Ver isn't in his room because it is <60 degrees but the AC is on full blast. He will get back to me when he decides to brave his room again. If this takes a while (and I decide I need to go to sleep), LTT may have to do the night post when he wakes up in the morning.

Tricode

United States538 Posts

May 18 2009 07:07 GMT

#622

@L I really hope you are not just basing this whole thing on one line i said. I had other reasons such as i believe more skilled players would benefit us more then Nemy and such.

Try not to nit pick very specific parts to help your argument while you ignore the other parts of the arguments.

and who is this Triforce by the way ;p?

It's kinda funny (nice coincidence), cause that was the first name i was probably going to use when i was making a tl account.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

May 18 2009 07:07 GMT

#623

How is he punishing the town? Nemy played dumb, and in a game this level he got caught in a big lie.

Hence, he's very likely mafia.

Sorry but that's the way the cookie crumbles sometimes.

As for my trio, I don't know about those other 2 guys for sure but I'm innocent. Detectives should be checking Mynock, BC, Showtime! and Caller soon anyway.

Caller

Poland8075 Posts

May 18 2009 07:09 GMT

#624

On May 18 2009 16:07 Ace wrote:
How is he punishing the town? Nemy played dumb, and in a game this level he got caught in a big lie.

Hence, he's very likely mafia.

Sorry but that's the way the cookie crumbles sometimes.

As for my trio, I don't know about those other 2 guys for sure but I'm innocent. Detectives should be checking Mynock, BC, Showtime! and Caller soon anyway.

I suppose 0ez3c isn't there too? lol

Ace

United States16096 Posts

May 18 2009 07:10 GMT

#625

who? never heard of him.

Tricode

United States538 Posts

May 18 2009 07:10 GMT

#626

Who is Oez3c? Never heard of him.

Caller

Poland8075 Posts

May 18 2009 07:11 GMT

#627

gah i cant spell

Tricode

United States538 Posts

May 18 2009 07:12 GMT

#628

On May 18 2009 16:10 Ace wrote:
who? never heard of him.

Jinx

Caller

Poland8075 Posts

May 18 2009 07:12 GMT

#629

they can't check tonight by the way -_-

edit: if there is a mafia here, then mafia will likely not hit any of these people. Therefore, medics, you may not want to protect these people. If one or more of us is mafia, and mafia hits, the remaining dts will be able to check the rest and narrow it down. Thus, mafia is likely not going to hit the list to force town to use more role checks.

Canada4732 Posts

May 18 2009 07:22 GMT

#630

I really hope you are not just basing this whole thing on one line i said. I had other reasons such as i believe more skilled players would benefit us more then Nemy and such.

I'm not.

A number of players stated flat out that they believed that nemy was not mafia, yet voted against him, or swung votes at the last minute.

How is he punishing the town? Nemy played dumb, and in a game this level he got caught in a big lie.

If someone believes Nemy is innocent, but votes against him, they are doing so either out of spite, which a number of players did and admitted they did. Go read the tricode post.

Yeah a DT revealed that should have never revealed himself or just a traitor.

Somehow the fact that the DT played contrary to his view of how a DT should play makes it acceptable that we now have a DT in the open if he was correct.

Tricode

United States538 Posts

May 18 2009 07:53 GMT

#631

On May 18 2009 16:22 L wrote:

Show nested quote +

I'm not.

A number of players stated flat out that they believed that nemy was not mafia, yet voted against him, or swung votes at the last minute.

Show nested quote +

If someone believes Nemy is innocent, but votes against him, they are doing so either out of spite, which a number of players did and admitted they did. Go read the tricode post.

Show nested quote +

Somehow the fact that the DT played contrary to his view of how a DT should play makes it acceptable that we now have a DT in the open if he was correct.

Your number 1 problem is that you seem to fully believe he is DT.

Number 2 problem is i never voted for Nemy.

Number 3, Even if Nemy is innocent, there is a lot of us that are innocent! 23 to be exact.

number 4 what I did is not out of spite, it's more out of picking the best option IMO. It's like you care less about our skillful players that really help town get through the game to Nemy who just has a blue role...and that's even if he does have a blue role.

Number 5, this Nemy thing about him not being able to get into office is over. Get over it. Look to what we should do next.

Tricode

United States538 Posts

May 18 2009 07:54 GMT

#632

Did anyone else have trouble with being on the site just a moment ago? My net was working but it seemed like TL wouldn't respond and I was kinda kicked out for a bit.

Qatol

United States3165 Posts

May 18 2009 07:58 GMT

#633

On May 18 2009 16:54 Tricode wrote:
Did anyone else have trouble with being on the site just a moment ago? My net was working but it seemed like TL wouldn't respond and I was kinda kicked out for a bit.

TL was taken down for maintenance. There was an announcement about it posted briefly before it went down.

Tricode

United States538 Posts

May 18 2009 07:59 GMT

#634

On May 18 2009 16:58 Qatol wrote:

Show nested quote +

TL was taken down for maintenance. There was an announcement about it posted briefly before it went down.

Thanks.

Ace

United States16096 Posts

May 18 2009 08:37 GMT

#635

Hmm I must say for a pretty new player Tricode's thought process is pretty spot on. He just has a hard time making people understand him :'(.

Qatol

United States3165 Posts

May 18 2009 09:06 GMT

#636

[No Clue Area]
The town gathered amid much confusion as Ver thrust infinity21 into the town gallows. As he turned green the town collectively groaned.

Ver is now your Mayor and Ace is now your Pardoner.

If you have a night action for night 1 (medics, DTs, mafia), please send it to me. I will be moving to day again at 10:30 PM mountain time (GMT-6) Monday night if they are all in (~20 hours). If not, we will wait until Tuesday night at the latest.

HeavOnEarth

United States7087 Posts

May 18 2009 09:18 GMT

#637

wut

HeavOnEarth

United States7087 Posts

May 18 2009 09:19 GMT

#638

i guess the playing dumb mafia idea failed eh?

Canada4732 Posts

May 18 2009 09:19 GMT

#639

No, he doesn't. His posts are logically incoherent. The obvious deficiencies are most prominent in 1-3, 4 is a topic we've previously discussed. 5 is a complete dismissal which asks for something I asked for previously. I don't see why we can't talk about multiple things at once. Lets examine:

1- no I don't. I believe that the likeliness that he is is very high, but I'm not 100% sure of anyone. I have weighed the risks against the benefits and come to my conclusions that way.

2- Go look at my post. I never said you did. I said a number of people did, not you. What you did was state that he's either a DT or traitor, and that even if he is a dt that its irrelevant because he played poorly.

3- If Nemy is innocent, he is 99% likely to be a DT. There 'is' a lot of DTs. 2.

number 4 what I did is not out of spite, it's more out of picking the best option IMO. It's like you care less about our skillful players that really help town get through the game to Nemy who just has a blue role...and that's even if he does have a blue role.

4. Care about our skillful players? There are skillful players on both sides of the fence. Being skillful does not mean you are exempt from scrutiny. I care about the town's wellbeing, not the feelings of some players who have convinced the town that they are superior players.

So that's where we differ in our opinions, and I've laid out the divergence between our thinking before. Again, this is another instance of the "we're so good, so you must obey us" argument. Ace went as far as to say that he's immune to scrutiny because of his past performance in games. Does that even sound remotely logical from the point of view that Ver proposed in his first large post?

Number 5, this Nemy thing about him not being able to get into office is over. Get over it. Look to what we should do next.

Killing nemy and the quality of the people in office haven't magically disappeared. I specifically asked people to talk about who we should lynch, yet no one took that question up. If you're town, you want activity, yet this is portion of your post is a blatant "shut up".

You don't suggest a new topic of discussion, yet I have,

So: even your condemnation here rings hollow. You're criticizing me for something you're MORE guilty of than I am. If you don't trust me, you want me to post more so you can see if i trip up. If you do trust me you want to see me trip up other people. Either way, more data is more power for town, and this thread is the largest repository of town knowledge. All other things being equal, more discussion gives us more potential to win.