MLG Groups and Casters - Page 21
Forum Index > SC2 General |
ZanXala
Sweden26 Posts
| ||
OpticalPhonon
Canada72 Posts
On March 21 2012 00:09 MLG_Adam wrote: I don't get the Rob hate ![]() The issue is that all of a sudden this guy comes out of nowhere and is casting major events. His only casting credentials appear to be the "Terrible, terrible damage" videos and whatever part-time job you're referring too. In contrast, every other caster we see on stage has paid their dues putting in hundreds (or thousands) of hours into the community with little or no pay. Can you honestly say that if Rob Simpson wasn't working for Blizzard that he would be casting this? There's nothing wrong with his casting but there are many people in the community who are just as good, if not better. In fact, you have a bunch of them casting your Beta stream. Why not give the opportunity to people who have shown their love and dedication to the community instead of someone who appears to be nothing more than a carpetbagger. Edit: Adam actually states "Rob's presence has nothing to do with Blizzard." I mean, that's just the biggest pile of bullshit I've ever heard. Is this how the hiring process went: Adam: "Hey Rob remember all those years ago when you were 16 and you casted for us?" Rob: "No." Adam: "Well, we'd like you to cast again! It's a totally different game so we'll just start you off nice and easy by putting you in front of about a hundred thousand live viewers. Don't worry they're on the Internet, so they won't be critical if it goes badly." Rob: "I actually work for Blizzard now, so I can't." Adam: "Blizzard? Huh, what a coincidence the game you'll be casting is made by Blizzard!" Rob: "Wow, that must be a sign! I guess I'll take the job." | ||
zManiacal
United Kingdom38 Posts
On March 21 2012 00:32 Mr Showtime wrote: Would you care to justify your claim that he's a bad caster, rather than writing something useless like "Cringe?" Most people seem to enjoy him, as do I, but I don't understand why others would rather see someone else. I never stated he was a bad caster? I just don't agree with his post game analysis that he gives, much like Husky/Apollo. These guys are full of enthusiasm, huge nerdballers and give a shit about the community but are they top casters when it comes to post game analysis? Heck no. | ||
johnny123
521 Posts
| ||
KaptenCulpa
Sweden29 Posts
![]() | ||
hunts
United States2113 Posts
| ||
Kralic
Canada2628 Posts
On March 21 2012 02:16 OpticalPhonon wrote: Edit: Adam actually states "Rob's presence has nothing to do with Blizzard." I mean, that's just the biggest pile of bullshit I've ever heard. Is this how the hiring process went: Adam: "Hey Rob remember all those years ago when you were 16 and you casted for us?" Rob: "No." Adam: "Well, we'd like you to cast again! It's a totally different game so we'll just start you off nice and easy by putting you in front of about a hundred thousand live viewers. Don't worry they're on the Internet, so they won't be critical if it goes badly." Rob: "I actually work for Blizzard now, so I can't." Adam: "Blizzard? Huh, what a coincidence the game you'll be casting is made by Blizzard!" Rob: "Wow, that must be a sign! I guess I'll take the job." Can you post a source to that job interview? I hope that isn't what went on. | ||
halfies
United Kingdom327 Posts
On March 21 2012 00:09 MLG_Adam wrote: I don't get the Rob hate ![]() well, its mainly because he isnt that good. his game knowledge isnt really good, and he doesnt make up for by being really funny, or even just being really good with someone else. i mean, the player casts at winter arena were awkward at times, but when they spoke, it was interesting. Robs role seems to be agreeing with who ever else is there, or trying way to hard to make an unfunny thought into a legendary moment that everyone will remember. thats why i dont like him | ||
Moosy
Canada396 Posts
Also lover the casters, especially Rob Simpson; his innocent casting is admirable. ![]() | ||
![]()
MLG_Adam
United States994 Posts
On March 21 2012 02:16 OpticalPhonon wrote: The issue is that all of a sudden this guy comes out of nowhere and is casting major events. His only casting credentials appear to be the "Terrible, terrible damage" videos and whatever part-time job you're referring too. In contrast, every other caster we see on stage has paid their dues putting in hundreds (or thousands) of hours into the community with little or no pay. Can you honestly say that if Rob Simpson wasn't working for Blizzard that he would be casting this? There's nothing wrong with his casting but there are many people in the community who are just as good, if not better. In fact, you have a bunch of them casting your Beta stream. Why not give the opportunity to people who have shown their love and dedication to the community instead of someone who appears to be nothing more than a carpetbagger. Edit: Adam actually states "Rob's presence has nothing to do with Blizzard." I mean, that's just the biggest pile of bullshit I've ever heard. Is this how the hiring process went: Adam: "Hey Rob remember all those years ago when you were 16 and you casted for us?" Rob: "No." Adam: "Well, we'd like you to cast again! It's a totally different game so we'll just start you off nice and easy by putting you in front of about a hundred thousand live viewers. Don't worry they're on the Internet, so they won't be critical if it goes badly." Rob: "I actually work for Blizzard now, so I can't." Adam: "Blizzard? Huh, what a coincidence the game you'll be casting is made by Blizzard!" Rob: "Wow, that must be a sign! I guess I'll take the job." Honest answers are never accepted ![]() You can be as dramatic as you like, I was being 100% honest. Rob is my friend, a former co worker, and we all feel he is a damn good caster. | ||
hunts
United States2113 Posts
On March 21 2012 03:15 MLG_Adam wrote: Honest answers are never accepted ![]() You can be as dramatic as you like, I was being 100% honest. Rob is my friend, a former co worker, and we all feel he is a damn good caster. Don't let the haters get to you ![]() | ||
Mr Showtime
United States1353 Posts
On March 21 2012 01:49 Ronski wrote: Finally Day[9] is back to cast at MLG, and unless they come up with another crazy PPV I will definately be watching. When are people going to shut up about this? They've announced that they don't have PPV for major events. | ||
skeldark
Germany2223 Posts
On March 21 2012 03:17 hunts wrote: Don't let the haters get to you ![]() Sweet irony/humor, thats what we want. Who needs lan if you can have sweet irony. oO Will there be a caster free stream? I would really like a stream without casters but with game sounds and a good observer! | ||
RedBlargh
99 Posts
Looking forward to seeing those who'll be coming out of the open-bracket. Always exciting :D | ||
Hing
Estonia26 Posts
| ||
OpticalPhonon
Canada72 Posts
On March 21 2012 03:15 MLG_Adam wrote: Honest answers are never accepted ![]() You can be as dramatic as you like, I was being 100% honest. Rob is my friend, a former co worker, and we all feel he is a damn good caster. These are all valid reasons for hiring someone. The only issue is that you're now stating that one of the primary reasons why you hired him is because he has worked for Blizzard for five years. This contradicts what you wrote earlier: "Rob's presence has nothing to do with Blizzard." If earlier in the thread you'd simply stated that "Yeah, he works for Blizzard and that makes him even more qualified for the position" I would have had less of a problem. But your earlier post came across as artificial as you tried to build him up as some sort of hard working community member that we just weren't aware of. While he may be a great guy who is a competent caster, at the end of the day he is a Blizzard employee and that's why he got the job over a community member. | ||
Ph0en1x
Czech Republic18 Posts
| ||
![]()
MLG_Adam
United States994 Posts
On March 21 2012 04:14 OpticalPhonon wrote: These are all valid reasons for hiring someone. The only issue is that you're now stating that one of the primary reasons why you hired him is because he has worked for Blizzard for five years. This contradicts what you wrote earlier: "Rob's presence has nothing to do with Blizzard." If earlier in the thread you'd simply stated that "Yeah, he works for Blizzard and that makes him even more qualified for the position" I would have had less of a problem. But your earlier post came across as artificial as you tried to build him up as some sort of hard working community member that we just weren't aware of. While he may be a great guy who is a competent caster, at the end of the day he is a Blizzard employee and that's why he got the job over a community member. The Blizzard reference is intended to highlight that he works on the game, understands the game, and has knowledge of tournaments/players. It is more of a resume highlight, e.g. he knows his shit. | ||
![]()
MLG_Adam
United States994 Posts
On March 21 2012 04:16 Ph0en1x wrote: Is there any posibility of any low free stream ? or atleast some free streamed games or anything. Yes every Pro Circuit has free stream options. | ||
Wolver1
Netherlands2 Posts
| ||
| ||