EPTReally unimpressed with City for now. They can't pass the midfield and they're receiving counters very easily. I don't get why Silva doesn't get back to help, there's a big distance between him and the 2 others.
2018 - 2019 Football Thread - Page 168
| Forum Index > Sports |
|
WillyWanker
France1915 Posts
Really unimpressed with City for now. They can't pass the midfield and they're receiving counters very easily. I don't get why Silva doesn't get back to help, there's a big distance between him and the 2 others. | ||
|
sneirac
Germany3464 Posts
1-0 https://streamja.com/XLbz 2-0 https://streamable.com/23p9p Tottenham Hotspur v Manchester City var handball https://www.clippituser.tv/c/qkarbn Aguero pen https://streamja.com/wmV1 1-0 https://streamja.com/23b6 | ||
|
sharkie
Austria18763 Posts
Klopp has learned so much | ||
|
sneirac
Germany3464 Posts
On April 10 2019 04:27 Bacillus wrote: Do you think the penalty call was correct? It's always really debatable with these sliding tackle/falling down/whatever type of situations where you can't really have your arms sticking to your body completely. To me it looked like Rose didn't make himself that much bigger considering the circumstances, but it really depends on the camera angle and all that. Arm is over his head and blocking a shot on goal, I hate calls like this because it seems incidental/reasonable arm poistion, but you just can't have people getting away with blocking shots on goal away from their body. It really becomes a debate what arm position is far enough and how much of it is intent. We apparently really need that black and white rule where any handball is a foul, regardless of intent or exact position, so the discussion goes away/calls finally are consistent. | ||
|
sneirac
Germany3464 Posts
| ||
|
Dav1oN
Ukraine3164 Posts
| ||
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
On April 10 2019 04:37 sharkie wrote: Liverpool is prolly the most balanced team of the last few years no? Klopp has learned so much Well they are no where near as attacking as they were and defend way deeper and better now. If that is balanced for you then yes that is true, but they are very much a more defensive side than offensive now. The last 2 games are literally the only time Scouse have played a more offensive midfield having Keita in it, normally they play 3 holding midfielders xd | ||
|
WillyWanker
France1915 Posts
Really dumb from Delph. Raising his hand for the offside, losing focus, while with VAR they should know referees can't raise their flag until the offense has concluded anyway... | ||
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
| ||
|
sharkie
Austria18763 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 10 2019 04:38 sneirac wrote: Arm is over his head and blocking a shot on goal, I hate calls like this because it seems incidental/reasonable arm poistion, but you just can't have people getting away with blocking shots on goal away from their body. It really becomes a debate what arm position is far enough and how much of it is intent. We apparently really need that black and white rule where any handball is a foul, regardless of intent or exact position, so the discussion goes away/calls finally are consistent. I agree, but until then. I think var intervening on a 50/50 subjective type call is also not right. On April 10 2019 05:39 WillyWanker wrote: Really dumb from Delph. Raising his hand for the offside, losing focus, while with VAR they should know referees can't raise their flag until the offense has concluded anyway... I dont get how he is still on that team. And dude talks the most shit apparantly in team meetings and stuff about being switched on and not doing the basics.. | ||
|
Pandemona
Charlie Sheens House51493 Posts
https://streamable.com/l1cv4 Salah does this, VAR does not look at it, referee does not even give a foul nor yellow card. For me and my anti Liverpool agenda its a clear red, but ofc thats me :D | ||
|
sharkie
Austria18763 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
Edit: Wouldnt give him a red though. Yellow would be fine because I sense minor petulance there but no intent to really hurt the guy. Its from the Gilberto Silva school of just foul enough to not get seriously censured. | ||
|
sneirac
Germany3464 Posts
| ||
|
Deleted User 173346
16169 Posts
| ||
|
Rebs
Pakistan10726 Posts
On April 10 2019 06:19 sneirac wrote: Someone on reddit argued that Salah is off balance due to being held and that causes the foul, however should it not be called for foul on porto then? As it stands with foul called against Salah, but no card and no review just feels weird Yeah my Liverpool fan friend said the same. And there is a pretty good case for the tug being a foul, but I dont buy the rest of it. He has enough balance to not do that. I think he got a frustrated and got a lick in, he just didnt mean to hurt the guy so its one of those where you just dont try to avoid the contact rather than try to actually stamp. | ||
|
nayumi
Australia6499 Posts
On April 10 2019 06:01 Pandemona wrote: DEBATE TIME!!! https://streamable.com/l1cv4 Salah does this, VAR does not look at it, referee does not even give a foul nor yellow card. For me and my anti Liverpool agenda its a clear red, but ofc thats me :D it didn't get a second look because Danilo was man enough to not start screaming immediately afterwards... had this been Neymar, Salah would have had a manslaughter charge laid up on him ... but i agree that was a reckless challenge assuming there was no ill-intention there, a yellow is the very least he should have received | ||
|
Bacillus
Finland2120 Posts
Edit: Speaking of Delph, who are the left back options for City right now? Mendy had that late nightclubbing thingy Guardiola probably doesn't appreciate at all. After that there's Zinchenko (sidelined with small injury) or Delph I guess. That doesn't sound ideal at all for Guardiola football. | ||
|
Harris1st
Germany7435 Posts
On April 10 2019 13:15 Bacillus wrote: They seem really reclutant to call in VAR review unless it's a clear cut red. I guess it's a bit awkward to review something for minutes only to hand out a yellow or nothing at all. Edit: Speaking of Delph, who are the left back options for City right now? Mendy had that late nightclubbing thingy Guardiola probably doesn't appreciate at all. After that there's Zinchenko (sidelined with small injury) or Delph I guess. That doesn't sound ideal at all for Guardiola football. VAR is only used for game changing decisions. A potential (first) yellow isn't quite on the level of red card/ goal. At least that's what they told us in Germany. | ||
| ||
