|
On April 17 2010 16:51 Boundz(DarKo) wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2010 16:49 eSen1a wrote:On April 17 2010 16:44 Scorch wrote:
To be quite frank, things would probably be more fair if everyone with <50 posts was auto-crossed off the list. There's certainly lots of them who won't even read this until Monday, and they don't have this sense of solidarity towards TL which would make them regret it if noone got a key. Also, there was already a wave of keys given to deserving new posters. i feel the same way (one of reasons why i took back my nomination) i am a member of another site, for 4 years (not going to say) that had some beta key giveaways and all the keys went to fake duplicate accounts made that day for the competition i was dissapointed that the real community (not just myself) did not get anything back for the time they put in, so i finally signed up here so yes i totally agree with you This is why the people who desires to get their names crossed over will get the keys. Proves that they are actually real accounts that are active. No, I don't have any source on this. I bring my epic theories to the table.
it clearly says
"3. You won't get a key. "
i believe the point of the competition is for everyone to agree who is most deserving
|
i wish i could have one 
|
Just cuz I have less than 50 posts doesn't mean much since I've been a member here longer than the beta has been out, and I've been keeping an eye on team liquid for years. I haven't posted much until recently, the better plan would be the remove accounts made after a certain date, hardly post count should be the different maker.
I shoudl qualify that by saying IF ANYTHING, that should be the case, but this plan works. Due to people that are solidly stating that they will nto remove themselves, we have already assured that nobody will be getting keys. All this means is we will be able to visibly see who will lose just a little bit of dignity and respect within the community.
|
Woah this is crazy! Will anyone get a key? we shall see!
|
On April 17 2010 16:50 GoodCat1 wrote:i'll go with the reverse psycology  and i'll never eliminate myself haha
That's not reverse psychology dude. Do you really think you are more deserving than most of the other people on the list?
|
On April 17 2010 16:54 madnessman wrote:I really can't see all the <50 posters opting-out. In the end, the selfless and deserving ones aren't going to get keys while some of the <50 posters are going to get their key and leave. Realistically, none of the <50 posters are probably going to even see this thread before the deadline and nobody from here will get the key. Show nested quote +On April 17 2010 16:35 ZlaSHeR wrote:On April 17 2010 16:20 madnessman wrote:On April 17 2010 16:17 maareek wrote:On April 17 2010 16:08 madnessman wrote:
Yo does nobody care about my suggestion? We can 1/2 the size of the list by sharing a key with someone who plays at a different time then you! Sharing keys is against Blizzard's rules. Doesn't even remotely make sense for TL to do something blatantly out of line according to the company providing them with the keys. Not to mention every thing else that's impractical with sharing keys. Oh just kidding. I didn't know it was against Blizzard's rules. I probably should've guessed it though. Now you know, and you still stay in ;3 shows more and more telling signs about your personality. I'll leave once I know it means I'm helping someone more deserving than me get the key. The truth is, I want a key just as much as you do. That's why we're both still on the list.
its kinda sad that you say that because i lurk on TL from 2008
i just don't like to talk alot.
|
On April 17 2010 15:01 Hot_Bid wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2010 14:58 lolaloc wrote:
I don't want to withdraw. I am firm with my decision to obtain one extra key for the purpose of boosting our local StarCraft scene just at least a bit. what if I told you that refusing to withdraw blacklists you from all future beta key give aways just kidding OR AM I
AHAHAHA. Too good.
|
Kau
Canada3500 Posts
On April 17 2010 16:44 Scorch wrote:
To be quite frank, things would probably be more fair if everyone with <50 posts was auto-crossed off the list. There's certainly lots of them who won't even read this until Monday, and they don't have this sense of solidarity towards TL which would make them regret it if noone got a key. Also, there was already a wave of keys given to deserving new posters.
I believe the list that Hot_Bid is using is from this
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=119965¤tpage=2
Now, this list does not contain everyone who self-nominated. Kennigit did specify that self-nominations were completely legit, if you thought you were deserving. So it ticked me off that all these undeserving people (mainly "everyone with <50 posts", as you say) self nominated. Of course you could have more posts and still be undeserving, so I tried to include those people too. The problem, however, is that I don't know everyone and what they've done, where they've helped out, stuff like that, so that's why I added that blurb at the top of my post. Anyways, I think it's completely fair that everyone with <50 posts remain on that list, because that's what that list is about. Again, I apologize for any self-nominees that were caught in my line of fire.
On April 17 2010 16:36 Cheree wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2010 16:33 {88}iNcontroL wrote:On April 17 2010 16:13 Cheree wrote:On April 17 2010 16:01 {88}iNcontroL wrote:
Btw: None of them will get any keys because NO WAY are there that many selfless people from THIS group. Let's say we can look into the future and we know that by nominating ourselves, we would win a key. It's as good as getting a beta invite from blizzard for doing jack shit. You don't see the latter person giving away their key, do you? Why should the person who nominated themselves step down? Stepping down is like giving up a beta key. The people nominating themselves as as selfish as the people who opted in and used their keys for their own play instead of giving it to someone more deserving. Oh, I'm sorry. People who got beta keys from blizzard and used it for themselves aren't selfish, they're lucky. Hey You can be as bitter as you want. But a thread asking for nominations for people that deserve a beta key resulting in 151 people with MOSTLY <50 posts nominating themselves is friggin hilarious. You can get angry at the cosmos for everyone who went through blizzard and was selfish enough to use the beta key they got on themselves.. that's fine if you wanna do that. I'ma sit here and watch this unfold! Lol, I'm not angry. I just don't think the people calling these guys out are any less selfish on the whole. General statement, not targetting you. Hypocrisy irritates me.
How are people that are calling these guys out not less selfish. If two people are almost exactly the same, same thoughts, same personalities, what have you, and one goes out and actually self nominates whereas the other thinks it's better not to. You're saying that one is not less selfish than the other?
|
On April 17 2010 16:56 Scorch wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2010 16:50 GoodCat1 wrote:i'll go with the reverse psycology and i'll never eliminate myself haha That's not reverse psychology dude. Do you really think you are more deserving than most of the other people on the list?
no i don't,but life isn't always fair...
like how the wow kids who get a beta key and don't even use it.
|
double post (dammit i quoted myself instead of editing @#$!#@!)
|
My only chances are random drawings and facebook crapola! Why can't my opt in from like a year ago and playing SC growing up count for something WHY!!!!!!!!!!! lol.
I must keep trying!
|
On April 17 2010 16:57 GoodCat1 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 17 2010 16:54 madnessman wrote:I really can't see all the <50 posters opting-out. In the end, the selfless and deserving ones aren't going to get keys while some of the <50 posters are going to get their key and leave. Realistically, none of the <50 posters are probably going to even see this thread before the deadline and nobody from here will get the key. On April 17 2010 16:35 ZlaSHeR wrote:On April 17 2010 16:20 madnessman wrote:On April 17 2010 16:17 maareek wrote:On April 17 2010 16:08 madnessman wrote:
Yo does nobody care about my suggestion? We can 1/2 the size of the list by sharing a key with someone who plays at a different time then you! Sharing keys is against Blizzard's rules. Doesn't even remotely make sense for TL to do something blatantly out of line according to the company providing them with the keys. Not to mention every thing else that's impractical with sharing keys. Oh just kidding. I didn't know it was against Blizzard's rules. I probably should've guessed it though. Now you know, and you still stay in ;3 shows more and more telling signs about your personality. I'll leave once I know it means I'm helping someone more deserving than me get the key. The truth is, I want a key just as much as you do. That's why we're both still on the list. its kinda sad that you say that because i lurk on TL from 2008 i just don't like to talk alot.
I guess I'm unfairly grouping all the super low post count people together. Obviously there are a bunch of lurkers who signed up so they wouldn't miss out on a competition but a bunch of super low post count people obviously just joined TL for this 'competition'.
EDIT: I un-nominate myself. Please take me off the list.
|
FREEAGLELAND26780 Posts
On April 17 2010 16:54 EmeraldSparks wrote:
Is 48 hours enough? What if some people don't see the thread?
Wait, you're saying that upstanding self-nominees that follow TL religiously but lurk in the shadows might not see this thread?
Also this is starting to devolve very fast. O Hot_Bid, what hast thou doneth?
|
Oh my god i love this.... Only because i already have a beta key, otherwise i would hate you so much right now
|
On April 17 2010 16:58 Kau wrote:
How are people that are calling these guys out not less selfish. If two people are almost exactly the same, same thoughts, same personalities, what have you, and one goes out and actually self nominates whereas the other thinks it's better not to. You're saying that one is not less selfish than the other?
Granted, not all the people who are calling these guys out fall under the two umbrellas I'm about to draw...
I'm saying there's no difference in selfishness between:
People who got lucky with a beta key invite from blizzard AND decided they're the most deserving person to have it by registering their key.
VS
A person nominating themselves, claiming they are the most deserving person to get the beta.
The only difference I see is that one group is acting on their selfishness behind closed doors and the other group is showing it in public.
|
Is nice to know your not worth it XD but hey like I said i'll be happy if some deserving ppl get it even if isn't me =D, come on guys get on agreement and share accounts if in the same city
|
On April 17 2010 16:01 {88}iNcontroL wrote:
I have to say.. this was the coolest fucking thing I have ever seen TL do. I'm not even kidding. This is like Saw 6 or some shit.. fucking amazing.
Btw: None of them will get any keys because NO WAY are there that many selfless people from THIS group.
But to all those that step down: I applaud you.
To respond to this, you realise Inc that the OP said that this was a list of self nominatees that the admins thought worthy of consideration, so spare us the scorn just because we don't post as much or whatever. Some of us love this shit but still have other shit to do, so we don't contribute as much, doesn't mean we dont appreciate the game or whatever. It's called being part of the masses lol, I'm ok with it and stop hating on me for being a fan of a game and a site that you are a massive part of etc etc
|
Given that only 10 keys have been allocated to nominees TOTAL, and less than 10 are even considered being given to self-nominators, I don't see any chance of enough self-nominators pulling out so that anyone gets anything.
|
On April 17 2010 16:44 Scorch wrote:
To be quite frank, things would probably be more fair if everyone with <50 posts was auto-crossed off the list. There's certainly lots of them who won't even read this until Monday, and they don't have this sense of solidarity towards TL which would make them regret it if noone got a key. Also, there was already a wave of keys given to deserving new posters.
So because I created my account when I got into Husky's and HD's youtube casts and haven't found anything to post my "knowledge" in i should be undeserving of a beta key. (BTW I opted in on day one) Personally I'd rather not spam a forum with useless dribble trying to up my post count just to make me look like I have been active. When in reality all you have to do is look at when the user name has been log in last, or at minimum, the IP. (sorry to get off topic here, but Scorch seems to be a bit mad that anyone here can just nominate them selves and get a beta key, when he didn't get one in the "I've been here forever" category.)
|
United States47024 Posts
On April 17 2010 16:54 EmeraldSparks wrote:
Is 48 hours enough? What if some people don't see the thread?
Too bad, then.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
