EPT
But I take it I'm probably the only guy here who actually likes silver lolol
Power Rank 11/21/2006 - Page 11
| Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
|
QuietIdiot
7004 Posts
But I take it I'm probably the only guy here who actually likes silver lolol | ||
|
Orome
Switzerland11984 Posts
| ||
|
Orome
Switzerland11984 Posts
- rA at #9, rA might have almost failed to qualify for the second round, but he played very nice games after that, 2-0'ing fake Yellow and Xellos in convincing fashion. - GoRush at #7 seems pretty random, it's not like GoRush's achieved more than many other lately, he got into the quarters of OSL, wasn't in MSL, and barely plays in Proleague. - Sea[Shield] at #5, but Etter's always been in love with Sea, so I guess that one's understandable. ;p Overall I think you weigh OSL too much, and Proleague too little, all the progamers say that most of their practicing goes into Proleague, I believe it should be as important as the other two leagues for you. Nice feature. : ) | ||
|
tKd_
United States2916 Posts
| ||
|
QuietIdiot
7004 Posts
On November 26 2006 18:10 Orome wrote: Silver's just horrible. Did you watch his games? That's why I love him | ||
|
tKd_
United States2916 Posts
On November 22 2006 10:05 oj- wrote: savior's record vs oov is disgusting isn't it? like 8-1 or something rediculous? I don't understand what you're saying here hmm and for the record yeah the list maybe biased but DJetter knows what he's talking about good feature. edit: but he is a smartass I think it was that many people voted oov when in fact there were tons of threads where savior was 7-0 vs oov. also it is pretty frightening to see how midas and xellos were at the bottom when midas was 2-3 savior and xellos is in savior's team, thus knowing his game a little better. Of course I voted casy  | ||
|
Orome
Switzerland11984 Posts
1. IPXZerg 2. Anytime[gm] 3. Nada 4. Midas 5. GGPlay 6. Nal_rA 7 Sea[Shield] 8. Jju 9. Jaedong 10. Bisu[Shield] GoRush dropped out because he hasn't done anything other than play in OSL (he would be 11th though), GGPlay is in front of Sea because they both did the same in OSL, but GGPlay is absolutely amazing in Proleague and additionally, he beat Sea in the OSL. Nal_rA before Sea was a tough decision, him on #7 and Sea on #6 would be fine for me as well. Jju moved up two places because he's performed better in Proleague than Bisu, plus he was in the MSL semis, which I would weigh around the same as Bisu's quarter finals in the OSL. Jaedong is between them because he's been tearing up this Proleague season. If this doesn't make sense, it's because it's 3:52 am here. T_T And I'd like an answer please. ; ) | ||
Manifesto7
Osaka27179 Posts
| ||
|
well_made
Korea (South)4 Posts
On November 26 2006 15:34 Jathin wrote: Yep, mindless fanboi. The highlighted names have not performed well in the past few months. They're good and were incredible in their primes but as of late they have not been performing well. Edit: Except GoodFriend who got relatively far in the OSL, but undeservingly according to his play in the last OSL. iloveoov have done an incredible job at proleagues and that goes the same for xellos. july's force is just too good to be underestimated. and you should argue about jju not july. july at least won second place in wcg. what have jju done | ||
|
useLess
United States4781 Posts
| ||
|
Jathin
United States3505 Posts
| ||
|
Manifesto7
Osaka27179 Posts
On November 26 2006 19:40 useless wrote: How would we know when this is updated? It will be monthly, and the rankings will change + newspost. | ||
|
racebannon
Canada1225 Posts
I thought the forum had a good thing going now that people can appreciate gamers despite them not being on the holy list of current bandwagon material. I mean if you take away all the pedophiles and retards anyway So I'm tremendously sorry your new feature sucks in its current state but I can really only shit on things in their present and past forms, I can only speculate as to how much they will require shitting upon in the future, so here's to hoping it inspires the crusade against random people who play a video game for a living like the last time | ||
|
Amnesty
United States2054 Posts
Look at any Kespa thread, its riddled with ridicule. And its easy to see why. While this list isnt perfect, its better than kespas IMO. Thats because Kespas uses JUST ancient history (some of the players look severly out of place) and doesnt factor in any sort of potential. This lists uses more recent history and the authors opinion on the players potential. While yours or anyones opinion of a players of potential could backfire, what do you think progaming scouts use? Yet still, IMO i don't think this is feature worthy. However i think it's timely because i don't follow the leagues closely at all anymore. Only when its the quarters, semis, (Proleague, wtf is that) i play catch-up. So i think it would be nice to read this list when there isn't finals happening. | ||
|
toshi
Poland469 Posts
| ||
|
AlexanderTheGreat
Canada521 Posts
10. Bisu[Shield] Just my opinion here of whos hot atm. Great idea with the power ranking. | ||
|
fig_newbie
749 Posts
Do you guys realize how great a feature this is? I love the vision of the TL admins; they aren't content to let BW stagnate, theyre constantly being innovative and taking risks in pushing the boundaries of the game through the community. Consider, every single "good" sport (football, american football, basketball, baseball etc etc) has their own opinionated columnists who give their own feedback as to whose hot or not. One only has to look at a local newpaper or hell ESPN to find these power rankings or an opinionated dickhead that you either love or hate. And dont compare KESPA to this. KESPA has no soul, its just a completely objective computer formula that has no consideration of the backstory in every game. Its fucking boring. Give me a well written, opinonated power ranking any day. As for Etter's qualifications, Mani already stated the obvious flaw - Etter was not properly introduced as a "expert" to the scene. Nevertheless, I've found his insights to be very valid and I value his opinions, and even though I dont necessarily agree with all of them, he makes very good arguments for it, which is more than I can say for tfeigns unhealthy obsession with chojja. His abrasivness is obviously a way to polarize and fire up the masses. I love it. | ||
|
Myxomatosis
United States2392 Posts
On November 28 2006 09:17 AlexanderTheGreat wrote: 1. Savior 2. Nada 3. Anytime 4. Nal_ra 5. Midas 6. Goodfriend 7. Silver 8. JJU 9. GoRush 10. Bisu[Shield] Just my opinion here of whos hot atm. Great idea with the power ranking. Your list is actually very very valid. I like it a lot. Just not too sure about GoRush. | ||
jkillashark
United States5262 Posts
I would really like to see the Power Rankings spark intelligent debates whenever they come out. But right now I see some people putting intelligent input and the majority putting half assed one line disagreements. Show some respect to DJEtter and put some thought into your criticisms. | ||
|
SuperJongMan
Jamaica11586 Posts
Besides the man thinking Reach is #1 protoss, he's pretty good about what he does. | ||
| ||
