EPTPainUser & HD Casting Feedback Thread! - Page 29
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Sky101
United States1758 Posts
| ||
|
EtherealDeath
United States8366 Posts
If anything that is extremely rare following a stargate opener, as it will delay the push substantially and allow the zerg enough time to be maxed out or have hydra/infestor or whatever other defensive route they take. It seemed quite clear he was just going straight into mass gate, without the immortals. There were some other instances as well, but I can't really remember them cause I didn't write them down or take mental not of them, but I think your Protoss knowledge could use some updating. I do like your casting though  | ||
|
HoMM
Estonia636 Posts
On April 09 2012 12:58 ravenKRaz wrote: you guys are really good casters, i don't know where the hate comes from T_T; except nestea and squirtle don't understand english.. It's much easier to understand a language and what is said, than to speak it. It's pretty safe to assume that they understand english reasonably well, and would be able at least understand some of the stuff that is said, as they know all of the important words (such as all sc2 terms in english too). | ||
|
PopcornColonel
United States769 Posts
Ignore reddit, you did just fine. | ||
|
bellz
United States20 Posts
| ||
|
Mrvoodoochild1
United States1439 Posts
On April 09 2012 13:18 PopcornColonel wrote: There has been a TON of negative feedback, particularly on reddit... And I believe that was a little bit uncalled for. You guys did as good a job as any non-day9/husky/tastless/artosis level caster would have, if not better. Ignore reddit, you did just fine. You are either trolling or oblivious to what makes a good caster if you believe your post. Painuser is a decent caster but HD is horrible. Saying that these two are anywhere near the likes of Tasteless/Artosis/Day9 is crazy. User was warned for this post | ||
|
Sinensis
United States2513 Posts
Seriously think of the worst thing your mother/girlfriend/boyfriend/someone who doesn't understand esports could possibly ask you: It's "Are you winning?" | ||
|
Vaelom
Korea (South)154 Posts
-But the things im a bit effy about is Taylor (Painuser) seems to do more studying of the game, players, meta, etc. Compared to you. And thats where its seem to have a casters imbalance! ^^ keep on casting you2 !! | ||
|
awu25
United States2003 Posts
On April 09 2012 13:18 PopcornColonel wrote: There has been a TON of negative feedback, particularly on reddit... And I believe that was a little bit uncalled for. You guys did as good a job as any non-day9/husky/tastless/artosis level caster would have, if not better. Ignore reddit, you did just fine. You're right, your opinion overrules the TON of feedback from a different community A lot of the criticism is valid and that is what he is asking for | ||
|
SexyBimbo
Germany89 Posts
Also there seemed to be more technical errors during your casts, too, but I don't think you are to be held responsible for that. And, but that may just be me, I didn't find you especially funny either. SB | ||
|
mrhobbers
109 Posts
| ||
|
NachiMe
250 Posts
| ||
|
provrorsbarn
Sweden766 Posts
Youre roles as casters was also a bit confusing and you guys didnt really have a nice "flow", both of you had the same caster "role" and took turns talking...... IMO have HD do most of the play-by-play and then use Painuser as the "analyser-expert"....So HD talks alot about whats going on and then throws it to Pain if he wants to know something particular....just like any other caster-duo that has ever been created in sports etc...... | ||
|
Vei
United States2845 Posts
| ||
|
Capulet
Canada686 Posts
On April 09 2012 13:18 PopcornColonel wrote: There has been a TON of negative feedback, particularly on reddit... And I believe that was a little bit uncalled for. You guys did as good a job as any non-day9/husky/tastless/artosis level caster would have, if not better. Ignore reddit, you did just fine. The OP is a caster who wants genuine feedback so he can improve his casting, so the negative feedback is necessary. I think HD's articulation and just general ability to speak is great. One of the best. I'm neutral about the side chit-chat, on one hand it get's carried away sometimes, on the other it shows personality and character. However, the content is outright terrible. A lot of the things says are just wrong with a few exaggerated miscalls. While I appreciate the enthusiasm, sometimes there is overreaction and overemphasis on things that are just trivial. eg: "Doing devastating damage!!" - when in reality only the shields from a bunch of buildings have been taken out eg: "Player X has a HUGE lead!" - when in reality supplies are just about even. The potential is there. I just feel like HD needs to get a deeper understanding of the game. Being a color commentator does not mean being allowed to say things that are incorrect. Just my $0.02 Edit: Painuser is overall a good commentator. Nothing bad to say about him. | ||
|
arfyron
518 Posts
| ||
|
ClanRH.TV
United States462 Posts
Good job. | ||
|
Mr.Ch4rms
Canada84 Posts
| ||
|
Vei
United States2845 Posts
On April 09 2012 14:01 ClanRH.TV wrote: I love how there are so many individuals commenting yet I'm sure not 1% of the people giving negative comments could perform nearly as good as either of these two.... Honestly, your calls were quite accurate and I think the people critisizing really don't know two shits about casting on a live stage. Good job. while i agree that in cases of like, criticizing an athlete (including e-athletes) you need to be able to perform yourself, in order to have truly poignant criticism, i think ANYONE can criticize an entertainer, because basically, everyone is "equally" good in terms of their importance of being entertained. | ||
|
n0ah
United States250 Posts
Also, smack whoever was in charge of the camera's during the games. Holy wow, showing the audience in the middle of an engagement?! Yeah, that's a good idea... -__- | ||
| ||
