EPTCaster Feedback Thread - Page 4
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
The Caster Feedback Thread is a place to provide constructive criticism and give thanks to community casters. Please do not use this thread to needlessly whine and bash casters. Be mindful of this when you post. | ||
|
Sapphire.lux
Romania2620 Posts
| ||
|
JimmyJRaynor
Canada17252 Posts
On July 24 2017 01:30 Seeker wrote: Thread has been renamed. From now on, all constructive criticism and feedback toward casters will go here. This thread will be moderated and watched carefully so be wary of what you post! thx for keeping this thread open and being willing to devote moderation resources to the topic. it will probably turn out to be a pretty thankless task. | ||
|
jpg06051992
United States580 Posts
Valdez needs to film himself or at least listen to himself objectively, his humor is mega awkward and usually badly timed, he also comes off as extremely negative alot of the times. He has good game knowledge but I often hear him just reiterating what Wolf said but less eloquently and more cringey. ZombieGrub is good I don't understand the hate she gets, for a girl she really knows what she's talking about, honestly Rifkin is the worst caster ever, mediocre game knowledge combined with maximum cringe mode side humor/commentary. | ||
|
SetGuitarsToKill
Canada28396 Posts
On July 24 2017 02:46 jpg06051992 wrote: Wolf is really good, well rounded, decent humor and good game knowledge Valdez needs to film himself or at least listen to himself objectively, his humor is mega awkward and usually badly timed, he also comes off as extremely negative alot of the times. He has good game knowledge but I often hear him just reiterating what Wolf said but less eloquently and more cringey. ZombieGrub is good I don't understand the hate she gets, for a girl she really knows what she's talking about, honestly Rifkin is the worst caster ever, mediocre game knowledge combined with maximum cringe mode side humor/commentary. "for a girl" really? | ||
|
JimmyJRaynor
Canada17252 Posts
On July 24 2017 02:46 jpg06051992 wrote:ZombieGrub is good I don't understand the hate she gets, for a girl she really knows what she's talking about is this a triple entedre reverse psychology counter-troll? i think when assessing a caster you must consider the production resources at their disposal. A person casting with a team of 8 people handling every aspect of the production for a 2 hour show has everything going in their favour for creating a solid show/cast. OTOH, in the early days of BTTV you had 2 people handling everything doing 12 hour broadcasts. You're going to get rough spots under those conditions. ZombieGrub and Rifkin aren't going to provide John Madden level commentary for every minute of a 12 hour extended marathon. | ||
|
niteReloaded
Croatia5282 Posts
So smooth, relaxed, not forcing anything. Like his balance between the extremes that other casters often go to. <3 | ||
|
Zaros
United Kingdom3692 Posts
| ||
|
LongShot27
United States2084 Posts
Esports is heavily male, starcraft is nearly 100% male, for any woman to be compared to other casters REQUIRES one to examine the fact that she has a GLARING biological difference, that's how data works. Just because someone calls someone what they are does not make it sexist. This is not a liberal arts campus, calm down. I have no opinion on ZG casting. I stopped watching BTTV when they started getting preachy. | ||
|
207aicila
1237 Posts
On July 24 2017 07:39 LongShot27 wrote: Esports is heavily male, starcraft is nearly 100% male, for any woman to be compared to other casters REQUIRES one to examine the fact that she has a GLARING biological difference, that's how data works. Just because someone calls someone what they are does not make it sexist. This is not a liberal arts campus, calm down. I have no opinion on ZG casting. I stopped watching BTTV when they started getting preachy. Just curious, when/how did BTTV get preachy? Didn't get to see this as I personally stopped following them the moment they started promoting a website that allows for the selling of stolen game keys and extorts its customers. Also their mods ban you in their chat if you point out how that website hurts developers' livelihoods. | ||
|
SetGuitarsToKill
Canada28396 Posts
On July 24 2017 07:39 LongShot27 wrote: Esports is heavily male, starcraft is nearly 100% male, for any woman to be compared to other casters REQUIRES one to examine the fact that she has a GLARING biological difference, that's how data works. Just because someone calls someone what they are does not make it sexist. This is not a liberal arts campus, calm down. I have no opinion on ZG casting. I stopped watching BTTV when they started getting preachy. It doesn't require any examinations like that though. You don't hear people say "for a really short guy, Nathanias knows his shit" or "for an indian guy, feardragon sure is great", it's just not necessary to add that detail. On July 24 2017 07:57 207aicila wrote: Just curious, when/how did BTTV get preachy? Didn't get to see this as I personally stopped following them the moment they started promoting a website that allows for the selling of stolen game keys and extorts its customers. Also their mods ban you in their chat if you point out how that website hurts developers' livelihoods. They aren't sponsored by G2A anymore, just fyi | ||
|
starkiller123
United States4030 Posts
| ||
|
ScrappyRabbit
200 Posts
| ||
|
JimmyJRaynor
Canada17252 Posts
On July 24 2017 08:17 starkiller123 wrote: I miss Apollo's casting a lot Apollo was excellent. Any one know why Apollo is no longer around? | ||
|
SetGuitarsToKill
Canada28396 Posts
On July 24 2017 09:23 JimmyJRaynor wrote: Apollo was excellent. Any one know why Apollo is no longer around? He got a higher up job at ESL, Production Manager or something like that, that keeps him busy. | ||
|
Chris_Havoc
United States600 Posts
On July 24 2017 09:23 JimmyJRaynor wrote: Apollo was excellent. Any one know why Apollo is no longer around? Apollo is now a producer for the ESL and currently lives in Los Angeles. And since Apollo's time is now taken up doing the behind-the-scenes work, he's retired from casting for now. | ||
|
Ensiferum8
Canada103 Posts
Tasteless Artosis Day 9 Kevin Knocke (any old fans remember him?) Moonglade Wolf Total Biscuit Good Tier: Apollo Kaelaris Mr Bitter (with rotterdam) Khaldor So-so tier: Nathanias Rotterdam Incontrol Bad tier: ToD Axeltoss (good voice, 0 knowledge) Rifkin ZombieGrub Whats your opinion bois? agree with that? | ||
|
starkiller123
United States4030 Posts
On July 24 2017 10:37 Ensiferum8 wrote: God tier: Tasteless Artosis Day 9 Kevin Knocke (any old fan remember him? Moonglade Wolf Total Biscuit Good Tier: Apollo Kaelaris Mr Bitter (with rotterdam) Khaldor So-so tier: Nathanias Rotterdam Incontrol Bad tier: ToD Axeltoss (good voice, 0 knowledge) Rifkin ZombieGrub Whats your opinion bois? agree with that? What is wrong with ToD? I have been loving his casting lately, same with Rotti and Incontrol, I think I prefer all 3 of them over Tasteless who I still think is pretty good I 100% agree about Rifkin thou, he just bothers me | ||
|
Ensiferum8
Canada103 Posts
On July 24 2017 10:40 starkiller123 wrote: What is wrong with ToD? I have been loving his casting lately, same with Rotti and Incontrol, I think I prefer all 3 of them over Tasteless who I still think is pretty good I 100% agree about Rifkin thou, he just bothers me Tod was always one of my least favorite (with PiG that i forgot to rank). First i really dislike his accent (even though im french canadian, i still dislike his accent). Also, i always thought he was one of the most bias caster (not sure if that an opinion or a fact). For rotti, i also dislike his accent (maybe im just quite picky vs non native english speaker ) but hes not bias much so thats why hes higher than Tod. (when he was with mr bitter, he would even be close to god tier). And honestly, i think incontrol can be funny, but he tries way too hard to be funny, and for me, too much is like not enough. I mainly watch the sc2 for the gameplay and to cheer for my fav players, not for the comedy aspect (unless im watching non korean gameplay  ) | ||
|
Vindicare605
United States16118 Posts
They need to enable the in game music and turn it up. Their stream is really hard for me to watch most of the time, even though Zombiegrub is great. | ||
|
yhellothere12
46 Posts
| ||
| ||
