EPTHowever, I disagree that we should be focusing elsewhere; the Dr. Dragoon vs. Swallow thing wasn't just a 'mishap'; it was either a blatant mistake on Dragoon's part, or a stupid action on Swallows. I don't think we can really let this slide. The attitudes people take on this will be noted for future days- people should weigh in on it, and I know that if I'm elected mayor, I will likely use the instant-lynch to kill either Dragoon or Caller at this point (the latter because he said 'I am mafia', which is.. well.. dumb.)
Team Liquid Mafia [gg] - Page 19
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Tracil
Australia505 Posts
However, I disagree that we should be focusing elsewhere; the Dr. Dragoon vs. Swallow thing wasn't just a 'mishap'; it was either a blatant mistake on Dragoon's part, or a stupid action on Swallows. I don't think we can really let this slide. The attitudes people take on this will be noted for future days- people should weigh in on it, and I know that if I'm elected mayor, I will likely use the instant-lynch to kill either Dragoon or Caller at this point (the latter because he said 'I am mafia', which is.. well.. dumb.) | ||
|
Dr.Dragoon
United States1241 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:18 ShaLLoW[baY] wrote: You only come to your own defense when you're sure to be lynched? I'm only saving my defense because it's basically you just insulting me  . It would show a reason for you to target me, but it would also make me look bad. lol... | ||
|
mahnini
United States6862 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:17 Dr.Dragoon wrote: Tsk tsk, you guys obviously haven't done your research. Have any of you thought of the possibility that NEITHER of us are mafia? read the first post on this page duh | ||
|
GeneralStan
United States4789 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:17 Dr.Dragoon wrote: Tsk tsk, you guys obviously haven't done your research. Have any of you thought of the possibility that NEITHER of us are mafia? What you're saying is that in a clever play, you send a PM to Shallow in hopes that he's a Mafia member, but this backfires and Shallow indicates you as mafioso and things go downhill from here? Or, our original thought that Shallow forged your message is correct, and shallow is a mafioso. I don't like this option though because it means that Shallow is a dumb mafioso, taking a big risk by forging something | ||
|
mahnini
United States6862 Posts
| ||
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:18 Tracil wrote: @ L2W: Hmm. Accepted that it's true townies shouldn't just blindly act in one direction. Still a bit miffed but I like your tone so far. However, I disagree that we should be focusing elsewhere; the Dr. Dragoon vs. Swallow thing wasn't just a 'mishap'; it was either a blatant mistake on Dragoon's part, or a stupid action on Swallows. I don't think we can really let this slide. The attitudes people take on this will be noted for future days- people should weigh in on it, and I know that if I'm elected mayor, I will likely use the instant-lynch to kill either Dragoon or Caller at this point (the latter because he said 'I am mafia', which is.. well.. dumb.) EDIT: It was a sort of reaction test to see what would happen. In this case, you had a strange reaction when I said that, which I thought was a bit odd. Hmm... | ||
|
ShaLLoW[baY]
Canada12499 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:18 Tracil wrote: @ L2W: Hmm. Accepted that it's true townies shouldn't just blindly act in one direction. Still a bit miffed but I like your tone so far. However, I disagree that we should be focusing elsewhere; the Dr. Dragoon vs. Swallow thing wasn't just a 'mishap'; it was either a blatant mistake on Dragoon's part, or a stupid action on Swallows. I don't think we can really let this slide. The attitudes people take on this will be noted for future days- people should weigh in on it, and I know that if I'm elected mayor, I will likely use the instant-lynch to kill either Dragoon or Caller at this point (the latter because he said 'I am mafia', which is.. well.. dumb.) SHallow. SHallow. SHallow. Jesus lol. | ||
|
Dr.Dragoon
United States1241 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:20 GeneralStan wrote: What you're saying is that in a clever play, you send a PM to Shallow in hopes that he's a Mafia member, but this backfires and Shallow indicates you as mafioso and things go downhill from here? Or, our original thought that Shallow forged your message is correct, and shallow is a mafioso. I don't like this option though because it means that Shallow is a dumb mafioso, taking a big risk by forging something I thought the mafia were supposed to know who the other members of the mafia are? I would be INCREDIBLY stupid to make the message that shallow posted. Game-wise at least | ||
|
dancefayedance!~
396 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:01 mahnini wrote: OR! Maybe dr dragoon was trying to bait shallow and see if it was HE that was the dumb mafia and being the mafia that he is dancefayedance!~ jumped on his chance to accuse two townies. AND he voted for Tracil! you've found many opportunities to accuse people, but how do we know you are not a mafia member yourself. deliberately accusing everyone as mafia members to give the impression you aren't one yourself? i sincerely believe dr.dragoon is mafia because of his reaction to shallow[bay]'s print screen. It does state in the very beginning that mafia members know other mafia members. why would dr.dragoon say shallow[bay] was a mafia member if he knew he was a mafia member himself?a rule we are all well aware of ( if we read the rules which im assuming you did) it's because dr.dragoon wanted to throw everyone into confusion! i think what dr.dragoon did is very cunning. he knew that it would be screen shotted. with this in mind he used a poor bait to throw us off. it wasn't that he was trying to bait shallow[bay] into admitting he was another mafia member ( because if shallow[bay] were he would know if dr.dragoon was a mafia member or not) it's because he wanted to use that poor attempt of a trap to really steer us away from believing he was a mafia member. now this is why i think shallow[bay] could be a mafia member. either dr.dragoon and shallow]bay] planned this, because for shallow[bay] to accuse dr.dragoon and post 'incriminating' evidence would mean that shallow[bay] has a shallow intelligence or because they both planned this out. im almost certain that dr.dragoon is a mafia member. it's about 60% for shallow[bay]. I think i've found clues pointing to both of them and other players which i will post when we elect a mayor. | ||
|
Dr.Dragoon
United States1241 Posts
HAHAHAHA I DIDN'T EVEN NOTICE THAT | ||
Live2Win
United States6657 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:18 Tracil wrote: @ L2W: Hmm. Accepted that it's true townies shouldn't just blindly act in one direction. Still a bit miffed but I like your tone so far. However, I disagree that we should be focusing elsewhere; the Dr. Dragoon vs. Swallow thing wasn't just a 'mishap'; it was either a blatant mistake on Dragoon's part, or a stupid action on Swallows. I don't think we can really let this slide. The attitudes people take on this will be noted for future days- people should weigh in on it, and I know that if I'm elected mayor, I will likely use the instant-lynch to kill either Dragoon or Caller at this point (the latter because he said 'I am mafia', which is.. well.. dumb.) Oh of course not. I am 99% sure Dragoon is a mafia. He is going to get lynched no matter what. I was addressing to those who believe Shallow should also be lynched. In my opinion he has no reason to be suspected... everything he did makes logical sense, while Dragoon's actions makes no sense if he was a townie. | ||
|
mahnini
United States6862 Posts
It's ok, he calls me manhini which sounds like man hiny (man booty) | ||
|
Tracil
Australia505 Posts
@ Shallow: Uh, sorry! | ||
|
Folca
2235 Posts
| ||
|
Caller
Poland8075 Posts
| ||
|
wurm
Philippines2296 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:23 dancefayedance!~ wrote: you've found many opportunities to accuse people, but how do we know you are not a mafia member yourself. deliberately accusing everyone as mafia members to give the impression you aren't one yourself? i sincerely believe dr.dragoon is mafia because of his reaction to shallow[bay]'s print screen. It does state in the very beginning that mafia members know other mafia members. why would dr.dragoon say shallow[bay] was a mafia member if he knew he was a mafia member himself?a rule we are all well aware of ( if we read the rules which im assuming you did) it's because dr.dragoon wanted to throw everyone into confusion! i think what dr.dragoon did is very cunning. he knew that it would be screen shotted. with this in mind he used a poor bait to throw us off. it wasn't that he was trying to bait shallow[bay] into admitting he was another mafia member ( because if shallow[bay] were he would know if dr.dragoon was a mafia member or not) it's because he wanted to use that poor attempt of a trap to really steer us away from believing he was a mafia member. now this is why i think shallow[bay] could be a mafia member. either dr.dragoon and shallow]bay] planned this, because for shallow[bay] to accuse dr.dragoon and post 'incriminating' evidence would mean that shallow[bay] has a shallow intelligence or because they both planned this out. im almost certain that dr.dragoon is a mafia member. it's about 60% for shallow[bay]. I think i've found clues pointing to both of them and other players which i will post when we elect a mayor. This summed up the whole situation the best. GJ dance. | ||
|
Dapperdan
United States38 Posts
| ||
|
ShaLLoW[baY]
Canada12499 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:26 wurm wrote: This summed up the whole situation the best. GJ dance. I eagerly await the "clues" that point to me as mafia. | ||
|
GeneralStan
United States4789 Posts
On February 12 2008 10:25 Caller wrote: why is tracil the only one that wants me dead atm? I kind of want you dead. You're either Mafia or a Liar, and a dead man in either case. | ||
|
Dr.Dragoon
United States1241 Posts
| ||
| ||
