EPTAnd it doesn't even matter, because IdrA made him look like a complete noob the next day anyways...
[R] Where can i find the replay of MLG idra vs huk - Page 4
| Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments |
|
1Eris1
United States5797 Posts
And it doesn't even matter, because IdrA made him look like a complete noob the next day anyways... | ||
|
AtrumX
United States17 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i56.tinypic.com/2upcxo7.jpg) | ||
|
ribboo
Sweden1842 Posts
On April 05 2011 01:47 Eppa! wrote: I just hope that MLG learns from this, Huk should have been DQ because of manners. He clearly broke the rules. Chat should be prohibited for just this reason. BM has no place in Esports. Idra was quite rude but you need to follow rules. He should've been dq'd back @ "tahts halo" then. Didn't see any complaints at that time. | ||
|
Diamond
United States10796 Posts
No conspiracy theory, just logistics  . | ||
|
Ownos
United States2147 Posts
| ||
|
IPA
United States3206 Posts
Also, HuK is one of the most incoherent typists in the history of esports. I've seen Koreans with better english typing skills. | ||
|
1Lamb1Rice
United States435 Posts
On April 05 2011 03:16 Ownos wrote: Lol people are faulting Huk for telling Idra he made a mistake leaving early last game? Idra fan-boys. -.- They're faulting him for in game chatting when you're not allowed to. | ||
|
Aeneous
United States27 Posts
| ||
|
Telenil
France484 Posts
Idra had just left to hallucinations. I can see HuK being baffled by that and mentionning it at the beginning of the game. Which was not necessarily the smartest thing to do, but I'm pretty sure insulting your opponents after they've won really is against the rules... | ||
|
getSome[703]
United States753 Posts
On April 04 2011 00:40 ZerganicChem wrote: All you really need to know is Idra played like a noob, lost like a noob, then cried like a noob like he always does. User was temp banned for this post. And then proceeded to rape Huk 3-0 the next day | ||
|
tyrless
United States485 Posts
and no of course there shouldn't be any penalty, this isn't Borecraft | ||
Whitewing
United States7483 Posts
On April 04 2011 17:21 Vorenius wrote: How on earth can people consider this BM from Idra?! If anything HuK should have been given an official warning or possible been DQ'd. Talking in-game is against MLG rules for this exact reason. Now I can understand they don't go after everyone saying some random thing but this was specifically meant to provoke Idra and influence the game. This just confirms the image I had of HuK as a douche. Because IdrA BM's everyone on a regular basis, and consistently leaves games without any form of good sportsmanship. If HuK had done that to anyone else it would be completely innappropriate, but when he does it to IdrA, it's just a reasonable reaction. | ||
|
mr.reee
121 Posts
| ||
|
GambleVII
126 Posts
On April 04 2011 17:21 Vorenius wrote: How on earth can people consider this BM from Idra?! If anything HuK should have been given an official warning or possible been DQ'd. Talking in-game is against MLG rules for this exact reason. Now I can understand they don't go after everyone saying some random thing but this was specifically meant to provoke Idra and influence the game. This just confirms the image I had of HuK as a douche. WHy should that not be allowed? What real sport does not allow chirping? If you wanna be taken as a real sport. allow chirping. If you can throw someone off their game because of what you say.. then there not mentaly strong. | ||
|
Paperplane
Netherlands1823 Posts
| ||
|
HighC
United States12 Posts
| ||
|
MoreFaSho
United States1427 Posts
On April 05 2011 03:01 ribboo wrote: He should've been dq'd back @ "tahts halo" then. Didn't see any complaints at that time. You weren't listening, there were complaints about chatting in-game like that. I don't personally have an issue with it, but I think players should avoid chatting once the game is actually going. I also love how people love to use the defense of "nobody complained when X happened" for eSports. Most of eSports is on the internet, on the internet people complain about EVERYTHING. | ||
|
Angelbelow
United States3728 Posts
On April 05 2011 06:13 GambleVII wrote: WHy should that not be allowed? What real sport does not allow chirping? If you wanna be taken as a real sport. allow chirping. If you can throw someone off their game because of what you say.. then there not mentaly strong. It doesnt matter what you believe. It doesnt matter if I agree or disagree with you. The current rules are in placed and should be enforced. Just like what happened to LiquidTyler. And btw, in "real sports" there are still penalty points and technicals given out for excessive trash talk. So your argument here is rather weak. | ||
|
lifecanwait
96 Posts
IdrA has proven more than many times he's not capable of doing that. He cannot control his temper. In the situation above, I don't see how HuK's comment should have been too much offensively. It wasn't professional either, but IdrA's answer "Fuck off" was just hilarious and in fact an insult. Btw for all you IdrA fans: This has nothing to do with talent. Obviously he is not a bad player, when you play 24/7 and don't do anything else you shouldn't be. But some sort of principles should be bewared or your repuation will clearly suffer.. | ||
|
warmus
United Kingdom196 Posts
Saying that huk should off been dq'd is simply wrong, as idra typed back. It absolutely does not matter that huk started the convo, as both of them egaged in the "chat". This is also probably the reason why MLG decided to just run on with the game, no point in restarting if both of them were talking. If only huk were to talk, then it would probably be a forfeit. Idra surely is well aware of the MLG rules, and when huk started the chat, Idra could of paused the game and refferred back to the rules. Instead, he chose to type back fuck off, at which point there is nothing to talk about in terms of huk getting dq'd. Second point. Fact of the matter is, on paper clearly Idra was the douche. Doesnt take a rocket scientist to figure out some specifics. Huk started typing, and as he was typing the "it was halluc" or wtvr idra already typed in the fuck you. As huk read it he says "LOL". He was not expecting this answer and then he is like "im just saying, u didnt lose". How do u make that out to be that huk is a douche and idra was right is beyond me. True, perhaps the whole point was to get a little edge over idra in g3, but its nowhere near as BM as how idra talks bout huk all day every day, and it wasnt typed in a "i am rubbing this in your face" manner at all. Besides, has any1 ever seen huk over the past few months actually BM in game any1 at all, especially at GSL/ other turneys? No you havent, because he doesnt do it. If you honestly feel like idra was justified in saying fuck off to him in a televised game, or that huk should of been dq ur sad. Idra is a great player, probably more polished than huk, but for crying out loud stop being such one sided fanboys. Other than a great player, he is also a big douche. No other player in the world says bad stuff about other players other then him. Justified or not, it just seems silly to me, and makes me look at him as a great player, but even as a bigger wanna be "badass" nerd, which he just cant pull off, and ends up being a crybaby. (TSL my favorite example) EDIT: There are a few guys that do talk bad of their opponents on rare occasions like mc and......mmmmm well and him, but MC never talks bad about a person who he knows he can lose to (big difference between him and idra) | ||
| ||
