EPTOn November 22 2006 09:10 Jathin wrote:
I would put Reach above IPXZerg. Other than that I agree with everything.
I would put Reach above IPXZerg. Other than that I agree with everything.
Agree.
Power Rank 11/21/2006 - Page 7
| Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
|
Guybrush
Spain4744 Posts
Agree. | ||
|
Myxomatosis
United States2392 Posts
1. sAviOr[gm] 2. [ReD]NaDa 3. AnyTime..[gm] 4. Midas[gm] 5. s.s.m~[SiLvEr] 6. Nal_rA 7. JJu 8. GoodFriend 9 or 10: pick 2 out of Iris, GGPlay, Bisu, Sea edited when put a little more thought into it. I like this feature, and I appreciate the actual explanations. They went a lot further than the humor. | ||
|
Alborz
Canada1551 Posts
awesome | ||
|
omgbnetsux
United States3749 Posts
On November 22 2006 14:56 ManaBlue wrote: DJ isn't jesus and the list isn't the bible. Blasphemy! | ||
|
GaG[SharKy]
New Zealand221 Posts
On November 22 2006 15:31 Myxomatosis wrote: How I would power rank ATM: 1. sAviOr[gm] 2. [ReD]NaDa 3. AnyTime..[gm] 4. Midas[gm] 5. Sea[Shield] 6. Bisu[Shield] 7. Nal_rA 8. GoRush 9. GGPlay 10. GoodFriend I like this feature, and I appreciate the actual explanations. They went a lot further than the humor. i appreciate this list, its probably what i would go with aswel. | ||
|
DarK]N[exuS
China1441 Posts
 | ||
|
Myxomatosis
United States2392 Posts
On November 22 2006 19:56 DarK]N[exuS wrote: Not sure if Tossgirl would get #1 ranking based on fellatio Perhaps Hery[Hyo] would (I've always wondered how he gets to start for SKT1).... | ||
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
I really like the speculation about anytime... maybe it's because I'm a toss user, but he really DID play better throughout the tourney. In all, I really like the concept of the power rank. Keep it up! | ||
|
a-game
Canada5102 Posts
don't take quotes from two different threads dumbfuck EDIT: haha, that was harsh, but really why would someone deliberately patch together two comments from two different threads? it seemed like you went out of your way to spotlight my incongruities. | ||
ManaBlue
Canada10458 Posts
On November 22 2006 21:15 Myxomatosis wrote: Perhaps Hery[Hyo] would (I've always wondered how he gets to start for SKT1).... He's on KTF. And considering how awful their proleague performance has been, it doesn't seem to matter who starts for them. | ||
|
Ilikestarcraft
Korea (South)17733 Posts
This is cool feature and congrats Dj. | ||
|
tfeign
United States2980 Posts
Anytime above Nada = laugh. I guess having a 10+ winning streak vs zerg, 3-0 Reach in Superfight main event, going far in MSL while placing #1 in OSL in the same seasons, and winning the first ever golden mouse isn't as good as some #2 OSL toss who hasn't done anything in a year, with nothing accomplished in MSL. Sea[shield] top 5 = disgusting. He's doesn't even belong in top 10, let alone top 5. He has done absolutely nothing that warrants him a higher spot than guys like Nal_rA, Jju, and others. GGPlay #6 = outrageous. GGPlay is one of the only bright spots on the Hanbit Proleague roster, providing his team with numerous victories in what would have otherwise been dismal performances Argue with this pick all you want, but GGPlay has shown flat-out amazing ZvT and ZvZ as of late. There’s no shame in losing to Anytime 1-2. He’s also anchored his team in the Proleague for a very long time. While guys like Silver is nowhere on the list; who, conveniently, is the MVP of Proleague. Proleague-performance-wise, Silver is miles ahead of GGPlay. Individual-league-performance-wise, he leaves GGPlay far in the dust. Oh well, I guess being MVP of Proleague and winning top 2 MSL gets less attention than a guy who has accomplished nothing in individual league and far less in proleague as of late. Gorush #7 is another out-of-nowhere pick. #7 for getting to ro8? There are literally a ton of guys who have accomplished the same thing, plus more, in recent memories. Yet no where mentioned. Bisu - Read above [Gorush] And Nal_rA, gosh, where do I even start. Nal_Ra – This is my final controversial choice, but I’m going to ask you to cast aside your love for all things cheesy for just a moment and consider a few things: Ra would have been eliminated from his MSL group if Boxer had not had to go into the military. Ra did not make the last OSL. Ra cannot qualify for the coming OSL. KTF is in last place in the Proleague. Making it into the semifinals of the MSL by virtue of a gift and losing 1-3 to Savior is nice and all, but putting him any higher than #9 would be an affront to all the players that have qualified for multiple leagues and actually advanced by virtue of their own merit. So what if rA only qualified for 1 league? IPXzerg, your #1 player, never qualified for the last OSL, or the last last OSL, or the last last last OSL, or the last whatever number of OSLs there has been.... Anytime, your #2 player, never qualfied for the last MSL, or the last last MSL, or the last whatever number of MSLs there has been... You bring up nal_ra qualifying for one league but not another as a sign of his weakness. The fact is, out of the all the players you have up in the ranking, only NADA and MIDAS are the only players who qualified for both leagues. You blame KTF's bad placement in Proleague on rA? ...sigh......do you just look at KTF's bad placement in Proleague and just automatically blame it on rA? I mean seriously, what is this? rA hasn't played a single game for KTF in this Proleague season since their first ever series with MBC. KTF's bad placement in Proleague has nothing to do with Nal_rA Here are the facts: Nal_rA placed top 2 in the last MSL, while going far into OSL during same season. He made to the semifinals of the current MSL. The only player to have stopped rA from either advancing to the final or winning whole the league possibly two times in a row has been 1 name: Savior, the unbeatable zvp of all zerg. What if guys like Anytime were put in the same situation where they had to beat Savior in a bo5 in order to advance in OSL? Not to mention Chojja, who's been #1 on the Kespa ranking for months and is still holding the #2 spot, is nowhere on the list. Chojja - You are the most overrated progamer ever. Give me a ring when you a) start winning and b) crack the five-foot barrier. And don't cheat and use a phonebook I'm sorry, but you don't hold the #1 spot on Kespa for months and still retaining top 2 without winning a fuckload of games. No offense, but this power ranking list is complete joke as I see it. The Kespa ranking miles and miles ahead more accurate. I really don't see the point of having this list for a TL member to freely rank with his own biased views. If I want to see who's hot and who's not, I look at the Kespa rankings. This power ranking is so inaccurate in comparison to the official Kespa I can't see any reason why it's needed. There are so much stuff on there that's put in solely based by bias, player favoritism, lack of sense, and etc. Players here are getting unfair recognition due to bias. If TL really wants a power ranking, put up the top 10 Kespa players on there, and its members can discuss about the top 10 official players with their comments underneath. Best way to do it. | ||
|
KovacsFlorian
204 Posts
Anytime above Nada = laugh. I guess having a 10+ winning streak vs zerg, 3-0 Reach in Superfight main event, going far in MSL while placing #1 in OSL in the same seasons, and winning the first ever golden mouse isn't as good as some #2 OSL toss who hasn't done anything in a year, with nothing accomplished in MSL. ... While guys like Silver is nowhere on the list; who, conveniently, is the MVP of Proleague. Proleague-performance-wise, Silver is miles ahead of GGPlay. Individual-league-performance-wise, he leaves GGPlay far in the dust. Oh well, I guess being MVP of Proleague and winning top 2 MSL gets less attention than a guy who has accomplished nothing in individual league and far less in proleague as of late. True. In fact, although I don't like to admit it, tfeign is sooooo right. | ||
|
siro)
Australia848 Posts
I'm higher than etter in liquibet, omg let #1 better do the rankings  | ||
|
AyOnY
Pitcairn1026 Posts
| ||
|
SuperJongMan
Jamaica11586 Posts
Shut up Tfeign. Everyone beats Reach now. Chojja loses to everyone and he is on because he did have a hotstreak and he was overused in PL from a season ago. Second... I still think... Yellow Name is better than GoRush. He is the only one carrying through for OGN right now. Sea is all hype. Bisu is just as much hype. And.... Jju's always good but I still think GF or Iris would be a better #10. | ||
|
Vo-
United States435 Posts
Say what you must about Anytime. Before Anytime the last Protoss in an OSL final was Ra. It was PvP and same with the OSL final before that. The last toss to win an OSL in an non-mirror matchup was Reach against Boxer. 2002. The other Protoss victories are 2000 ( grrr... and garimto ). Besides the Protoss dominance era... It comes down to Reach and Anytime. Reach really did own Boxer. But to me, never really showed results. Anytime has proven himself in two OSL's. He's proved he can play PvZ and PvT in matches that count. He out-played NaDa. No debate. Period. He has shown that he can adapt to any strategy and that he can out strategize ( is that a word? ) any player. I don't see how anyone can argue Anytime is not one of the greatest Toss's to play the game. I believe he holds atleast the #2 spot. If it was my list, #1. Some random person's list... Top 3 ATLEAST. Just my 2 pennies. | ||
Manifesto7
Osaka27172 Posts
| ||
|
Red_Dragon
Croatia2862 Posts
 I have missed your posts Nice post, agreed with most of it. | ||
|
Beamo
France1279 Posts
On November 22 2006 23:39 tfeign wrote: Not to mention Chojja, who's been #1 on the Kespa ranking for months and is still holding the #2 spot, is nowhere on the list. I'm sorry, but you don't hold the #1 spot on Kespa for months and still retaining top 2 without winning a fuckload of games. I agree on parts of your post but as said before this is NOT Kespa ranking !! We don't care if Chojja had #1 Kespa spot for a while and now is second, the fact is he lost every single of his last games. Even if he did qualify for both leagues, he finished last of his OSL group and finished 3rd of his MSL group... He hasn't done anything in proleague lately either ! Chojja does not belong in a list of who is hot right now ! | ||
| ||
