|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
Won't have the impact you think it will. Here's why.
At some arbitrary point in the game you stop producing workers; obviously because you have a sufficient number of them, or there are just too many other things to do to worry about silly workers. Also at some arbitrary point in the game there will be a point where adding +4 workers to mineral field makes a small different (as the minerals approach carrying capacity). So let's take a simplistic approach and divide it up into three stages; 1) Normal 2) Adding workers is negligible benefit 3) No more workers produced
Basically, a typically game oscillates between 1 and 2, with 1 being closer and closer to 2 and when that happens you get to 3 (and pretty much stay there). I hope that makes sense.
So we open up in the early game. You have a small number of probes; more importantly, a manageable number of probes. At this stage in the game you can perfectly control strip mining (just like you can with the gas mechanic right now; speaking from experience). As the probe count increases the additional benefit of each probe decreases, but you can still get optimal mining from them. We've gone from 1->2
Now we take an expansion, maynard our workers over, and we're kinda back to stage 1 again. It's slightly more difficult to get optimum mining; but its still possible. However after awhile we reach stage 2 again, but this time with 2 bases. With 15/20 workers/expo it's kinda impossible to get optimal mining, and the benefit of 4~ probes getting an extra 2 minerals is kinda pointless at this point. So you end up just selecting all your workers and making them strip mine in phase with each other, and then stop etc. This is manageable, and is very close to optimal mining capacity.
This is where the mechanic falls down. This simply becomes a repetitive cyclic task at this stage in the game where getting all probes 100% optimal yield very little benefit to having 90~95% doing it. You really only need to set all probes to say, 0, and then every so many seconds change their mode.
Once we get 3-4 expos up we move into phase 3. In phase 3 we're not producing any more probes, and then this repetitive cyclic task is even easier and yields 100% efficiency. While this is still more than you would be doing in SC1; there are already plenty of this you need to be doing at this stage of the game anyway. Most importantly macroing. This mechanic doesn't negate any of the MBS effects at all at this point.
tl;dr version Mechanics usefulness/micro intensiveness decays over time and basically becomes a glorified gas mechanic
|
this is great work, hopefully blizz tests this...extensivly honestly how I understand it, it is the best fan solution thought up so far
|
This is honestly the smartest and most well thought out solution that I would whole heatedly embrace. I wouldn't mind if it applied to gas as well to be honest, because it adds more macro to the game and numbers could always be balanced. Perhaps since gas is the largest factor in the game, the return would be less (6/10 or something) or the deprivation of future resources more intense like (7/20) ect. That would make it a much more strategic and important decision.
EDIT: I think plexa has a point, so to negate the decay of this mechanic I had an idea, what if instead of just not returning an amount of resources like 7/10, they return 7/7 but make the minerals themselves decay. This means that if you ignore the amount the probes are taking out, the mineral patch would have 1499, 1498, or whatever left in it, and the rate would increase the longer you left your probes on. This adds more strategical choice to it, instead of just being a repetitive switch. Its essentially the same concept but it has no exact time that it would switch to being unprofitable (wasteful). The choice is totally up to the user, and is very game dependent.
EDIT 2: lol, That decay thing was just the first thing to pop into my head. I guess a simpler way would be to keep it the same, but have them slowly increase their inefficiency. Say, start at 7/7, then 7/8, 7/9 ect.
|
I stated my issues with this before, so I should be no suprise that I´m not entirely fond of this proposal.
Basically "Regular" mode is "noobmode", existant to work like everyone WANTS it to work.
But then there is "Pro-mode" which simulates the frustrations of SC:BW mechanics for increased efficiency.
As I see it now I´d play "pure-noob" as long as possible since gameplay involving "have to look at base" are not enjoyable for me. I´d be gratefull that, as Plexa said, the mechanic isn´t even all that good which would mean that I would still be able to be competative for a while even if I ignore this hassle.
Learning to work with this mechanic is actually something I´d try to avoid. And I´m really suprised that you can call this KISS, if it were you wouldn´t have to resort to status relations to explain part of your idea - Hell despite all it´s faults the ORIGINAL manual mining mechanic was easy to understand:
Your Peons will mine as they are suposed to BUT you have to personally tell them.
The new mechanic currently in is even easier:
Your Peons will mine as they are suposed to.
Your idea would be by far the most complex mechanic in the game - the next "worst" would be warp-in.
|
I dont really seem the complexity in it.
You tell your workers to work faster however its less efficient(therefore you are gaining resources faster but resources are being wasted).
You tell them to work normally and go back to 100% efficiency.
The mechanic is simply switching guys with the red marker off every now and again.
|
Great work on this guys.
But I don't really like it. Like it was stated before the benefits of strip-mining are only visible/useful early in the game.
And what if strip-mining was a global setting (as cc hotkey or whatever) and every time you turn it on countdown begins: during this time each and every mining probe brings 7 instead of 5 minerals EACH trip, after it runs out, ALL of your mineral patches go into cooldown (more like your workers refuse to mine for some time, easier to do codewise), just like gas. (counter would not reset if you turn it on/off, every time you use strip-mining it goes down and only resets when the cooldown hits you). Would be much easier with some possibilities (use it early on or leave it for later stage struggle).
But that would be too much like the current gas mechanic.
Personally I don't have anything about automine. I will only bitch about unit/terrain models/animations until I get to play the actual game for a week at least so I can tell which mechanic is fine and which is not.
|
United States3824 Posts
wait so can you choose to switch to regular mining right before you get wasteful mining? And doesn't this leave a lot of room for someone to rush the shit out of you? I mean, choosing not to strip mine at the beginning means that you are going to get ran the fuck over by a person who is strip mining, and there is no way to tell whether or not your opponent is strip mining probably until it is to late. Maybe strip mining as an upgrade that each race can have at their command center? (or hatch or nexus)
|
I can not believe how much I like this idea.
To be honest this is the first thing posted sc2 related that has ever sounded awesome to me.
I really hope blizzard is paying attention because this basicly INSURES that sc2 has the same depth of strategy that bw does, it insures that those devuldging hours upon hours of play And it isn't 100% important to master for casual games just like knowing the exact saturation of probes per patch to the casual bgh/lotem 2v2 player.
Thank you guys, I don't know if it means anything but I 100% endorse this idea!
|
is awesome32282 Posts
I really dislike this idea. Any base with many workers will become a glowing red arrow fest, even though it can be activated with alt key or whatever it seems like a very complex gas mechanic to me. I understand the complexity it adds in early game, recover situations and han bang attacks, but late game it just falls behind to number of production buildings, total amount of workers and attention in general.
Making the change worker by worker seems really artificial: If you want to get an edge to do a big attack (let's say PvT going bulldog vs a fast expo), you would want all your workers to do it, not just 2 or 3. So you just created another "MBS" for mining alone. People would want to be able to select all workers and re-establish the mineral patches. Or why not put the feature to the nexus/hatch/cc itself rather than workers alone? Reason, to keep mechanics up. It just seems unnatural to me.
I mean you could add a whole new mechanic to the game, fast mining vs normal mining.
You click on your nexus/cc/hatch and that expansion would run at the mining mode you choose. If you pick fast, workers travel faster and hence collect more minerals, but this way you run out of minerals faster. Normal mode you mine at the normal speed. This adds the same strategical factors without a repetitive mechanical task.
I really liked the picture presentation/chart to explain it though, and I appreciate the effort.
|
I hate to be "that guy" but please, Blizzard just keep auto mine off and keep macro the same. -_-. People will still buy your game and it's the most natural way to keep macro and micro both important in SC.
That being said, if Blizzard absolutely WONT do the smartest thing (keep it the same) this is a good alternative for early and mid game.
|
I'd rather not have this. No stupid Dawn of War style RTS additions.
|
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On December 26 2008 15:56 Vasoline73 wrote: I hate to be "that guy" but please, Blizzard just keep auto mine off and keep macro the same. -_-. People will still buy your game and it's the most natural way to keep macro and micro both important in SC.
That being said, if Blizzard absolutely WONT do the smartest thing (keep it the same) this is a good alternative for early and mid game. Yea seriously, the only fix that necessary is killing automine and this entire macro issue fades away into nothing;;
|
Hmmm it seems kind of gimmicky but it could work and its streets ahead of that shitty gas mechanic.
|
I had a similar idea, but it had modes like this: 1: 10/15 2: 8/10 3: 6/5
I think this is a lot better.
|
Opens up a lot of options early game. Like Plexa said though, its unclear how that will play out late game
|
On December 26 2008 09:38 Plexa wrote: Won't have the impact you think it will. Here's why.
At some arbitrary point in the game you stop producing workers; obviously because you have a sufficient number of them, or there are just too many other things to do to worry about silly workers. Also at some arbitrary point in the game there will be a point where adding +4 workers to mineral field makes a small different (as the minerals approach carrying capacity). So let's take a simplistic approach and divide it up into three stages; 1) Normal 2) Adding workers is negligible benefit 3) No more workers produced
Basically, a typically game oscillates between 1 and 2, with 1 being closer and closer to 2 and when that happens you get to 3 (and pretty much stay there). I hope that makes sense.
So we open up in the early game. You have a small number of probes; more importantly, a manageable number of probes. At this stage in the game you can perfectly control strip mining (just like you can with the gas mechanic right now; speaking from experience). As the probe count increases the additional benefit of each probe decreases, but you can still get optimal mining from them. We've gone from 1->2
Now we take an expansion, maynard our workers over, and we're kinda back to stage 1 again. It's slightly more difficult to get optimum mining; but its still possible. However after awhile we reach stage 2 again, but this time with 2 bases. With 15/20 workers/expo it's kinda impossible to get optimal mining, and the benefit of 4~ probes getting an extra 2 minerals is kinda pointless at this point. So you end up just selecting all your workers and making them strip mine in phase with each other, and then stop etc. This is manageable, and is very close to optimal mining capacity.
This is where the mechanic falls down. This simply becomes a repetitive cyclic task at this stage in the game where getting all probes 100% optimal yield very little benefit to having 90~95% doing it. You really only need to set all probes to say, 0, and then every so many seconds change their mode.
Once we get 3-4 expos up we move into phase 3. In phase 3 we're not producing any more probes, and then this repetitive cyclic task is even easier and yields 100% efficiency. While this is still more than you would be doing in SC1; there are already plenty of this you need to be doing at this stage of the game anyway. Most importantly macroing. This mechanic doesn't negate any of the MBS effects at all at this point.
tl;dr version Mechanics usefulness/micro intensiveness decays over time and basically becomes a glorified gas mechanic
I agree. However i think this idea is the best possible compromise between blizzard and the progaming world.
Since the numbers are subject to change, we shouldn't criticize balancing quite yet, however Plexa's reply is nothing but the truth at this point; Plexa you shouldn't be so discouraging (!); they put alot of work into this.
You have indeed raised a serious problem with their idea, however i'm sure there are ways to make it so that this doesn't become a simple, useless, repetitive task in Late-Game !!! Thats they way you should be thinking Plexa, help them don't discourage them.
I'm sure you've seen the recent battle report and just as the rest of us, you were not at all impressed with the feel of the game and the actual "NEED FOR SKILL".
Blizzard wants to make the game "newbie friendly" in order to sell as much as they possibly can (as if they didn't get enough money from WoW!!) while the progaming world needs a game thats competitive etc. (basically everything that starcraft is right now).
If retarded western (and not only) newbies didn't always go for the game with better graphics thats easier to play we wouldn't be having this problem; there wouldn't be a need for SC2 since SC1 would be played globally. And retarted noob games such as "dota" would not exist either; i only hope such a plague does not infect StarCraft2 although i'm sure that the same newbies who created dota in the first place will try and recreate it in the StarCraft universe (because and only because its got better graphics !!!!) F*cking twats !!!
If you ask me the best thing that could happen to progaming is if Samsung or OGN and MBC would simply buy all the rights for StarCraft 1 from Blizzard, repaired some on the unused units in the game (like Scouts or ghosts or queens), added another race and 2 more units to each race.
But thats not going to happen, at least not for a while; StarCraft2 needs to become the huge failure that its shaping-up to be and disappoint everyone in terms of competitive play.
StarCraft1 won't die in Korea, it will simply continue as a national sport after SC2's failure and after StarCraft1 will be bought by a Korean company and placed in the capable hands of people like Boxer, Reach, Yellow, Garimto, Kingdom, the_marine etc... and then turned into something beautiful and updated periodically. (Perhaps even improve the graphics a bit, but keeping it 2D !!!!)
Getting back to the topic at hand, i like this idea; i like it so much that i wish it were introduced into StarCraft1 while keeping everything else the way it is (i'm a little flexible on auto-mining).
Even so, i can't help but feel very sorry for you guys since i know Blizzard; i've known it for 10 years now. They say they're going to listen but they rarely do. They're trying to create the next StarCraft, but they're too "money-hungry" to listen to us and to the Korean Progaming Scene. Which is retarded, considering that out of ~ 50 million Koreans, ~ 10 million would buy the game if it was truly living up to the StarCraft name. I'm sorry for all the work you guys have put into this but i feel Blizzard will break all our hearts !
|
On December 26 2008 14:50 AttackZerg wrote: I can not believe how much I like this idea.
To be honest this is the first thing posted sc2 related that has ever sounded awesome to me.
I really hope blizzard is paying attention because this basicly INSURES that sc2 has the same depth of strategy that bw does, it insures that those devuldging hours upon hours of play And it isn't 100% important to master for casual games just like knowing the exact saturation of probes per patch to the casual bgh/lotem 2v2 player.
Thank you guys, I don't know if it means anything but I 100% endorse this idea!
Appart from what i just wrote, this is exactly how i feel too !
This is an awsome idea, don't get too caught up with the description the guys made in their article because everything is subject to change, but the overall idea is excellent (!) and taken to perfection (the idea) it will ensure and add another level of strategy, meta-game, depth, uniqueness etc. to the game !
|
Yeah just like Blizzard disapointed us with Starcraft when they introduced atrocies like A-attack. That´s after all the reason we are all still playing WC2 isn´t it?
|
I've read the entire article... I've also read 90% of the posts in this thread.
1. As it stands right now, it has some problems; mainly that as someone suggested, players would try and use strip-mining and even wasteful all the time in order to "get an edge"; this is 100% true and you (or we) need to find a way around this; As it stands now, wasteful gathering might not be "wasteful enough" to force players to switch back to regular, but decreasing the percentage might help; However i think that a patch losing 14 minerals at once might be sufficient; if not just raise it to 20 and you'll see that patch disappear in no-time.
2. Blizzard wont like it if its too complicated to understand ! You need very simple new laws producing extremely complicated results (which would then be "hard to master"); 3. This should work for gas aswell.
4. The basic idea is amazing; keep thinking about it and remember, simple laws producing very complicated outcomes.
|
On December 26 2008 22:20 Unentschieden wrote: Yeah just like Blizzard disapointed us with Starcraft when they introduced atrocies like A-attack. That´s after all the reason we are all still playing WC2 isn´t it?
Your "reductio ad absurdum" won't work with me sir !
Blizzard has disappointed us with WarCraft 3 that rendered macro and APM USELESS because of having:
- units with too much hit-points, making micro that much easier - MBS and low,high-upkeep to ruin any sort of Macro !! - a main resource (gold) which has a fixed income because of using only 5 workers; and because the main resource type is fixed things like "economy management" don't exist anymore ! - APM was ruined (made useless as a skill) because of TOO FEW THINGS TO DO ! and thus (as someone else already said in this topic) progamers, with almost equal skill, simply became equals and matches were decided based on trivialities. etc.
THATS WHAT I CALL A DISAPPOINTMENT !
And on top of everything, newbies created dota to ruin the game for good.
P.S. Thats precisely why W3 IS and always WILL BE impossible to completely balance ! StarCraft, at its core, is probably not well balanced either but because there are so many things that depend on the player and not the race-balance, it simply doesn't matter.
|
|
|
|
|
|