|
On December 30 2008 01:02 maybenexttime wrote: So you want SC2 to be a micro focused game like WC3, etc.?
No, not to the same extent as WC3, just more micro than in BW and I'm still saying that automine/mbs won't destroy macro in any way, the current mechanics of SC2 are quite pleasing and don't need much tweaks imo (maybe except this stupid gas mechanic that should be thrown out). What should be worked on though are some graphics/animations because that's where the most issues lie now.
I want it to be better AoX 
|
Why don't you want the same to apply to micro? And if you actually do, then that'd basically mean turning RTS into a turn based game, which is contradictory (because otherwise mechanics/hand speed would always matter to some degree).
|
On December 30 2008 01:14 maybenexttime wrote: Normal mining is supposed to be 5...
Oh. Well, not much of an issue there, just change the numbers I suggested to suit.
On December 30 2008 01:14 maybenexttime wrote: And it's not supposed to fix MBS.
Meaning for this feature to be a good enough addition to make the game as challenging as SC1 is, you have to pair it with another feature that may or may not correspond with the addition of MBS.
On December 30 2008 01:14 maybenexttime wrote: After all, if you're going to adjust your mining modes every new worker or so produced, it's probably more than enough. Yes, it's definitely enough to compensate the addition of auto-mining, I don't disagree with that.
On December 30 2008 01:14 maybenexttime wrote: SC2 is going to be different - more dynamic, etc. That's something to keep in mind. Which is a statement impossible to verify without having played the game, we can only hope it's actually true and that this difference you speak of is enough to make this game as challenging as SC1 is.
|
BWI/BlizzCon attendees have all (well, most of them) agreed that MBS is not much of an issue compared to auto-mining, so we (FA/me) thought coping with auto-mining is the most important issue. ;]
|
On December 30 2008 01:11 randomsalad wrote: The only way I could see this work is if the numbers were tweaked to say,
8/8 normal mining 10/12 strip mining (or any values X/Y where X>8 and Y>X) 7/15 wasteful strip mining (or any values Z/A where Z<8 and A>Y)
and then (maybe) with a mid-to-late game upgrade, 9/15 wasteful strip mining (or any values B/A where X>=B>8 and C>Y).
Even so, this feature might add enough clicks to compensate the addition of auto-mine, but it doesn't even touch the MBS problem.
:D We think alike my friend If they make it complicated enough, it might replace 20% of the current macro, at best. Its probably not enough though.
Oh boy, SC2 is so gonna fail in Korea... : (
|
On December 30 2008 01:44 maybenexttime wrote: BWI/BlizzCon attendees have all (well, most of them) agreed that MBS is not much of an issue compared to auto-mining, so we (FA/me) thought coping with auto-mining is the most important issue. ;]
No offense but MBS is much more of an issue compared to auto-mine. MBS ruins macro whereas auto-mine ruins a much smaller part of the game (basically going back to each expo to set the new probe to mine, which is that much more rarely done in mid to lategame when you're moving probes from depleted expos to new ones).
Give me something that replaces (skill wise) building units from 9 factories or 14 gateways or 7~9 hatcheries spread across the map (!) without going 6+tttt 7+vvvvv
P.S. (Edit)
If your only intention is to deal with auto-mine then there is a much simpler and somewhat better solution:
Giving each worker that is manually set to work the ability to mine 1/3 faster than all the other workers for a given amount of times; say 15 or 20. This will reward good players and set them aside from casual newbs who don't have to bother with it since they're never gonna achieve anything anyway because they lack motivation and a competitive attitude not just in starcraft but in everything they do. Basically people who don't want to do something because it's too difficult and want everything made easy to them.
I feel blizzard will rather go for whichever solution is the simplest and doesn't confuse newbs. However this will not add the new mentioned aspects of gameplay. Sad isn't it.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
God, regardless of wether SC2 turns out good or not, I'm gonna miss SC style macro so much -_-;; Fuck.
|
On December 30 2008 02:36 FrozenArbiter wrote: God, regardless of wether SC2 turns out good or not, I'm gonna miss SC style macro so much -_-;; Fuck.
Watch this game:
Idra vs Neel GOM Classics Round of 256 (despite the fact that Idra's attacks fall appart a few times he is able to simply out-macro his opponent and win the match - he is pumping marines from 9 (or more) barracks, tanks from 3 factories and vessels from 2 starports while managing and defending 3 "un-natural" expos and also dealing with a swarm-plague crazy zerg attacking constantly !!!!
http://www.gomtv.net/videos/288
You simply cannot miss this game, the series was BO3 but the other 2 games were much shorter.
This one VOD will speak for itself. StarCraft-like macro will never be as fun with MBS and automine.
(There's tasteless commentary in english too)
For the newbs:
Its precisely because macro-ing like Idra did is VERRY difficult and you need 250+ apm at least, (not mindless spamming like they do in W3) that we, the fans, the spectators, the casual gamers and pro's alike are able to appreciate the effort Idra put into the game, just how much he wanted to win and how many hours he practiced to reach this level.
|
|
|
On December 30 2008 01:27 maybenexttime wrote: Why don't you want the same to apply to micro? And if you actually do, then that'd basically mean turning RTS into a turn based game, which is contradictory (because otherwise mechanics/hand speed would always matter to some degree).
Speed will matter anyway. When 2 invisible Ghosts meet the player who is faster with scan/snipe will have the advantage, simple as that.
Most of these suggestions aim to make Micro and Macro compete with each other - if you are good with your combat units your economy suffers since your peons are crying for attention and vice versa. Why would that be good? RTS is effectivly a Hybrid genre. The economic and Combat aspects are supposedly entirely different but merged. Think about it as the Biatlon of Computer Games.
Just as Biathlon is a mixture of Endurance and Precision, RTS is a mixture of "Strategy" and "Speed".
SC:BW isn´t actually that loopsided when compared to other RTS - especially WC3 where they purposly focused on "Speed" but on the other hand it´s not a "real" RTS anyway. The other side of the spectrum would be for example Sins of a Solar Empire a 4XRTS.
Basically think about it as if in chess instead of removing a "attacked" figure you´d just start a different game that determines who wins - obviously the agressor would have an advantage.
|
I want you to answer that question: why should macro be solely dependent on your decision making abilities whereas micro can be dependent on speed/mechanics/whatever (besides decision making)?
edit:
What you're essentially arguing macro should not be is the actual premise of this thread and this whole contest in general, so I think this is not the right place for this type of discussion.
|
On December 30 2008 06:02 maybenexttime wrote: I want you to answer that question: why should macro de solely dependent on your decision making abilities whereas micro can be dependent on speed/mechanics/whatever (besides decision making)?
edit:
What you're essentially arguing macro should not be is the actual premise of this thread and this whole contest in general, so I think this is not the right place for this type of discussion.
good question, i'd like to see mbs lovers answer this one.
|
I think most "mbs lovers" would agree that an effective macro solution should require speed AND decision making.
With the macro mechanics proposed so far (this one included) the problem most people have is that the mechanics fall too far on the speed side or too far on the decision making side. Many people feel that the mineral mechanic in this thread falls too far on the speed side.
|
On December 30 2008 06:33 decembrie wrote:Show nested quote +On December 30 2008 06:02 maybenexttime wrote: I want you to answer that question: why should macro de solely dependent on your decision making abilities whereas micro can be dependent on speed/mechanics/whatever (besides decision making)?
edit:
What you're essentially arguing macro should not be is the actual premise of this thread and this whole contest in general, so I think this is not the right place for this type of discussion. good question, i'd like to see mbs lovers answer this one.
it is not solely depends on your decision making, cause if you want to make 30 zealots you have to press z 30 times.
|
A good way to address the speed(multi-tasking) vs desision making problem is to look at what works for micro.
Psi Storm Example
Speed: 1) selecting templar and activating ability 2) positioning and casting effect
Desision making: 1) Maximizing enemy units affected by spell. This requires calculations of the area and duration of spell as well as present enemy location and possible future locations. 2) Managment of templar energy levels. When is the templar going to have enough to cast psi storm? Do I spend energy on psi storm or halucination? Maybe I should just make archons instead?
|
|
|
On December 30 2008 07:02 Archerofaiur wrote: I think most "mbs lovers" would agree that an effective macro solution should require speed AND decision making.
With the macro mechanics proposed so far (this one included) the problem most people have is that the mechanics fall too far on the speed side or too far on the decision making side. Many people feel that the mineral mechanic in this thread falls too far on the speed side.
Well, I and may others disagree that it falls too far on the speed side. I think that as far as Blizzard manages to balance all the figures neatly it's going to be pretty much even as far as speed vs. thinking goes.
It's impossible to tell without playtesting it extensively though.
|
On December 30 2008 07:22 maybenexttime wrote:
It's impossible to tell without playtesting it extensively though.
True. I am not saying your mechanic is severly flawed. I am merely wondering if it is possible to improve it. Now, if your mechanic is trully balanced between speed and decision-making then you have parts of the mechanic that contribute to speed and parts that contribute to decision-making. Can you tell us some of the design options that you COULD include IF we wanted to put even more emphasis on decision-making?
|
I don't care for MBS that much i can see why people wouldnt want it and i can see why people would want it personally I could live with it aslong as they make it if you have 12 Gateways selected to make 12 zeal you need to press z 12 times not once, and for the Automine thing they NEED to remove it screw no mechanics(cantspell) they should just make it like BW where no really point to mine where you have to manually selected unit to mine then i can see no more problems like this. Oh and I dont think that people will not buy starcraft 2 just cause theres no Automine in it seriously, if they remove automine then i KNOW that SC2 will be a awesome RTS and a good esport only balancing will see if it will fill the big shoes of BW. Now no more typing im gonna eat.
|
They might not care if there's automining, but they certainly will if some clueless jerk like e.g. that Dan guy gives the game a bad review just because he utterly sucks at the game. ;/
|
|
|
|
|
|