[SCL Contest] The Mineral Mechanic - Page 3
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Tritanis
Poland344 Posts
| ||
|
decembrie
93 Posts
On December 26 2008 22:36 Tritanis wrote: Stating that something is retarded(aka dota) and giving zero arguments to back up your 'opinion' is way more retarded for me. I'm sick and tired of giving arguments why dota is retarded. I wont be bothered if you think playing dota can be compared to playing StarCraft, competitively. Its not even a RTS for crying out loud. I refuse to ruin this thread by making it about "why dota sucks". End of discussion. What we should be doing is help this idea develop since its clearly one of the last things that can possibly save SC2. | ||
|
Tritanis
Poland344 Posts
On December 26 2008 22:43 decembrie wrote: If I say that something is retarded, it really is. Don't you dare to argue with my unquestionable right. Fixed | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On December 26 2008 21:25 decembrie wrote: While I can see that a lot of hard work went into this submission, the mere fact that a lot of hard work went into doesn't mean that the idea wins or is the best solution to the problem. There's no easy way to solve the trivialization of this mechanic; the same fault lies within the gas mechanic as well. In essence, they are the same mechanic but for different resources. In fact, I would wager that the gas mechanic is better in being an command sink because you can't simply go 0i or w/e the hotkey for strip mine is. You have to manually move each set on/off the gas to optimize it, which can't be done with an in-phase two button press. I agree. However i think this idea is the best possible compromise between blizzard and the progaming world. Since the numbers are subject to change, we shouldn't criticize balancing quite yet, however Plexa's reply is nothing but the truth at this point; Plexa you shouldn't be so discouraging (!); they put alot of work into this. You have indeed raised a serious problem with their idea, however i'm sure there are ways to make it so that this doesn't become a simple, useless, repetitive task in Late-Game !!! Thats they way you should be thinking Plexa, help them don't discourage them. I'm sure you've seen the recent battle report and just as the rest of us, you were not at all impressed with the feel of the game and the actual "NEED FOR SKILL". Worst case scenario, the benefit of more resources coming is too important to stop, so people spend all the time on wasteful to get maximum resource in and make more units -> kill opponent. In this worst case scenario it is pretty much a pointless mechanic as it becomes set and forget. | ||
|
CuddlyCuteKitten
Sweden2918 Posts
Edit: I'd rather see it was the manpower rush ability or whatever it's called in CoH where you get a massive boost of resources then reduced income after that. IE you strip mine, it goes into wastefull and then you only mine half as much for a short period of time or something like that. | ||
|
decembrie
93 Posts
I still think that with the right tweaking, this idea can flourish and replace some of the things that StarCraft2 will lack. | ||
|
minus_human
4784 Posts
![]() | ||
|
decembrie
93 Posts
On December 26 2008 23:26 minus_human wrote: So then how about gas mechanic + mineral mechanic? ![]() I'm also for using them both. Another option to force players to switch back to normal would be as follows: After a number of trips using "strip", at the same time as "wasteful" or after using "wasteful" for a while, workers would start, progressively, to lose speed, little by little; so the more you use "wasteful" the more the speed of your workers decreases which hurts your economy without hurting the mineral patches. | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On December 26 2008 23:23 decembrie wrote: No, you put the wasteful mining back to normal but wasting minerals ie 5/10. That only alleviates the set and forget aspect. Still, you want to be strip mining as often as possible; and you never want to waste minerals. There will be no timing rush involving strip mining (unless its an upgrade) because it will always be a "must have" rather than a strategic tool. There is no solution to this, its the nature of these mechanics. And at that it will still be easier to do than the gas mechanic in the latter stages of the game. Then you simply make "wasteful" too painful to "set and forget"; imagine a 1500 mineral patch being sucked dry at 25 minerals per trip while receiving just 10 of those 25 (instead of the normal 8). If you've got 1000 minerals left on each patch it would only take 40 trips for your mineral line to vanish. I still think that with the right tweaking, this idea can flourish and replace some of the things that StarCraft2 will lack. EDIT: at your post above; interesting idea.. however on a micro level it would be very hard to identify slowing workers | ||
|
decembrie
93 Posts
It should not be available earlier than "early-mid-game" to preserve early-game balance. | ||
|
decembrie
93 Posts
On December 26 2008 23:35 Plexa wrote: EDIT: at your post above; interesting idea.. however on a micro level it would be very hard to identify slowing workers That's hardly a problem; instead of a red triangle, just place a red number showing the speed of each worker from 1 to 3, to 5, or to 9. Or have a yellow circle for just wasteful, and a red triangle for slow and wasteful workers. :D This is becoming too complicated i admit; things need to get more simple for blizzard to even consider their idea. | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
| ||
|
decembrie
93 Posts
| ||
|
maybenexttime
Poland5928 Posts
On December 26 2008 09:38 Plexa wrote: Won't have the impact you think it will. Here's why. At some arbitrary point in the game you stop producing workers; obviously because you have a sufficient number of them, or there are just too many other things to do to worry about silly workers. Also at some arbitrary point in the game there will be a point where adding +4 workers to mineral field makes a small different (as the minerals approach carrying capacity). So let's take a simplistic approach and divide it up into three stages; 1) Normal 2) Adding workers is negligible benefit 3) No more workers produced Just so we're clear, I'm making the assumption that Blizzard would be able to tweak all the numbers to keep the difference between regular and strip mining in balance (i.e. result in the player havng to make a choice regarding the mining mode often). I think "workers' being silly" is an inherent result of following the reward doctrine. As far as I'm concerned, it's just a matter of making the drawback of staying in wasteful mining harsher. Maybe, as someone has suggested, the efficiency could escalate over time (mining trips to be exact). Basically, a typically game oscillates between 1 and 2, with 1 being closer and closer to 2 and when that happens you get to 3 (and pretty much stay there). I hope that makes sense. I think you might be underestimating the metagame's effect. I'd expect SC2's gameplay to be (much) more dynamic than BW's, resulting in more harassment, attacks, etc., and thus leading to the balance between #1, #2 and #3 stages being in constant fluctuation (worker harassment, ovie hunting, depot raids, gate nuking, etc.). So we open up in the early game. You have a small number of probes; more importantly, a manageable number of probes. At this stage in the game you can perfectly control strip mining (just like you can with the gas mechanic right now; speaking from experience). As the probe count increases the additional benefit of each probe decreases, but you can still get optimal mining from them. We've gone from 1->2 Yeah, but it's the same for BW, except (assuming the mechanic gets balanced properly) the fact that the Mineral Mechanic would give you more options. Now we take an expansion, maynard our workers over, and we're kinda back to stage 1 again. It's slightly more difficult to get optimum mining; but its still possible. However after awhile we reach stage 2 again, but this time with 2 bases. With 15/20 workers/expo it's kinda impossible to get optimal mining, and the benefit of 4~ probes getting an extra 2 minerals is kinda pointless at this point. So you end up just selecting all your workers and making them strip mine in phase with each other, and then stop etc. This is manageable, and is very close to optimal mining capacity. You're assuming that worker count will be the same for both mineral lines, that the number of mineral patches will be the same (otherwise you couldn't synch those two mineral lines), and that the number of workers will be constant. There's also a suggestion made by Archerofaiur (he was talking about a different mechanic, but still) - the mining mode toggle could be an AoE "spell" of the main building - this way you'd actually have to go back to base, you wouldn't be able to simply hotkey your workers. This is where the mechanic falls down. This simply becomes a repetitive cyclic task at this stage in the game where getting all probes 100% optimal yield very little benefit to having 90~95% doing it. You really only need to set all probes to say, 0, and then every so many seconds change their mode. By synching all mineral lines (different worker count, different number of mineral patches) AND neglecting to consider all workers your missing on quite a bit of resources, don't you think? Not to mention you completely ignored the decision making process, calling the whole thing repetitive. Once we get 3-4 expos up we move into phase 3. In phase 3 we're not producing any more probes, and then this repetitive cyclic task is even easier and yields 100% efficiency. While this is still more than you would be doing in SC1; there are already plenty of this you need to be doing at this stage of the game anyway. Most importantly macroing. This mechanic doesn't negate any of the MBS effects at all at this point. Well, it's not supposed to negate MBS in any way. I also don't think you can't make this assumption that you're gonna make it to phase 3 and just stay there. This implies an extremely safegame on both sides. And if you're saying that at this point you're already doing plenty of things, then is there any "macro issues" in the first place at all? ;/ edit: I'll address other posts in due time. ^______^;; | ||
|
Manit0u
Poland17875 Posts
On December 26 2008 22:33 decembrie wrote: Your "reductio ad absurdum" won't work with me sir ! Blizzard has disappointed us with WarCraft 3 that rendered macro and APM USELESS because of having: - units with too much hit-points, making micro that much easier - MBS and low,high-upkeep to ruin any sort of Macro !! - a main resource (gold) which has a fixed income because of using only 5 workers; and because the main resource type is fixed things like "economy management" don't exist anymore ! - APM was ruined (made useless as a skill) because of TOO FEW THINGS TO DO ! and thus (as someone else already said in this topic) progamers, with almost equal skill, simply became equals and matches were decided based on trivialities. etc. THATS WHAT I CALL A DISAPPOINTMENT ! And on top of everything, newbies created dota to ruin the game for good. P.S. Thats precisely why W3 IS and always WILL BE impossible to completely balance ! StarCraft, at its core, is probably not well balanced either but because there are so many things that depend on the player and not the race-balance, it simply doesn't matter. There are 2 things that annoy me with this post. 1. It has too much text in bold. 2. You apparently don't know much about WC3, do you? Let me argue with you a bit: - units with too much hit-points, making micro that much easier Those same units have a lot of activated skills and you can't really let them die, can you? It's different micro, not easier. - MBS and low,high-upkeep to ruin any sort of Macro !! MBS has absolutely no meanigful use in WC3 and things you mentioned just change (reduce) the mechanical aspect of macro while putting more strain on the mental part (when to switch upkeeps, how many exps at current upkeep etc.). - a main resource (gold) which has a fixed income because of using only 5 workers; and because the main resource type is fixed things like "economy management" don't exist anymore ! Fixed number of workers aren't really part of "economy management", eco management in WC3 is production/upkeep etc. - APM was ruined (made useless as a skill) because of TOO FEW THINGS TO DO ! Then what do WC3 pros do with their 400apm? When they're playing they don't seem to look like people who have too few things to do. Sorry for the offtopic. | ||
|
LonelyMargarita
1845 Posts
On December 26 2008 23:59 decembrie wrote: They will never do that; and besides this idea aspires to replace some of the macro that will have been lost once SC2 is out aswell; plus it might create a whole new aspect of game-play. Thats why i'm so impressed with it. Wanna talk about what they're absolutely NEVER do? A fan idea. There are too many legal issues with using an idea someone has publicized beforehand, even if its intent was obviously to help Blizzard. I'd also recommend laying off the bold. It makes it sound like you're shouting, and I couldn't even stand to read your posts because of it. EDIT: Rereading it this post sounded mean, but was not intended to be. I guess I worded it poorly. | ||
|
maybenexttime
Poland5928 Posts
![]() | ||
|
Plexa
Aotearoa39261 Posts
On December 27 2008 08:20 maybenexttime wrote: Silly workers = idle workers when you have 3+ basesJust so we're clear, I'm making the assumption that Blizzard would be able to tweak all the numbers to keep the difference between regular and strip mining in balance (i.e. result in the player havng to make a choice regarding the mining mode often). I think "workers' being silly" is an inherent result of following the reward doctrine. As far as I'm concerned, it's just a matter of making the drawback of staying in wasteful mining harsher. Maybe, as someone has suggested, the efficiency could escalate over time (mining trips to be exact). I think you might be underestimating the metagame's effect. I'd expect SC2's gameplay to be (much) more dynamic than BW's, resulting in more harassment, attacks, etc., and thus leading to the balance between #1, #2 and #3 stages being in constant fluctuation (worker harassment, ovie hunting, depot raids, gate nuking, etc.). Yeah, but it's the same for BW, except (assuming the mechanic gets balanced properly) the fact that the Mineral Mechanic would give you more options. You're assuming that worker count will be the same for both mineral lines, that the number of mineral patches will be the same (otherwise you couldn't synch those two mineral lines), and that the number of workers will be constant. There's also a suggestion made by Archerofaiur (he was talking about a different mechanic, but still) - the mining mode toggle could be an AoE "spell" of the main building - this way you'd actually have to go back to base, you wouldn't be able to simply hotkey your workers. By synching all mineral lines (different worker count, different number of mineral patches) AND neglecting to consider all workers your missing on quite a bit of resources, don't you think? Not to mention you completely ignored the decision making process, calling the whole thing repetitive. Well, it's not supposed to negate MBS in any way. I also don't think you can't make this assumption that you're gonna make it to phase 3 and just stay there. This implies an extremely safegame on both sides. And if you're saying that at this point you're already doing plenty of things, then is there any "macro issues" in the first place at all? ;/ | ||
|
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33723 Posts
From the battle report, and the number of games i've played of sc2, there is no substantial difference the amount of harass (if anything theres less). However my simplification into three stages is still valid on the grounds that those three states exist and that there is an oscillation between these three states If someone played <50 games of SC versus random BNet players and tried to tell you how SC "plays", would you a) Laugh at him b) Laugh at him ? ![]() It wouldn't give you more options; it would be a necessity for all races. And even if there is an upgrade for it; timings would be worked out for it which pretty much negate the strategic impact it would have. On top of that, upgrades for something like this are pretty artificial =/. If optimal timings are worked out then surely that is strategy? There is no decision making process; players would want the most minerals as fast as they can get them. That is because getting more minerals means getting a larger army faster which means winning the game sooner. Who cares if you waste some minerals in the process; in the long term thats not going to matter if you seal the game then/there. There is 100% going to be a point(s) in a standard macro game where you want to turn it off, because you'll be bringing in WAAAAAAAAY more minerals than you can spend. The issue at this point in the game is more of the MBS issue and whatnot. The effectiveness of the mechanic at this point in the game is exactly a cyclic task. I suppose thats a plus, but still... The macro issues are early/mid game and this mechanic does little to alleviate them, and the level that it alleviates is on par with the gas mechanic soo ;; But MBS has next to 0 impact on the early game, and not that much impact on the midgame (as midgame you can keep most of your production facilities hotkeyed anyway). | ||
|
Manit0u
Poland17875 Posts
On December 27 2008 08:20 maybenexttime wrote: Yeah, but it's the same for BW, except (assuming the mechanic gets balanced properly) the fact that the Mineral Mechanic would give you more options. It would give you only 1 option. Mine the way you get the most minerals as soon as possible. Anything else would be suicide (you remember the "oov macro" vid? Where Zerg begins to build his drone and several BC's come in and obliterate his hatch?). And gathering minerals faster but wasting some of them in the process (you get less mins total/base) is not a viable setback, no one will even consider the 'safeplay' option because it puts you way back in income (and actual income is relevant, not how many minerals you'll get in the long run, you can always capture more exps if you're getting low on patches and by mining faster you'll be able to do it earlier/easier). Personally I only see 2 ways of "fixing" automine (and gas mechanic too): 1. remove it completely (not gonna happen imo) 2. reduce the production time on everything, increase the amount of minerals gathered by workers - this will speed the game up to the level where you won't really have time to even think about going back to send your workers to mine since you'll be constantly adding more production buildings/supply depots and producing units like crazy. The games will develop a lot faster and the best thing is that it won't hurt casual players even the slightest bit (you have all the 'easy' mechanics like automine/mbs, you don't have stupid gas mechanic, you get resources faster and your units are making fast = good for turtling and owning the campaing) and at higher levels it will require tremendous skill to macro properly while still having some resemblance of control over your army. Edit: Actually, you don't even have to reduce production time, you just need to increase the income: increased income = increased spending = more time/actions required = more skill needed It is really that simple. You don't have to invent some complex new 'mechanic' to increase the skill gap and offset the automine feature. (and it's way easier to balance/tweak) | ||
| ||
