|
On December 27 2008 08:29 Manit0u wrote:Show nested quote +On December 26 2008 22:33 decembrie wrote:On December 26 2008 22:20 Unentschieden wrote: Yeah just like Blizzard disapointed us with Starcraft when they introduced atrocies like A-attack. That´s after all the reason we are all still playing WC2 isn´t it? Your "reductio ad absurdum" won't work with me sir ! Blizzard has disappointed us with WarCraft 3 that rendered macro and APM USELESS because of having: - units with too much hit-points, making micro that much easier - MBS and low,high-upkeep to ruin any sort of Macro !! - a main resource (gold) which has a fixed income because of using only 5 workers; and because the main resource type is fixed things like "economy management" don't exist anymore ! - APM was ruined (made useless as a skill) because of TOO FEW THINGS TO DO ! and thus (as someone else already said in this topic) progamers, with almost equal skill, simply became equals and matches were decided based on trivialities. etc. THATS WHAT I CALL A DISAPPOINTMENT !And on top of everything, newbies created dota to ruin the game for good. P.S. Thats precisely why W3 IS and always WILL BE impossible to completely balance ! StarCraft, at its core, is probably not well balanced either but because there are so many things that depend on the player and not the race-balance, it simply doesn't matter. There are 2 things that annoy me with this post. 1. It has too much text in bold. 2. You apparently don't know much about WC3, do you? Let me argue with you a bit: Those same units have a lot of activated skills and you can't really let them die, can you? It's different micro, not easier. MBS has absolutely no meanigful use in WC3 and things you mentioned just change (reduce) the mechanical aspect of macro while putting more strain on the mental part (when to switch upkeeps, how many exps at current upkeep etc.). Show nested quote + - a main resource (gold) which has a fixed income because of using only 5 workers; and because the main resource type is fixed things like "economy management" don't exist anymore !
Fixed number of workers aren't really part of "economy management", eco management in WC3 is production/upkeep etc. Show nested quote + - APM was ruined (made useless as a skill) because of TOO FEW THINGS TO DO !
Then what do WC3 pros do with their 400apm? When they're playing they don't seem to look like people who have too few things to do. Sorry for the offtopic.
I'm only going to answer to your last remark... what do W3 players do with their 400 apm ? its easy, they spam away like they got something to do, but in actuality 140apm is more than enough for W3.
I cannot believe you insist that there's even the smallest bit of macro in w3... where everyone struggles not to go into low-upkeep and there are no freaking workers to worry about. You are insane.
|
I like this idea a lot, I think it has good potential. I'm guessing that you'd want to do strip mining as much as possible, though.k
|
Lots of effort into an awesome mechanic. I actually really like it.
I also like the concept of purposely wasteful mining an expansion that you fear the opponent will eventually take, killing off the resource before the enemy can obtain it. Though with the current numbers it's quote as viable. I've just always loves RTS's where you can destroy resources that you yourself cannot control.
|
On December 27 2008 10:55 Nintu wrote: Lots of effort into an awesome mechanic. I actually really like it.
I also like the concept of purposely wasteful mining an expansion that you fear the opponent will eventually take, killing off the resource before the enemy can obtain it. Though with the current numbers it's quote as viable. I've just always loves RTS's where you can destroy resources that you yourself cannot control.
I like it...
How about having a few units in the game, mid to late-game that can destroy minerals and gas geysers ?
- So there could be just 1 or 2 units for each race that would be able to do this; units produced in mid-game; plus this ability would be an upgrade of sorts.
- The mineral patches and the geysers would have alot of hitpoints (not fixed but changeable in map editor so that some maps would be more oriented towards this strategy while others, not so much) to make it difficult to mass-use this strategy, but not so difficult so that nobody would ever use it.
This would force players to scout more to make sure that the minerals closer to their base aren't being destroyed; it would create several weak-spots that one can exploite; the notion of map-control would take a whole other meaning; it might put an end to turtle-ing since it would force players to have an active role on the maps at all times etc...
And not only that but because its such a simple idea... Blizzard might go for it.
Obviously this idea isn't as good as Strip mining, but its as simple as it could possibly be, while adding a new aspect to the game; unfortunately it won't solve the MBS / Macro problem at hand. I still think Strip Mining should be pushed first.
P.S. Nintu, what RTS games do you know of where this is possible ?
|
On December 27 2008 19:39 decembrie wrote: what RTS games do you know of where this is possible ? CnC3:KW
|
On December 27 2008 09:53 decembrie wrote: I'm only going to answer to your last remark... what do W3 players do with their 400 apm ? its easy, they spam away like they got something to do, but in actuality 140apm is more than enough for W3.
I cannot believe you insist that there's even the smallest bit of macro in w3... where everyone struggles not to go into low-upkeep and there are no freaking workers to worry about. You are insane.
There's much more to macro than just producing units/workers and sending them to mine. And W3 is not about macro at all so why should there be put more emphasis on it?
|
On December 27 2008 22:35 Manit0u wrote:
There's much more to macro than just producing units/workers and sending them to mine.
hahha : )))
Name one thing !!! hahaha how old are you kid ? 14 ? 15 ?
|
On December 28 2008 00:20 decembrie wrote:Show nested quote +On December 27 2008 22:35 Manit0u wrote:
There's much more to macro than just producing units/workers and sending them to mine.
hahha : ))) Name one thing !!! hahaha how old are you kid ? 14 ? 15 ?
... for example: when to expand? how old are you
|
Sweden33723 Posts
On December 28 2008 00:20 decembrie wrote:Show nested quote +On December 27 2008 22:35 Manit0u wrote:
There's much more to macro than just producing units/workers and sending them to mine.
hahha : ))) Name one thing !!! hahaha how old are you kid ? 14 ? 15 ? Don't make posts like this, absolutely nothing good comes from it.
|
On December 28 2008 00:20 decembrie wrote:Show nested quote +On December 27 2008 22:35 Manit0u wrote:
There's much more to macro than just producing units/workers and sending them to mine.
I haven't played wc3 at all, but when I say it sucks it really does, also don't bother to provide any arguments - I'll just laugh and ignore them. Fixed it for you
This topic is becoming too much like flame fest because of one egocentric guy, we should talk more about how to improve this great ability...
|
@ Tritanis, you've only been making useless posts since you came to this thread.
@ FrozenArbiter, i haven't crossed any lines; i was simply under the impression that he is very young, i might have been wrong; he might just not be very good at StarCraft or WarCraft, or at least he doesn't seem to understand much.
@ freelande, really, when to expand... ? thats your best answer ? I don't understand why you would jump in and help Manit0u knowing he is wrong. You do don't you ? I mean come on... "when to expand" ? part of macro ? tell iloveoov that.
This just goes to show how crippled macro becomes with MSB, and automine; I'm affraid that the beauty of "14 gate toss" will be forever lost.
The infinite pleasure of having a screen or two full of factories or gateways and building just one unit in each so that your minerals are not queued pointlessly, knowing that your opponent cannot match your macro, will be lost forever. Doing it with such regularity that it becomes "a second battlefield" and still managing everything else needed to win the game.
I will say this again. The Korean Progaming scene (and public) has a built in mentality and they will never follow a game, be it StarCraft 2 or any other, if they know it is not challenging enough and not difficult to play.
I do not understand; i cannot understand why so many of you want a game that's easy to play. Did the fact that StarCraft 1 did not have MBS make it impossible for casual gamers, newbies or simply untalented players to play and enjoy the game ? I don't think so.
In fact it was precisely that which gave StarCraft such a huge crowd, so many spectators. Knowing that the game is extremely difficult made the fans appreciate that much more what the progamers were doing.
Unless something changes, StarCraft 2 will not catch on in Korea and it will have the exact same fate as WarCraft 3; going strong in western countries for a while, just like W3 did until some f-ing r-trds come along and create another "dota".
In the end i'm not even going to care because as long as i can watch StarCraft VODs from Korea everything will be fine for me; i don't have the time to play alot anyhow. Watching progamers play a "real game" is way better than playing an overly simplified game myself from which i get little satisfaction knowing that there are too few things to differentiate between skilled players and unskilled ones.
|
Sweden33723 Posts
@ FrozenArbiter, i haven't crossed any lines; i was simply under the impression that he is very young, i might have been wrong; he might just not be very good at StarCraft or WarCraft, or at least he doesn't seem to understand much. Your post was obviously antagonistic, or at least rude. I don't even know what his age (which I'm pretty sure is way more than 15) has to do with anything.
EDIT: And for gods sake, stop going off-topic. This thread is about the mechanic in the OP, stop talking about MBS and WC3.
|
On December 28 2008 04:50 FrozenArbiter wrote:Show nested quote +@ FrozenArbiter, i haven't crossed any lines; i was simply under the impression that he is very young, i might have been wrong; he might just not be very good at StarCraft or WarCraft, or at least he doesn't seem to understand much. Your post was obviously antagonistic, or at least rude. I don't even know what his age (which I'm pretty sure is way more than 15) has to do with anything. EDIT: And for gods sake, stop going off-topic. This thread is about the mechanic in the OP, stop talking about MBS and WC3.
I was trying to but they keep popping out of nowhere :D
Talking about MBS isn't that much offtopic; Strip Mining looks to replace just that.
|
motbob
United States12546 Posts
This mechanic is great! Newbies can just ignore it, but it opens up a lot of possibilities for pros to gain an advantage through clever strategies. Neat!
|
I think this is a very creative and useful idea and Blizzard should implement it. The argument about always using strip mining regardless of wasteful or not could be solved by tweaking the numbers a bit, i.e. making wasteful strip mining 4/15 or something horrid. Details need to be worked out but the idea is promising.
|
On December 28 2008 06:23 raiame wrote: I think this is a very creative and useful idea and Blizzard should implement it. The argument about always using strip mining regardless of wasteful or not could be solved by tweaking the numbers a bit, i.e. making wasteful strip mining 4/15 or something horrid. Details need to be worked out but the idea is promising.
That was precisely my argument a while back. only i said 8/8, 10/12, 10/25. 25 is indeed horrid for a 1500 mineral patch;
You idea to also lower minerals gathered in wasteful such as 4/15 would make sure once and for all that players wont use wasteful mining at all since going back to normal would be more beneficial. Thumbs up !  (The only downside to this is that a number of strategical advantajes will have been lost; for example gathering from a hidden expansion (using wasteful) you know you can't maintain for long)
So then, a compromise:
8/8 10/12 9/18 so wasteful stays a little better than normal (so you can use it on distant expansions) but also it would be to painful to use on your natural expansions.
Anyone have any more thoughts on the matter ?
|
(Didn't read comments!) So far this seems to be the best solution I've had the time to read/study, hope Blizzard understands the benefits of this one.
|
On December 28 2008 00:20 decembrie wrote:Show nested quote +On December 27 2008 22:35 Manit0u wrote:
There's much more to macro than just producing units/workers and sending them to mine.
hahha : ))) Name one thing !!! hahaha how old are you kid ? 14 ? 15 ?
I'm 26.
And to give you even more than one thing I will just copy/paste the wikipedia entry, ok?
macromanagement refers to the general economy aspect of the game. This includes constructing buildings, conducting research, and producing units, among other things involving the intake and expending of resources.
Discussion is over.
|
yeah, haha quote wikipedia.. lol they must know alot about macro :D
buildings - yes research - no units - yes intake - no expending - yes
As you can see: - even making buildings has been taken out of macro somewhat, with terran getting reactors to make 2 in each... lol - MBS > units gg no re. - MBS > expending gg no re - automine > intake gg no re
Its as simple as that.
|
Great Theorycrafting Maybe I like the approach taken to create this mechanic. Its a good mineral mechanic. However allow me play devils advocate about a couple things.
The first would be lore. How does strip mining work? How come all the races can do it? Why does it become wastful after a while. Also, be sure to come up with a really good reason why my minerals are turning christmas colors.
The secont concern I have is not exclusive to your mechanic but rather a game built on uni-mechanic macro. How fun will returning to the base be if increased mineral production is the only thing you can accomplish with most trips?
|
|
|
|
|
|