EPT*Edit, Keep laughing, i like it when casters seem to be having a good time
Khaldor's casting for GomTV - Feedback & Poll - Page 22
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
tpmraven
United States833 Posts
*Edit, Keep laughing, i like it when casters seem to be having a good time | ||
|
_Nova_
United States167 Posts
On February 14 2012 21:22 FuFighter wrote: I've just been watching Code A and I started to notice one thing that I really don't like. I think it's nice that you point out where players are from but I think it would be quite enough if you only did this like once a matchup. Instead you quite often say "the swedish player" "the swedish zerg" etc. etc. and for some weird reason this annoys me. I don't know, it's probably just me but I'd prefer it if you said it less. Other than that I think you have quite improved from when I first saw you so keep it up  This. Constant reiterations of what team/country they're from, it just gets kind of irritating. Once would suffice. Another small thing that bothers me is something else he says constantly. It feels like everytime a battle is about to happen, someone's going for something unexpected like DTs, etc.. He feels the need to say "ladies and gentleman", every single time. Same for Moletrap, honestly. I can see it occasionally, sure. But saying it so much is pretty irritating. Maybe it's just me, I don't know. Aside from those little things, I like his casting. He could stay at GOM and I wouldn't have any big complaints. | ||
|
Hermanoid
Sweden213 Posts
The last phrase gets annoying in the "we cannot hold"-kind of way when there's actually not even anything defending the beseiged, for example, Nexus. Khaldor often makes it sound like there's way more effort involved for the attacker than there actually is, from my point of view. Moreover, there's too little insight and enthusiasm during commentating of midfield-fights. We only get to know that someone is "losing so many yoooonitz", which is always going to be the case. Some short analyzing comment of what happened would be spot on. Criticism aside, Khaldor's doing an awesome overall job atm. I'm glad he got to cast the foreigner matches today!  Keep up the good work. | ||
|
Versioned
United Kingdom73 Posts
Other than that, I enjoyed what I managed to see at Code A today, GJ! | ||
|
i3rainless
Germany34 Posts
For me you are definitely one of the best casters out there!! Pls keep the work up and stay with esports! Esport needs guys like you, don't listen to the haters!!! Im also sure you will improve drastically over time what is kind of scary, because you will be the greatest caster on the planet earth for all time if you improve :D | ||
|
hansmuff
United States23 Posts
The voice pitching higher and higher when you get excited makes me absolutely cringe. I don't mind if you get a little louder, but the voice pitch is just very jarring to me. I think in particular tasteless does this very well. Pick up more idioms and work on repeating less of them. I know it's not your native language, but this isn't impossible to do if you focus on it. Try to cast less with Moletrap if you can help it. You two have zero chemistry and it makes the casts way more awkward than they have to be. That's not your fault, it's just something I believe you should be told. GL HF. | ||
|
sCuMBaG
United Kingdom1144 Posts
please stop repeating yourself. you did it A LOT, and you still occasionally do it. e.g. the beginning of a sentence twice... "He is going to... going to... drop now" or sth like that. other than that I enjoy the commentary. | ||
|
KuKri
Germany168 Posts
good job in today's Code A! Your best performance, though, was with Sheth, especially the event one day before the Idra vs Alive showmatch (I can't remember which it was, maybe KSL). You seem to know the game very well, I assume your own play is not too shabby either. Best regards from Karlsruhe | ||
|
battleraper
Sweden9 Posts
| ||
|
Trusty
New Zealand520 Posts
I like how you don't hide your opinion, or try to be 'nice' about when a player makes mistakes. It's nice and refreshing :D Sometimes I even prefer to hear your german(?) casts, because your voice flows well to match the pace of the game. it's similar to watching korean bw casters, you can enjoy the cast without knowing the language!! :D | ||
storywriter
Australia528 Posts
By all means point out the mistakes the players make but the way you do it is extremely annoying. Things like "why WHY would he do that???" "that was a HUGE mistake" are what I mean. starcraft 2 is a game of mistakes and they will be made even if the players try their hardest. On top, for every mistake they make, there must be a hundred things they do right. Basically, what I'm trying to say is that starcraft 2 is a difficult game and the players in the GSL are the best of best so I think you should cut them some slack. You could say things like "It would have been much better for player X if he did Y" "I hope I don't see the same mistake next time they play" Just my 2 cents edit: grammar | ||
|
Peekaboo
Canada219 Posts
My only insight would be I enjoy the casts much more once things get going. Early on with not much happening its sort of like casting baseball...take a page from tastosis and don't worry about talking about the game so much at that point. I do like the fact Khaldor usually has something prepared to say about each player or the match but after that things don't flow too well after that until there is something worth talking about in game. Sometimes the guess what build he is going to do game is dull even with the excited "he took a gas!". This is true of all SC2 casters though. Speculation gets tiresome. Like that baseball, its more interesting to say that pitch was a fastball rather than try to guess the next pitch with every batter. Unless its interesting analysis just entertain us until the point something happens... "interesting story, lively banter....he put down a robo!".... rather than "he took his second gas so he could be going blink stalkers, dts, or stargate, or robo, or wants a lot of sentries to expand, or any other tech build in the game, or my pet build THE XXXXX....blah blah blah blah.....oh, he he put down a robo." But if you analyze things relative to other games what the opponent might be thinking, or what you've seen in the past its more interesting. Anyway, that wasn't really Khaldor specific, lol. Khaldor is doing well, I think. | ||
|
Isaac
United States810 Posts
| ||
|
Kontys
Finland659 Posts
He should be doing the analysis of strategy and higher level things and let moletrap do the shouting / pointing out individual small mistakes. His great strength is on the upper level, and whilst he isn't strictly worse than moletrap at explaining the small little things, he isn't better than moletrap either. Role up and roll and it'll be all very good. | ||
|
dani`
Netherlands2402 Posts
On February 18 2012 17:18 Isaac wrote: I noticed in tonights cast you criticized the players play. I dont watch the GSL a lot but it is more exciting when you say when a player is doing good/doing right. These folks that are playing are progamers. Progamers are people, people make mistakes. I think it's fine when mistakes are pointed out. Likewise, if they make smart / cool moves this should be hyped. Only highlighting the positive moves is not really fair, ignoring a player's mistakes is something I don't agree with at all. | ||
|
ShiniSama
United States103 Posts
A lot of these problems can be fixed by practice and playing the game a little more to get a better understanding of it. Again I know that this sounds a little harsh, but I'm sure as you know you can either get pissed off and call me a faggot or you can take what I have said and use it in a constructive way. I hope to see how you are doing in the future. | ||
|
Mohdoo
United States15690 Posts
On February 19 2012 15:40 ShiniSama wrote: I'm sure I will be flamed for this, but I must say it. First of all I am not saying this to try to be an asshole or anything I am truly trying to help your casting. I will start with the things that bug me the most. You tend to talk over everyone you cast with, especially in times of action. You are always talking over wolf when I am watching the GSL and he doesn't ever get to say much until you are finally done with your rant (I say rant for lack of better word). Another thing, that many people have already said, is when you raise your voice your pitch goes up like crazy. I am not even sure if you play the game at all from your casts, and I am saying that because it just doesn't seem like you are very analytical. When you are analyzing or making a prediction of a game you are often wrong or not very close. To sum everything up: A lot of my friends, and I, mute the stream when you're casting. A lot of these problems can be fixed by practice and playing the game a little more to get a better understanding of it. Again I know that this sounds a little harsh, but I'm sure as you know you can either get pissed off and call me a faggot or you can take what I have said and use it in a constructive way. I hope to see how you are doing in the future. Aside from the sometimes interrupting Wolf, I completely disagree. I'd say Khaldor is one of my favorite casters. I always make sure to watch events Khaldor is casting. I also think that Khaldor + Wolf is definitely my favorite combo ^^ Keep up the great work, Khaldor, I've really been enjoying your casts lately! | ||
|
dgwow
Canada1024 Posts
On February 19 2012 15:40 ShiniSama wrote: I'm sure I will be flamed for this, but I must say it. First of all I am not saying this to try to be an asshole or anything I am truly trying to help your casting. I will start with the things that bug me the most. You tend to talk over everyone you cast with, especially in times of action. You are always talking over wolf when I am watching the GSL and he doesn't ever get to say much until you are finally done with your rant (I say rant for lack of better word). Another thing, that many people have already said, is when you raise your voice your pitch goes up like crazy. I am not even sure if you play the game at all from your casts, and I am saying that because it just doesn't seem like you are very analytical. When you are analyzing or making a prediction of a game you are often wrong or not very close. To sum everything up: A lot of my friends, and I, mute the stream when you're casting. A lot of these problems can be fixed by practice and playing the game a little more to get a better understanding of it. Again I know that this sounds a little harsh, but I'm sure as you know you can either get pissed off and call me a faggot or you can take what I have said and use it in a constructive way. I hope to see how you are doing in the future. I'm pretty sure Khaldor is master league in north america and was masters in europe, he's like plat in KR or something.. so he must have a decent understanding of the game. Ditto towards the other comments | ||
|
ShiniSama
United States103 Posts
| ||
|
SovSov
United States755 Posts
| ||
| ||
