EPT#10: Rain - Greatest Players of All Time - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
Read the introduction article for information on the methodology behind this article series. Editor's note: In 2015 TL.net's stuchiu tried to answer the most controversial question in all of StarCraft II: Who are the greatest players of all time? No, the series didn't lead to the community reaching a harmonious consensus, but it was a fantastic way to look back on competitive StarCraft II history and celebrate its most accomplished players. Eight years after stuchiu named Mvp the GOAT, Mizenhauer has decided to take a shot at creating an updated list. His approach and viewpoints are entirely different, but it's no less appreciative of StarCraft II history. Who will make the top ten cutoff this time around? | ||
|
MJG
United Kingdom1197 Posts
| ||
|
Drahkn
193 Posts
On January 12 2024 16:59 Poopi wrote: INnoVation was above Rain in pure talent imho I wonder if the fact that Rain remained a top BW player after his departure from sc2 cemented the fact that he could have won more tournaments in sc2 if he were to stay; and thus keep his 10th spot Innovation was known for his hard work ethic he is not considered a super talent , of course I would never say he was not talented at RTS games I'm just saying there are a lot more players who are more talented then he is but then they didn't have his work ethic imho | ||
Waxangel
United States33431 Posts
On January 12 2024 18:30 Drahkn wrote: Innovation was known for his hard work ethic he is not considered a super talent , of course I would never say he was not talented at RTS games I'm just saying there are a lot more players who are more talented then he is but then they didn't have his work ethic imho lol perhaps that was the narrative in like 2012-13 (and I'm not saying he didn't work hard back then), but in latter years he's become one of the posterboys of talent > everything | ||
Poopi
France12891 Posts
On January 12 2024 18:30 Drahkn wrote: Innovation was known for his hard work ethic he is not considered a super talent , of course I would never say he was not talented at RTS games I'm just saying there are a lot more players who are more talented then he is but then they didn't have his work ethic imho The fact that his brother is already in the list of potential GOATs for his role in League of Legends makes me confident INno was not all about hard work (especially how he managed to stay relevant despite barely playing in his last LotV years) | ||
|
Comedy
456 Posts
| ||
|
RPR_Tempest
Australia7798 Posts
| ||
BluemoonSC
SoCal8910 Posts
On January 12 2024 18:53 Poopi wrote: The fact that his brother is already in the list of potential GOATs for his role in League of Legends makes me confident INno was not all about hard work (especially how he managed to stay relevant despite barely playing in his last LotV years) Success is the product of both hard work and talent. Some have varying levels of each but you can't get there without both. But I didn't realize that Gumayusi was inno's brother that's pretty cool. Wiki says he is also a distant nephew of Faker so that shit HAS to be genetic haha | ||
|
Haku
Germany550 Posts
| ||
|
SoleSteeler
Canada5446 Posts
| ||
|
t5Fab
183 Posts
For 2015 I remember sOs, Life and Innovation Since I have no particular memory of Rain during his 2 best years, I cannot put him in my top10 | ||
|
Xamo
Spain880 Posts
I remember initially not believing the style of Protoss that Rain pioneered was going to achieve anything. The more Artosis felt in love with it, the higher my disbelief. But he quickly proved me wrong. Later on I realized Rain forced that style to be successfull with his enormous talent. He might have selected a different one and still become a champion. But he did not, and changed the Protoss race forever. | ||
|
AxiomB
69 Posts
| ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland25618 Posts
| ||
|
Nakajin
Canada8989 Posts
On January 14 2024 22:28 WombaT wrote: Beautiful write up for a player who is an absolute lock for top 10 for me, look forward to the rest (although obviously I am still affronted to not be consulted) True democrats know that the only real GOAT has to be elected through a 6 months long voting process. Serral 18th greatest SC2 player forever. | ||
|
Yoshi Kirishima
United States10347 Posts
On January 13 2024 07:29 t5Fab wrote: To put down my 2 cents, I started watching SC2 in 2013. My memorable players from that year were Maru, Jaedong and sOs For 2015 I remember sOs, Life and Innovation Since I have no particular memory of Rain during his 2 best years, I cannot put him in my top10 This is pretty much how i feel, i was still half-watching SC2 during HotS, and i don't remember watching or hearing anything much about Rain. It doesn't seem he has many achievements either, though I know it's still pretty good for the length of his short career. Throw Taeja in (maybe Zest) and the players you named are all the ones I felt were the era-defining players. | ||
Mizenhauer
United States1886 Posts
On January 14 2024 23:09 Nakajin wrote: True democrats know that the only real GOAT has to be elected through a 6 months long voting process. Serral 18th greatest SC2 player forever. I must say, I respect the moxie required to rank him there. | ||
|
ejozl
Denmark3408 Posts
I would rate Zest, MC, herO, sOs and PartinG above this guy, but I somehow doubt that they will all be in the top 10 Trap has a similar peak, right? And Stats is a more evolved macro Protoss. Maybe you are counting in his BW career? He only had achievements when Toss was good and at the time he was only top 3. | ||
|
Xamo
Spain880 Posts
On January 15 2024 02:31 ejozl wrote: We get it, you're a Rain fanboi. I would rate Zest, MC, herO, sOs and PartinG above this guy, but I somehow doubt that they will all be in the top 10 Trap has a similar peak, right? And Stats is a more evolved macro Protoss. Maybe you are counting in his BW career? He only had achievements when Toss was good and at the time he was only top 3. Taking into acount the methodology I think only sOs should be clearly above him. Classic and Zest have a small chance. | ||
|
WombaT
Northern Ireland25618 Posts
On January 15 2024 02:31 ejozl wrote: We get it, you're a Rain fanboi. I would rate Zest, MC, herO, sOs and PartinG above this guy, but I somehow doubt that they will all be in the top 10 Trap has a similar peak, right? And Stats is a more evolved macro Protoss. Maybe you are counting in his BW career? He only had achievements when Toss was good and at the time he was only top 3. Parting? I don’t see any kind of objective metric that puts him ahead of Rain. | ||
|
Cricketer12
United States13977 Posts
On January 15 2024 02:31 ejozl wrote: We get it, you're a Rain fanboi. I would rate Zest, MC, herO, sOs and PartinG above this guy, but I somehow doubt that they will all be in the top 10 Trap has a similar peak, right? And Stats is a more evolved macro Protoss. Maybe you are counting in his BW career? He only had achievements when Toss was good and at the time he was only top 3. I love PartinG more than most and this is pure cope. Zest and prob herO will make it though. | ||
| ||
