|
Sweden33723 Posts
On December 31 2008 10:19 Archerofaiur wrote:Show nested quote +On December 31 2008 10:07 FrozenArbiter wrote:
I don't think my definition of fun and yours are the same. Why do you say that? I was under the impression that you like MBS/automining and that you aren't a big fan of physical requirements in RTS games. If I'm wrong then okay, but there are still plenty of people who dislike things that I find fun (ie the physical side of SC).
I appreciate that I'm probably in the minority as far as their target market is concerned, but that doesn't make me think it's any less fun ; [
|
Im part of the wierd crowd that is a big fan of physical requirements and MBS. I believe we can make mechancis based on physical requirements AND make them fun at the same time.
My point isn't to get in a arguement with people over what I do or don't consider fun. My point is to stress that with theorycrafting it is much more important to focus on fun rather then worrying about balance.
|
how about after a worker has mined 5 times it only brings 6 minerals instead of 8 per round of mining. to prevent this youll need to command the worker to mine somewhere for the counter to reset.
this forces player to hotkey their workers at different expansions and to add new workers to that hotkeygroup and reapply all those workers to the minerals every now and then for maximum mining efficiency.
|
On December 31 2008 09:52 Archerofaiur wrote: It amazes me that people can worry about balance before worrying whether a mechanic is fun. That seem odd to anyone else?
Sometimes the balance is in the numbers, sometimes it is in the concept. Why do you think Medivacs don´t heal units they are currently carrying? It would give (mechanically skilled) Terrans a "Hard" advantage against nonairtargeting Units. Yu can´t fix that by reducing Marine damage by 1 or 2 points, for example.
|
On December 31 2008 21:41 Unentschieden wrote: Sometimes the balance is in the numbers, sometimes it is in the concept. Why do you think Medivacs don´t heal units they are currently carrying? It would give (mechanically skilled) Terrans a "Hard" advantage against nonairtargeting Units. Yu can´t fix that by reducing Marine damage by 1 or 2 points, for example.
But shouldn't you first figure out if dropships with healing is a fun thing to put in the game?
Fun first. Always.
|
On January 01 2009 07:28 Archerofaiur wrote:Show nested quote +On December 31 2008 21:41 Unentschieden wrote: Sometimes the balance is in the numbers, sometimes it is in the concept. Why do you think Medivacs don´t heal units they are currently carrying? It would give (mechanically skilled) Terrans a "Hard" advantage against nonairtargeting Units. Yu can´t fix that by reducing Marine damage by 1 or 2 points, for example. But shouldn't you first figure out if dropships with healing is a fun thing to put in the game? Fun first. Always.
Sniping medivacs with hydras sure seems fun.
|
Balance and fun are mutually exclusive? Seriously?....................
...anyways, compromising between two groups which are so diametrically opposed is impossible in the sense that there is little, if at all, common ground between the two playstyles. When push comes to shove, any "solution" to the macro problem will include, to some degree, a requirement of mechanical ability which is inconsistent with the casual crowd. It's like Muslims and Catholics in the Middle Ages. There is no compromise. There is no coexistence. One side must conquer the other.
If there is indeed a solution which magically accommodates both sides of the macro debate, it would have been suggested or discovered by now. That is not the case - in the end, regardless of whether casual players are punished or pros benefited, the net result is that because of mechanical incompetence, casual players WILL be disadvantaged, ceteris paribus.
Anyone really want a "compromise"? Here's how you do it: sucker the masses into believing as firmly as possible that the "pro" approach is "optional" when in fact it is not. Otherwise, if you think dexterity should be de-emphasized, you should be rejecting EVERY COMPROMISE - because, frankly, they're NOT. The other option is to accept a compromise that ultimately rewards BW-style play... which is hypocritical, isn't it?
|
On January 01 2009 09:56 bottomtier wrote: ...anyways, compromising between two groups which are so diametrically opposed is impossible in the sense that there is little, if at all, common ground between the two playstyles.
Warp-In
|
Let me begin by saying I like the spirit of the mechanic, but it needs some serious detail work. There are three major issues I see with the mechanic in its current state.
1. Strip mining offers too much of a short-term reward.
I agree with LM and Plexa - strip mining offers so much of a short-term reward that it outweighs the long-term disadvantage of wasting minerals, especially at high-level play where players can parlay those extra resources to take expansions faster. This makes constant strip mining a dominant strategy, apart from the situations explained in the OP.
The first situation where strip mining isn't a dominant strategy is when your minerals are saturated, at which point the dominant strategy becomes to cycle your workers en masse from regular mining to strip mining and back as Plexa pointed out. The second is when you can't produce anything with your minerals, whether through destruction of production or supply buildings, which is a pretty infrequent situation compared to the other situations listed in the OP.
One solution to this issue is for wasteful strip mining to actually give the player less minerals per trip than normal mining, say 3 or 4. Making the disadvantage short-term encourages players to cycle between regular mining and strip mining. This cycle would still be a dominant strategy, but it would effectively replace manual mining as an APM sink without feeling "forced" like manual mining and the gas mechanic.
Another solution is for mineral patches in the wasteful state to actually shut down for the cooldown period, giving no minerals. Workers would automatically redirect themselves to working patches, and then back when the patch refreshed. This would give enough of a disadvantage to make using the mechanic a strategic choice, but the mechanic loses much of its APM sink potential.
2. Tracking individual workers over-complicates the mechanic.
First, it's impossible for spectators, and even difficult for players, to distinguish which workers are in which mode. The only way to tell is to use the ALT key, and the arrows over the workers' heads are going to conflict with the health bars, making it hard to analyze the situation with a quick glance. In addition, there's no way to track which workers are mining which patches, so it's practically impossible to stop strip mining a single patch without switching all one's workers back to normal mining mode past early game.
Secondly, due to these UI issues and the fact that it's rather inefficient to individually change each worker's mining mode past the early game, in most cases the player is going to select all their workers at once and change their mining mode en masse. Therefore, it's rather pointless to individually track each worker's mining mode.
One solution would be to make the mechanic an ability of the main building (CC/Hatchery/Nexus), or make it an AOE spell, so that the player can easily change the mining mode of all the workers at a base. The workers would also need a graphical change to show players and spectators their current mode.
Another solution is to remove workers from the equation entirely, and base the mechanic on the mineral patches. The player uses a worker to build a low-cost strip mine building on a mineral patch, and all workers mining from that patch get the strip mining benefit. When the patch goes into wasteful mode, it dims and the disadvantage persists until the player destroys it (or possibly dismantles it with a worker). Then the patch goes into cooldown, and when it refreshes the player can build another strip mine on it. This solution corrects the UI issues and makes it simpler for spectators to see how players are using the mechanic. However, with this version the player only has to go back if they need the new worker to go to one of the strip mining patches (auto-split wouldn't take strip mines into account), so it may reduce the APM sink potential of the mechanic.
3. Mechanics can't be APM sinks and offer deep strategic choice simultaneously.
This is a more fundamental issue with the mechanic, and mostly has to do with the self-imposed requirement that the mechanic must be a viable APM sink by itself. The problem with trying to be an APM sink and offer a strategic choice at the same time has to do with risk and reward. Making the mechanic a viable APM sink adds more risk to the mechanic, as the player has to spend more of the limited resource of time on the mechanic in order to effectively use it. Thus, for players to use the mechanic, the net reward must be proportionate to this increased level of risk. Unfortunately, the higher the net reward is, the less strategic choice is offered to the player.
Manual mining demonstrates this clearly: the net reward for going back and sending your workers to mine is huge (worker mining vs. doing nothing), and so it becomes a huge APM sink since the player always wants to go back and send workers to mine. However, as a result it can't offer much strategic choice, since the reward is too high to forsake.
This ties into the first issue: because the mineral mechanic is designed to make the player regularly return to their base to change the workers' mining mode, it has to give a large reward (more minerals per trip), with a relatively smaller disadvantage (the base runs out of minerals faster). But because the net reward is large, the mechanic encourages players to always strip mine, or at least constantly cycle between regular and strip mining, which makes using the mechanic more of a requirement for higher level play and less of a choice. There are still times when the player is encouraged to stay in regular mining for long periods of time, but they are few and far between in the course of a regular game.
To offer more strategic choice, the mineral mechanic needs a stricter, more short-term disadvantage so that players aren't encouraged to keep strip mining on or constantly cycle in between the two states. However, this stricter disadvantage cuts down on the net reward, and thus makes the mechanic less of an APM sink (since players will use it less often).
A solution to filling the APM gap while ensuring strategic choice is simply to have the mineral mechanic be one of a collection of different macro mechanics, each offering a different strategic choice. The combination of these different mechanics fills the APM gap, while ensuring the game never forces the player to spend precious time on strategically shallow actions.
This solution also fixes one of the long-term issues of BW - strategically shallow APM sinks like manual mining are valuable in that they encourage multi-tasking. However, since these APM sinks lack strategical depth, as a player becomes faster at dealing with these sinks, the need for multi-tasking skill decreases - it is much easier to decide when to go back and macro when it only takes the player 1.5 seconds to do so, than when it takes the player 5 seconds to do so. But if there are several mechanics filling the APM gap that all offer different strategic choices, multi-tasking skill is valuable no matter how fast the player is.
Edit: Fixed a grammatical issue.
|
I didn't want to include this in the previous post because it's off-topic, but for old times' sake:
On December 30 2008 06:02 maybenexttime wrote: I want you to answer that question: why should macro be solely dependent on your decision making abilities whereas micro can be dependent on speed/mechanics/whatever (besides decision making)?
Because out of macro decision-making, macro mechanics, micro decision-making, and micro mechanics, macro mechanics contains the most often used (if not the only) static skills.
By static, I mean that the player performs the same actions whether the opponent is there or not. For example, with manual mining you're going to go back to your base and order your worker to mine/build/scout/whatever regardless of whether you're playing against a high-level opponent, a low-level opponent, or just doing the 200 supply time attack by yourself. Same goes clicking on buildings to produce units; if you set your base up in the same way every time, you're always going to click on the same buildings in the same location regardless of your opponent.
Now, which hotkeys you press are going to change based on the composition of units you create based on your opponent's actions, so this is a dynamic macro mechanic. MBS removes the static part of unit production, clicking on buildings, while keeping the dynamic part, hotkeying which units to build.
In case you were wondering, most micro mechanics do qualify as dynamic because where you click on the screen to select units, where you place AOE spells, and so on depend on your opponent's decisions and actions. The only static BW micro mechanic I can think of offhand is cloning, since you're going to shift-click through units to keep from activating all of their abilities at the same time regardless of your opponent's actions. SC2 does away with this with smart-casting, automatically choosing a unit out of the group to cast the spell instead of having all the units waste their energy casting spells that don't stack.
In the old MBS discussions, one of the major design positions of pro-MBS players was to replace most of the static skills from BW with more dynamic skills. Your own mineral mechanic does this, replacing the static skill of manual mining with a skill that (hopefully) relies more on the other player's actions, making it more dynamic.
Edit: Didn't realize you had my answer as one of the OP criteria, so here's a TL:DR version - Most BW macro mechanics violate criteria 5: A macro mechanic should be dynamic in the sense that it depends on the player and his opponent's choices.
|
On January 05 2009 06:36 1esu wrote: Let me begin by saying I like the spirit of the mechanic, but it needs some serious detail work. There are three major issues I see with the mechanic in its current state.
1. Strip mining offers too much of a short-term reward.
I agree with LM and Plexa - strip mining offers so much of a short-term reward that it outweighs the long-term disadvantage of wasting minerals, especially at high-level play where players can parlay those extra resources to take expansions faster. This makes constant strip mining a dominant strategy, apart from the situations explained in the OP.
The first situation where strip mining isn't a dominant strategy is when your minerals are saturated, at which point the dominant strategy becomes to cycle your workers en masse from regular mining to strip mining and back as Plexa pointed out. The second is when you can't produce anything with your minerals, whether through destruction of production or supply buildings, which is a pretty infrequent situation compared to the other situations listed in the OP.
One solution to this issue is for wasteful strip mining to actually give the player less minerals per trip than normal mining, say 3 or 4. Making the disadvantage short-term encourages players to cycle between regular mining and strip mining. This cycle would still be a dominant strategy, but it would effectively replace manual mining as an APM sink without feeling "forced" like manual mining and the gas mechanic.
Another solution is for mineral patches in the wasteful state to actually shut down for the cooldown period, giving no minerals. Workers would automatically redirect themselves to working patches, and then back when the patch refreshed. This would give enough of a disadvantage to make using the mechanic a strategic choice, but the mechanic loses much of its APM sink potential.
2. Tracking individual workers over-complicates the mechanic.
First, it's impossible for spectators, and even difficult for players, to distinguish which workers are in which mode. The only way to tell is to use the ALT key, and the arrows over the workers' heads are going to conflict with the health bars, making it hard to analyze the situation with a quick glance. In addition, there's no way to track which workers are mining which patches, so it's practically impossible to stop strip mining a single patch without switching all one's workers back to normal mining mode past early game.
Secondly, due to these UI issues and the fact that it's rather inefficient to individually change each worker's mining mode past the early game, in most cases the player is going to select all their workers at once and change their mining mode en masse. Therefore, it's rather pointless to individually track each worker's mining mode.
One solution would be to make the mechanic an ability of the main building (CC/Hatchery/Nexus), or make it an AOE spell, so that the player can easily change the mining mode of all the workers at a base. The workers would also need a graphical change to show players and spectators their current mode.
Another solution is to remove workers from the equation entirely, and base the mechanic on the mineral patches. The player uses a worker to build a low-cost strip mine building on a mineral patch, and all workers mining from that patch get the strip mining benefit. When the patch goes into wasteful mode, it dims and the disadvantage persists until the player destroys it (or possibly dismantles it with a worker). Then the patch goes into cooldown, and when it refreshes the player can build another strip mine on it. This solution corrects the UI issues and makes it simpler for spectators to see how players are using the mechanic. However, with this version the player only has to go back if they need the new worker to go to one of the strip mining patches (auto-split wouldn't take strip mines into account), so it may reduce the APM sink potential of the mechanic.
3. Mechanics can't be APM sinks and offer deep strategic choice simultaneously.
This is a more fundamental issue with the mechanic, and mostly has to do with the self-imposed requirement that the mechanic must be a viable APM sink by itself. The problem with trying to be an APM sink and offer a strategic choice at the same time has to do with risk and reward. Making the mechanic a viable APM sink adds more risk to the mechanic, as the player has to spend more of the limited resource of time on the mechanic in order to effectively use it. Thus, for players to use the mechanic, the net reward must be proportionate to this increased level of risk. Unfortunately, the higher the net reward is, the less strategic choice is offered to the player.
Manual mining demonstrates this clearly: the net reward for going back and sending your workers to mine is huge (worker mining vs. doing nothing), and so it becomes a huge APM sink since the player always wants to go back and send workers to mine. However, as a result it can't offer much strategic choice, since the reward is too high to forsake.
This ties into the first issue: because the mineral mechanic is designed to make the player regularly return to their base to change the workers' mining mode, it has to give a large reward (more minerals per trip), with a relatively smaller disadvantage (the base runs out of minerals faster). But because the net reward is large, the mechanic encourages players to always strip mine, or at least constantly cycle between regular and strip mining, which makes using the mechanic more of a requirement for higher level play and less of a choice. There are still times when the player is encouraged to stay in regular mining for long periods of time, but they are few and far between in the course of a regular game.
To offer more strategic choice, the mineral mechanic needs a stricter, more short-term disadvantage so that players aren't encouraged to keep strip mining on or constantly cycle in between the two states. However, this stricter disadvantage cuts down on the net reward, and thus makes the mechanic less of an APM sink (since players will use it less often).
A solution to filling the APM gap while ensuring strategic choice is simply to have the mineral mechanic be one of a collection of different macro mechanics, each offering a different strategic choice. The combination of these different mechanics fills the APM gap, while ensuring the game never forces the player to spend precious time on strategically shallow actions.
This solution also fixes one of the long-term of issues of BW - strategically shallow APM sinks like manual mining are valuable in that they encourage multi-tasking. However, since these APM sinks lack strategical depth, as a player becomes faster at dealing with these sinks, the need for multi-tasking skill decreases - it is much easier to decide when to go back and macro when it only takes the player 1.5 seconds to do so, than when it takes the player 5 seconds to do so. But if there are several mechanics filling the APM gap that all offer different strategic choices, multi-tasking skill is valuable no matter how fast the player is.
Incredible Post! You disect the mechanic, get directly to the problem(s) AND offer possible solutions. At the same time you provide insight into the nature of macro gameplay. I agree with just about everything you said. I also believe that if we take the time to address these issues we can turn this good macro mechanic into a great one!
It is increasingly obvious that one macro mechanic will not be enough to fill the void left by automation. For starters we did not have one macro mechanic in broodwar. A game with one micro mechanic (say dragoon micro) would be ok but it wouldn't be anywhere near BW. Likewise a game with one macro mechanic becomes shallow and one dimensional over time. It is the interaction of different micro systems that have allowed players to discover and enjoy BW micro for 10 years.For starcraft 2, macro must take a cue from micro and operate in the same dynamic and exciting way.
One final thing to add. If you tie different macro mechanics to a singular resource you can create a dicision making system. This resource can be min/gas/supply/universal cooldowns/creep/nexus energy etc. Do I spend my nexus energy on increasing mineral mining or zealot production? Maybe I would rather pour this resource into special abilities or convert it into some other resource.
|
This is an interesting idea, but personally I don't think it should be in Starcraft 2 because it's similar to the gas mechanic. I want more emphasis on military micro/macro than economic worker management.
|
I agreed totally with 1esu about the problems of the strip mining mineral mechanic. It is too complicated and time consuming. I think it's better for us to focus on the worker instead of the mineral, just enable worker overclock and to cool down
Let say in Normal Mode, worker mine 8 min each time
In Overclock Mode, worker mine 10 min each time A worker can Overclock and mine faster for 5 minutes When the 5 minutes is used up, then they get tired, automatically switch to Normal Mode
You can switch them to Cooldown Mode to let them recover In Cooldown Mode, worker only mine 5 min each time and mine a rate of 5 min for 5 minutes to recover After recovered, they automatically switch back to Normal Mode
You can manually switch worker to between Overclock Cooldown and Normal, so that you workers are not tired and you have optimal income for different periods. This simple toggle will let you have more mine 25% faster in one period, then stop and mine at normal rate. When you have abundant resource, you can choose to mine 37.5% slower so that you can mine 25% faster when you need to.
This toggle has many applications: Rush = overclock them then cooldown when micro your attack force, you resource will be likely pill up during anyway. Be cute and let your workers rest when Maynarding Let worker rest when you Gateway are warping and overclock them when you Gates are done Overclock when low on resource and Cooldown when high on resource.
This is the perfect solution for auto mine because it forces you overclock every single worker, hence = not auto mine yet still auto mine :D It pushes macro to another level, yet it is noob friendly
|
On January 05 2009 06:36 1esu wrote: Let me begin by saying I like the spirit of the mechanic, but it needs some serious detail work. There are three major issues I see with the mechanic in its current state.
1. Strip mining offers too much of a short-term reward.
I agree with LM and Plexa - strip mining offers so much of a short-term reward that it outweighs the long-term disadvantage of wasting minerals, especially at high-level play where players can parlay those extra resources to take expansions faster. This makes constant strip mining a dominant strategy, apart from the situations explained in the OP.
I think you need to note that SC2 has a high probability of being (much) more dynamic than BW, so situations like the ones described in the OP should occur (much) more frequently.
E.g. take a look at certain new gameplay dynamics, such as creep spreading or Warp-in. The former gives the Zerg player more incentive to scatter Overlord about the map, making them indirectly more vulnerable. The latter leads to proxy Pylons, which - assuming you don't want to waste resources on extra Pylons - means they're much more exposed (kind of like Overlords in BW).
[/quote]The first situation where strip mining isn't a dominant strategy is when your minerals are saturated, at which point the dominant strategy becomes to cycle your workers en masse from regular mining to strip mining and back as Plexa pointed out. The second is when you can't produce anything with your minerals, whether through destruction of production or supply buildings, which is a pretty infrequent situation compared to the other situations listed in the OP.
One solution to this issue is for wasteful strip mining to actually give the player less minerals per trip than normal mining, say 3 or 4. Making the disadvantage short-term encourages players to cycle between regular mining and strip mining. This cycle would still be a dominant strategy, but it would effectively replace manual mining as an APM sink without feeling "forced" like manual mining and the gas mechanic.[/quote]
(Bold added.)
I have already suggested that in some of my previous posts.
The sole reason why I decided to stick with 7/15 Wasteful Strip Mining was because I didn't want the voters (stupid politics...) to feel like the Mineral Mechanic is "just another repetitive task" with depth to it or that being slow punishes you too hard (i.e. your mining rate is regular but efficiency's decreased).
But I guess Wasteful being 5/10 is a reasonable solution. It's all up to balance.
However, that'd mean staying in Wasteful is not really an option. So maybe 6/12 or something?
Another solution is for mineral patches in the wasteful state to actually shut down for the cooldown period, giving no minerals. Workers would automatically redirect themselves to working patches, and then back when the patch refreshed. This would give enough of a disadvantage to make using the mechanic a strategic choice, but the mechanic loses much of its APM sink potential.
The problem here would be that the cooldown (necessarily a fixed amount of time, obviously) would work very differentlly with varying worker saturations. That'd make thinks way too chaotic, borering randomness.
That's why I thought making the cooldown based on mining trips is the only reasonable option.
2. Tracking individual workers over-complicates the mechanic.
First, it's impossible for spectators, and even difficult for players, to distinguish which workers are in which mode. The only way to tell is to use the ALT key, and the arrows over the workers' heads are going to conflict with the health bars, making it hard to analyze the situation with a quick glance. In addition, there's no way to track which workers are mining which patches, so it's practically impossible to stop strip mining a single patch without switching all one's workers back to normal mining mode past early game.
First of all, I completely forgot about the healthbars.
The ALT key was just an example - it can be any key. So avoiding the healthbar conflicting with mining mkde display is not a problem.
Secondly, the idea is to actually manage a mineral line as a whole. Dunno if that's good or bad, but it's definitely more straigh forward, intuitive.
If you wanted to be more meticulous in your worker management by e.g. having 1/3 of your workers in Strip and the remaning 2/3 in Regular, I think things would just average out over time (in higher saturation; in lower saturation workers wouldn't switch mineral patches unless you told them, so that's not an issue in that case).
Secondly, due to these UI issues and the fact that it's rather inefficient to individually change each worker's mining mode past the early game, in most cases the player is going to select all their workers at once and change their mining mode en masse. Therefore, it's rather pointless to individually track each worker's mining mode.
Pretty much, yes (although, "these UI issues" are, as explained above, not an issue at all).
But you'll have to manage each mineral line on individual basis.
It's not much different from BW approach by the way: later in the game you can't be arsed to manual-mine with each newly produced workers, neither to make sure that you only got one unit in each queue.
One solution would be to make the mechanic an ability of the main building (CC/Hatchery/Nexus), or make it an AOE spell, so that the player can easily change the mining mode of all the workers at a base. The workers would also need a graphical change to show players and spectators their current mode.
The AoE thing has been suggested by Archerofaiur for his own mechanic.
I think this might be a good solution if need be. I admitted that in some previous post (maybe it was another thread, not sure anymore).
As for graphical changes, if that's necessary - by all means! However, you could argue the same about units' health needing graphical change. 
I think a quick glance with ~ pressed (instead of ALT ^^) should be enough.
Another solution is to remove workers from the equation entirely, and base the mechanic on the mineral patches. The player uses a worker to build a low-cost strip mine building on a mineral patch, and all workers mining from that patch get the strip mining benefit. When the patch goes into wasteful mode, it dims and the disadvantage persists until the player destroys it (or possibly dismantles it with a worker). Then the patch goes into cooldown, and when it refreshes the player can build another strip mine on it.
I've been brainstorming about the mechanic being entirely mineral-based with FA, but it's not necessarily the best solution.
What you're suggesting here is too complicated imo. The new mechanic should be more streamlined, but that's just my personal opinion.
What's bad about it being based entirely on mineral patches is the fact that it doesn't give the freedom of having 1/3 of workers in a different mode, though.
3. Mechanics can't be APM sinks and offer deep strategic choice simultaneously.
This is a more fundamental issue with the mechanic, and mostly has to do with the self-imposed requirement that the mechanic must be a viable APM sink by itself. The problem with trying to be an APM sink and offer a strategic choice at the same time has to do with risk and reward.
Such requirements are a must if the new mechanic is supposed to solve the core issue, i.e. lack of frequent macro/base related task, leading to multi-tasking being deemphisized and/or heavily shifted towards micro.
If the new mechanic doesn't solve that - why introduce it in the first place? It certainly won't satisfy those who have issues with SC2 macro (aka the "anti-MBS" crowd), and is simply pointless if you only want to cater to the "pro-MBS" crowd aka people who haven't had issues with SC2 macro in the first place aka didn't think implementing any new macro mechanic is necessary.
Catch my drift?
I also think "attention sink" is more appropriate since "APM" could make people think it's just "clicking for the sake of clicking," which would give the new mechanic some bad rep. T__T Making the mechanic a viable APM sink adds more risk to the mechanic, as the player has to spend more of the limited resource of time on the mechanic in order to effectively use it. Thus, for players to use the mechanic, the net reward must be proportionate to this increased level of risk. Unfortunately, the higher the net reward is, the less strategic choice is offered to the player.
I think the examples mentioned in the OP show plenty of strategical potential, especially given SC2' (possibly) more dynamic gameplay.
It's obviously easy to design a new mechanic if there's little to no physical aspect to be involved, but why design it in the first place if people who are not content with SC2 macro will not be satisfied by it and those who are won't even think such a mechanic is needed?
Manual mining demonstrates this clearly: the net reward for going back and sending your workers to mine is huge (worker mining vs. doing nothing), and so it becomes a huge APM sink since the player always wants to go back and send workers to mine. However, as a result it can't offer much strategic choice, since the reward is too high to forsake.
I think the main reason it's not strategic is because manual-mining doesn't contain any decision making within itself - just in terms of time management.
On the other hand, the Mineral Mechanic offers plenty of room for various choices (including one mineral line being in Strip and the other constantly in Regular).
This ties into the first issue: because the mineral mechanic is designed to make the player regularly return to their base to change the workers' mining mode, it has to give a large reward (more minerals per trip), with a relatively smaller disadvantage (the base runs out of minerals faster). But because the net reward is large, the mechanic encourages players to always strip mine, or at least constantly cycle between regular and strip mining, which makes using the mechanic more of a requirement for higher level play and less of a choice. There are still times when the player is encouraged to stay in regular mining for long periods of time, but they are few and far between in the course of a regular game.
I think the key is simply making sure that Wasteful is still an option and that the player has to make decisions related to the mining modes frequently enough.
I don't think it's an inherent flaw of the mechanic, more like a balance problem that can be solved.
To offer more strategic choice, the mineral mechanic needs a stricter, more short-term disadvantage so that players aren't encouraged to keep strip mining on or constantly cycle in between the two states. However, this stricter disadvantage cuts down on the net reward, and thus makes the mechanic less of an APM sink (since players will use it less often).
A solution to filling the APM gap while ensuring strategic choice is simply to have the mineral mechanic be one of a collection of different macro mechanics, each offering a different strategic choice. The combination of these different mechanics fills the APM gap, while ensuring the game never forces the player to spend precious time on strategically shallow actions.
(Bold added.)
I think it's a good idea. They'd just have to make sure the game is not cluttered with various new mechanics.
Imo, they should just stick to Warp-in, Mutant Larvas and that sort of things. Not too clumsy, intereating and dynamic.
They could maybe figure something out for Terran. Maybe Depots. I don't think add-ons are enough (it's basically set up and leave it like that).
|
On January 06 2009 06:01 maybenexttime wrote:
The AoE thing has been suggested by Archerofaiur for his own mechanic.
I think this might be a good solution if need be. I admitted that in some previous post (maybe it was another thread, not sure anymore).
If it will help your mechanic then by all means use it. I don't have a monopoly on AoE theorycrafting mechanics :-P
I really think we can do some fun things with your mechanic but we need to jazz it up a little. First off it really needs some skin. Do you have anything planned as far as flavor? Something Zergish, terranish or Protossish? A mechanic is much more palpatable if it has a solid lore background.
Also I am glad to hear you agree that multiple macro systems operating in dynamic and intersecting ways is the best solution to the macro problem. It does not need to be one big apm sink. It can be several with desicion-making, multitasking, attention requirements and fun. All the while maintaining its elegance.
|
Well, I haven't really bothered with coming up with any racially different 'skins' - I think it's totally up to Blizzard, after all, Chris Sigaty knows best what his mom likes.
|
Can I just first say that I really like the overall idea and it is very well presented in the OP.
That said, I agree with the opinions that the (significant) short term reward is not made up for by the punishment of wasteful strip mining. I mean look at it like this:
The boost that you get from strip mining is "Improved rate of income". To compensate, you're sacrificing longevity of the expo. In other words, you say you are willing to give up some of the expo's lifespan in exchange for a burst of money.
However, the penalty for failing to go out of strip mining is ONLY that you lose even more longevity. This doesn't oppose the player's goals here, and surely if forced to choose between switching back to regular mining or controlling his newly made army, he will choose the army - as he will still have the same income with which to reinforce, in the short term.
So, basically saying that I support the suggestions that wasteful strip mining should be a penalty to income, not a (further) penalty to efficiency.
Also, can I check that my understanding of how to leave wasteful mining is correct:
1. Once you reach 15/15 on strip mining, you enter wasteful strip mining and your bar resets to 0/15, and continues increasing in wasteful mode
2. When you switch to regular mining, your wasteful bar goes down
3. When your wasteful bar reaches zero, you re-enter normal mode
?
If so I would like to suggest a refinement (may have already been suggested, apologies if so). To add a higher skill gradient, wouldn't it be a better idea to have the wasteful mode "health bar" start at 5/20? (obv numbers subject to balance etc)
That way, as soon as you let your probes mine into wasteful mining, you are forced to mine for at least 5 cycles on wasteful mining. This would further reward people with timing, who could consistently strip mine to 13 or 14/15, compared to people whose timing was off and sometimes missed the boat.
|
I don't really see how this gets used beyond the first 10 minutes of the game
And I also don't see how it's any different from methods already used to gain increased mineral yield like cutting worker production, taking them off gas, etc. This just seems like it's virtually the same thing but slap in the face obvious with glowing crystals and shit. You had to actually look at what your opponent was doing in SC to see if they are trying to gain some mineral advantage and determine from there why, instead of seeing their minerals magically glowing a different color.
|
I just can't imagine anyone not mining in strip the entire game to be honest. The penalty would have to be much greater than it is with your numbers imo, to the point where you burn so many minerals that you have to be expanding very frequently and the cost of setting up new bases becomes prohibitive or about equal to the benefit of extra minerals. 7 minerals per trip increases your mineral production by 40%. If you have two bases and hit strip mine it is almost like putting up your third instantly.
I think it would have to be more like: Regular: 5/5 Strip: 6/12 Wasteful: 6/24
I think a bigger penalty for wasteful like 5/15 or even 4/16 is a great idea.
Unrelated point: Another situation where you would not want to strip beyond just being low on supply/production buildings is if your strategy is limited by gas and not by minerals, sort of like a zerg player. They can certainly use the extra minerals but the gas is much more valuable.
|
Have we considered making it so that the workers (instead of the minerals) power down temperarly if strip mining to much?
|
|
|
|
|
|