does use it and thouse who don´t.


Even if you can´t ensure that it should be the goal. If you need to make compromises it should work towards consistent, fair and fun Gameplay, ESPECIALLY facing different approaches to gameplay. Segmentation of Community groups, skill levels, whatever is a BAD thing.

I´m NOT criticising your approach for being a compromise - in fact I don´t think it actually IS a compromise since, again, it offers 2 completely different types of gameplay.

For a compromise you DON´T try to come up with 2 approaches, each for a group and try to bring them into the game but you get 1 approach that works for everyone. I´m not trying to ignore the groups but I´m looking for solutions that work with their SIMILARITIES, not their DIFFERENCES.


Archerofaiur
Profile Joined August 2008
United States4101 Posts
Last Edited: 2008-12-31 00:53:25
December 31 2008 00:52 GMT
#138
It amazes me that people can worry about balance before worrying whether a mechanic is fun. That seem odd to anyone else?
http://sclegacy.com/news/28-scl/250-starcraftlegacy-macro-theorycrafting-contest-winners
Liquid`Jinro
Profile Blog Joined September 2002
Sweden33723 Posts
Last Edited: 2008-12-31 01:08:38
December 31 2008 01:07 GMT
#139
The compromise, at least when I thought of it, was that we add something that benefits the mechanical side of macro (what "we" want) but with strategical considerations (what "they" want, or at least what they say they they want*).

*I think pretty much everyone prefers a mechanic with strategical aspects to it, regardless of side.

On December 31 2008 09:52 Archerofaiur wrote:
It amazes me that people can worry about balance before worrying whether a mechanic is fun. That seem odd to anyone else?

I think 4z5z6z7z8z9z0z and manual mining is fun.

I don't think my definition of fun and yours are the same.
Moderatortell the guy that interplanatar interaction is pivotal to terrans variety of optionitudals in the pre-midgame preperatories as well as the protosstinal deterriggation of elite zergling strikes - Stimey n | Formerly FrozenArbiter
Archerofaiur
Profile Joined August 2008
United States4101 Posts
December 31 2008 01:19 GMT
#140
On December 31 2008 10:07 FrozenArbiter wrote:


I don't think my definition of fun and yours are the same.


Why do you say that?
http://sclegacy.com/news/28-scl/250-starcraftlegacy-macro-theorycrafting-contest-winners
Prev 1 5 6 7 8 9 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
PSISTORM Gaming Misc
09:00
FSL s12 week3: POG vs ST
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RuFF_SC2 191
PiLiPiLi 12
StarCraft: Brood War
sOs 32
Icarus 6
League of Legends
JimRising 615
Counter-Strike
taco 421
Other Games
summit1g8474
gofns5632
PiGStarcraft267
Maynarde113
Models3
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1087
[ Show 11 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• davetesta17
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• RayReign 22
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Lourlo285
Upcoming Events
RSL Revival
7h 20m
AI Arena Tournament
13h 20m
BSL
16h 20m
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
1d 8h
OSC
1d 9h
IPSL
1d 13h
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
1d 16h
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
1d 19h
WardiTV Weekly
2 days
Kung Fu Cup
3 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
[ Show More ]
PiGosaur Cup
3 days
The PondCast
5 days
KCM Race Survival
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
RSL Offline Finals
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
CSL 2026 Winter (S23)
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.