EPTAs an aside, I'd love it if there was an even bigger list or another one with different criteria. I've thoroughly enjoyed reading all of these :D
Greatest Players of All Time: Part 3 - Page 6
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
DSK
England1110 Posts
As an aside, I'd love it if there was an even bigger list or another one with different criteria. I've thoroughly enjoyed reading all of these :D | ||
|
sc2chronic
United States777 Posts
| ||
|
LongShot27
United States2084 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:46 sc2chronic wrote: ITT: ppl that are easily convinced and delusional to agree with 3rd ranking. lets not mention in the article all the dips TaeJa had in his career. lets just blast MC for an illusion of fair comparison and call out "liquid bias" before-hand because deep inside, you know that there was in fact some bias involved. Everyone knows taeja isn't top 3 or even top 10, it's just an opinion piece, its whatever | ||
|
royalroadweed
United States8301 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:43 LongShot27 wrote: Polt would be lower if it was skill? yeah k sure I think he's talking about mechanical skill. | ||
stuchiu
Fiddler's Green42661 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:21 Ardias wrote: And we have top 10 of: 10. Rain 9. Innovation 8. Zest 7. Nestea 6. MMA 5. Polt 4. MC 3. Taeja 1/2. Life/Mvp without any doubt. Damn I was close, but high underestimation of Polt failed me. Still happy that i was correct about the abscence of Parting in this list. Yea not putting Parting is actually really impressive in retrospect. | ||
|
InExcelsis
United States38 Posts
| ||
|
Roadog
Canada1670 Posts
| ||
|
Elentos
55511 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:55 InExcelsis wrote: What is this nonsense Taeja at 3 WTF? Yeah who cares if he has a crap ton of titles he never won in Korea with the big boys just a bunch of less competitive European events. I guess Homestory Cup and Dreamhack are more prestigious than GSL absurd you put a 2 time GSL champion behind Taeja MC is much better. Your "Criteria" makes no sense in this situation Taeja should be 6th or 5th at best this is just a joke and has destroyed the credibility of this article. He dedicated about half the TaeJa section to what you're complaining about. | ||
|
PinheadXXXXXX
United States897 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:55 InExcelsis wrote: What is this nonsense Taeja at 3 WTF? Yeah who cares if he has a crap ton of titles he never won in Korea with the big boys just a bunch of less competitive European events. I guess Homestory Cup and Dreamhack are more prestigious than GSL absurd you put a 2 time GSL champion behind Taeja MC is much better. Your "Criteria" makes no sense in this situation Taeja should be 6th or 5th at best this is just a joke and has destroyed the credibility of this article. His criteria is clearly explained if you read the article, and I don't see a hole in it. Do you? | ||
|
stuchiu
Fiddler's Green42661 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:56 Roadog wrote: Polt didn't get 2nd in the 2014 IEM WC, he lost to herO in the semifinals Updated that, thanks. | ||
|
Elentos
55511 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:58 PinheadXXXXXX wrote: His criteria is clearly explained if you read the article, and I don't see a hole in it. Do you? But accepting that is no fun! I'd rather look at the rank and complain without reading! | ||
|
nkr
Sweden5451 Posts
 | ||
|
Dreamer.T
United States3584 Posts
| ||
|
Gorlin
United States2753 Posts
IPL 5 - 3rd - YoDa, Creator, loss to Leenock, Sniper, Bomber, loss to viOLet vs. GSL 2011 October - 1st - loss to Nestea, Happy, Mvp (Finals higher prestige) Iron Squid 1 - 1st - Jjakji, pre-Champion Life, loss to MaNa, aLive, Symbol You really think that 3rd at IPL 5 beats out a first in a GSL? Would like to hear more about this. Even the players MMA beat along the way are more impressive in my opinion, notably an Mvp in his prime at TvT. Honestly, I think WCS 2015 (which you said were unable to pair with anything, but doesn't add that much in terms of victories against top opponents) and IPL 5 is a reasonable matchup with GSL and Iron Squid. Furthermore, and I don't know if you addressed this anywhere, but your ranking seems to completely ignore team league results. Polt has essentially no results in this regard, while MMA was a team league monster at two seperate times (the driving force behind two GSTL wins and a big part of Acer's success in ATC. I think that easily pushes the comparison into MMA's favor. | ||
|
InExcelsis
United States38 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:58 PinheadXXXXXX wrote: His criteria is clearly explained if you read the article, and I don't see a hole in it. Do you? Yep the "HOLE" is you don't WIN a GSL you don't make top 5 that simple in my mind. Someone else already complained about it but putting Dreamhacks, and IEM's in the same boat as a GSL title is silly GSL needs to be its own tier and given more credit. So yeah following "his criteria" guess there isn't a hole and Taeja is properly placed but that still doesn't make it right at least imo. It is just silly cause if you ask any knowledgeable Starcraft player "Do you think Taeja is the 3rd best player ever?" I would venture to say 99% would say NO. He has 1 GSL top 4 finish in his life I'm sorry but I don't care how many IEM's,Dreamhacks, Homestory Cups, Asus ROG's you win if you don't win the hardest tournament you can't be top 5 all time. | ||
|
Specialist
United States803 Posts
| ||
shiroiusagi
SoCal, USA3955 Posts
On April 26 2015 02:47 LongShot27 wrote: Everyone knows taeja isn't top 3 or even top 10, it's just an opinion piece, its whatever Why shouldn't he be top 10. Can't really argue with his achievements. I am pretty sure a lot of the top 10 isn't as decorated as TaeJa. He was fairly dominate in 2013 into 2014 halfway. http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/TaeJa#Achievements | ||
|
Darthsanta13
United States564 Posts
| ||
|
fezvez
France3021 Posts
On April 12 2015 09:16 fezvez wrote: Allright then! From 10 to 1 : Polt Rain Taeja Zest INnoVation MMA MC Nestea Life Mvp That Nestea pushed back to the end of the rankings... I think he is the Savior of the Zerg race, he just codified how to play it (in the same way that Life did what JD did) | ||
|
Cricketer12
United States13974 Posts
| ||
| ||
